Pakistan Plays Ball

The U.S. intelligence community has long viewed Pakistan's military with suspicion, due to its ties to the Afghan Taliban. Following the arrest of Mullah Baradar, the Taliban's second in command, that may finally change.

BY IMTIAZ GUL | FEBRUARY 24, 2010

Since Oct. 7, 2001, when the first U.S. B-52 bombers began bombarding Taliban installations around Kabul, the United States and its allies have been waiting for Pakistan to demonstrate its sincerity in the war being fought on Afghan soil. The arrest of nine Taliban militants in the Pakistani city of Karachi, including the Afghan Taliban's second in command, Mullah Abdul Ghani Baradar, may indicate a fundamental shift in Pakistan's relations with the NATO states fighting in Afghanistan.

Despite former President Pervez Musharraf's repeated public commitment to the war on terror, the U.S. intelligence community has remained wary of its Pakistani interlocutors -- the military and the mighty Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI), Pakistan's main spy agency -- because of their longstanding complicity with Afghanistan's Taliban factions. Its suspicions kept falling on the ISI for allegedly protecting Afghan Taliban leaders such as Mullah Omar, Gulbuddin Hekmatyar, and Sirajuddin Haqqani, the eldest son of veteran jihadist leader Jalaluddin Haqqani.

The arrest of Baradar, known as the Taliban's master strategist, might put an end to these rumors. This success was followed by a deluge of arrests of other Taliban and jihadi leaders, likely on evidence provided by Baradar. These include Ameer Muawiya, an associate of Osama bin Laden responsible for foreign al Qaeda militants in Pakistan's border areas, and Akhunzada Popalzai, also known as Mohammad Younis, a former Taliban shadow governor in Afghanistan's southern Zabul province and ex-police chief of Kabul. Earlier this week, the Pakistani police also picked up Maulvi Kabir, a former governor of Afghanistan's eastern Nangarhar province, from a town about 20 kilometers east of Peshawar.

Pakistan also captured a number of other significant figures in the raid that netted it Baradar. Others captured in Karachi include Hamza, a former Afghan army commander in Helmand province during Taliban rule; Abu Riyad al-Zarqawi, a liaison with Chechen and Tajik militants in Pakistan's border area; and Mullah Abdul Salam and Mullah Mohammad, former shadow governors for Kunduz province and Baghlan province, respectively.

The arrest of over a dozen key Taliban commanders amounts to a serious blow to the insurgency in Afghanistan. Intriguingly, while Pakistani officials claim Baradar was captured in Karachi, some sources insist the arrest took place several days earlier in Baluchistan, the Pakistani southwestern province along the border with Afghanistan. But regardless of where Baradar was picked up, the utility of the intelligence gained from his capture and the motives of Pakistan in going after the Afghan Taliban, this development is significant in many ways.

First, Baradar has become the latest in a long string of Taliban stalwarts captured by Pakistani and U.S. authorities. The ISI, possibly working in conjunction with the CIA, was responsible for the killing of key Taliban commanders Mullah Dadullah and Akhtar Mohammad Osmani in 2006. The 2007 arrest of Mullah Obaidullah, the former Taliban defense minister and Baradar's predecessor, was also apparently the result of a joint operation -- not so different from the arrest, in 2003, of alleged 9/11 mastermind Khalid Sheikh Mohammad. The expanding list of Pakistani successes underscores the ever-increasing army-to-army cooperation and intelligence sharing between the two countries.

Intelligence officials in Islamabad also point to the Feb. 17 drone strike in North Waziristan as further evidence of growing intelligence cooperation between the United States and Pakistan. The attack killed Muhammad Haqqani, the 30-year-old son of Jalaluddin Haqqani and the younger brother of Sirajuddin Haqqani, who is leading the Haqqani network in the area. U.S. officials have long accused Pakistan of protecting the Haqqanis, and this strike could be proof that the two allies are increasingly on the same page on this issue.

Perhaps the most important reason for the improved ties between these two allies is the personal rapport that the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Adm. Mike Mullen and Centcom chief Gen. David Petraeus have cultivated with Pakistani Chief of Army Staff Lt. Gen. Ashfaq Kayani and the head of the ISI, Gen. Ahmed Shuja Pasha.

Since assuming his position as Army Chief from Musharraf in November 2007, Kayani has quietly endeavored to distance himself from his predecessor, relieving Musharraf's allies of sensitive duties and charting a new course in the Army's relationship with the United States. He has increasingly provided U.S. military commanders with operational details and critical information concerning regional developments.

ASIF HASSAN/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: AFGHANISTAN, SOUTH ASIA
 

Imtiaz Gul heads the independent Center for Research and Security Studies in Islamabad. He is the author of Most Dangerous Place: Pakistan's Lawless Frontier, due out in June.

AHSON HASAN

9:30 PM ET

February 24, 2010

Pakistan Plays Ball

Agreed that Pakistan has indeed 'helped' catch innumerable Taliban, the question that still haunts one's mind is why every tom, dick and harry associated with terrorism is 'discovered' from Pakistan?

The good news is that Pakistan will be remembered in world history. The bad news is that it'll be remembered for the wrong reasons! It's all about 'style' and not much substance.

Pakistan does a good job of going through the motions - poses well. When it comes to delivering, it's got little to show.

General Kayani's army and ISI has skeletons in their respective closets. Before he launches an onslaught on the Pakistan antagonists, he needs to understand the dynamics of a rather nasty role that country's military intelligence has played over the past three decades or so.

Pakistan is pushing its luck a bit too much. Kayani should stop acting like a 'hard rocker'. Pakistan has a really small range when it comes to playing a genuinely honest role in international affairs. The country only has a nuisance value and not much else to offer.

If Kayani is really sincere in attacking religious fanatics and stripping them down, he needs to use his charm and shoot where it matters most. He must work together with the neighboring countries and the international community.

If Pakistan needs to ‘pick’ itself from the doldrums and utter shambles, it needs to search and redefine is its role. Questions like, ‘Who are you? What kind of music do you sing best? What is the nature of your personality?’ need to be answered. Challenge yourself. Let the world embrace you. Stop being the ugly religion-crazy hideous nation.

Right now Pakistan is an infection that no one wants to associate it. It’s not up there. It needs to shine more. It has to accept that it can, at best, play a support role rather than the main role.

 

NADEEMS19658

12:05 AM ET

February 25, 2010

PAKISTAN PLAYS BALL

I am shocked at Mr Ahson Hasan’s jaundiced, biased and ignorant take on Pakistan. His portrayal of Pakistan as ugly, religious crazy hideous nation is malignant propaganda spewing out of a putrid mind.

Pakistan is a modern Islamic state suffering and struggling because of its geography. On one side it has Afghanistan where superpowers jostle for power and on the other side it has a hegemonistic India which has occupied the state of Kashmir despite UN resolutions for plebiscite.

Every Tom Dick and Harry associated from terrorism is picked up from Pakistan because the road to Afghanistan travels through Pakistan. Afghanistan does not have a safe airport, roads, hotels, internet, markets, banks and other modern infrastructure, so Pakistan’s modern infrastructure and facilities are used by the good and bad and the ugly.

The border between Pakistan and Afghanistan is as porous and difficult to monitor as U.S Mexico border. If U.S cannot stop Mexicans from coming over, how can a poor country like Pakistan make its border fool proof?

For Mr Hasan’s information, Pakistan is a victim of superpower rivalry. U.S & USSR fought their bloody battle in the fields of Afghanistan. Pakistan Army and ISI supported U.S. in their battle to stop communism in its track. After handing Russia a crushing defeat through Mujahideen, the U.S conveniently packed up leaving Pakistan with 3 million refugees to take care of for the longest period of time. Instead of being commended and rewarded for its services, U.S slapped sanctions on Pakistan, thus forcing many people into poverty and fundamentalism and throwing Afghanistan into a civil war.

On the other side of Pakistan, there is a bully called India which has employed state terrorism to control Kashmir with the help of one million plus strong army despite the U.N resolutions to hold Plebiscite in Kashmir.

If U.S can be a respectable country keeping in view its war record on Japan, Vietnam, Cambodia, and Iraq. If India can be respectable country keeping in perspective the state oppression and state terrorism unleashed in occupied Kashmir. Then Mr Hassan needs to revise his definition of respectability.

Now that U.S. will start evacuating from Afghanistan, Pakistan will hold the fort. And the world will need Pakistan to fight for it. So hold on to Pakistan dearly and learn to respect your benefactor.
SINCERELY
NADEEM SHEIKH

 

SHAN

4:38 AM ET

February 25, 2010

Pakistan's role

Mr. Nadeem - you of course have a right to be biased towards what is presumably your country. However, that should not blind you to obvious facts that reveal Pakistan's complicity in several terroristic activities worldwide. There is enough evidence that Pakistan has been supporting and fomentig Taliban violence against the US forces for quite some time now. Neither is it hidden that several terrorist acts in Afghanistan has actually been orchestrated by the ISI e.g. the bombing of the Indian embassy. There are call transcripts that prove the connivance of Pakistan's military establishment. Claiming to be a victim and not perpetrator of terrors in the face of such irrefutable evidence is, frankly, laughable.

That's not all. It is also conclusively proven and admitted by your own government that the that the Bombay attacks were planned and executed from within Pakistan. This time your "innocent" government establishment choose to roll out the canard of "non-state actors" out of the control of the government. It is also a known fact that a man designated as a global terrorist - Dawood Ibrahim - is safely hiding in Karachi as a guest of the Pakistan establishment.

The inescapable conclusions are either a) the Pakistan government is actively encouraging terrorism in Afghanistan and India, or b) The government is so pathetically inept and clueless, that it has no knowledge of any insurgent activities within its territory, even if those are planned by the military establishment.

The fact is that Pakistan is a hotbed of terrorism and militant Islamism - and a failed state, spiraling downwards into an inevitable morass of chaos and militancy. It produces nothing except militants, and only exists because the US chooses to repeatedly fill its (always-extended) begging bowl to further its own geopolitical interests. It has a single point foreign policy agenda - Kashmir - and is driven by a myopic and obsessive Oedipal focus on India. This has cost Pakistan its progress, its credibility, and ultimately, its future.

Proof? India, in spite of being attacked and bombed repeatedly by Pakistan-supported terrorists, generally ignores Pakistan, and thrives economically, culturally and morally. And Pakistan is a hellhole. That is the truth, and I hope it hurts.

 

ARYABHAT

9:38 AM ET

February 25, 2010

Is the world jaundiced or ....?

Just responding to your first paragraph - "I am shocked at Mr Ahson Hasan’s jaundiced, biased and ignorant take on Pakistan. His portrayal of Pakistan as ugly, religious crazy hideous nation is malignant propaganda spewing out of a putrid mind. "

Allow me to start with an example, three highly reputed Pakistanis vented vitriolic religious hatred on air describing India post IPL snub. In a TV show hosted by a lady named Farah - Pakistan's highest paid anchor - the guests were paceman Sohail Tanvir and a journalist named Zahid Farooq Malik. Now, Tanvir became famous, and rich, only after his exploits for Rajasthan Royals in the first edition of the IPL. And here he was, saying on air, 'Hinduon ki zahaniyat hi aisi hai (the Hindu nature is like that only)' while describing the IPL snub.

There was very little condemnation of this event. Can you imagine an Indian cricketer or English footballer or American basketball player making such inane remarks about all Muslims and getting away with it? The media in India, UK or USA would have forced him out - and rightfully so.

Let me give you another example of Lahore lawyers threatening to burn anyone who fights the case of a 12-year-old Christian girl murdered by the ex-head of the Bar association. And Lawyers are projected as the liberal of liberal and protector or Pakistani democracy!

And the mainstream media in Pakistan accepts this as regular behaviour.

The rub is not that such criminal behaviour happens - whether that of Sohail Tanveer or that against the 12-year-old Christian girl (it happens in all countries) - BUT THAT THE ENTIRE COUNTRY, ITS INSTITUTIONS AND ITS MEDIA FIND NOTHING WRONG WITH IT!

So Sir, may be it isn’t the world that has a biased view but perhaps time to you accept Pakistan as ugly, religious crazy hideous nation, in your aptly chosen words.

 

IGNACIO PEREZ DE VARGAS

1:34 AM ET

February 25, 2010

I think many of them have

I think many of them have been so brainwashed by the Mullahs that the only form of "love" they know is love for their faith and ideals. Many of them don't have families as they were taken as children to live away from them - so again - the Taliban is their family.

Ignacio Perez de Vargas

 

ARYABHAT

10:13 AM ET

February 25, 2010

Pakistan Army Playing ball or runnign a Puppet show?

Mr Gul joins here like of Bruce Riedel in singing praise for Pakistan Army.

Yes, There have been some other arrests of middle-level office-bearers of the Afghan Taliban in Karachi. These arrests have been projected by many American analysts, including Bruce Riedel, formerly of the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), as a possible game-changer and indicator of a welcome Pakistani decision to co-operate sincerely with the US against the Afghan Taliban.

However, these projections have not been borne out by reports from well-informed police sources in Karachi, which describe these arrests as a manoeuvre by the ISI to discard the well-identified leaders of the Afghan Taliban and usher in a new leadership consisting of well-motivated and well-trained recruits of recent vintage, who have not yet come to the notice of the US agencies.

Also interesting to note that Mr Gul thinks that for last 9 years Pakistan has been turnign out likes of Ramzi Yousaf when pressure rises but carefully keeping out not just Siraj Haqquani and Quetta shura but conning Amricans and rest of the world that they are cooperating while actually making money from both the ends. Their "retired" Army officers train new crop of fighters in garb of NGOs (funded by donations from Gulf) and existing officers get billions from American tax payers money as aid!

How come EVERY so called big fish that was caught is found NOT from tibal area but from cities like Karachi, Faisalabad, Islamabad etc? Because that is where ISI safe houses are! How come if Pakistan Army is so cooperative, War never ends and we never reach Osama, Zawahari, Omar etc? Pakistani PM says Govt acted in catching Baradar by acting on American intel. How come that American get intelligence about Taliban leaders hiding in Karachi and not the mother of all Pakistani agencies - ISI?

As for Admiral Mullen etc. havign great rapport with Kiyani, lets remember that War is too serious a business to be left to Generals!

Untill US nullify Puppeteer (ISI) - not Puppets (occasional catch of a few mid level Taliban leaders) - this war would just bleed USA in terms of Tax payers money and soldiers blood.

No, Pakistan is NOT playing ball - it is just running a Puppet show for last 9 years.

 

AMJIDIQBAL

1:13 PM ET

February 25, 2010

Pakistan's legatimised intersts

For ARYABHAT. Mr. Aryabhat is trying to show that he has maximum ground information about Pakistan, i am afraid he does not know. As far as concern to protect Afgha Taliban, i am in great favor because Pakistan has legal right to protecrt her interest in Afghanistan after face saving exit of NATO because Pakistan has to counter the influence of India. Now look at indians their whole country is showing picture of slumdog, hundred of thousands of people living under poverty line but indians are spending billion of dollars in Afghansitan when that country is not her immediate neighbor. As far as concern with security situation in india recet moist attack is its evidence. look into Hindu radicalisation, burning of Muslims in Ahmadabad in 2001 and Christains in 2008 is its recent example. If Pakistan is running Puppet show then what india is doing for last 9 years in Afghanistan

 

ANNIESH

12:46 PM ET

February 25, 2010

I think pakistan

I think pakistan is totally with taliban. One side they say that they are protecting the country from taliban attacks, but in real they seem to give protection to them. No one knows the truth behind this. Terrorism will never end if same continues.
Ylod

 

NADEEMS19658

3:19 PM ET

February 25, 2010

Pakistan Plays Ball

On a more sobering thought, I would like to know from those Indian friends who are more level headed and intellectually inclined the following questions.

Can we ever have peace without resolution of Kashmir and Palestine issue?

What do you call someone seeking independence, or removal of foreign forces from its land?

In my opinion as long as there is injustice in the world, there shall be no peace. Every decent human being on both sides of India Pakistan border should listen to his voice of conscience and pray for Justice.

Only Justice can deliver peace and promote happiness.

Love to all
Nadeem