They Killed My Lawyer

A story of Putin's Russia.

BY WILLIAM BROWDER | DECEMBER 22, 2009

In mid-October 2007, we got a telephone call from a bailiff at the St. Petersburg Arbitration Court inquiring about a judgment against one of the fund's Russian companies. It was a strange call because the company had never been to court and we knew nothing about any lawsuits or judgments in St. Petersburg.

We called Sergei right away and asked him to look into this call. After researching the situation, he came back to us with shocking news. He discovered that our investment companies had been sued by shell companies that we had never done any business with based on forged and backdated contracts. He also discovered that the fund's companies had been represented by lawyers that the fund had never hired, and who proceeded to plead guilty to all the liabilities in the forged contracts. As a result, the fund's companies were hit with court judgments for hundreds of millions of dollars. On top of that, the fund's companies had been fraudulently re-registered in the name of a company owned by a man convicted of manslaughter.

Most shockingly, when Sergei analyzed the forgeries and fraudulent re-registrations, he was able to prove that they could have only been executed with the documents seized from our offices by the Moscow Interior Ministry.

On the back of Sergei's discoveries, in early December 2007, we filed six 255-page complaints outlining all the details of the frauds and the names of the police officers involved. The complaints were filed with the heads of the three main law enforcement agencies in Russia. However, instead of investigating, they passed the complaints straight back to the specific police officers named as conspirators. Those officers then personally initiated retaliatory criminal cases against Hermitage employees.

At this point, Sergei was becoming visibly angry. Sergei wasn't a dispassionate lawyer like many we have encountered in the past. He was our advocate in the truest sense of the word.

By the summer of 2008 it still wasn't clear why the police would be involved in such a complicated scam against us. If the intention was to steal the fund's assets in Russia, they had failed because, by the time our companies were stolen, the assets had been safely moved outside the country.

To help us find the answer, Sergei sent out more than 50 letters to different tax authorities and registration offices requesting information on our stolen companies. Almost no one replied, but on June 5, 2008, Sergei received a letter that broke the case wide open.

AFP/GETTY IMAGES

 SUBJECTS: RUSSIA, EASTERN EUROPE
 

William Browder is the founder and CEO of Hermitage Capital Management, which was once the largest investment firm in Russia.

SONYTECH

3:35 PM ET

December 24, 2009

Heart breaking

One of the most heart breaking stories I have read on FP.com. I hope something can be done to help Sergi's family and to get posthomumorus justice on his behalf in some form. Please continue fighting for his cause and know that I support him and your efforts.
Best,
Gabriel

 

XIAOJUN982711

10:24 PM ET

December 24, 2009

Shocking!

I'm very sad about this story.In China,similiar cases are even more,and I don't know when the real democracy,freedom and justice will fall upon China.

 

DA BUFFALO AMONGST WOLVES

2:18 AM ET

December 25, 2009

It happens

A travesty, but truth be told it happens to 'unknowns' in US prisons ALL the time.

I won't even bother pointing you to the references Tom... They're quite easy to find.

Medical oversights by overworked staff, mis-medication... A suicide due to inhumane conditions of a prisoner sentenced in Idaho who died in a private Texas prison is one that got some media attention a couple of years ago... His sheets hadn't been changed-out for a year or two either. Corporate cost-cutting at it's finest.

The US is also the highest per-capita, OR raw numbers imprisoner of it's citizens as well.

California, the state I live in is STILL stonewalling a federal court order on IT''S overcrowded condition.

I could go on.

 

VONILAN

2:01 PM ET

December 26, 2009

Really?

Medical oversights? Overcrowding? Corporate cost-cutting?

I'm sorry, but the issues you describe completely miss the point of this article. American prisoners, regardless of the conditions they are subject to, are still imprisoned after being subject to legal processes. The issue at stake here really isn't how bad the prisons in Russia are, but the blatant disregard for rule of law Russian authorities have displayed. The fact that the Russian government was implicitly involved in the attempted takeover of a business is bad enough, but when an innocent citizen's life is taken simply because he attempts to stand against injustice, that is a true violation of the respect for human rights we have come to expect from a developed nation in the 21st century.

I could even argue against the supposedly bad conditions of American prisons as compared to Russian ones, but I won't. The real tragedy here is not that Sergei was treated badly in prison; the tragedy is that he was treated badly even though he did the right thing.

 

RKERG

2:33 AM ET

December 25, 2009

Russia is a thugocracy

Russia is a thugocracy. There is no rule of law. Journalists have been getting murdered for turning up dirt on corrupt officials, and it is not unusual for foreign companies to have their assets taken. With all this being common
knowledge, I am somewhat amazed at the naivete of the author of this article and his poor lawyer.

 

GPSADVOCATE

2:35 AM ET

December 25, 2009

So Sad....

The thing about this story is, that yes, Sergei was truly a very very diligent, ambitious, and pro justice man. It is so sad to hear about his stroy, one of the saddest stories of the ending of a life Ive ever known....

Yes, while maybe the commenter above me says "it happens", id like to see someone he knows have that happen.

In the day and age we live in this is so unacceptable. They shouldve just assasinated him, just like the Russian agent Alexander litvinenko in london three years ago who was going to release corruption and scandalous information. At least then this poor man, no this hero, wouldnt have died and suffered in such a way. to Have so many people follow his trail and to fight for him.

Mr. Browder, i think another good way to get Sergeis case on the global populus' attention would have been Facebook, and Tv channels.
It would have created a global movement for his cause possibly. Just like the Newsweek journalist Maziar Bahari who was held in a prison in solitary confinement and tortured in Iran without having done anything wrong. It was the media movement, TV, facebook that got him out and he lived to tell his story to Fareed Zakaria on GPS.

This story is truly so sad, i admire Mr. Sergei Magnitski for his vigilance, bravery, and honor. God does not forgive those who take lives in this manner, those who are responsible will one day get what is coming for them, and Sergei will get his vengeance.

My heart goes out to Sergei family, and their terrible loss.

 

RKERG

8:45 PM ET

December 27, 2009

Nope

I didn't say that "it happens", what I said was that the actions taken
by the attorney were well documented to be VERY RISKY in RUSSIA
which is a THIRD WORLD COUNTRY with nukes. Closer to Zimbabwe than Sweden if you get my drift.

 

JIM6363

8:16 PM ET

December 26, 2009

terrible

I am sorry to hear of this, however, it happens worldwide. In this case the author notes that they had rescued their assets therefore I feel the lawyer and his family could have gotten out of country to continue the fight before he was arrested. I am currently serving four years of felony probation for not keeping my mouth shut when an oil company decided to put in a natural gas well across the street from my house. I called the cops when they climbed my fence without permission to survey, I called when my mailbox was destroyed thrice, I called when they threatened to kill my dogs in my yard and I called when one of their trucks ran me off the road. One night after midnight the cops pulled up when I went out to see what was up I immediately was told face down on the ground or we will shoot, I was cuffed then one of them walked to my fence and threatened to shoot my dogs if they did not shut up. I told them if they killed my dogs you best kill me also or I will kill you both. Wrong thing to say it just came out before I thought. According to their report they had gotten a call that someone was in my yard threatening to throw rocks at one of the oil company employees as he left the site across the street in a pick-up. As the officers explained to me later and then my so called public defender I am a disabled US veteran who pays minimal taxes where as this oil company has drilled six wells in this area and pay a lot to the local government so keep your mouth shut. I am now a felon who threatened cops while lying face down handcuffed in my own driveway. Money talks service to country or honesty counts for nothing.

 

KOSIPOV

9:38 PM ET

December 26, 2009

>>It is also a story about

>>It is also a story about how Stalinism and the gulags are alive and well in Russia today.

It is difficult to convey the depth of my disgust after reading the above sentence from the first paragraph of the article. I share both Russian and Jewish heritages and to my dismay I frequently encounter writings that belittle the history of Holocaust. In comparison, Stalinism and gulags are less known to the Western audience and it is much easier for opportunistic and agenda driven writers to use events of 1930s Soviet Union to scare uninformed and impressionable readers. It is just as despicable to use Holocaust as Stalinist atrocities to score points against political opponents. A death of a single lawyer behind bars or the deaths of numerous enemies of the modern Russian state should never be compared to systematic killing of millions of innocent people.

Foreign Policy magazine editors should resign for allowing to publish drivel hurtful to lives of so many people.

 

TRAVELLER42

12:53 AM ET

December 29, 2009

Well said, KOSIPOV

I share your disgust with those who compare the events of 1930s Soviet Union with Putin's Russia today. I have visited Russia five times and spoken with many Russians about Putin. Putin has huge support among the population - something like an 80% approval rating last time I checked. So to suggest that Russia today resembles the Russia of the 1930s is absurd in the extreme. I can only suspect that Foreign Policy magazine is criticizing Putin every chance they get because Putin effectively pulled the oil and gas concessions that had been awarded to American and British oil companies (concessions that every Russian I have spoken to was thoroughly convinced were awarded as a result of bribery of government officials).

Russia has very serious issues with its governance - but it is far from a Stalinist dictatorship. In addition to the US governments civil rights abuses of Khalid El-Masri raised by the commentator above, there is this "top 10 civil liberties violations of 2006" list compiled by Dahlia Lithwick of Slate: http://www.slate.com/id/2156397/

Perhaps FP magazine would like to do a fact based comparison of the civil rights abuses perpetrated by Putin with those perpetrated by G. W. Bush? No, I think they will instead stick with writing slanted and sensationalist articles like the one above.

 

RADBADGER

7:31 PM ET

December 27, 2009

Alexander Solzhenitsyn

A. S. was in some of these places mentioned in which conditions have only worsened since Cathryn The Great and Tzar Nicholus ran things. The Gulag is a beast so large and long that it may never be stopped. What is poignant for U. S citizens to me is how slowly but surely our system is becoming legally in line with the Russian one. The confess to one charge or be faced with ten is'nt quite as bad as confess or endure torture, but it is getting there. Private ownership of prisons and expanded legalization of using prisoners as a work force is what the system in Russia was based. As our dominate corporate culture strengthens demand for free labor might easily be something we will be encountering more than we are already. Our hero who as just passed on in the Russian holding cells was fighting all of our battle against corporate gangsterism which is a world wide scourage.

 

KOOLAU

11:23 PM ET

December 27, 2009

War

Why don't we bomb the Kremlin with Putin and his lackeys in them? I know that would start a war, but if we can cut the head off, I'm pretty sure we could destroy their army, navy and air force.

The US doesn't need to occupy, just rain terror and destruction indiscriminately to cause mass chaos, rioting, disease and zombie infestation.

Once the zombies appear, entire cities will be eaten and then the Chinese can clean it up and make more toys for our children.

 

NKT

8:17 AM ET

December 28, 2009

3arabsoft

i agree with TRANSTRIST it's the 3arabsoft wrong place guys

 

UZBEKPOLICY

7:29 PM ET

December 28, 2009

Yeah, That's Russia.

Even though I heard about Sergei for the first time, the story itself sounded so much familiar. You can virtually put any name instead of Sergei's and it still will be true because this is how The System in Russia works -- hell, a slice of stale bread and hell again.

That's KGB's Russia, that's Putin's Russia, it hasn't changed a bit since the collapse of the Soviet empire. Nor did many other ex-Soviet countries. Take Uzbekistan, for example, lawyers, journalists or simply truth-loving citizens are being subjected to EXACTLY the same routines in pre-detention everyday. This is a Soviet heritage that became a norm for the law enforcement in these countries.

It's like what one of my former Russian professors said (only half-joking) while taking an oral examination on criminal procedural law class -- "if I stick to the protocol, I would have to beat you in your livers to obtain the needed confession from you, my dear."

With Love from Russia.

 

UZBEKPOLICY

8:20 PM ET

December 28, 2009

correction

the professor said "...to obtain the answers", not "confession". But I think he meant both.

 

MANYAKPISCO

12:36 PM ET

January 15, 2010

are reported to be

are reported to be missing.

Because Sergei is no longer ali-indirmeden izle-inndir-albüm indir-liseli kizlar-sex-firikik-yesilcam pornosu-anal sikis-macini izle-full indir-canli sikis--uzun pornolar----full porno indir-----18lik porno--canli porno kanallari--ve to tell his story, I feel it is my duty to tell it for him. I am not a writer or a journalist, but a fund manager at Hermitage Capital Management. I ran what was thünlü pornosu-
xvideos--vidyo---">günlükfilm----ünlü pornosu-
-----
e largest investment fund in Russia. Sehemsire sikisrgei was our Moscow-based outside counsel who worked for the American law firm Firestone Duncan.

Sergei wasn't involved in politics, he wasn't an oligarch, and he wasn't a human rights activist. He was just a highly competent professional -- the kind of person one could call up as the workday was finishing at 7 p.m. with a legal question and he would cancel his dinner plans and stay in the office until midnight to figure out the answer. He was a smart and honest man working hard to better himself and to make a good life for his wife a