The World's Strangest Tax Laws

As April looms and the tax man cometh, everyone's looking for an exemption. But some taxes and exemptions are more defensible than others.

BY ANDREW SWIFT | MARCH 26, 2010

Mooncake Tax

Country: China

Who's affected: Chinese pastry-lovers

The bottom line: In the midst of last year's economic downturn, Chinese authorities upped their tax-collection efforts (which are usually notoriously lax) in a bid to top up the state's coffers. One of their main targets was the mooncake -- a pastry stuffed with lotus seed paste and egg yolks, or "whatever the baker feels like chucking in," that is a ubiquitous delicacy especially popular in the fall.

Mooncakes were traditionally given out during the Mid-Autumn Festival (historically a time of moon worship) to friends and family to cement relationships. But now, many businesses also offer mooncakes to employees or provide coupon vouchers redeemable at local groceries for the treat. Additionally, the cakes are given as a sort of soft bribe to employers, party officials. Where bakers saw a mooncake explosion, government officials saw yuan signs -- and launched an inspection of more than 3,100 companies last year, slapping 30 billion yuan worth of back taxes on gifted mooncakes and coupons. In modern China, apparently, you can have your cake and tax it too.

MIKE CLARKE/AFP/Getty Images, BAY ISMOYO/AFP/Getty Images, SIMON MAINA/AFP/Getty Images, 2010 FIFA World Cup Organising Committee South Africa via Getty Images, LIVER LANG/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: ECONOMICS
 

Andrew Swift is an editorial researcher at Foreign Policy.

TEASER38

12:22 PM ET

March 30, 2010

Not really wierd laws...

these are almost entirely odd enforcement issues. I'm sure you can find parallels in the US since:the US has Tax laws about the giving of gifts, a few US states have actually imposed taxes on live adult entertainment in addition to all that cash which strippers neglect to document, municipalities give tax exemptions to movie shoots and help pay for sport stadiums, and I'm pretty sure you could deduct part of your tuition if you went to study witches here in the US.

I guess the real lesson here is that the maxim "The power to tax involves the power to destroy," is the same in the rest of the world as it is here.

 

BMCB

3:13 PM ET

March 31, 2010

US Jock Taxes

A total of 18 states now charge what's commonly called a "jock tax" to make money off pro athletes visiting their teams. In Tennessee this tax is different from the other 17 because the visitors cannot get any relief through a deduction when filing taxes back home because the tax isn’t based on earnings. Tennessee, which does not have a state income tax uses what it calls a "privilege" tax. In some cases, athletes visiting Tennessee will be paying more money in taxes than they will earn for playing in games….a tax of more than 100%

 

L0B0T

9:28 AM ET

April 14, 2010

In the US, the Mossberg 500

In the US, the Mossberg 500 shotgun is available in several styles. Some ship from the factory with a pistol grip attached & a full buttstock loose in the box, others ship with the full buttstock attached & the pistol grip loose in the box. If one wants to modify the barrel of these shotguns to a length under 18 inches, one pays a different tax rate depending on the style. When one puts a short barrel onto the firearm that ships with the full buttstock attached, under US law, one has created an "SBS" (short-barreled shotgun) that must be registered with the BATFE and a tax-stamp purchased for $200.00 per year. If, however, one puts a short barrel onto the firearm that ships with the pistol grip attached, under US law, one has created an "AOW" (any other weapon) that must be registered with the BATFE and a tax-stamp purchased for $5.00 per year. A difference of $195.00 per year determined by the purely cosmetic detail of which piece of plastic is used to hold the shotgun. Lets not forget the US telephone excise tax, levied in 1898 to pay for the Spanish-American War. The war lasted 110 days (April 25 – August 12), the tax was collected for 108 years (1898-2006).

 

L0B0T

11:05 AM ET

April 15, 2010

Illegal material tax

Yeah... In the US, when marijuana was effectively outlawed by the Marihuana Tax Act of 1937 (sic) the government used a similar tactic. To purchase a tax-stamp for the cultivation of hemp, one had to have a crop of hemp in hand. The farmers that showed up with samples of their crop in hand to purchase their tax-stamps were promptly arrested for possessing hemp without a tax-stamp. Thanks to Mr. Harry Anslinger (head of the Federal Bureau of Narcotics, precursor to the DEA) and his testimony that cannabis use caused "murder, insanity and death" & (my favorite) "If Frankenstein's monster encountered the demon marihuana, he would drop dead of fright."