• NOVEMBER 7, 2009
DISPATCH PRINT  |   TEXT SIZE        |  EMAIL  |  SINGLE PAGE

And Then There Were None

How they killed Chechnya's conscience.

BY ANNA NEMTSOVA | JULY 16, 2009

Natalia Estemirova had a dry sense of humor and a giant heart. I remember the first time she showed us around her apartment, in the war-weary city of Grozny, she pointed to a huge shrapnel hole in the wall separating her daughter's bedroom from the hallway. "Check out the new design of the ventilation," she said. "I never have time to fix it, so let it stay a part of our interior."

COMMENTS (1) SHARE:
Digg
 
Facebook
 
Reddit
 
Bookmark and Share More...

That was classic Natalia -- a single mother and a human rights activist in a place that desperately needed them, she never had time for her own life; there were too many troubles to report on. She was a walking fountain of Chechnya's sad stories: "I want to tell you a story about this man, a widower who was kidnapped from his house in a mountain village and now is being tortured in jail. His two little children live with his mother, who is almost 100 years old." That was the first thing she told me when we met in Grozny in 2005.

Many times after that, I would call her to see how things were in Russia's forgotten war zone. Natasha, as we called her, would always quickly reply: "They abduct people by the dozens, they burn their houses, they torture guerrillas' relatives, kick people out of their apartments -- something has to be done, something has to be done to help them." Who are they? I would ask her. "Come over, I will tell you."

Well, on Tuesday, they came for Natasha. At 8:30 that morning, as she walked out of her house, she was dragged into an unmarked white Lada, screaming vainly for help. Just like one of the stories she so doggedly pursued. And of course, we know how this one ends: They found her body later that day, in nearby Ingushetia, riddled with bullets. This, unfortunately, was the Chechnya that she knew all too well, the place of thuggery, violence, and corruption that most of the rest of the world has been content to forget. Just recently Moscow declared that the war there is over. Well, it may not be war, but it remains as lawless as a war zone. Abductions and killings by them are rising.

Until this week, Natasha had a simple rule: She never gave up her investigations until she knew for certain that nothing else could be done. That became her practice from an early age, when she was a reporter. Before the wars started, she had been a history teacher. Back in the 1990s, when the violence began, she reported 13 documentary stories for local television stations. "That was when I became a human rights activist at heart. When my husband died in war, my heart hardened," she said. That was all she told me about her personal life; there was none. She never liked talking about what happened to her husband.

123NEXT
Save over 50% when you subscribe to FP.

REUTERS/Dylan Martinez

 

Anna Nemtsova is a Russia correspondent for Newsweek.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE: Facebook|Twitter|Digg
  • Handicapping the Next Palestinian Leader

  • All I Want for Xmas Is an Afghan Strategy

  • Kashmir, the Forgotten Front

  • Does J Street Lead to Jerusalem or Washington?

 (1)

HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE

ALONZOJOE

12:40 PM ET

July 19, 2009

silence

Anna Thanks for sharing your experiences and thoughts about Natalia Estemirova. A very brave woman who deserved far better then she got form her Gov't and from her country. Many people around the world are deeply saddened.

 
TODAY | PAST WEEK

MOST
READ

MOST
COMMENTED

  1. Falling Like It's 1989
  2. Planet Slum
  3. Today's Berlin Walls
  4. Hollow Victory
  5. Good Riddance, Abbas
TODAY | PAST WEEK

MOST
READ

MOST
COMMENTED

  1. The Top 10 Craziest Things Ever Said During a U.N. Speech
  2. Nobel Peace Prize Also-Rans
  3. Edward Burtynsky's Oil
  4. Think Again: God
  5. Bolivia's Lithium-Powered Future
TODAY | PAST WEEK

MOST
READ

MOST
COMMENTED

  1. Good Riddance, Abbas
  2. Next in Line
  3. The Memory Trap
  4. Think Again: God
  5. Nightmare on J Street
TODAY | PAST WEEK

MOST
READ

MOST
COMMENTED

  1. Unsettling Questions
  2. Why Are the United States and Israel at the Top of Human Rights Hit Lists?
  3. Think Again: God
  4. Hollow Victory
  5. Who's Really Running Iran's Green Movement
  • PASSPORT

    It's not a "diplomatic breakthrough" if it doesn't work

    BY JOSHUA KEATING

  • ARGUMENT

    The real reason the revamped EU matters

    BY ANNIE LOWREY

  • DAVID ROTHKOPF

    Obama: the last baby-boomer president?

  • ARGUMENT

    1989 through Russian eyes

    BY NINA KHRUSHCHEVA

  • THE CABLE

    Afghan strategy rollout imminent

    BY JOSH ROGIN

  • SMALL WARS

    Why the Army's most effective vehicle doesn't work in Afghanistan

    BY ROBERT HADDICK

  • STEPHEN WALT

    Is Obama worse than Bush on Israel?

  • MARC LYNCH

    Why Abbas's resignation might not be a disaster



  • 1. Opting Out: Canada Plans Withdrawal from Afghanistan
  • 2. Trade Objections: China Calls New U.S. Anti-dumping Duties “Protectionist”
  • 3. Lowering the Bar: U.N. Delegates Move Ahead on Climate Change Despite Reservations
  • 4. Death of a Deal: Honduras Calls off Political Compromise
 See All Photo Essays
  • Falling Like It's 1989

  • Obama's Globe-Trotting Adventures, One Year in

November/December 2009
  • Feature

    Revolution in a Box

  • Feature

    Plague, by Robin Cook

  • Opening Gambit

    My Plan to Overthrow the Mullahs

  •  See Entire Issue

     Preview Digital Edition

  • An online guide to following today's floor action on health care reform.
  • Advertisement:
  • Why Arby's is so low on the restaurant food chain.
  • Profit Not Satanic, Says Wealthy Banker
  • Presented By:
  • No Goodwill for Hummers
  • ‘Precious’ and the Pushback
  • ‘Precious’ and the Pushback
  • Raise Your Voice for Health Care Reform

About FP: Meet the Staff | Foreign Editions | Reprint Permissions | Advertising | Corporate Programs | Writers’ Guidelines | Press Room | Work at FP

Services: Subscription Services | Academic Program | FP Archive | Reprint Permissions | FP Reports and Merchandise | Special Reports | Buy Back Issues

Subscribe to FP | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | RSS Feeds | Contact Us

FP Logo


1899 L Street NW, Suite 550 | Washington, DC 20036 | Phone: 202-728-7300 | Fax: 202-728-7342
FOREIGN POLICY is published by the Slate Group, a division of Washingtonpost.Newsweek Interactive, LLC
All contents ©2009 Washingtonpost.Newsweek Interactive, LLC. All rights reserved.