Calm Down, Chávez

War-mongering Venezuela is stirring up trouble down south again. But will he really go to war with Colombia this time around?

BY MICHAEL SHIFTER | NOVEMBER 10, 2009

Hugo Chávez's Sunday TV and radio program Aló Presidente is not exactly known for its brevity or reassuring tone. The Venezuelan president's chief communications vehicle -- the 21st century, socialist version of FDR's notably less incendiary "fireside chats" -- often signals his preferred next steps in the 11th year of his grandiose "Bolivarian" reformation of the country. 

So it was cause for concern when Chávez used last Sunday's program to declare in his characteristically combative style, "Let's not waste a day in our main aim to prepare for war and help the people prepare for war." In a politically unsettled and polarized South America, where arms purchases have nearly doubled over the past five years, reaching almost $50 billion last year, could his Venezuela be the spark needed to light a conflict?

The target of Chávez's ominous warning is Colombia, Venezuela's Andean neighbor. The two countries are deeply interconnected; they share a porous and increasingly combustible border and have had a trade relationship worth upwards of $7 billion. Chávez and Colombian president Álvaro Uribe (now entering his eighth year in office) are at opposite ends of the ideological spectrum and have long mistrusted one another. They have similar take-charge styles of governing, which has made relations even testier and the two leaders' occasional compromises all the more impressive.

But Chávez's war talk has now escalated tensions between the countries to a whole new level. The bilateral relationship had already taken a sharp turn for the worse, when Chávez decided in August to close the border to Colombian manufactured goods, preferring instead to buy from Brazil. Exports dropped 50 percent the following month. And while the shutdown is not airtight, the clampdown has hurt; Colombia was Venezuela's second-largest trading partner. Not only has the commercial relationship suffered, but, for the first time, there have been deaths -- at least a dozen -- on both sides of the border. Massive deportations have sent Colombians back home, and arrests of accused spies have exacerbated the diplomatic spat. Even before the crisis erupted Sunday, Chávez had ordered some 15,000 troops to the border.

The sources of the mistrust run both ways. Uribe is convinced that Chávez is providing support to the leftist FARC insurgency, which has been seeking to topple the Colombian government since the 1960s. And, though less plausibly, Chávez is just as confident that Colombia, with ample and sustained military support from the United States -- and particularly a recently unveiled 10-year agreement to give the United States access to seven Colombian bases for counterinsurgency and anti-narcotics operations -- poses a threat to Venezuela's security and therefore must be resisted. Chávez's worst nightmare is that the Yankees are coming.

So for Chávez, the threat from the United States (acting through the proxy of Colombia, he believes) justifies an arms buildup. He is determined to protect Venezuela from a possible invasion launched by the "imperio" (empire) to his north, however improbable that prospect may be. Since 2005, Chávez has bought between $5 billion and $7 billion in military equipment from Russia, including tanks and advanced anti-aircraft missiles. Cuban President Fidel Castro, Chávez's mentor, has also weighed in on the U.S.-Colombia nexus, alleging in a Nov. 6 newspaper column that the base accord is equivalent to the annexation of Colombia by the United States.

Both Bogotá and Washington have been trying to control the considerable political fallout since the base agreement was leaked in August. Suspicions of U.S. military motives remain, not only in Caracas, but throughout the continent. South America's strong reaction could have been averted with some diplomatic groundwork, such as prior, high-level consultations with natural allies like Brazil. But the Obama administration had apparently miscalculated how big an effect such seemingly narrow questions can have in the hemisphere.

PABLO COZZAGLIO/AFP/Getty Images

 

Michael Shifter is vice president for policy and director of the Andean program at the Inter-American Dialogue.

Facebook|Twitter|Reddit

WINTERKO

8:59 PM ET

November 10, 2009

Chavez's Bluff

This guy is bluffing. Obviously he is trying to draw attention and transfer local attention since he's afraid of fellow Honduras ousted Manual Zelaya. Chavez will be over soon. He and his friend Putin are really good at wasting national revenue earned from natural resources. Latin Americans, Asians, Russians and Africans will always be underdogs as long as they don't change their mindsets. Chavez is digging his own grave. He'll follow fate of Pinochet.

 

SOULBOY

10:07 PM ET

November 10, 2009

Not surprising

The good ol' democracy lovin' US attempted to depose the democratically elected Chavez in a Coup in 2002 and now the US are going to open military bases in the neighbouring country. Its hardly surprising that they would feel threatened. That said seeing as the US is tied up in two occupations in the middle east it would be surprising if it attempted a third.

 

DABASTES

11:43 PM ET

November 10, 2009

Monster At Work...

So it seems that Chavez has finally created an argument pro war against Colombia. The excuse seems tangible, real and threatening-! Those Yanks will use Colombian bases as a decoy for invading Venezuela and take over South America in its entirety. Problem is, the extended agreement between the US and Colombia does not actually add anything new to Colombia-US military relations, or not much anyway, also, the military build-up Venezuela has been pursuing is not new and has never been justifiable, nuclear enrichment programs with Iran and Russia are not new either, and support for FARC guerrillas is well known and has been for years... Chavez' rhetoric on South American invasion are real, but I would not fear the USA, I would however very much fear the greed for power and "Bolivarian" expansion expressed by Chavez. Lets not forget he has already taken over Bolivia and Ecuador, not quite, but yes really!.

 

BLONDONI@YAHOO.COM

12:30 AM ET

November 11, 2009

Chavez not real

Chavez is trying to show his muscles, and let the world know that he has new weapons to test. Unfortunately, given the current pretext of US military bases, Colombia might be the target for his arm test.

 

JERRYD

1:24 PM ET

November 11, 2009

Bluffing

Chavez is just trying to deflect his incompetence at delivering services at home which he is losing fast as everyone sees just how bad things are getting.

And Chavez was caught red handed financing, supplying arms to the FARC to attack Columbia which shows the authors bias.

Chavez like all socialists will fall of their own devices, he just entering they final stage where his incompetence leads to his downfall. He will be gone at the next election.

 

ANDREAMARIANA

5:15 PM ET

November 11, 2009

Hmmm...

Just how unlikely is it that the USA will try to interfere in a foreign country for economic purposes? I wonder..... Because its never happened before like, ever, in the history of the world there has not even been a single coup financed by the States. No! No way!

 

SPOOD

6:09 PM ET

November 12, 2009

Chavez would get pasted in a war with Colombia

One has to keep this in mind when it comes to a conflict between both countries. Despite Venezuela's military expenditures, its military has zero practical experience in the field and its training is questionable. Venezuelan military personnel haven't fired a shot in anger against anything resembling an armed foe in decades, possibly a century.

Colombia on the other hand has experienced hands in the field after 40+ years of near civil war conditions dealing with their various insurgents. You can't tell me that Venezuelan parade ground conscripts can come close to the level of ferocity of narcotrafficante mercenaries, Maoist fanatics and ornery paramilitaries.

Add to the fact that Chavez is not exactly Mr. Popular with his own people now, such a foolhardy and mostly likely disastrous military venture will probably result in an ouster by a PO'ed general or colonel.