Dagestan: Russia's Most Overlooked Hot Spot

Why the coming weeks will only get more dangerous for the troubled North Caucasus Republic.

BY GREGORY ZALASKY | FEBRUARY 9, 2010

On Feb. 8, Russian President Dmitry Medvedev selected a new president for the troubled North Caucasus republic of Dagestan. The lead-up to the selection was marked by an uptick in violence, and the political controversy surrounding the choice is likely to lead to even further instability.

When the international media reports on the instability in Russia's North Caucasus at all, reporters tend to focus on the violent chaos in Ingushetia and the repressive governance in Chechnya. But it is recent trends in Dagestan -- Russia's most ethnically diverse province -- that most threaten to further inflame this volatile region. Medvedev's selection of Magomedsalam M. Magomedov, a vocal critic of Dagestan's current government, is seen by many as an admission that the region's problems are spiraling out of control. And this month's events might finally put this volatile flashpoint on the world's agenda.

Historically, violence in Dagestan has stemmed from ongoing conflicts between its major ethnic groups -- the Avars, Dargins, Kumyks, Lezgins, and Laks -- over political power, resources, and jobs. More recently, Islamist militant groups, such as Shariat Jamaat, have forged close ties with Chechen separatists to launch terrorist attacks against the government in an effort to unite Muslims across the North Caucasus. Islamist militants have also taken advantage of Dagestan's high unemployment rate and staggering corruption (even by Russian standards) to actively recruit youth in the republic.

In late 2009, Islamist militants and criminal gangs, often described in the media as neizvestniye, or "unknown [assailants]," frequently attacked government officials, religious leaders, and police, as well as the republic's energy and transportation infrastructure. Electricity blackouts sparked protests in the capital city of Makhachkala, and residents in the town of Derbent witnessed mayoral elections so corrupt that officials overturned the results (a rarity in Putin-era Russia).

Due to changes in the provincial electoral process, Dagestan's People's Assembly must now rubber-stamp the choice made by Medvedev and officials from his United Russia party. Despite the lack of direct elections, the political process in Dagestan has been overtly contentious and punctuated by political violence, a lack of confidence in Moscow, and a transparently corrupt electoral process at the local level, as evidenced by a judge's decision to nullify October's mayoral election results in Derbent.

The murder of Interior Minister Adilgerei Magomedtagirov last year exemplifies how political figures have recently become targets of violence. Observers viewed Magomedtagirov as a potential challenger to the rule of incumbent President Mukhu Aliyev, who has governed Dagestan since 2006. On June 5, snipers shot and killed him as he stepped outside during a wedding in Makhachkala, and authorities still have not apprehended any suspects. In the run-up to the presidential selection, attacks and threats against political figures and institutions continued. On Jan. 13 and 14, authorities shut down central Makhachkala due to a threat of a terrorist attack against several prominent locations, including the presidential administration building and Dagestan's Supreme Court. Two weeks later, unknown assailants shot at the motorcade of Nikolai Alchiyev, deputy chairman of Dagestan's People's Assembly.

Adding to the threat of political violence, there is also an unusually low level of confidence in Russian leaders, and particularly United Russia's selection of election candidates. On Nov. 26, Dagestan's legislature passed a motion asking Medvedev to hold further "consultations" about the most suitable candidate. The motion was an unusual public riposte against United Russia's regional governance. Some politicians' open dissatisfaction with the process led to a rumor that Dagestan's branch of United Russia planned a mass exodus from the party, but regional representatives have since denied all rumors of a potential split.

ABDULA MAGOMEDOV/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS:
 

Gregory Zalasky is a senior analyst on the Emerging Threats Project at Georgetown University's Imaging Science and Information Systems Center, which is funded by the Director of National Intelligence Open Source Center.

Facebook|Twitter|Reddit

NORBOOSE

11:06 AM ET

February 10, 2010

What Should Happen and What Will Happen

I agree with the author that Russia's first step should be to admit it has a problem. But in the long run, its only solution to problems like these is for it to stop relying on onetime massive force actions. I understand you cannot simply switch to diplomacy when war is already going on, but Russia needs to end its bad policy habits. Russia has three. It responds to domestic and minor threats with force. It responds to threats from medium sized states with belligerence. It responds to threats from major powers with brinksmanship. If it does not develop some sense of resatraint and subtlety it is doomed to collapse into failure or transform into an absolute dictatorship.

I really wish Russia would change course, but it wont. Russia will respond with more strongmen, more tanks, more crackdowns, more government control, and more restriction of freedoms. The problem is that most of the Russian people just dont see it and they just dont care. Russias is a history of oppression. Even their great leaders, like Catherine, were monstrous. For Gods sakes, she hacked a man to death in public with a hatchet to serve as an example against the peasents. The only ways we can hope to solve this problem would be to somehow change Russias cultural mindset, which seems unlikely, or to somehow get the United States and China to condemn it. This would be a difficult process, one would have to get US public opinion by exposing Russian atroicities and then somehow get it in Chinas interest to do the same. I know China is also repressive, but its just not the belligerant, war-like threat to humanity that Russia is. Any less external pressure than that will not be enough.

 

MARISSA

3:52 PM ET

February 10, 2010

I really wish Russia would

I really wish Russia would change course, but it wont. Russia will respond with more strongmen, more tanks, more crackdowns, more government control, and more restriction of freedoms.
faceimyok
amdan
sinirsiztv
hhtr

 

RYAN PRICE

2:25 AM ET

March 10, 2010

Overlooked Hot Spot

Dagestan is a province that is part of the Russian Federation and has been fighting a long struggle of resistance against Russian occupation since the 19th century when the Russians annexed the entire region of the Caucasus Mountains. The lands became part of Russian expansionism that partly made up what became the Soviet Union. Learn about how you can get hemorrhoid relief in less than 2 days from now, pain free, perfectly safe and purely natural external hemorrhoid relief.