Trouble in Paradise

Welcome to the world's newest narcostate.

BY DORN TOWNSEND | MARCH 11, 2010

Manning has tackled these problems head-on -- claiming he will build "Fortress Trinidad and Tobago," buying helicopters and summoning his security forces. But, unfortunately, the Port of Spain government helps stoke the drug trade and the gangs. The country's annual per capita GDP has risen from about $11,000 to $18,800 in the past decade due to strong exports of natural gas and steel. Still, unemployment remains high, and to create jobs, the government spends about $400 million per year on make-work projects. The bulk of this money is ultimately funneled to gang leaders, who administer "grants" and distribute "salaries." Indeed, corruption -- always a problem in the country -- is reaching new heights. According to several security analysts, a damning unofficial study carried out by the government in 2009 suggested that almost 90 percent of police officers were regularly involved in illegal activities. Those pursuits ranged from running and selling drugs, to colluding with gangs by renting out weapons to criminals, to performing extralegal killings.

Plus, despite Manning's saber rattling, Trinidad and Tobago's security teams have not been terribly effective. Trinidad's security forces have never intercepted a cocaine-carrying fast boat or made a significant bust. In 2005, officers did impound a shipment of cocaine said to be worth $800 million. But this find was accidental. Late one night, officers investigating suspicious lights on a deserted beach literally tripped over the contraband.

Senior intelligence officials cite the lack of arrests as proof that claims that major cartels operate in their country are mistaken. They claim the allegations are the invention of local muckracking reporters. Residents and workers on offshore oil rigs near those drug channels disagree. According to one foreign oil worker, so many fast boats cruise toward Trinidad's sheltered coves that "It's like the Normandy invasion." A few years ago, Trinidad purchased a sophisticated new 360-degree radar system. According to one senior official, the government has yet to turn it on. Another analyst disputes this, saying the problem is that too few staff members understand how to use the radar technology.

Thus, whether or not Manning is effective in protecting Trinidad and Tobago from drugs and guns from overseas, it is clear he needs just as badly to tackle problems at home. To do so, he needs help -- and international supervision. A coalition of governments -- including the United States and Britain, whose navies patrol the region -- should step in to help patrol the lane between Trinidad and Venezuela. Training should also be supplied to Trinidad's Coast Guard so it can vigorously pursue smugglers. With its new navy, the largest in the English-speaking Caribbean, Trinidad may be able to fill a real void in detecting cocaine smuggling. But it has to secure its own borders first and purge its security forces of corrupt members. Until Trinidad gets serious about this, the United States should disinvite the country from regional security dialogues. With its wealth and strategic location, Trinidad and Tobago is a natural partner. Yet these countries would be wise to make sure that they do not let the fox guard the henhouse.

TED ALJIBE/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: LATIN AMERICA
 

Dorn Townsend is a freelance reporter. He recently led an investigation into guns, drugs, and governance in Trinidad and Tobago for the Small Arms Survey, a Geneva-based think tank.

TEKAREY

7:54 PM ET

March 12, 2010

Getting your Facts Right Mr. Townsend!

Now I appreciate a good story as the next when they consist of facts and not just assumptions and make believe.

I live in the twin island of Trinidad and Tobago more specifically I reside in Trinidad, in east Trinidad as a matter of fact.

I 400% disagree with the statement that Trinidad is as bad as or violent as Johannesburg or Baghdad. For one in those places there is civil unrest and there are bombings and killings daily. It is unsafe to walk about or even use public transportation. Where as in Trinidad, while there may be murders daily, 99% of them are gang related and there is the rare occurance of family fighting eachother , and friends falling out and killing eachother and maybe the occassional robbery.

This is a far cry from Baghdad and Johannesburg! The Trini culture is typically about having a good time all year round and partying! So it is unfair and unjust when you cast into a catergory that does not suit us therefore tarnish our name in the world's eyes. For those who do not know better they will really think we are a country of disorder, chaos and extreme violence , when we are truly not.

The few in our society, in our nation are in the minority less than 2% of our 1.3 million population is the ones that commit these crimes. And it is a fact that they hardly ever involve innocent by standers unless they are a means to end or linked to their rivals in one way or another.

If we were so bad Mr. Townsend why would foreigners flock from all around the world year after year to come be part of the greatest show on earth, (Carnival)! Why would people throughout the Caribbean and Latin America, The African States, Middle East, Asia, Europe and North American come to live here??
When you come experience the REAL Trinidad and Tobago for a few monts then you can write about our "tiny" island with supposedly "no navy to defend itself" We do have an army and while we maybe a small army we can adequately defend our island state if the need arises.

So Mr. Townsend do us all a favour and start reporting facts and not your deluded assumptions or notions to get your story published. Thank you.

 

PATRICK WATSON

10:18 AM ET

March 13, 2010

Nothing wrong with Townsend Analysis

This is what Townsend said "Over the past decade, Trinidad's murder rate has risen nearly 400 percent; last year, the rate in the capital city of Port of Spain rivaled those in Johannesburg and Baghdad." Is that incorrect? Is crime not a very serious concern in Trinidad & Tobago? Is the average Trinidadian or visitor not mindful about the dangers that lurk everywhere? That does not mean that the "REAL Trinidad and Tobago" does not have its enjoyments although I am not sure that I like the image that "we party all year round". We do enjoy a good party but we can be serious. By the way, I do not hear about bomb explosions in Johannesburg and many people from all over the world have already booked tickets to go to the REAL world cup in REAL South Africa, including Johannesburg. Does that make the murder rate there less high? Will the visitors not party? Trinidadians must stop trying to portray a false image of the realities there and must avoid the temptation to give the impression that all is well.

 

KELLOJR

2:45 AM ET

March 16, 2010

Kello

I bought a copy of foreign affairs recently and was pleasantly surprised by the great articles. It is with dismay that i read the Mr Townsend's fairy tale. Riddled with inaccuracies, hearsay and innuendo. It does seem to be written in a condescending tone, and it is embarrassing that Foreign Affairs let this slip through to print.
The author should contact the local embassy, and do proper research. His assumption that in a nation of 1.3 million which builds and commissions its own offshore gas platforms, which also does air traffic control with its radar system for the Southern Caribbean cannot turn on or operate simple radar systems is an astonishing assumption. It reflects the colonial, and deluded bias of the writer who has an axe to grind. Where do drugs go from this transhipment point, to the US, and Europe and is it Trinidad and Tobago's responsibility to protect US citizens or their own. We do both out of a sense of responsibility. These are facts, US gang activity, leaking borders and a huge demand has spill over effects on a small island state. You are brilliant our problem is because 90% of the force is corrupt, and no seizures are made. Brilliant
Please do proper reserach. You seem to know nothing about the secuirty system on which you preach!
Simple, basic, grade school research could have provided seizure figures which the writer seems to have avoided. The regional cooperation, the training.
Please Foreign affairs protect the freedom of speech but not with shoddy, innacurate sermons from false priests. I for one will never purchase Foreign affairs again because i cannot trust it anymore.
Mr Townsend or whatever your name is JIATF South, INL, Cipoline, Tradewinds exercise and the two seizures over the weekend are basic research terms check it out.
http://guardian.co.tt/news/crime/2010/03/16/5-court-35m-drug-charges

 

TRINIDADSKY

11:34 AM ET

March 13, 2010

Yes but

I think this is a fair overview of the drug/crime situation in Trinidad and Tobago. I'm also Trinidadian but that doesn't mean I should be deluded by misplaced patriotism that makes me blind to the most alarming statistics. That attitude is what the government counts on to convince people that we're not as terribly derailed as we obviously are.

What worries me most about our failed governance though is, as the author proposes, it invites inroads into our sovereignty. Because if the natives can't handle the situation themselves, well...

"A coalition of governments -- including the United States and Britain, whose navies patrol the region -- should step in to help patrol the lane between Trinidad and Venezuela."

Yes I'm sure that would suit the purposes of the US just fine.

 

UNLTDBLOGGER

6:08 PM ET

March 13, 2010

Tekarey a True Trini Ostrich

Very fair and REAL overview of Trinidad; it's a pity that a great majority of our citizens are like Tekarey - the never-ending party mentality. I know so many people who have been hit so close to home and who were killed or had family members or fiends killed who also had nothing to do with drugs; who've been there during a shoot out and he's definitely had his head in the sand when he says this doesn't affect the innocent. The truth is when there's chaos, it filters through all aspects of life - like traffic offenses - so many offenses yet so few tickets.

Trinidad is one of the few places where you can sometimes stop your car from being wrecked by cursing off the wreckers. If you get on bad enough or if you're a woman with extra charm, you get away. That's a joke and a party mentality because some Trinis are actually very proud of these things.

As many Trinis of his type too, he conveniently forgets the period of bombings we suffered in Trinidad in 2005 - which seemed to have stopped suddenly through contract killings - if you can;t get them legally, then take out contracts to kill them - saves on spending money for them to go to jail too.

You have to feel sorry for people who are not like Tekarey as HE is definitely happy with things the way they are - ignorance is truly bliss!

 

JUANITO

10:49 PM ET

March 13, 2010

So. . .

. . .you're saying I SHOULDN'T visit T & T this summer for vacation?

 

DYLMARC

8:59 PM ET

March 14, 2010

Jamaica for Summer

Juanito ,what can I tell you but to go Jamaica or some other Caribbean island for summer and before you go there let Mr Dom Townsend and the others who continue to make us believe that crime exist only in Trinidad and Tobago send you a report on drugs and gang killings and impoverished young men behind those killings in those islands.
A lot of us like to talk and put forward a lot of stats but will not admit that every country is fighting this scourge of crime that has gone up to a different level.
We only focus on the crime we see and read about but nothing can be done before the people change and stop crime from within the home and family.
Mr Townsend should write about how the impoverished youth are getting drugs,guns,cars etc to do their crime?They do not have import license to import and export containers that are used to smuggle narcotics onto ships to the US and UK ,nor do they have speed boats or yachts that make the trips to and fro the mainland to Trinidad.
Yet,we blame the impoverished youth because they are the ones that die and are seen and not the businessmen who make it all happen and we all know them and their activities but we do nothing to stop White Color crime because of who is involved.
So,we continue to talk all the stats and negative but still put forward no solutions to help stop crime in the entire country because its popular to do so.
Juanito,as any traveler does when visiting a new country or Caribbean island,he checks for the in's and out's and where and where not to go and also safety tips while visiting and recommended places to visit while there.
I am involved with visitors to our island all the time and they all leave with a different idea of Trinidad and Tobago then before they came.
Do enjoy your trip.
DylMarc

 

TRINI2DBONE

3:58 PM ET

March 15, 2010

Denial

If you drop a frog in very hot water it will immediately jump out. However if you put the frog in at a comfortable temp and gradually heat the water up to boiling, it will stay in and die.

Seems fitting for what's happening in Trinidad. I am here every year and am constantly amazed at people like Tekarey who deny that there is a problem, or that our problem is different from any other big city. I'm also amazed at Trini's who take it as some sort of attack on our nation to criticize what's going on. Their position is that what's going in Trinidad is "normal".

What's going on should not be considered normal. Yes big cities have crime, but the average citizen of New York city can not typically name people that they know personally, or who are only one person removed from people who have been raped, murdered or kidnapped. I know 3 people who have been murdered, no sorry 4 (if I think harder I may come up with another). I know a guy who was beheaded. Yes, right here in sweet T&T. A few weeks ago a friend was killed in his own home. I have a family member who was held up at gunpoint and had his girlfriend raped in front of his eyes. This is over a period of 10 to 15 years mind you, but still ....

I have lived in big cities like New York and Toronto, for most of my life and the average resident cannot say the same.

Neither murders nor kidnappings are solved in Trinidad, and no one goes to jail for corruption. People routinely do what they want, like drive along the side of the road to beat traffic. or drive 100 miles an hour weaving among the traffic and they are not prosecuted. Our people don't want to work (and many are proud of it), and the government chooses to invest in skyscrapers and not people.

We have a problem on a huge scale my fellow Trinis, and we need all hands on deck to solve it. And it starts first by admitting we have a problem. If we can't even do that, then all is lost.

 

RUSKIE

7:28 AM ET

March 16, 2010

AGREED

You took the words out of my mouth Trini2DBONE.

While it may be difficult to see the article from the POV of the writer, let us remember that the magazine is one about Foreign Policy and not that of Tand T.

While it may be difficult to read if one is not aware of our politics and history, I feel that his article is a good synopsis of one symptom of a much much greater series of issues we (Trinidad and Tobago) suffer as a people.

The percentage of Police involved in illegal activities I find almost impossible to believe, but if abdication of duty is included, then the percentage is probably higher.

I certainly feel we would benefit from some foreign policy cooperation in this particular problem from the markets where these narcotics are destined (Including not repatriating those seasoned trained criminals from the U.S. Penal system that so rapidly developed our crime-wave).

As far as the rest of our problems that exacerbate this one, a huge mental and social shift/upheaval is the only thing that will change those.

 

INTLOBSERVER

3:14 AM ET

March 20, 2010

Sweet TnT

As a Trinbagonian who has resided in NYC and now Johannesburg, I must say that I find this article rather intriguing. First, the author correctly analyses what is going on in my homeland, and then he assumes a neocolonialist stance by advocating for an increased presence of the major colonial powers in the waters around TnT and Venezuela.

This is no accident...it is the same type of rationale which was used to establish their presence in Iraq. The answer is oil, and TnT and Venezuela share the curse of this rich naatural mineral endowment. The US/England neocolonialist discourse can be summarized as "First we locate (or create) the problem and then we move in". Much more drugs and crime exist right in the US/Mexico border but the US presence remains ineffective despite a decades-long "war on drugs". We must not be deceived into beliveing that this article has anything to do with crime and drugs...it's about oil and occupation.

So my fellow Trinbagonians, dont bicker about whether there is crime or drugs or not. Forget about whether we are compared to Jo'burg or Baghdad. Honestly appraise the growing culture of crime and corruption plaguing our nation and understand that there needs to be serious efforts made, to marshall all our national intellectual capacity (wherever they currently exist) and tackle Trinidad and Tobago's problems head-on. If we don't then the case will grow, another foreigner will be killed on TnT soil, and the case for the next occupation will be solidified. Then our navy would be seconded to the new colonial power and put to do work against our citizens in the name of regional security.

 

SPECIALINVESTIGATORS

6:33 AM ET

March 26, 2010

The truth hurts

It is never pleasant when you are forced to take a long hard look at yourself or your country where you grew up. This article should not be viewed as a smear campaign but should serve as a wake up call for those of us who would live in denial and think that Trinidad is still a paradise.

The evidence is overwhelming and did not even mention the fact that of the 400 murders 75% of those killed worked for or was in some way involved in the Government run Unemployment Relief Program. This fact continues to be ignored by the government of the day who claims that they are helping the helping the 'economically disadvantaged" Yet legitimate government issued cheques in the names of Michael Jackson, Frank Sinatra and Serena Williams surfaced without those individuals having worked on the URP projects .

In an foolish attempt to combat this ATM cards are now issued as payments which eliminates the human interaction with a teller and the funds continue to be paid.

Take an honest look at these and other facts and you will realize this article was not a misguided vindictive attempt to put our country in a bad light. But an opportunity for us all to really take a long hard look at what is going on.

 

RACCOON91

1:29 AM ET

April 9, 2010

NARCOSTATE- perfect analysis

This article is bang on the money. I was born in T&T and agree wholeheartedly.
Why security services cannot seem to catch and prosecute drug dealers.How come the gov cannot manage the rising murder rate and reduce crime??

You Trinidadians should accept constructive crtitism.If things were so perfect, we would not have a murder rate of more 500, in 2009, would we? The Gov should engage the private sector in job creation.

The problem lies within the mondset of Trinidadians though- they glorify partying, carnival and bachannal instead of nation building!!!!

Wake up Trinidad!!!!!!!! ( and this come from a Trinidadian)

 

NAN

2:22 AM ET

April 10, 2010

Sad But True...

I've worked for several years in the Beetham Estate, East Port-of-Spain (at SERVOL, a wonderful NGO helping young people) and it's a crying shame how the government makes life difficult for Trinis. The Beetham is a dangerous area, but the people who live there are by and large good people who don't have many options.

My parents live in Chickland Village, an agricultural area, and they haven't had pipe-borne water in YEARS. (they do pay their water rates though!) Private trucks charge US$100 to deliver water to the area. Hardly anyone can afford that, so during the dry season, hours every day are spent fetching water on barrels and buckets.

I recently (September) moved to the UK with my family, and the other day we saw a banged-up car being towed... my kids looked thoughtful and said "Gosh, we haven't seen a single dead person on the road, since we got here!" Trinidad is rich in oil and gas. Trinis deserve some of that wealth, we deserve water, properly policed roads, a police force that we can trust.

I love, love Trinidad and Tobago. It is my homeland, and my children's homeland. It is sad to see what has happened in the last few years.