The Real Tragedy in Nigeria's Violence

Nigeria's problem isn't Islamist fundamentalism -- it's the country's corrupt and self-serving government.

BY JEAN HERSKOVITS | AUGUST 3, 2009

And so it goes. Nigeria's far north has a history of charismatic leaders who preach unorthodox Muslim beliefs and rally large numbers of young men in clashes with traditional Islamic and political authorities. In the early 1980s, a major wave of violence spread from Kano to Maiduguri. A smaller outbreak in 2004 in Yobe and Borno states was a forerunner to the present clashes. Then, a rebellious group of young men who called themselves "Taleban," having no doubt heard the name (but not the spelling) on the Hausa service of the BBC or Voice of America, demanded the imposition of full sharia law. That same plea was sweeping all the far northern states, thanks in part to strong popular feeling that Nigeria's secular institutions were not delivering justice. Sharia, it was hoped, would do a better job.

Boko Haram, which by some accounts evolved from the "Taleban," judged that sharia did not help: Ironically, the four states where last week's death and destruction occurred are all states that did adopt sharia criminal law. It is said loudly and frequently by those who live there that not only has sharia law been quietly set aside, but that now these are among the worst governed states in the country.

Meanwhile, Nigerians note that as the violence last week was escalating, their president -- who is himself from the far northern state of Katsina -- chose to leave the country on a visit to Brazil. (An attack on a police station in Katsina followed.) Newspaper columnists contrasted this unfavorably with the Chinese president's decision to skip the G-8 meetings in Italy last month when unrest enveloped Xinjiang province.

And in the Niger Delta, as in the north, the goverment's indifference to life on the ground has had growing consequences. Protests there have escalated over the years to kidnappings, explosions, and armed combat. Successive governments, especially at the lavishly funded state level, have done little to develop the area and improve people's lives. What is different, of course, is that the delta's oil, which despoils the mangrove creeks but funds Nigeria's government at all levels, has also produced criminal networks whose activities, with political and even military complicity, have made the tragedy there all the more intractable. And the massive importation of weapons into the delta has made guns of all kinds -- particularly AK-47s -- available cheaply throughout the country, notably now in the north.

The problems are not new. Nigerians and others who cared to look closely have seen the political venality, lack of concern, and flamboyant lifestyle of the corrupt rich and powerful who have made daily life for the vast majority of the population worse and worse, year after year. A decade ago, with the return of democracy, Nigerians had high hopes. But now, after rigged elections at all levels in 2003 and 2007, and the prospect of nothing different in 2011; with unclean drinking water, a failed electrical grid, unsafe roads, ever rising crime, and a host of other grievances, they have little hope left.

The world will misunderstand if it looks at the latest Nigerian tragedy through the lens of global radical Islam. If Nigeria's leaders do not urgently start to address their country's most basic, obvious needs, the only question is what will trigger the next spate of armed mayhem, and where. It could be anywhere. And its causes, with deep roots in corruption in high places, will be no mystery.

PIUS UTOMI EKPEI/AFP/Getty Images

 

Jean Herskovits is research professor of history at the State University of New York, Purchase. She has been traveling to Nigeria for nearly four decades, most recently two weeks ago.

PSMOSES

12:15 PM ET

August 4, 2009

Not new

You are right, such problems are not new for Nigeria, or many other places in Africa. Not only should the world not look at this "through the lens of global radical Islam" but the United States in general must radically change its foreign relations beyond dealing with supposedly immediate security threats. The State Department and specifically USAID need to be revised and expanded enormously so that the US and others are more forcefully addressing foundational, systemic problems. Otherwise, the approach will remain as nothing more than applying band-aids.

http://www.enewse.com/

 

MICHAELSELTZER

5:05 PM ET

August 8, 2009

The Real Tragedy in Nigeria's Violence

As Jean Herskovitz illuminates in her excellent article, international journalists have once more promulgated an overly-simplified analysis of recent events in northern Nigeria. To attribute outbreaks such as those that occurred in several northern Nigeria states as another example of encroaching Islamic terrorism helps to blur the real underlying issues of poverty and lack of educational opportunities.

 

BOMBONES

10:24 PM ET

August 13, 2009

Same old Narrative

Thanks to the global war on "terror"; Muslims have been stripped off of any legitimate right to voice their grievances, express pluralism of ideas, demand basic human needs and inviolable right to political destiny. Nigeria's "Boko Haram" compared to the Ogoni people in oil producing delta states, are just noise makers, the intelligence apparatus knew that. The armed gangs of Ogoni land constitute a clear and present danger to the security of Nigeria and on all oil productions. What we have in Northern Nigeria is, mention "Islam" and dissent in the sentence, the world will give you a pass to come down hard with impunity on Muslims. I thank Ms. Herskovits for addressing the causality of civil unrest in Nigeria that has become common place. I am, however, afraid that she might have had her visa to Nigeria just revoked. Cheers.