A Third Intifada?

Contention over the disputed Al-Aqsa mosque and Temple Mount site have once again unleashed violence in Jerusalem and the West Bank. Could a third intifada erupt?

BY BOBBY PIERCE | OCTOBER 14, 2009

Uriel Sinai/Getty Images

Smoke and ire, rekindled: Clashes broke out between Israeli police and Palestinians at the end of last month after reports spread that radical Jews entered the Al-Aqsa mosque compound in Jerusalem. The fighting has so far remained relatively contained, but with rival factions Fatah and Hamas not getting along, and with Israel and the Obama administration differing on sensitive issues such as settlements, some worry that a third intifada could be brewing. Above, a Palestinian youth fires a sling shot at Israeli troops on Oct. 9 in Qalandia, south of Ramallah in the West Bank.

Uriel Sinai/Getty Images

 

Bobby Pierce is a researcher at Foreign Policy.

GRANT

12:15 AM ET

October 16, 2009

If Hamas does decide to fight

If Hamas does decide to fight a third one it will be very poor politics internationally speaking, though probably smart domestically. At the moment a great deal of hope is being bet on the idea that Hamas is ready for a deal. If Hamas dashes that with renewed terrorist attacks it will suddenly become very difficult for Western nations to criticize Israeli actions.

 

WAFA

8:33 AM ET

October 16, 2009

No to violence and no to FATAH/Abbas

Hamas should not start a third Intifada but it would be absolutely foolish to give Abbas any legitimacy by reaching a unity deal. Abbas is on his way done for overdoing his collaboration and cheating the Palestinians - he doesn't understand that the Palestinians will not accept this treachery ALL the time! If Hamas supports him now, it will lose its legitimacy and will be on its way to becoming 'FATAH version 2', a new strain of in-house collaborationists and puppets of the illegal occupiers.

 

PRW

9:27 AM ET

October 16, 2009

Please stop repeating falsehoods

This article repeats the debunked fiction that Ariel Shoron's visit to the Temple Mount started the second intifada.
The week prior to Sharon's visit two Israeli policemen were murdered by PA policemen who they were with on a joint patrol, and there was a bus bombing in Azza .
A peak was reached after the Al Dura Hoax was broadcast. The Al Dura footage was part of a program of guerilla skits videoed in Azza. Each youth in turn would act out being hit by Israeli army bullets. The footage of Mohamid Al Dura being "killed" was sliced out by France's Channel Two reporter Edilin and broadcast to the world. Later the French media ohmbudsman would agree that the scene did not show anyone being killed. And Philip Karsanty would win a court case to label the scene a hoax.
Several PA politicians had said that the Intifada was planned by Arafat after he did not get what he wanted from PM Barak.

 

ISRAELDEFENDER

5:02 AM ET

October 18, 2009

They always have a reason...

"Palestinians say the latest outbreak of violence started after right-wing Jews were seen entering the Al-Aqsa compound to worship, in violation of agreements that put the site under Muslim control."

They always have a reason, but it's never the honest one - we have been raised from birth to hate Jews by fundamentalist Imams and we believe that every inch of this land is ours (and must be liberated by violence).

 

JPWREL

12:01 PM ET

October 16, 2009

A curse on both their houses.

A curse on both their houses.