Switzerland Goes Rogue

Is it still possible for a country to be neutral?

BY STEVE KETTMANN | MARCH 19, 2010

No place in Europe has clung to an anachronistic, airbrushed image longer than Switzerland. The country's oddly entrenched reputation for pristine and inviolable "neutrality" has left it ostensibly so removed from the normal give-and-take of international politics that for many Americans the place could pretty much be summed up with the sugary, beyond-politics appeal of Nestlé chocolate.

In fact, however, the myth of Swiss exceptionalism is increasingly tattered these days. The unraveling of the legend began in the postwar period, accelerating in the 1990s, as more and more stories came out on the Swiss banks' involvement in helping the Nazis and their stubbornness about concealing that role. It didn't help matters that right-wing Swiss political parties continued to make periodic gains, with the Radical Party signaling a turn to the right in the 1983 parliamentary elections, for example, by drawing more votes than the Social Democrats for the first time in 58 years.

Recent months have brought Switzerland into a vortex of unwelcome international publicity, much of this brought on by a flinty, proud brand of Swiss independence that looks less and less charming to the outside world. Burt Neuborne, a New York University professor who served as counsel to Holocaust survivors in wrangling with the Swiss, went so far last year to charge in a widely read Los Angeles Times op-ed that it might be time to dub Switzerland a "rogue state."

Here's how things got this far:

  • The Swiss tossed their reputation for tolerance out the window last November with a nationwide referendum to ban minarets. Analysts cited raw fear of an encroaching Islam, but that seemed a far-fetched rationale given that there are an estimated 400,000 Muslims in the country, but a grand total of four minarets.
  • Switzerland has found itself in a bizarre war of words with Libyan leader Muammar al-Qaddafi, who responded to the jailing of his son on assault charges in Geneva by expelling Swiss diplomats, calling for an anti-Swiss jihad, and even proposing to the U.N. General Assembly that the country be abolished.
  • Film director Roman Polanski showed up in Zurich last September to accept a lifetime achievement award at the Zurich Film Festival, and the longtime French citizen was promptly arrested on a warrant dating back to 1978. Given how squeamish most are about the deeply disturbing Polanski case, dating to his 1970s admission of having sex with an underage girl, the untimely Swiss arrest did the seemingly impossible and generated some sympathy for an admitted sex criminal.
  • German Chancellor Angela Merkel, whose leadership style is built on unflashy pragmatism and a dislike of headline-grabbing, grabbed headlines in February as word surfaced that Germany was considering making a deal with known thieves to purchase a CD containing information about German tax evaders with Swiss bank accounts, a move that, as the German news weekly Der Spiegel noted, "risk[ed] a falling-out with Switzerland." Later came word that officials in the German state of Baden-Württemberg planned to buy a second CD.
  • The huge Swiss bank UBS was forced to make a deal with the United States to provide information on the banking history of thousands of wealthy U.S. citizens implicated in possible tax evasion, rather than risk U.S. legal action, a move that continued to erode the reputation of Swiss banks.
  • The controversial euthanasia organization Dignitas has taken advantage of Switzerland's liberal assisted-suicide laws to make the country the world's most popular destination for "suicide tourism." Widespread media coverage of the organization throughout the continent has not done wonders for Switzerland's image.

BORIS HORVAT/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: CULTURE, EUROPE
 

Steve Kettmann lives in Berlin and writes a weekly column on politics for the Berliner Zeitung.

DISIGNY

10:53 AM ET

March 20, 2010

Nonsense

This idea that "modern living" requires global integration at every level is cultural suicide. It only takes an intransigent minority of 5 or 10 % to make much more trouble than its worth. Also, "national sovereignty" allows criminal states like Myanmar, N. Korea, various African states, etc. to commit all kinds of atrocities without penaltly, why shouldn't Switzerland be allowed banking privacy?

 

HERIBLOG

2:25 AM ET

April 10, 2010

Whats

I have too many Jewish friends (Israeli Jews) not to understand some of the problems faced in their country...but i never hear them complaining about the world...and rarely about the current problems that face the world.
bienalsiart

 

MYCOCC

5:29 PM ET

April 15, 2010

Not like you said

DISIGNY, you should not to do like you said, its not nonsense, it has some facts behind that.
You should also see the face behind the mirror.
bible church NY

 

LOLCAT

12:28 PM ET

April 17, 2010

Original Swiss ??

Switzerland has long been the model country. Its -image as a diverse, harmonious nation with light regulations and political neutrality is a main reason the World Economic Forum holds its big annual meeting. But the lately comments frm this country result a fatal error how to say.

 

MKP

1:08 AM ET

April 18, 2010

The move is great by them. We

The move is great by them. We should always take good care of animals. There are many good ebook stores which would provide very much detailed information. I agree with your strong comments. Switzerland should be allowed banking privacy.

 

JRE_CH

11:06 AM ET

March 20, 2010

Why not?

I think this article has some truth in it. It is completly true that a significant part of the population is dreaming about a past that never existed and that will never exist. The right-wing country is exploiting the fear of globalization and it is working quite well.
When it comes to bank secrecy, I think that is a different story. I am not sure that what the City, Jersey, Caiman Islands and others financial places of the world are doing is in practice different from the swiss bank secrecy.
It is also unfair to blame the Swiss Government for the Qaddafi affairs, they just applied the law and in response, they got bashed by a dictator. Now that the government is using the Shengen agreement to exerce some pressure on Qaddafi so that it release to last swiss hostage it still has, the EU and even the US had to apologize in front of this madman in order to maintain good economic relations...
Since when democracies need to apologize to dictatorship for applying the law?

 

MYCOCC

2:22 AM ET

April 11, 2010

I am totally agree with

I am totally agree with Jre-Ch, you talked about It is also unfair to blame the Swiss Government for the Qaddafi affairs, they just applied the law and in response, they got bashed by a dictator. Now that the government is using the Shengen agreement to exerce some pressure on Qaddafi so that it release to last swiss hostage it still has, the EU and even the US had to apologize in front of this madman in order to maintain good economic relations. Great thinking Pizza Press

 

LOLCAT

2:14 PM ET

April 17, 2010

That is just clear

There has been a lot in the news lately about Swiss Xenophobia and racism due to the largest party, a nationalist party, making provocative statements about immigrant populations. Unlike a lot of opinages, I have actually been to Switzerland (St. Gallen and Zurich primarily) and I am non-white so I feel I have more of a take on racism in Switzerland. My take on this has seemed to shock a lot of people, but here it is and this is not an apology for racism:car games

 

FREEZEICE04

8:00 AM ET

April 19, 2010

I disagree

I disagree with the part where you said it's unfair to blame the Swiss Government for the Q. Affairs. The Swiss are the ones who escalated it so I believe it was very fair to blame them and also the rules were fair too. Just my 2c.

 

BEEMSEE

11:02 AM ET

March 21, 2010

The causes of unwelcome international publicity

You list five sources of Switzerland's current bad press, but fail to identify their true cause, which has nothing to do with Switzerland's neutrality:
1. Bank secrecy. The financial crisis of 2008 has forced governments who had to bail out their financial institutions to seek money from its own tax dodgers. UBS was the off shore target of choice due to its massive presence in the USA, which gives Obama leverage.
2. Minaret ban. The citizens of most countries in Europe feel their cultural identities are threatened by their growing Muslim populations (Holland, France, and Denmark most notably). But only in Switzerland do they have the direct power to take action via their system of raising and voting on referendums.
3. War of words with Libya. Only one side is warring with words - as usual. If it weren't for the Swiss hostage, he'd be talking to himself - as usual, because we haven't noticed any ill effects from being deprived of his oil.
4. German purchase of stolen Swiss bank names. See 1. above. If this had happened to any country but neutral Switzerland, it would have been called an act of aggression against the State.
5. Polanski's arrest. See 1 above about US leverage with Switzerland.

 

MYCOCC

5:24 AM ET

April 9, 2010

BEEMSEE, you have putted the

BEEMSEE, you have putted the right question. I agree with you over that When it comes to bank secrecy, I think that is a different story. I am not sure that what the City, Jersey, Caiman Islands and others financial places of the world are doing is in practice different from the swiss bank secrecy. Baseball Tickets
The true picture should be explained.

 

FSILBER

7:06 AM ET

March 22, 2010

The Dutch are worse

A bigger threat to the world equilibrium are the Dutch, with their secret conspiracy to take over the world by weakening our children by making them fat with their cheese and chocolate. They've programmed their electric shavers to cut up our faces when the command is given. Then, when they invade, they're going to cut all our doors in half.

 

AVALANCHE

11:13 AM ET

March 31, 2010

They'll take advantage of the

They'll take advantage of the rising sea levels caused by climate change and invade us by floating their army with wooden clogs!

 

G-R

11:32 AM ET

April 19, 2010

haha

Ok.. I was getting bored by this post.. but you definitely just made my day. I thought the cheese and chocolate part was ridiculous until I got to the electric shavers part. I've been using them since as far back as I can remember.. am I first doomed? This comment made my day.. thanks :)
-Greg, grout stain guy

 

MR.GERRY D

7:57 PM ET

March 22, 2010

Why is it that...

...Switzerland is "rogue" because 65 years ago they did the banking for an, at the time, legitimate government? (Nazi Germany)...If there is a current ROGUE on the world stage, it is Israel...or am I being an anti-semetic by stating the obvious.

How about a little break on the "anti Jewish" stuff. I don't believe the world hates the Jews... The constant whining is wearing very thin out here...and furthermore, I sincerely think it hurts the Jewish people more that in helps...carrying the grudge forever...the weight of which will wear us all down, or piss some of us off.

I have too many Jewish friends (Israeli Jews) not to understand some of the problems faced in their country...but I NEVER HEAR them complaining about the world 65 years ago...and rarely about the current problems that face the world.

Switzerland has a "right", just as Israel and the rest of the world nations have.

 

ZT

4:59 PM ET

April 6, 2010

Because...

...because Switzerland has still been dragging its heels in compensating victims, even in modern times. Did you not read the article closely? And did you even read the entire thing-- this was just one of the examples mentioned.

The fact you read an article on Switzerland that mentions Jews in one small part and the Jewish state nowhere, but then go on a huge unrelated rant about how Israel is a rogue state (which is just about as absurd as your claim the Nazi regime was ever legitimate-- they came to power by crushing all of Germany's democratic organs) just goes to show that Jews are still, in fact, frequently singled out.

 

MR.GERRY D

8:03 PM ET

March 22, 2010

Minaret Ban...

...Look up Geert Wilders...I think the man has the whole Muslim thing distilled to it's very essence...He clearly defined, what I take as the absolute truth as to what the civilized world faces as this "disease" expands throughout the world. Sorry for your hurt feelings...but the reality is: There people...ARE NOT YOUR FRIEND!!!!

 

MARKIE98

5:58 AM ET

March 23, 2010

I REALLY CAN'T TELL

-- what the point of this article is. For the first two pages, I wondered if I was on the Onion site.

People around the world ought to start paying their taxes to the countries they live in.Talk about entitled elites. Tell me again-- WHO'S avoiding responsibility and getting a free ride on the backs of taxpayers everywhere?

Those snotty Swiss banker types with their cushy jobs should be put out of business and forced to do real work.

 

SWISSROBINSON

7:35 AM ET

March 23, 2010

A most amusing account of Switzerland

As an Australian national happy to avoid the EU mess now abundantly clear to the world, Occidental imperialism in Central Asia, taxation without representation that is business as usual in the UK, Aust. and USA, I
am amused to hear of the country I live in receiving "rogue" status.

"Neutrality" continues to be discussed and redefined, Mr Kettmann, like most subjects of social importance. With Switzerland's decision to enter the UN as a participant in the global politic, the term now lies largely on the nation's refusal to go to war in foreign lands. A most refreshing experience that would be for the American Republic.

If the American people do not want their monetary wealth to be continuously robbed by the deficit spending of the CONgress of the United States, aided and abetted by Wall St. fraud and Fed maleficence, Switzerland will I imagine continue to warmly welcome their business.

With nonsensical articles like this playing on people's ignorance (kind of like the politicians playing on Swiss peoples' ignorance of Islam) I see no reason to subscribe to the FP anytime soon.

Good day sir.

 

BLUE13326

8:43 AM ET

March 23, 2010

This is nonsense. Neutrality

This is nonsense.

Neutrality has little to do with the recent events you cite, and to compare them to the complicity of the Swiss with the Nazis is a sick joke.

 

F1FAN

9:19 AM ET

March 23, 2010

Picking on the Swiss is pretty low

Just another 'everyone should do what we say' opinion. The rest of the world doesn't have to be the US or EU if they don't want to, live with it.

 

ANDY1832

9:24 AM ET

April 19, 2010

I Agree

Where would i rather live?? beautiful swiss alps or overcrowded, ungrateful USA??... let me think

Thanks

Find Jobs

 

MORGANJAMES

2:29 PM ET

April 19, 2010

I kinda agree

You know, while I love my country I can't help but agree with you. While the US falls deeper and deeper into economic bondage and becoming a welfare state, Switzerland don't sound like such a bad place to be.

Of course, I need to earn a couple more million before they'd let me stay longer than a weekend but that is what capitalism and self motivation is all about... so I can go live in the beautiful Swiss Alps :)

 

FIREBIRD54

3:21 PM ET

March 23, 2010

Cuckoo clock

The author forgot to blame the Swiss for that annoying bird sound that goes off in my kitchen on the hour and every half-hour.

If the rest of the world committed twice the sins attributed to the Swiss here, the world would still be a better place.

 

TGGP

3:06 AM ET

April 3, 2010

Switzerland's standing just

Switzerland's standing just went up in my view after I read this article. Hooray for Switzerland, may it ever retain its independence and laugh in the face of those like Mr. Kettmann who would like to push it around.

 

MSB

6:51 AM ET

April 19, 2010

Author Cynical

I, too, don't share the author's cynicism. If the Swiss' "purported" neutrality has kept them out of war, it's all good. As a resident of Kenya, I hear horrifying stories coming out of neighboring war-torn Somalia everyday and if I had to choose between the 2 extremes, I would certainly choose Switzerland's model.

 

JOHNSONE149

2:56 PM ET

April 7, 2010

Well revealing bank secrecy

Well revealing bank secrecy in national interest or to enforce some laws is not bad habit, and I think if Swiss banks shared information of account with American authorities then its part of their cooperation. Of course you are living in this world, there are some expected level of cooperation in every field, I agree with you. Only those people are against this policy of Switzerland whose bank information being disclosed to US authorities for tax purpose, and considering it as a Rogue state. pulse oximeter
Thanks

 

MICEONLY

6:56 PM ET

April 7, 2010

Switzerland

Switzerland goes Rogue! I think people giving these kind of compliments are mentally sick, its an era of globalization. So there is a need of cooperation in every field. If Swiss banks shared information of clients with US govt, it was done to maintain good governance. Nobody raised his voice when issues of black money in Swiss banks opened, but now when information of clients to provided to Govt then there is a group of people making such comments.
Oklahoma Bankruptcy Law
Thanks

 

STACYFARIOT12

11:47 AM ET

April 8, 2010

The author forgot to blame

The author forgot to blame the Swiss for that annoying bird sound that goes off in my kitchen on the hour and every half-hour. If the rest of the world committed twice the sins attributed to the Swiss here, the world would still be a better place. best ab exercises for men and 10 minute ab workout.
Regards, Stacy.

 

FIXITUP

8:38 PM ET

April 17, 2010

Watch

Lets not forget the watch, where would we be without it! I might even have to fix driver problems all alone. LOL

 

STACYFARIOT12

11:49 AM ET

April 8, 2010

Switzerland's standing just

Switzerland's standing just went up in my view after I read this article. Hooray for Switzerland, may it ever retain its independence and laugh in the face of those like tv shows Mr. Kettmann who would like to push it around.

 

GIGA34

2:37 PM ET

April 8, 2010

Not a Rogue State

I agree with you SWISSROBINSON, I think people considering Switzerland as Rogue state are mentally sick and their remarks not based on solid grounds. Somewhere they are quoting the example of Swiss banks helping Nazi and somewhere quoting cold war with Libya. I don't whats the problem of these people, if Swiss bank sharing information then its the same happening in US. Why don't anyone raised voice when it happened in US.

Secondly if they are talking about referendum, I think its part of their political system and entering into UN and then not participating in war is a good decision. Of course why people fight for others?? This is not the war against terrorism. I don't know what the author wanted to make point, quiet confusing. I am working in a seo company and there are some people making such compliments but a country can be neutral even in this globalization period. If I rely on above mentioned facts, then I will consider it as rogue state, its supporting or comparing??
Thanks

 

MARKDANIEL

2:27 AM ET

April 9, 2010

Why Called Rogue State?

I have read the post as well the comments. After reading all the text and by using my knowledge I must supprt SWISSROBINSON. Here in the comment section GIGA34 has also come out with a good points. If people blamed the state for swiss bank case, the why not people fingering at US. Look if any country wants to stay out of war then its a good news and nothing bad at all. After all if they have not any problem in their state then why they put their lives in denger? It is totally a baseless accuse.

As a co-incident I am also involved with professional [url=http://www.competeinfotech.com/seo-services.html]seo services[/url] and I have read so many blogs on this issue, I can not get the authors properly, what they want actually? Sorry dear authors I am not agree with you.

 

GIGA34

10:04 AM ET

April 9, 2010

Globalization and Switzerland

Well author is trying to make his point that country cannot remain neutral in the era of globalization. But I think country can remain neutral and it solely depends on its policies. Switzerland is not a Rogue state and I think people making such compliments are part of Retirement Communities. Basically its become a media war and Swiss don't want to spend their efforts in these discussions.
I think we must allow Swiss govt. to work best for their people and these kind blames are becoming hurdle in doing so.
Thanks

 

MARKDANIEL

2:29 AM ET

April 9, 2010

Why Called Rogue State?

I have read the post as well the comments. After reading all the text and by using my knowledge I must supprt SWISSROBINSON. Here in the comment section GIGA34 has also come out with a good points. If people blamed the state for swiss bank case, the why not people fingering at US. Look if any country wants to stay out of war then its a good news and nothing bad at all. After all if they have not any problem in their state then why they put their lives in denger? It is totally a baseless accuse.

As a co-incident I am also involved with professional seo services and I have read so many blogs on this issue, I can not get the authors properly, what they want actually? Sorry dear authors I am not agree with you.

 

LIDAH

1:41 AM ET

April 10, 2010

Everyone can expression their

Everyone can expression their opinion,
for example on bussiness or everything no exception, as you say :D

 

ARIFBOLANGA

1:55 AM ET

April 10, 2010

<a href="http://ar1f.com">i like switzerland</a>

i has hear about switzerland but i never been go there
switzerland is nice place.

 

GAKJELAS19

6:42 AM ET

April 12, 2010

Quit Smoking

thanks dude, nice information
I like your post
Quit Smoking

 

ZENITH

1:22 AM ET

April 15, 2010

Switzerland

Ich muss hören, Über die Schweiz habe aber noch nie hingehen
Die Schweiz ist schöner Ort.

 

KOMSPB

6:27 AM ET

April 16, 2010

KV-RENT

German purchase of stolen Swiss bank names. See 1. above. If this had happened to any country but neutral KV-RENT Switzerland, it would have been called an act of aggression against the State.

 

CHEROKEBARWELL

3:28 AM ET

April 17, 2010

It is not possible for any

It is not possible for any country to behave as neutral. If someone thinks in that manner he is totally wrong. Attitudes and policies change over the time to time with the change of the governments. Different governments accepts different methods. That cannot resist. Michael from acai berry

 

GARY2KL

8:19 AM ET

April 17, 2010

Great post

Good old Switzerland, let's hope the rogue in them continue!
Gary from Free iPhone

 

JOBS IN SALES

8:40 AM ET

April 17, 2010

great post

I have read the post as well the comments., and yes it is hard for this country to stay neutral, especially with certain things happening, such as the vote over minarets
www.salesroles.com

 

JOBS IN SALES

8:42 AM ET

April 17, 2010

great post

I have read the post as well the comments., and yes it is hard for this country to stay neutral, especially with certain things happening, such as the vote over minarets
jobsinsales

 

VIJ

8:47 AM ET

April 17, 2010

Oh My

Tough times ahead. Policies change with changing governments.

Mary Statue

 

VIJ

8:50 AM ET

April 17, 2010

Mary Statue

Good Old Switzerland. Btw, fantastic photography.

http://www.marystatue.net
Mary Statue

 

JOSEPHTING

12:37 PM ET

April 17, 2010

LoLed at the picture! Anyway,

LoLed at the picture! Anyway, I believe changes are to be made for good purposes. We citizens will just have to obey and follow the changes.
get your ex back

 

FLURGLE

1:07 PM ET

April 17, 2010

U.S Big Brother strikes again

"The huge Swiss bank UBS was forced to make a deal with the United States to provide information on the banking history of thousands of wealthy U.S. citizens implicated in possible tax evasion, rather than risk U.S. legal action, a move that continued to erode the reputation of Swiss banks."

What gives the U.S the right to interfere with another countries laws?

To be honest this stinks of Big Brother in operation again.

Sky Bingo

 

ROBBRAD182

2:51 PM ET

April 17, 2010

Well Put!

Are they really causing that much of a problem? one thing in this article i agree with is that they do make great chocolate! Rob
website value

 

LUTHIPOWER

5:17 PM ET

April 17, 2010

Switzerland

Switzerland is NOT just the country with great chocolate. I think they do everything they can to keep their traditions alive. Hope globalization will not affect their levels of democracy and great culture.

Petr, The Rapidsharefox company.

 

VIJ

11:53 PM ET

April 17, 2010

Swiiss whiz

Switzerland has been synonymous with beauty and culture. Hope it stays that way.
Sincerely
Dr Viju ,

 

VIJ

11:56 PM ET

April 17, 2010

Swiiss whiz

Switzerland has been synonymous with beauty and culture. Hope it stays that way.
Sincerely
Dr Vij , Menstrual Cramps Center

 

SUSUANLULU

2:48 AM ET

April 18, 2010

Switzerland

I think Banks should maintain strict confidentiality rules of her clients, but Banks also can deny some clients if they think later the banks can not maintain these clients's secret. That is good to both banks and clients.

Susan, Car Games 60 Center

 

RIPUL

4:19 AM ET

April 18, 2010

Swiss Banks

I do agree with what has been said above, but whom to deny remains a very subjective question.
Regards,
Ripul

 

LOLCAT

5:26 AM ET

April 18, 2010

thanks

Well revealing bank secrecy in national interest or to enforce some laws is not bad habit, and I think if Swiss banks shared information of account with American authorities then its part of their cooperation. Of course you are living in this world, there are some expected level of cooperation in every field, I agree with you.
Recent months have brought Switzerland into a vortex of unwelcome international publicity, much of this brought on by a flinty, proud brand of Swiss independence that looks less and less charming to the outside world.
compare spread betting

 

LIGER

9:29 AM ET

April 18, 2010

switz

Well, the only things I know about Switzerland are the swizz cholocates and Roger Federer :) Good article!

Sincerely
Liger, Indoor Aviary and Outdoor Aviary Center

 

LUNCHBOX82

3:01 PM ET

April 18, 2010

Glad to hear that Switzerland

Glad to hear that Switzerland took this stance. I love Switzerland, it is a great place to visit.

 

RUTHTYLOR

12:51 AM ET

April 19, 2010

You are right

I love Switzerland and I wish it will keep its neutrality.
that is a very important part of being whom it is right now.
Ben10 games

 

MOVIEMOTION

4:39 AM ET

April 19, 2010

Swiss Banks

Swiss banks are the largest in the world so that USA and Germany involved with Swiss banks to steal information about their citizens financial situation to investigate taxes breaking
John

 

FRANK2010

1:07 PM ET

April 19, 2010

I agree

I think everyone has the right to express their opinions but I do believe this will cause for some tough roads ahead. There are a lot of pros and cons to this but who knows what will happen. Thanks for the great article.California Security

 

MAXGOODWELL

2:24 PM ET

April 19, 2010

Switzerland

You just got to love the swiss. I like how they dress up there cows. Switzerland is such a beautiful country. It is definitely a place you need to visit if you get a chances. Thanks

 

KELLYMAN

6:18 PM ET

April 19, 2010

Country Life

The Swiss and the Nazis again in one breath, haha, rogue state, now we are going too far, The Swiss have always been a neutral place, for what reasons i ask, if im honest

Articles like this always cause a reaction to which i am not getting involved but people will always have their own opinion on this
lease car deals

 

KWANH

7:25 PM ET

April 19, 2010

change

Switzerland is also changing like the rest of the world. We cannot expect it to stay the same forever...
Yemek Tarifleri