• NOVEMBER 20, 2009
FEATURE PRINT  |   TEXT SIZE        |  EMAIL  |  SINGLE PAGE

The Rift that Began in Tiananmen Square

When Deng Xiaoping met with Mikhail Gorbachev in May 1989, neither communist leader could have predicted that the events simultaneously transpiring in Tiananmen Square would ricochet around the world -- all the way to the Berlin Wall.

BY CHEN JIAN, JEFFREY A. ENGEL | NOVEMBER 9, 2009

The world changed in 1989.

At the start of the year, the globe's strategic map looked much like it had since the end of World War II. Communist leaders in China and the Soviet Union held power. Their American counterparts, skeptical of recent calls for change throughout the communist world, prepared for a reinvigorated Cold War of unknown duration and ferocity. Meanwhile, Europe prepared for another year divided along fault lines imposed by conquering armies nearly a half-century before.

A year later, communism would be dead in Eastern Europe and dying in the Soviet Union itself. China would be once more in the grip of hard-liners wary of reform, and once more on the precipice of isolation. Washington would be looking to capitalize on its Cold War victory. Europe would soon be rejoined. The future -- our 21st-century present -- would be at hand. And no one had seen it coming, least of all perhaps China, where the first of 1989's cracks in communism would begin.

Related

1989: The Lost Year

For Gorbachev and Bush Sr., it was 12 months of missed opportunities.

By David E. Hoffman

Following decades of enforced deprivation, justified by the quest for ideological purity, Chinese leader Deng Xiaoping and his ruling cadre sought to change their country, but without simultaneously losing the communal zeal and nationalism that had largely defined China since its 1949 revolution. More immediately, they sought some means of managing the social and political transformation sure to result from their economic reforms, believing only strict government control could ensure that the mayhem and violence of China's recent past did not reappear.

In March 1989, dismayed by the growing power of reform movements throughout the Soviet-dominated half of the communist world, Chinese Communist Party officials met to discuss "the unrest in Eastern Europe," concluding that "every effort should be made to prevent changes in Eastern Europe from influencing China's internal development." What was undermining communist rule abroad, they worried, might infect their own country. In 1989, they proved right to worry.

By April, Chinese masses were demanding change to a degree unseen in a generation. Students began to march in favor of reform. Others quickly followed their lead. From the hinterland, protesters surged into the city. While Chinese officials debated, the crowds continued to grow in size and enthusiasm. By May 15, more than 500,000 people filled Tiananmen Square. Just two days later they would number more than a million.

123NEXT
Save over 50% when you subscribe to FP.

CATHERINE HENRIETTE/AFP/Getty Images

 

This piece was adapted from excerpts from The Fall of the Berlin Wall: The Revolutionary Legacy of 1989. The selection was written by Chen Jian, the Michael J. Zak Chair of history for U.S.-China relations at Cornell University and edited by Jeffrey A. Engel, the Evelyn and Ed F. Kruse '49 faculty fellow at Texas A&M University.

SHARE THIS ARTICLE: Facebook|Twitter|Digg
  • The Al Qaeda Diaries

  • Boring Summits Are Better for Everyone

  • D.C.'s New Game: Who's Paying Your Pundit?

  • Lowering the Bar: The ABA's Ties to Despots

 (1)

HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE

WINTERKO

8:48 PM ET

November 10, 2009

Fall of China

Fall of China will be imminent under corrupt communist regime. 95% or more of Chinese population is still poor and social gap wide. PRC is still practicing most of the corrupt practices from monarchial era. Though it has culture of more than 5000 years, Chinese mindset is still sustained. As a matter of time when they encounter more n more political, economics & social mistakes as well as Chinese Favorite Corruptions. PRC will only last for some time and collapse will be imminent. Tibet, Uighur and Mongolia problems are just introductions. Let's watch!

  REPLY
 
TODAY | PAST WEEK

MOST
READ

MOST
COMMENTED

    Edit
  1. The Terrorists Among Us
  2. Is There a Palin Doctrine?
  3. The Real Shock of Fort Hood
  4. 5 Things to Be Thankful For This Year
  5. Planet Slum
TODAY | PAST WEEK

MOST
READ

MOST
COMMENTED

    Edit
  1. Nobel Peace Prize Also-Rans
  2. Edward Burtynsky's Oil
  3. Think Again: God
  4. Bolivia's Lithium-Powered Future
  5. Planet Slum
TODAY | PAST WEEK

MOST
READ

MOST
COMMENTED

  1. Is There a Palin Doctrine?
  2. Afghanistan Is Not Making Americans Safer
  3. The Real Shock of Fort Hood
  4. Hollow Victory
  5. Planet Slum
TODAY | PAST WEEK

MOST
READ

MOST
COMMENTED

  1. The President, the Professor, and the Wide Receiver
  2. Is There a Palin Doctrine?
  3. The Real Shock of Fort Hood
  4. The Only Hope Left?
  5. The Terrorists Among Us
Edit
Edit
  • NET EFFECT

    Why are people creating Facebook profiles for Holocaust victims?

    BY EVGENY MOROZOV

  • PASSPORT

    North Africa's escalating soccer war

    BY JOSHUA KEATING

  • ARGUMENT

    How the Chinese media covered Obama's visit

    BY WILLIAM MOSS

  • SMALL WARS

    The U.S. and Pakistan are heading for a bad breakup

    BY ROBERT HADDICK

  • DANIEL DREZNER

    Time's not-so-shocking Obamaland expose

  • BEST DEFENSE

    What would George Marshall think of today's generals?

    BY THOMAS E. RICKS

  • SHADOW GOVT.

    What does containing North Korea actually mean?

    BY JAMIE FLY

  • THE CABLE

    How the Chinese government censored Obama's visit

    BY JOSH ROGIN



Edit
  • 1. Aligning on Afghanistan? President Obama and PM Brown Turn Focus on Exit Strategy
  • 2. R.I.P.: Russia to Continue Ban on the Death Penalty
  • 3. All for One: Jailed Fatah Leader Implores Palestinian Unity
  • 4. Global Warming Time Out: Stagnating Temperatures Baffle Climate Experts
 See All Photo Essays
    Edit
  • Planet slum: From Nairobi to Caracas, Mumbai, and Jakarta

  • Falling Like It's 1989

Edit
November/December 2009
  • Feature

    Revolution in a Box

  • Feature

    Plague, by Robin Cook

  • Opening Gambit

    My Plan to Overthrow the Mullahs

  •  See Entire Issue

     Preview Digital Edition

Edit
  • How to score chicks on the Disney Channel.
  • Stupid drug story of the week: NBC's Today show discovers huffing.
  • Slate writers and editors debate the ramifications of new cancer-screening guidelines.
Edit
  • Ron Paul Wins Lifelong Fight, Now May Be Forced To Vote Against Everything He Believes
  • Wonk Watch 11.20.09
  • BW Maneker TAP 1 promo
Edit
  • What Would the Pilgrims Say About Tofu?
  • What Kobe, LeBron and Dwyane Owe Spencer Haywood
  • What Kobe, LeBron and Dwyane Owe Spencer Haywood

About FP: Meet the Staff | Foreign Editions | Reprint Permissions | Advertising | Corporate Programs | Writers’ Guidelines | Press Room | Work at FP

Services: Subscription Services | Academic Program | FP Archive | Reprint Permissions | FP Reports and Merchandise | Special Reports | Buy Back Issues

Subscribe to FP | Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | RSS Feeds | Contact Us

FP Logo


1899 L Street NW, Suite 550 | Washington, DC 20036 | Phone: 202-728-7300 | Fax: 202-728-7342
FOREIGN POLICY is published by the Slate Group, a division of Washingtonpost.Newsweek Interactive, LLC
All contents ©2009 Washingtonpost.Newsweek Interactive, LLC. All rights reserved.