The Things I Forgot to Carry

My very first embed.

BY JAMES TRAUB | APRIL 5, 2010

A forward operating base (FOB), I have discovered, is a great place to be a reporter. The farther away you get from civilization, the more its conventionalizing forces diminish. The giant Kandahar Airfield is full of high-level military and civilian officials who deliver high-level briefings; one I attended featured an almost Talmudic parsing of the differences among "off the record," "on background," and "deep background." In the end, the official decided to say nothing at all.  At a FOB, however, no one seems to be watching anymore, or possibly even paying attention. It's an isolated and lonely place. There aren't many people to talk to. There's a lot of down time, and a journalist is a welcome novelty. People here just talk. And talk. They bitch. They express doubts. They criticize each other. As a journalist, what's not to like?

And you meet characters. After days of hearing nothing but Southern accents (or Pashto), I had dinner with Frank -- or so I'll call him -- who spoke pure Bronx. Frank is a retired New York City detective straight out of Serpico. He now plies his trade in a rustic corner of a medieval war zone, hunting down "bad guys" -- his term -- and training the local cops. A pink-faced, middle-aged man with a white spade goatee, Frank has the weary and cryptic air of a man who has learned too many dark secrets. He has such a pronounced mumble that it's a wonder the Texans, much less the Afghans, can make any sense of him.

Lenny is one of the Texans. I thought I had him pegged when he told me that killing a man while you look him in the eye isn't hard at all once you get used to it; that's the terrible thing about it. But I had no idea. Lenny couldn't accept the idea of a cardboard enemy, so he decided to learn Arabic. When he found that the men at his hometown mosque wouldn't get anywhere near him, he had the women teach him the language, and he commenced to read the Quran, from which he can now quote germane passages, often matching them with a congruent passage from the Bible. He now prays with the Afghan soldiers and cops. That's what he says, anyway -- never mind that most Afghans can't speak Arabic. Although Lenny seemed to have the drop on everything, I could never be entirely sure about anything he said. He also proudly called himself a sociopath. He was full of obscure knowledge, not all of it correct. However, the other day he paid me what I gather is a high compliment: "I can't believe I've become friends with a New York Democrat." There aren't many of them around. (Well, maybe Frank.)

OCCD-Arghandab is considered a big success story: Taliban violence is down, governance is going great guns, and the Americans and Afghans are really synched up. Afghan President Hamid Karzai and commanding U.S. Gen. Stanley McChrystal were supposed to visit this morning. It would have been a big feather in some local caps. But the trip was scrubbed a few hours before touchdown. I realized that I was disappointed, not for me -- it would have blown a hole in my day -- but for OCCD-Arghandab. I guess embeds root for the home team.

POOL/AFP/Getty Images

 

James Traub is a contributing writer for the New York Times Magazine and author of, most recently, The Freedom Agenda. His column for ForeignPolicy.com runs weekly.

SONGSHU

12:58 AM ET

April 6, 2010

Tim O'Brien was one of the

Tim O'Brien was one of the first people who introduced me in vivid yet relatable prose to a realm far removed from my upbringing in 90's. Traub's humanist FP outlook is a tribute to the man to whose work Traub's title here alludes

 

MOORFIELDSTOREY

7:18 PM ET

April 6, 2010

Who do embeds root for?

Embeds root for the home team?

The home team, Mr. Traub, is the Taliban, which is fighting the American occupation of Afghanistan and its puppet, the corrupt Karzai government. Their attitudes towards gender, corporal punishment, and a dozen other things are positively sociopathic, but then again, so is your new Texan buddy Lenny. They are, however, the ones fighting on their home turf.

This report is unfortunately typical of 'embed' reporting. So-called 'journalists' become so enamored of their ability to rough it with the soldiers that they lose sight completely any wider context--particularly the people who live in the country where the war is being fought--and become simple propagandists.

Let's be honest: The 82nd Airborne is, without a doubt, the visiting team. Let's hope they won't be visiting for too much longer.

 

VIPERAPH

8:39 PM ET

April 6, 2010

So I can't tell what you're

So I can't tell what you're saying here. Do you think that the Taliban is a better option than trying to protect a fledgling (and somewhat failing to be honest, but that is a separate discussion) democracy? I get that you're trying to be contrarian and different, but do you have any idea what you are supporting by doing so? I don't know about you but I think that women are people too, that religious history is something that should be respected, and that rule through fear is a pretty weak way to rule. By supporting the Taliban you disagree with all of those things. Or is that not what you think?

 

PINJAB ROHUNEY

8:58 PM ET

April 6, 2010

He is just mad

the rooskies got A$$ kicked. Home team...that's some funny there. 800 years of fighting has a way of blurring the uniforms. Meet the new boss, same as the old boss or an easier version, we come in peace, shoot to kill!

PR

 

ATWOODBRIANLA

9:19 AM ET

April 7, 2010

break in new shoes

Didn't break in your Timberland boots before leaving? I'd make sure to do that for a camping trip! Of course, that was probably not high on "newbie" your priority list ;)

 

JEFF RIGSBY

10:57 AM ET

April 8, 2010

A note on language

Traub notes that Lenny "now prays with the Afghan soldiers and cops. That's what he says, anyway -- never mind that most Afghans can't speak Arabic".

All Muslims pray in Arabic. It is the liturgical language of Islam.