Failed No Longer

How Georgia came back from the brink.

BY MIKHEIL SAAKASHVILI | APRIL 15, 2010

This week's Nuclear Security Summit included not only large nuclear powers, such as Britain and India, but also countries like Georgia -- a small state with no nuclear weapons, no nuclear energy, and no nuclear materials.

Why is a small country like Georgia relevant to the large challenges facing our world? Although the deep transformations Georgia has undertaken in recent years are important to our own people, they also are relevant to global efforts to address such crucial challenges as nuclear proliferation.

To understand Georgia's role in a global challenge like nuclear proliferation, it helps to understand how Georgia is evolving and how Georgians see their place in the world.

Just a decade ago, Georgia could not seriously speak of playing any constructive role in the world. We were, to be perfectly frank and accurate, a failed state. Major areas of our country were effectively run by warlords. The police system was corrupt beyond description, with state police extorting payments from prisoners' families and shakedowns by traffic police at almost every corner.

Young people with talent and ambition sought to join local gangs -- or they simply fled the country. Our economy was literally in the Dark Ages. Even in Tbilisi, the capital, people had electricity for only a few hours a day. Real civil liberties did not exist because there was no one to enforce them. Chaos and corruption, like their predecessor, communism, deadened any sense that merit mattered.

Against that backdrop, our Rose Revolution in 2003 was not just about waving flags and storming the Parliament. It was a decision to move our state from failed to functioning. Even more, it was an attempt to change the very relationships between our citizens and their state, and among our people. It was, simply, the start of an audacious process to create a new Georgian society.

Seven years later, we are far from declaring victory. Our people continue to face hard times, with far too much unemployment and poverty. The 2008 Russian invasion and continuing occupation of our country exacted a terrible toll. And though we made big changes, we also made big mistakes, such as our overly harsh response to the opposition street protests in November 2007. Our democratic reforms remain incomplete, a work in progress.

IRAKLI GEDENIDZE/AFP/Getty Images

 

Mikheil Saakashvili is the president of Georgia.

AVRAM

2:01 PM ET

April 15, 2010

Misha makes a good "argument"

Misha/ FP appropriately decided to file this under the "argument" section.

 

GRAFOMANKA

9:32 PM ET

April 15, 2010

Kudos on fighting corruption

fail for starting wars, controlling media and somehow dubious economic achievements especially in the face of recent crisis.

 

THOMAS111

5:07 AM ET

April 17, 2010

To GRAFOMANKA

"fail for starting wars,"

- Erm what? Georgia has been INVADED to it's hystoric region of "Samachablo" that Russia has renamed to "South Ossetia" after occupation of Georgia in 1921.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Army_invasion_of_Georgia

At the same time "Republic Alaniya" has been renamed to "North Ossetia" in the north Caucasus. (to back it up...)

In fact up to FIVE times MORE Ossetians live peacefully ONLY in the capital of Georgia than in WHOLE so called "South Ossetia" (which is nothing more than a strategic Russian military base in the South Caucasus.)

As for the war, it has started in 1993 and NOT in 2008

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=onEJ3WtA4_0

Up to 85% of the population of Abkhzia region of Georgia was ethnically cleansed by Russian army and Chechen's.(who turned on Russians later on...)

As for the 2008 war, Putin made it clear... time and time again that he WOULD invade Georgia in case of the Kosovo recognition (which was really the opposite of what happened in Abkhazia, because in Abkhazia 85% where Georgians and in Kosovo was the nearly same amount of Albanians... - Georgians ARE the Kosovo, not somebody else.) Also this was Putin's response to the Polish missile defense plans and radar in Czech republic.

Needless to add Russians where preparing for war for months and months, moving it's army very openly to the Georgian border.. having military execrises a week before invasion in 5 km from the Georgian border... and so on.

The European report about war stated: "the more intense conflict followed the shelling of Tskinvali(a small town overtaken by Russian army in 1994) by the Georgian military", TRUE, BUT it does not mean anything. You should realize that there is a comma after this sentance and a list of all the provocations by the Russian side, including the ones that have caused deaths of Georgian civilian and peace-keepers weeks and months before this. In the end the fire and bombardments of the Georgian villages, in the CENTER of georgia where nonstop by the Russian GRU/FSB backed gangs.

"controlling media"

- I would Strongly disagree as somebody who speaks Georgian and has access to Georgian media. Georgian media is far from perfect (as any media I have seen personally) but saying that Saakashvili is "controlling media" is just wrong. EVERY TV channel in Georgia is covering the opposition every hour, up to 1/3 of the news are views/opinions of the opposition... Not to mention that radical opposition owns several TV channels that broadcast 24/7 across the country, all the broadcasts are starkly anti-presidential, often insulting and nonconstructive.
Same goes to papers, radio, internet...

Reporters without Borders index, France, Paris:

spot Level of Freedom
9 Iceland 2,00
68 Bulgaria 15,61 (EU and NATO member)
77 Montenegro 17,00 (EU and NATO member)
78 Croatia 17,17 (EU and NATO member)
***
81 Georgia 18,83 (I really thin it's not that bad at all!)
***
88 Albania 21,75 (NATO member, soon EU member)
90 Ukraine 22,00
111 Armenia 31,13 (Border with Georgia)
114 Moldova 33,75
123 Turkey 38,25 (NATO member) (Border with Georgia)
146 Azerbaijan 53,50 (Border with Georgia)
153 Russia 60,88 (Border with Georgia)

http://fr.rsf.org/press-freedom-index-2009,1001.html

"and somehow dubious economic achievements especially in the face of recent crisis."

- As somebody who has been visiting Georgia before Saakashvili and after, I have to say you are very wrong here too. it is completely a different country and I know few big European and Asian businessmen who agree with Saakashvili when he talks about economic reforms... You can clearly see a HUGE difference that those reforms have brought to the country.

But that's just an index:
Georgia 11
http://www.doingbusiness.org/EconomyRankings/

and there is a detailed explanation why Georgia is on that spot. I even met some Russian economists (not Illationov) who agree thats Saakashvili's reforms have been very positive. As for the crisis, I can't blame Georgia or their people for that.

 

DOGMA1980

6:22 PM ET

April 17, 2010

some facts

After reading this article someone could think- WOW!!! What a country!!! I want to live there.
According to CIA World Factbook in 2009 GDP list:
58 Russia $9000
64 Turkeu $7700
74 Kazakhstan $6900
85 Azerbaijan $5200
109 Armenia $2900
And finally 118 Georgia $2400
I just listed Goergia's neighbours.
Does not impress, right? Even isolated Armenia has a higher GDP.
More:
GDP per capita using again CIA:
56 Russia $15200
76 Kazakhstan $11400
78 Turkey $11200
84 Azerbaijan $9900
109 Armenia $5900
120 Georgia $4500
Again, I don't see any prosperity in Georgia, do you?
And you have to keep in mind american and EU help in over $4 bil.
Georgia's debt trippled in 2009 and now stands to 80% of GDP.
Now, I am not surprised why we have 1,5 mil gergian immigrants in Russia.
This week 45 georgian tourists asked assylum in Israel.
It is so great to live in Georgia people leave the country by thousands and this is in the country with 4,5 mil population.

 

AVRAM

9:55 AM ET

April 16, 2010

Misha's Naivety

Misha's foreign policy has been an absolute failure, even judging by the low standards of eastern europe. I know someone is going to correct me to say that Georgia is not technically eastern europe, but who cares.
Misha's policy was to join Nato, join european union and host a bunch of those "missile shields." This policy makes Georgia entirely dependent on western interests, i.e, lacking independence. Even in this, he put the horse before the cart by trying to join Nato before becoming part of the european union. Joining the union would have given the country access to european markets and improved job opportunities for georgians. In order to join european union you have to quiet the unrest at home, put your budget in order etc., none of which can be accomplished if you are sabre rattling russia on the north, spending tons on western weapons etc.
Furtheremore, Misha's overemphasis on its relationship with US is misguided. It sounds more like a battered woman trying to cuddle up to another big thug just to get even. What Georgia needs is independence, not more dependence. It also need to build relationsships with its neighbors, especially with russia because they are capable to causing trouble in georgia regardless of whether us is supplying you weapons. Its also important for georgia to get over its soviet past because sovient union doesn't exist any more, moscow is not red anymore, georgia's favorite son's (stalin) statute isn't up on every corner in russia anymore and putin is apologizing for katyn. its time for georgia to bury the hatchet with russia.

 

THOMAS111

5:15 AM ET

April 17, 2010

partly agree

I agree, but only with the first half of your comment. The second one is wrong. Russia has been invading Georgia time and time again. It does not matter if you think that Russia is "not Soviet" any more, because all the people who run Russia today LOVED Soviet union, I as a native Russian speaker should know this. I have all their media propaganda from Kremlin. As for words - " georgia's favorite son's (stalin)" - I think you just insulted Georgians very much, every Georgian I know has lost somebody thanks to Stalin, the "Autonomous regions" -Abkhazia/Ajaria/Samachablo where created on a historically Georgian soil and this is a tool for Kremlin's control of Georgia up to today. Also I think your knowledge of Russia is far worse than you think. I suggest go and live there for a couple of years... learn language and try to understand... I did and I did not like what I saw.

 

AVRAM

10:00 AM ET

April 16, 2010

one more point of advise for Misha

When a head of state decides to post something on a blog, they should at least plant a couple of people to write couple of supporting comments.

 

LEON

11:53 AM ET

April 16, 2010

No mate that's where u get it wrong :)

It should be all seen the frustration of the COMUNIST mentality

U should move to Russia but i dough u ll be able to give up western comfort !!!!!!!!!!

C'mon hateful comments LOLLLLLLLLLL

 

AVRAM

3:39 PM ET

April 16, 2010

"COMUNIST mentality"?

Yes, the puritan western governments do not plant bloggers to influence public opinion!!!! The last I heard, the bushy administration was paying iraqi journalists to plant stories in iraq, funding its own arab television channels, and even paid radio commentators in the US to do their publicity. Which western government do you think is not communist enough to plant stories, bloggers etc for publicity? Thats just the blatant manipulation. How about the sneaky leaking of stories to preferred "journalists" with sympathetic views, like judy miller and company at the storied times? Do you really think the western society has some form of independent media? Why look at the communists and even then why associate them with the russians. There are no more communists in russia; they are all in china, india and france.

 

THOMAS111

4:31 AM ET

April 17, 2010

This is the style of

This is the style of Saakashvili.... through, I could never understood him. We always wanted to play fair... well, it's a sign of stupidity in my book.

 

F1FAN

10:25 AM ET

April 16, 2010

Opposition Counter Article was to follow..........

BUT President Saakashvili had them all arrested and then blacked out the media.

Democracy: You're doing it wrong.

 

THOMAS111

4:30 AM ET

April 17, 2010

"UT President Saakashvili had

"UT President Saakashvili had them all arrested"

- Nothing like that ever happened.

"and then blacked out the media."

- In 2007, yes. For TWO DAYS! Because it was a "State of Emergency rule" This was only way to calm down the crazy part of opposition and former corrupted mafia that wanted to come back.

"Democracy: You're doing it wrong."

- Saakashvili is not perfect, but by god... look at ANY OTHER COUNTRY AROUND GEORGIA!

 

MUSTNOTSLEEP14

1:16 PM ET

April 16, 2010

I Applaud Him

There might be instances of an unfree press or other less than stellar items on the Georgian resume, but look at the region he is in. Look at the states that surround him. In the face of myriad problems such as war, heroin abuse, Islamic terrorism, homophobia etc, Georgia has managed to make significant reforms in becoming a transparent, functioning state. This is a massive accomplishment and we should give the Georgian people their due.

If Afghanistan, Pakistan Uzbekistan et al had only the problem of an unfree press and less than perfect democracy, the western world would still lament the situation. However, compared to the current status quo of those countries, less than perfect democracy is an improvement on the order of several magnitudes.

 

THOMAS111

5:20 AM ET

April 17, 2010

Well I have been to Georgia

Well I have been to Georgia time an time again and I can say that we vastly underestimate Georgia and Georgians. This is pretty much a European country with amazing history and culture (and food!) as for Freedoms, Georgians have PLENTY of them. I watch Georgian TV regularly and can understand the language... Also I know who the opposition is. If you visit Georgia, you will laugh that you where even trying to compare it to the countries that you listed. It's a nice country... in a very wrong neighborhood...

 

ZORRO

2:35 PM ET

April 16, 2010

Good/stupid

He thought he good do a wag the dog just like Israel. This makes him stupid in my book. However I don't doubt that Georgia will be a nicer country to live in than Russia, will be until the next time Mikhail decides to poke the sore toothed bear.

 

AVRAM

3:46 PM ET

April 16, 2010

Why is a head of state blogging?

Why would a head of state, albeit a failed state, publish an article in the bloggosphere? If he wanted the world elites to get behind him, he should have published in Financial Times. If wanted the foreign policy apparatus to take notice, he should have published in Foreign Affairs. If he wanted american public to take notice he should have published in one of those toilet newspapers like ny times or post. If he wanted the nutty right wing to read it he should have published in washington times? What audience is he trying to get to by publishing in fp? walt and rothkopf? it really is an odd choice for a head of state to put up an article in the bloggosphere, especially to title it "failed no longer." I have nothing against Misha, but it just seems odd.

 

JKOLAK

8:29 AM ET

April 17, 2010

Excellent Article

Whatever the reality on the ground, the values expressed in the article show the finest aspirations of Western Civilization.

What I would like to hear more of is how these dramatic changes were accomplished, especially regarding corruption.

Perhaps Georgia should send advisors to places like Somalia.

 

DOGMA1980

6:25 PM ET

April 17, 2010

Goegia is becoming Somalia itself.

After reading this article someone could think- WOW!!! What a country!!! I want to live there.
According to CIA World Factbook in 2009 GDP list:
58 Russia $9000
64 Turkeu $7700
74 Kazakhstan $6900
85 Azerbaijan $5200
109 Armenia $2900
And finally 118 Georgia $2400
I just listed Goergia's neighbours.
Does not impress, right? Even isolated Armenia has a higher GDP.
More:
GDP per capita using again CIA:
56 Russia $15200
76 Kazakhstan $11400
78 Turkey $11200
84 Azerbaijan $9900
109 Armenia $5900
120 Georgia $4500
Again, I don't see any prosperity in Georgia, do you?
And you have to keep in mind american and EU help in over $4 bil.
Georgia's debt trippled in 2009 and now stands to 80% of GDP.
Now, I am not surprised why we have 1,5 mil gergian immigrants in Russia.
This week 45 georgian tourists asked assylum in Israel.
It is so great to live in Georgia people leave the country by thousands and this is in the country with 4,5 mil population.

 

THOMAS111

1:32 AM ET

April 19, 2010

Well Georgian economic

Well Georgian economic ministers and some businessmen are economic consultants in reforms in some countries as I have read... so i guess they are helping with what they can.

 

THOMAS111

1:49 AM ET

April 19, 2010

To DOGMA1980

"After reading this article someone could think- WOW!!! What a country!!! I want to live there."

- Erm? This article just pointed out the changes in the country that was filled with corruption and bureaucracy and abuse of law in the past. Reforms that have been there are very real at they are very visible at least to me, who has been there in 1999 and in 2007 and 2009... This is a VERY different country now.

"According to CIA World Factbook in 2009 GDP list:
58 Russia $9000
64 Turkeu $7700
74 Kazakhstan $6900
85 Azerbaijan $5200
109 Armenia $2900
And finally 118 Georgia $2400
I just listed Goergia's neighbours.
Does not impress, right? Even isolated Armenia has a higher GDP."

- I honestly don't agree with the figures for Armenia... (I have lived there for two years..) As for Russia, Kazakhstan and Azerbaijan - Their GDP in very hevily Oil/Gas depandant. georgia unlike all those countries does not have any Oil or Gas.

but what it has is MUCH less corruption, simple and transparant economic laws and one of the best economic conditions for buisness IN THE WORLD! You can check any ratings by World bank, Forbes, Heritage foundation...

http://www.doingbusiness.org/EconomyRankings/

The country has jumped for 100+ something.. 11th place IN NEARLY EVERY economic rating agency.

"Again, I don't see any prosperity in Georgia, do you?"

- The article it called "Failed No Longer -
How Georgia came back from the brink" AND NOT - "We are ALL prospering in Georgia!"

"And you have to keep in mind american and EU help in over $4 bil."

- Well, yes. but you have to keep also in mind that ALL of this money went to healing scars from the Russians invasion in 2008 and building houndreds of thousands of homes for Georgian/Ossetian Refugees that Russian army has thrown out to clear a place for their military base.

"Georgia's debt trippled in 2009 and now stands to 80% of GDP."

- georgia's debt has grown indeed, but far less that 80%, it is a Russian figure posted in Kremlins "Izvestia" propoganda paper, it's not serious at all. The possibe 6% of GDP growth in Georgia in 2010 in a possiblity on the other hand.

"Now, I am not surprised why we have 1,5 mil gergian immigrants in Russia."

- Well... if you are Russian you might really want to belive in that. putin said 1 million, Medvedev few months later sad 2 millions... WOW, Russkies the Georgians have occupied you! RUN!

"This week 45 georgian tourists asked assylum in Israel."

- hey did and ALL of them where refugees from "Samachablo region" ("South Ossetia" in Russian propoganda) Their village "Nuli" has been looted, burned and bulldozered to the ground by Russian army... so they could build the military base there.

"It is so great to live in Georgia people leave the country by thousands and this is in the country with 4,5 mil population"

- It is great to live in Georgia and I have been lucky enbougth to visit that country many times and will visit in many more times, maybe even move there. And I've even met a whole family from US that has moved to Georgia to live. They told me we where looking for a nice, warm hospitable country
and we found Georgia. Maybe I will do the same.

For all you hater! Stay where you are! Peace! As Georgians say "Gaumarjos!"