Dead or Alive?

Five world leaders who may or may not still be with us.

BY JOSHUA E. KEATING | FEBRUARY 4, 2010

HAKIMULLAH MEHSUD

Location: Pakistan

Last appearance: Last video released Jan. 9. Audiotape released Jan. 16.

The evidence: U.S. drones have had a number of near misses with the Pakistani Taliban leader, who generally releases a videotape after a failed strike to taunt his pursuers. But after drone strikes aimed at Mehsud on Jan. 14 and 17, White House officials say they are "95 percent" sure that he was killed. The Taliban denies that Mehsud was killed but has offered little proof -- only a short audiotape. They have declined to provide further evidence of Mehsud's existence, saying they don't want to make him vulnerable to spies. However, reports indicate that the Taliban leadership recently met to choose Mehsud's successor. There have also been secondhand reports that a funeral was held for him last week. Despite the contrary evidence, at the time of this writing the Taliban continues to maintain that Mehsud is alive. "All the reports regarding his death are propaganda," a spokesman told CNN.

If he was indeed killed, he would be the second Pakistani Taliban leader -- after his predecessor Baitullah Mehsud -- to meet his maker in only six months.

Update: The Taliban confirmed Mehsud's death on Feb. 9.

A Majeed/AFP/Getty Images, PIUS UTOMI EKPEI/AFP/Getty Images, STR/AFP/Getty Images, AFP/Getty Images, AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS:
 

Joshua E. Keating is associate editor at Foreign Policy.

Facebook|Twitter|Reddit

PBKONING

3:36 AM ET

February 5, 2010

Kim Jong-Il error

Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't Kim Jong-Il appear in public when meeting with Bill Clinton and his "rescue" delegation in August 2009??

 

TONTI

9:14 AM ET

February 5, 2010

Slumbering Sharon

Surely Ariel Sharon, even in a vegetative coma, deserves inclusion in this ghostly pantheon?

 

JACOB BLUES

12:08 PM ET

February 5, 2010

Sharon shouldn't be included in the page

Sharon was replaced by Olmert following the stroke, and later, Olmert was listed as Kadima's party head in the subsequent election. Sharon wasn't even on Kadima's MK list during not just the subsequent election, but in 2009, there was a second election which brought Likud to power.

At this point in time, Kadima isn't even in the governing coalition.

So no, Ariel Sharon, while in a coma, holds no governmental position in Israel.

 

TONTI

3:28 PM ET

February 5, 2010

"Five world leaders who may or may not still be with us. "

Holding current "governmental position" seems not to be the criteria for several of the Gang of Five "who may or may not still be with us." I was being facetious, JB.

Tonti

 

NAZIA

12:03 PM ET

February 7, 2010

Rule wihtout rules

Super power has destroyed three countries in search of WMD and these stone age warriors.
Millions have been killed and billion dollars have been spent and still they are missing.
The super powers can see water traces in mars but cant find wanted ex CIA agents living in mountains lying on earth.
Conclusion of all annual efforts.
These cave men still have an edge on US technology and military strategy.

 

GRANT

10:18 PM ET

February 7, 2010

I'm not quite certain how

I'm not quite certain how that relates to the topic, and despite common assumptions I don't know of any scholar or ex-spy who has provided confirmation or evidence that Osama bin Laden ever came into contact with the CIA. Hekmatyar is another matter.

 

BLUND

6:07 PM ET

February 11, 2010

all right

At this point in time, Kadima isn't even in the governing coalition.
sex videolar