Does Mahmoud Ahmadinejad Have Jewish Roots?

True or not, the rumors matter. Here's why.

BY JAMSHEED K. CHOKSY | OCTOBER 6, 2009

The world has been transfixed this week by speculation that Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, a self-proclaimed devout Shiite Muslim infamous for his frequent anti-Semitic and anti-Israel remarks, may be of Jewish heritage. Jews may not be eager to claim him, but his family's religious history -- or even just the rumors surrounding it -- could have serious implications for Iranian foreign policy nonetheless.

Ahmadinejad has admitted that his family changed its name when he was young, but has provided few details. According to Iranian government documents and family members, his original family name was Sabourjian or "cloth-weavers." That name, although present among Muslim Iranians, often indicates a minority background. Despite the official position, another former family name alleged by Ahmadinejad watchers has been Sabaghian, or "cloth-dyers." It doesn't matter much which name it was, given the similarity of the jobs they describe: Traditionally in Iran, both the coloring and weaving of cloth were professions left to non-Muslims as religiously unclean activities.

Generally among Iranian Muslim family names, the ending -ian or -yan signifies a relationship to a profession or location. But this can also indicate an Armenian or even an Assyrian (Nestorian-Chaldean) background and, therefore, identify Muslims with a Christian family heritage -- something other observers have picked up on. However, Jewish cloth weavers and dyers were more common during the past century in the region around the family's hometown of Aradan than were Armenian and Assyrian weavers and dyers. Ahmadinejad's hometown of Aradan had a Jewish minority into modern times, the remnants of a community dating back to Silk Road traders during the 3rd to 6th centuries B.C. Likewise, both Sabour and Sabagh (or Sabbagh) were uncommon last names for Muslim cloth weavers and dyers.

As Ahmadinejad claims to be from a multigenerational Shiite family, the name change in the 1950s was unusual. It is true that, as Ahmadinejad's relatives have noted, there was steady migration from villages to Tehran during the late 19th and 20th centuries. But urbanizing families did not tend to change their names so radically -- not even to conceal humble backgrounds.

If Ahmadinejad is indeed of Jewish descent, his family's story represents a classic pattern for religious converts: Adopt Islam, leave the hometown where people might know you as a Jew, move to a new location where blending into the Muslim population is easier, take up different occupations, and, just in case anyone were to question their confessional fidelity, demonstrate zeal for Islam by attacking their former religion and other minority faiths.

ATTA KENARE/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: IRAN
 

Jamsheed K. Choksy is professor of Iranian, Central Eurasian, Indian, and Islamic studies and former director of the Middle Eastern Studies Program at Indiana University. He also is a member of the National Council on the Humanities at the U.S. National Endowment for the Humanities. The views expressed here are his own.

Facebook|Twitter|Reddit

BGARD6977

8:11 PM ET

October 5, 2009

 

JCHOKSY

11:07 PM ET

October 5, 2009

Please refer to "Iran's

Please refer to "Iran's Imperial Presidency" in Foreign Policy on September 14, 2009.

 

SAILOR BILL

10:12 AM ET

October 6, 2009

Briliant and thoughtful response

Your command of the language is, of course unparalleled, as is your abitlity to articulate advanced thoughts. You might consider remedial reading, creative writing 101 and some courses in etiquette before responding to subject matter well above your station.

 

SAILOR BILL

10:14 AM ET

October 6, 2009

Brilliant reply

Some basic courses in remedial reading and creative writing might compliment basic studies in etiquette 101. May I suggest learning more about matters well above your station prior to responding?

 

SAILOR BILL

10:17 AM ET

October 6, 2009

Well over your head

Are you aware that this topic is well above your station? Please respond to articles concerning Miley Cyrus and Japanese cartoons rather than wsting space in this blog.

 

WEPUMP

9:08 AM ET

October 6, 2009

wepump

Really people in the west do not know or understand the basics of life or religion to spend time reading if some one has Jewish herritage everyone knows who is Islamic Musluim and at least up todate on worlds religion herriitage it just dont matter

In order of Religion as seen by Islamic peoples its starts off with

Adam and eve ( yes they belive in them as well )
Then we have what is called the Sabeans age the time before God revelled relegion

God revels religion and we get the Jewish religion first
( yes they belive in this as well After all they pray and do Hauge at someones house who was before The Profit Mohamed PBUH )

Just so you know Jesus was born a Jew but he starts Christainity
As this is second religion in world reconising the same God ( yes Jesus is a profit as well to Muslums )

Rest of world are busy doing Idols cows assorted other things to pray about

Along Comes The Profit Mohamed PBUH and the angel Gabrial passes to him a new way forward called Islam and in Islam it reconises this passage of belief in God from 1/ Sabeans 2/ Jewish 3/ Christians 4/ Muslums

Now remember Saidia to Tehran at this time only had Jewish Idol lovers and Christians before the Koran was spread to all reachs of the world

So yes I belive all leaders in middleast to America and Russia can have and have a 50/50 chance of either having Jewish blood line or an Idol lovers blood line before religion of Islam took hold of the middleast Far east and central Asia so to try and shock anyone who Bad mouths Isreal that he may have a jewish back ground is silly as everyone in Middleast has a jewish background and all Christians started out as Jewish people before Jesus walked the earth Im even sure Adolph Hitlar had Jewish blood in his family as well

Enjoy the histoory lesson and no I do not like the leader of Iran but I do understand his position on the state of Isreal

Enjoy

 

SAILOR BILL

10:09 AM ET

October 6, 2009

MiddleEastern History and Religion

While a quick course in remedial reading and writing might add some relevance to your comments, the basic foundation is obviously not rooted in real study. Consider the three families who really established the middle eastern regions, and that the proven cradle of modern civilization is long known to be at the confluence of the Tigris and The Euphrates (now known as "Baghdad"). Mesopotamians spread out from there into the region, and eventually formed into those three families. While the formation of ideologies such as Judiasm, Christianity and other religious factions grew many centuries after the dawn of man in this area, the peoples of the region continued to migrate and both intermingle culturally and to interbreed. Given the basic notion of Adam and Eve, we are all the products of incest, not considered a sin until much later than it's concept in the "Garden of Eden" tale, and in many current cultures, still not unacceptable. Cultural differences do not make for political ideology. Political aspiration is an issue of natural competition within the human species. Cultural diversity is an issue of regional developement, mostly relevant to climate, food sources and natural geography. Whether or not Iran's leader is of Jewish decent is a moot point. According to the bible and it's teachings, we are all brothers and sisters anyway.

 

MEAGEN70

11:11 AM ET

October 6, 2009

Bill, it's obvious English is

Bill, it's obvious English is his second language and I'll bet his English is better than your Arabic. It's also obvious you are an arrogant a**.

 

WEPUMP

1:13 AM ET

October 7, 2009

Three families What about Noah

He was a Profit and all started off a mountion when the boat stopped floating araound and having been to this mountion its very close to your three families location so still we are all the same Bible and Koran tell same thing and have same profits untill Mohamed but he came after the Bible so how can he be there

Anyways we in this world are all from one so we are related my writting skills can be picked on its OK I am whaite and a product of the west for 44 years last while I have worked all over Iraq Iran Egypt Yemen Sudan and gotton to know some good people and seen there is another story to all the storis we in west hold so dear to our hearts and it is not the same as we are told. Mr bill get off your boat and come for a walk on dry land and really meet the people you will find the news you read is very slanted always in a bad way

Enjoy

 

SIR_MIXXALOT

4:43 PM ET

October 6, 2009

LOL!

It's Zionist plot to overthrow the Islamic Republic!!!!

hahahahahaha!

;)

damn mossad all getting in my as* everywhere!

 

GRANT

6:37 PM ET

October 6, 2009

Certainly is amusing, even if

Certainly is amusing, even if it won't produce any useful possibilities unless the Grand Ayatollah decides that the man is too much of a liability to keep.

 

COMPASSIONFORBOTHSIDES

3:33 AM ET

October 7, 2009

So is Ahmadinejad a real threat to Israel?

Mr. Choksy,

While Ahmadinejad may be trying to increase his power at the expense of the religious establishment, as noted in your other article, do you not think that since he is possibly overcompensating for his questionable Islamic background by verbally attacking Israel that it means tought talk on Israel is strictly rhetoric and political posturing?

If the anti-Israeli rhetoric is mostly deflection and overcompensation regarding his roots, would it therefore be illogical to assume this is strictly a talking point he has engineered and is not an indicator of actual policy backed by the rest of the administration & mullahs?

I don't think his administration would send nukes off to a proxy to bomb Israel all in the name of solidyfing Ahmadinejad's Islamic faith. Much of the middle east (indeed, politics) is more about rhetoric and words than it is about actions.

It seems that the fragmentation and political competition in Iran at the moment would only make it LESS likely for any Iranian aggression, contrary to what Mr. Netanyahu would like us to believe.

 

YEHUDABENNAZER00

6:42 AM ET

October 7, 2009

Rare opportunity for Peace

Actually this is a very excellent opportunity for peace.

Israel should apply the Law Of Return to President Iran and make him as the President of Israel.

With Ahmadinejad becomes the President of both countries Iran and Israel, Jews and the rest of the middle east will be at peace. Jews in Iran doesn't want to migrate to Israel, so Jews can have it both ways, while the Iranian could get the benefit of more advanced nuclear technology without any country being frightened.

Israel will no longer consider Iran and Ahmadinejad as enemy and AIPAC will not drag our country the USA into another unnecessary war.

 

HASS

10:30 AM ET

October 7, 2009

RUBBISH!

"Traditionally in Iran, both the coloring and weaving of cloth were professions left to non-Muslims as religiously unclean activities." THIS IS
COMPLETE AND UTTER RUBBISH!

 

DAVE1995

4:32 PM ET

October 7, 2009

Informative is the coverage of this "item" in Iran and the West.

In Iran, the 'news" ( rumor) that Ahmadinejad's father may have been a Jew did not find any coverage in the official and/or the opposition media. Ahmadinjead was the mayor of Tehran for two years prior to being elected as president in 2005. He was involved in at least two bitter political campaigns prior to the disputed presidential election of 2009. Why Ahmadinejad's opponents in Iran did not pick up on the "news" or the "rumor" that Ahmadinejad's father may have been Jewish?!!!

By contrast, the "news" (rumor) that Ahmadinejad may habe been born to a Jewish father was widely reported in the West in such weighty papers as the Daily Telegraph, the Gardian, and now expertly analyzed in FP. Why?

The difference in coverage is simple. In Shi'ite Islam it is a great honor to descendant of a recent convert to Islam. (A new muslim and up to seven generations of his/her descendants are said to go straight to heaven irrespective of their sins on earth). Hence, in Iran, it is Ahmadinejad and his supporters that may have had an interest in highlighting the fact, or spreading the rumor, that Ahmadinejad has a Jewish heritage. Note also that in Iran the mullahs distinguish between Judaism and Zionism -- just as certain Jewish sects do. Hence, in Iran, there is no contradiction for Ahmadinejad to be of Jewish descent and anti-Zionist.

In the West, by contrast, the distinction between Zionism and Judaism is blurred.

 

DAVE1995

12:56 PM ET

October 8, 2009

Also pertinent is the following:

http://www.rferl.org/content/Ahmadinejad_Jewish_Wouldnt_Matter_If_He_Was/1846811.html