Helpless to Help in Afghanistan's Local Government

Back in Kunduz, encounters with the unfortunate men whose job it is to keep northern Afghans safe and secure.

BY ANNA BADKHEN | APRIL 22, 2010

KUNDUZ — "The roads are safe," the police chief of Kunduz province, Gen. M. Razaq Yaqobi, declares categorically. "Day and night."

The map behind his desk suggests otherwise. It is covered in green and red dots. The green dots are police outposts; they fan out from the provincial capital, the city of Kunduz, in concentric circles, thinning out as they approach the edges of the province. The red dots are the forces of the Taliban, al Qaeda, and Gulbuddin Hekmatyar, a rebel leader who has opposed every Afghan government since the 1970s. On Yaqobi's map, red dots line every major road in Kunduz.

For More

To follow Anna's path through Afghanistan, check out this Google Map.

"Kunduz city is under government control," the provincial governor, engineer M. Omer, elaborates more cautiously an hour later. Shortly after our interview, I lose my cell phone reception. I assume it's a glitch in the network. Later, I learn that the Taliban switches off the local cell-phone towers every night. No one can call for help until dawn. They say the Taliban owns the night in Kunduz. It's unclear who owns the day.

"Let's say this is Kunduz," says Ahmadullah Daagh, the editor of the Kunduz magazine Afghanistan Today, pointing to a copy of his monthly. On the cover, a woman in a blue burqa is buying gold bracelets at a jeweler. Daagh draws invisible circles with his fingers all over the magazine: "Taliban, Taliban, Taliban, Taliban, Taliban."

A tiny area, no larger than a quarter, is left in the center. Daagh points at it: "Government," he says. "What can it do?"

Somewhere inside that dot of impotent government in Kunduz is a man named Meher Ali. I like him right away. He has a nice smile under a graying mustache, kind eyes, and horizontal wrinkles on his forehead to suggest that he spends a lot of time in melancholy.

Meher Ali is the head of the local department of Afghanistan's Ministry of Refugees. All day long, he sits in his crepuscular office in a tired brown suit over a pale-blue shirt. Three pink bouquets of plastic flowers on his desk clash with the beige window curtains, which are always drawn. Three crystal candy bowls, one next to each bouquet, stand empty.

There are, by Meher Ali's estimation, 222,000 refugees in this province of 1.2 million people. Last year, he received enough funding to hand out blankets and mattresses to about 400; he distributed those at the onset of winter.

This year, he has received no funding at all.

"They need food. Flour, rice, oil, tea. Medicine. We have nothing to help them with," Meher Ali tells me, and shows me the empty palms of his small hands, as if to prove he has nothing.

Some of the refugees have returned from exile in Pakistan, Tajikistan, and Iran after the U.S.-led war began in 2001 but found the lands that once had belonged to them taken by someone else. Others were displaced from their homes by the cycle of ethnic and tribal revenge that followed the fall of the Taliban regime. They have settled in camps, in abandoned villages, in homes they have hastily slapped together with clay and straw on tiny parcels of land the government has given them. Most of the refugees are unemployed.

I imagine the indigence of these refugees easily. Last week in Camp Shahraqi Mawjirin, in neighboring Balkh province, I met families who had returned to Afghanistan from Pakistan after the Afghan government promised them housing and jobs. Instead, the government had dumped them in a tract of salty desert, where nothing will ever grow, where there are no jobs, no electricity, no doctors. The refugees told me their children have been dying of cold. I tell this to Meher Ali, and he nods that yes, yes, that, sadly, is quite common. In Kunduz, children of refugees have been dying of cold, too. But he can do nothing about it.

MASSOUD HOSSAINI/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: AFGHANISTAN, SOUTH ASIA
 

Anna Badkhen's reporting trip to Afghanistan was made possible by a grant from the Center for Investigative Reporting. Her book about war and food, Peace Meals, is coming out in October.

Previous Entries of The Crossing:
Day 1: "Don't even dare travel on that road": Our correspondent ponders maps and routes in Kabul.
Day 2:
Our diarist flies from Kabul to Mazar-e-Sharif, carrying photos of old, lost friends.
Day 3: Digging out in Afghanistan’s forgotten village: Our correspondent visits a town buried in mud.
Day 5: "Who needs a playground when the children are dying?"
Day 6: “In my father’s house they gathered all the women into one room.”
Day 7: The muezzin of the Blue Mosque.
Day 8: Earthquakes and other disturbances.
Day 10: Ruins and reunions.

F1FAN

3:06 PM ET

April 22, 2010

Great travelogues

Very informative and interesting.

 

JORDANC

9:56 AM ET

April 23, 2010

Fantastic yet again.

Fantastic yet again.

 

SAMARKORBAN

1:13 PM ET

April 23, 2010

Commenting from Dubai: Please FP, Check your Facts!

I’m a Dubai Resident, Lebanese living in UAE since 6years and I would like to comment on what you raised in your article: Waste Land, BY MICHAEL Z. WISE | MARCH/APRIL 2010
1-Dubai was never a bubble, that word “Bubble” was created by British Medias & carried forward by other Medias, including FP, as just a “trendy” repetition.
2-Regarding the cars abandoned, every year, Dubai police raise a clear report listing a number of abandoned cars which is usual, to some nationalities, mainly Asians, who plans before coming to Dubai, to come over, get a job, then take loans & credit cards, send the money to their home countries than fly back home without cancelling their residencies, leaving the cars at the airport so they don’t raise their employers doubts. It had always happen and it’s happening everywhere else as un-straight people will always exist everywhere. That year it was extremely exaggerated as part of the media bashing on UAE & especially on Dubai.
3-The comment on the phone lines and fax machines on different floors are really “grand mother’s stories” and an insult to all UAE residents. I’m in a mid level senior position in Advertising and like all the working people in UAE , we all have access to all high tech communications on all the levels. We don’t even talk about it, as these are basic things related to work. Maybe Mr. Schindhelm didn’t know how to use the 28th floor facilities so they directed him to an easier option on a lower floor!.
4-Referring to your comment “refuge for those who had substantially failed and now far away use gold to build fake artistic dreams and castles in the air”, not any single thing was in the air, everything was planned & build on solid ground as we saw it & lived it as expatriates in UAE. It’s not because one project was not done or postponed, that we will deny the reality. And the reality is that UAE & Dubai specially delivered all what was promised in majority. From Burj Kkalifa to Meydan race course, to all the big projects that was executed, to the high end Metro, to all the sports events that are on going, to all the cultural events & international plays, to all the international Exhibitions , to all & every single effort to make everything continue on & on…
Of course some projects were cancelled due to the global recession, & of course a lot of things needed to be re-organized in order to cope with the new era, like every other country.
But today let us ask ourselves & Mr. Schindhelm: where can we find see such kind of ambition, will & determination to make every dream turn into a reality?
Obviously Mr. Schindhelm couldn’t catch the spirit of Dubai & its ongoing beat, which makes from the city the ultimate “City of Life”.
5- Regarding the terms you are using in your article, “the collapsed Dubai”, again check your information as Dubai never collapsed, Dubai is working hard, keeping ON against ALL winds
6- Regarding your mention about “the money-mad al-Maktoum dynasty”, for you so you know that we are all proud to live this era under the Al Maktoum family, which made from the sand a heaven, bringing the entire world to us, family which is combining inside her deep core, strategists, thinkers, planners, sportsmen & mostly achievers.
7- And last but not least, FP should be sure about such stories, like the story of Mr. Schindhelm which could be a one side story, carried over by some frustration & angriness. Obviously, for some personal & unknown reasons ,Mr. Schindhelm decided to tweet his story everywhere, using different kind of media’s in order to attract attention & to destroy in the same time., .
I’m really sorry for Mr. Schindhelm, who is coming obviously from the-traditional-squared- German culture, because he couldn’t understood what’s happening.
He just missed the most important: the chance to live the melting pot, the achievement, the tolerance, the self-realization, the exposure, the cross cultural relations and most of all that here, in Dubai, every dream can comes true.
I’m here because I like Dubai, so again FP, please check your facts!