Epiphanies: Ashraf Ghani

Afghanistan's first postwar finance minister has now set his sights on reforming the country from the ground up, calling out his former boss, President Hamid Karzai, for corruption and failure. Here, the poetry-loving Pashtun speaks with FP about his troubled homeland's past and future.

INTERVIEW BY DAVID KENNER | JANUARY/FEBRUARY 2010

I remember touring Afghanistan with my wife back in 1975, '76, and '77 -- there was this immense hospitality about the Afghan people. It was an Islamic culture, but they practiced an incredibly tolerant version of Islam. It was nothing like what exists in parts of Afghanistan today.

The nouveaux riches, as I call them -- the warlords who currently rule Afghanistan -- are a relatively new phenomenon. They rose to power essentially because of the CIA. And they brought with them a totally different way of ruling Afghanistan, which really obscured many of the best qualities of Afghanistan.

Dean Acheson is a figure that I admire greatly, even though I think he's sometimes forgotten in America. He was integral to building the Marshall Plan, even though George Marshall gets much of the credit. Deng Xiaoping in China is also very important. People talk of Mao Zedong, who attempted these Great Leaps Forward -- but whenever he attempted one, tens of millions would die or be impoverished. Deng really took China in a totally different direction, with profound consequences.

Pashtuns are fiercely individualistic, and they are very proud. No Pashtun will ever admit that another Pashtun is his natural superior. So what you always have is competition for leadership, and in these competitions someone must win. It could be a young man, or it could be an old greybeard -- but the key notion is that, once the competition is over, both the winners and the losers should be deserving of respect.

Illustration for FP by JOSEPH CIARDIELLO

 SUBJECTS: AFGHANISTAN, SOUTH ASIA
 

Ashraf Ghani is chairman of the Institute for State Effectiveness. David Kenner is an assistant editor at Foreign Policy.

GRANT

7:48 PM ET

January 4, 2010

An intelligent man, but I'm

An intelligent man, but I'm not sure what he's trying to get at.

 

DI MENG

8:33 PM ET

January 20, 2010

Sounds like he's just

Sounds like he's just reminiscing about the past. Doesn't have much to say about how exactly to return to that wholesome Afghanistan of his memory.

 

DAVID KENNER

6:19 PM ET

January 21, 2010

If it appears that way

If it appears that way, that's my fault, not Dr. Ghani's.  This interview was done for our "Epiphanies" feature, which tries to get our subjects' reflections on broader historical trends, or lessons they've learned during their life, rather than particular policy suggestions tied to the current events of the day.

So, you should rest assured that Ghani has plenty of ideas on how to fix Afghanistan's current mess -- but that simply didn't happen to be what I asked him about. As I remember it, we talked at length about what books he was reading, and why it's so hard to learn Pashtun!