Germany Has a Gay Minister -- Yäwn!

Guido Westerwelle, Germany's new vice-chancellor and foreign minister, is very popular and openly gay. And nobody in Germany cares.

BY CAMERON ABADI | SEPTEMBER 30, 2009

Guido Westerwelle, right, celebrates his party's victory with his boyfriend.

For more than 50 years, the tabloid daily Bild -- currently Europe's best-selling newspaper -- has served as both a reliable barometer of Germany's conservative movement and a steady vent of its populist id. The editors have never felt compelled to question their winning formula: The conservative parties' current talking points go above the fold, the naked "Page One Girl" below it. The self-appointed guarantors of all that is traditionally Deutsch aren't much interested in the finer points of sensitivity training.

And in that way, the tabloid might have been expected at some point this week to express ambivalence, if not disapproval, of the fact that the country's newly elected vice-chancellor and foreign minister, Guido Westerwelle, is gay. Instead, though, Bild waved a white flag on one of the fronts of the country's decades-long culture war. As part of its gleeful coverage of the victory of the country's two main conservative parties in Sunday's election, the newspaper paid its respect to Westerwelle in the form of a sentimental page-one profile of his boyfriend, complete with a trashy headline: "His Boyfriend Makes Him Strong!"

Taking its cues from voters, Bild's editors didn't wring their hands over Westerwelle's sexual orientation, nor did they sensationalize it as a novelty. For one thing, it wasn't news: The chairman of the FDP, the free market Free Democratic Party, hadn't hidden his sexual orientation during the campaign -- his partner, event manager Michael Mronz, was often on stage with him at his rallies -- and no one he encountered on the trail seemed inclined to make an issue of it. Being a gay politician in Germany, it seems, is well on its way to being utterly normal, even banal.

Germany's ready public acceptance of homosexuality is the product of recent sea changes both in the character of society and in the letter of national law. For much of western Germany's history, neither the CDU, the Catholic-dominated Christian Democratic Union, nor the opposition Social Democratic Party (SPD), with its focus on the industrial working class, had much interest in setting up protections for gays. In eastern Germany, the ruling communist party dismissed homosexuality as "contrary to the healthy mores of the people." Nazi-era laws that criminalized homosexuality remained in force in East Germany until 1958 and in West Germany until as late as 1969.

Change didn't come easy. The gay-rights movement that began organizing in earnest in West Germany in the 1960s -- part of the student-driven backlash that wanted to interrogate and overcome the country's Nazi past -- elicited strong conservative resistance. For decades, the polarized camps faced off in homes, universities, and city streets in a tense stalemate. When Helmut Kohl took office as chancellor in 1982 at the head of a "black-yellow" coalition between the CDU and the FDP, he promised a "moral-spiritual revolution" that would return the country to its traditional understanding of public morality and decorum. What that amounted to, during his 16 years at the head of German government, was periodic populist agitation against politically correct cultural liberals in the arts and academia. Certainly, it was unthinkable that a gay man would gain a major portfolio in the Kohl-led coalition that governed until 1998. (Westerwelle, as a high-ranking FDP official, was involved in the Kohl government, but didn't come out of the closet until 2004.)

How, then, has the tide turned so dramatically in Germany in favor of acceptance of homosexuality? On the legal and political side, the gay-rights movement was fortunate to have found an amenable political home in the late 1970s in the fledgling Green Party. Although dismissed by the establishment in their early years, the Greens came into power in 1999, together with the SPD, with a clear and focused agenda to update German law to better reflect society's present-day values.

In addition to reform of immigration and citizenship statutes, the Greens pushed through a law recognizing same-sex partnerships and also rooted out the final remnants of legalized discrimination against gays in the German military. These efforts were passed with the support of the left-leaning SPD and Westerwelle's free market, culturally liberal FDP. Westerwelle, for his part, blasted the Catholic Church for its "19th-century worldview" in response to a call by the Vatican to campaign against the gay-marriage law.

Joern Pollex/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: EUROPE
 

Cameron Abadi is a Berlin-based writer for Die Zeit and Spiegel International.

KMH8

1:05 PM ET

October 2, 2009

Well, good for Germany...

It's really about time that a person's sexual orientation doesn't matter as more than general trivia knowledge, just like hair color or favorite food or math skills. Being gay does not define a person or say anything about his or her personality, morals, or tastes anymore than being straight tells us those things about a person. I have always failed to see how it is anyone else's business how a person sexually identifies him or herself, or how sexual orientation is even remotely relevant to anything at all.

Now if only we could get to a point in America where it is no longer news to us that someone being gay isn't news in another country.

 

HEISEL

1:07 PM ET

October 5, 2009

Somewhat hyperbolic article

In order to make his point sound more interesting, the author has somewhat dramatised the background. While "Bild" is overall more conservative than leftist (both in the German sense), it is above all populist (plus vulgar and tacky) and rather tolerant of different lifestyles, at least since the late 80s or so. Berlin's mayor is gay (Social Democrats), which has never been negatively commented on by Bild (to my knowledge), and so is the mayor of Hamburg (Christian Democrats). The "culture wars" were nothing like those in the US and I do not think that when Helmut Kohl spoke of "moral-spiritual revolution" this was meant or understood to include a rejection of homosexuality.

So nothing to report, really.

 

VIRGINIAREADER

3:21 PM ET

October 3, 2009

A reflection of the problem

Having a homosexual public official is not itself a problem, but an openly homosexual senior leader is because of what it reflects about society. Germany's chief problem is its demographic collapse brought on by the same value system which makes open homosexuality possible. Societies mantain themselves by upholding certain responsibilities as basic to society. Homosexuality is as complete a perversion of the basic functions of the family as is possible. While I wouldn't make a big deal about it if it were a matter of private conduct, anything that has the affect of sanctioning homosexuality will undermine the norms which underpin the family. This is why this matters.

It is apparent from the rash of pro-homosexual articles recently - and always from that point of view - that Foreign Policy takes its writers from the social left. I would like to suggest that the editors think about why it is that those societies which most accept homosexuality are all in a state of social collapse - just look at the rates for marriage, divorce, illegitimacy and fertility.

There are, of course a wide range of factors here - as I've made clear, the problem is not primarily individual conduct so much as a social model that needs to be rejected. And of course, there are societies with demographic problems which do not accept homosexuality. But you will not find a society that both sanctions homosexuality and maintains itself over time.

 

GVA-STEVE

8:47 AM ET

October 5, 2009

Ummmm

Haven't visited Germany for a while, have you dude? Wow - just look at some headlines coming from California and other parts of the US lately - the recent Gardian article a day or two ago - take a trip to Germany, why don't you, and then come back and tell us about the "social collapse" happening over there !!!

 

RAINER24

8:54 AM ET

October 5, 2009

Get thee to a library, Virginiareader.

Sorry Virginiareader, but there is no evidence to suggest that there is even a hint of truth to your theory. Historically, there have been very few societies that "sanctioned homosexuality," and yet all societies do come to an end or irreversible change at some point, with sexual orientation playing no discernible roll in the process.

There is no link between acceptance of homesexuality, or any of the other societal "problems" you list. Germany, a country far less driven by Judeo-Christian mores and superstitions than the United States, a nation whose two largest cities are both governed by openly gay mayors, has a divorce rate 15% lower than that of the U.S.!

"Demographic collapse"? I mean, really? Thanks for the euphemism, but this sort of xenophobic nonsense isn't winning anyone to your side.

The things you define as norms may in fact qualify as such for you, but they do not for most of the people in the world. How about minding your own business for once instead of railing against how someone else chooses to live their life? How about talking to our children and listening to them instead of worrying so much about what people who have little to no contact with them do?

Anyway, I don't know open Germany really is to having a gay foreign minister. With the multi-party power sharing that goes on over here, Westerwelle has been able to attain a very powerful position as the leader of a party that gained less that 15% of the popular vote in these elections, so using his rise as evidence of a social trend seems a bit of a stretch to me. Having grown up in the American South and lived in Europe for several years, yes, people do care less about their public figures' sexual orientation in Germany, but that doesn't mean there are a rash of socially conservative grandmothers willing to cast there vote for Westerwelle, Wowereit, et al. While more accepting of personal choice than the U.S., Germany still has quite a ways to go.

 

KAMPULUS

4:14 AM ET

October 6, 2009

Germany only tolerates Westerwave homosexuality

Westerwelle is gay. And this does not cause any drama for most Germans. The author should differentiate, however, between somebody like Wowereit (=openly gay, coining the famous phrase "Ich bin schwul und das ist auch gut so", I am gay and it's good that way), and somebody like Westerwelle, who constantly declared his homosexuality as being a private affair.

Westerwelle tried to hide his boyfriend for a long time, and his refusal to be public about his sexuality has earned him harsh criticism from germany's gay community. To be sure: he talks about what he eats, shows his appartment to journalists, revealing everything private to the media - except his homosexuality. Nobody in the gay community believes that somebody who is still hiding - and now in a coalition with Merkel, a woman who still defends the traditional family unit as the only entity holding up "real" german values - will make any improvements towards more acceptance and understanding.

What the author is observing in Germany is not acceptance of gay people, but a form of tolerance. Like you are "tolerant" against pain. It's still a long way to go...

 

ROMANOV

10:47 AM ET

October 11, 2009

Germany tolerates anything as long it's German

The subject twice, and you have my point.
If you did not get it (or you did but like to hear an elaboration, there you go) :
I lived several years in Germany, in Stuttgart mostly, and at some point was about to commit myself to a life spent in Germany among Germans.
I love Germany, I thought! It made sense, the clock-like system, the people were all seemingly friendly and, to some extend, helpful to a foreigner like me.
I loved it to bits. Until one day, summer1998, I was walking down the Stutgart's King Street, when a couple of policemen stopped me asking for my documents, in the middle of the high street and looking really good! I was taken aback, and thought, OK, what have I done? walking, yes, and nothing else. How did I look: spotless.
Why did they ask me, because I have a darker complexion than Germans and have dark brown hair. That is it. All the Germans were passing by, and ALL the GERMANS were passing by, including probably a criminal or two, but the policemen's best target was a man that was no German.
So, to me, there is nothing astonishing in the report, gay or not, as long as s/he is German, Alles Klar. What could cause a row, however, is if they see someone with a foreign background ascends to parliament, that day might come