Postcard from Tehran

Western journalists don't get too many opportunities to visit Iran these days. On my recent trip, I found economic discontent, growing political apathy, and plenty of Persian swagger.

BY HOOMAN MAJD | MAY 6, 2010

TEHRAN—Memo to Secretary Clinton: Iran is neither a military dictatorship nor or a police state. Yet. There is no visible military presence at the international airport, where despite a European ban on flights to and from its capitals in mid-April when I arrived, jumbo jets discharged and loaded thousands of passengers a day arriving and leaving for points east and west. Tehran's sleek and bustling Imam Khomeini international airport reminded one that an Icelandic volcano had temporarily managed to do to Europe what no American administration has succeeded in doing to Iran: isolating it -- though not for lack of effort.

There is also no visible military presence in the sprawling city of some 12 million souls and at times it seems an equal number of cars -- save for the occasional hapless-looking, newly shorn, and unarmed young army conscript in fatigues, begging a ride on the back of a motorcycle or in a shared taxi, a presence that has always been visible in any city in Iran, even in days of the monarchy. The mind-numbing traffic congestion, complete gridlock, on the newly transformed one-way Valiasr Avenue, the broad boulevard that runs from the south of the city all the way to the foothills in the north, the Sunset Boulevard of Tehran and the scene of many past marches and demonstrations in support of the Green Movement that sprang up after last year's disputed election, is as it always was. Drivers -- men, and often mal-veiled and heavily made-up women -- listen to loud pop music of the sort frowned upon by religious authorities, just as they always did, ignoring traffic laws and even the entreaties of the occasional traffic cop. The restaurants and cafes are bustling; weekly, and sometimes nightly, salons at the homes and offices of the elite continue unabated in a city where public entertainment is limited, the conversations usually fearlessly political in nature. Taxi drivers, reliable barometers for the average Iranian as they include everyone from professional working class drivers to the highly educated unemployed, and moonlighting office workers, continue to offer wisdom on everything from the political situation to social ills and the state of the economy.

My driver at the airport, an eager man in his forties who jumped out of his car with a smile, rather than the more normal scowl, to stow my suitcase, was likely from the professional class of cabbies -- for the airport trade is strictly controlled -- and it didn't take him long to explain his latest theory. "Business is bad, huh?" I first asked him, as he took off at an unsafe speed, barely missing a family struggling to load their private car with a mountain of luggage, presumably containing Western consumer goods from Dubai. "Yeah," he said, "there are no flights from Europe." I mentioned something about the travel ban potentially contributing to Iran's economic stagnation. "I hear Europe could be cut off for days, even weeks!" he excitedly replied. "But you know, Allah always finds a way to punish the wicked, doesn't He? England is the worst country in the world and what happens? Their airports are shut down by God."

I laughed. "England is evil," he continued. "What if their airports don't reopen for a month, or forever! What if Allah decides the volcano will continue to erupt forever? England will finally go down the drain, and we'll be standing!" My driver's dislike of the U.K., and his suspicion that Britain is behind all of Iran's (and the world's) woes, is actually shared by many Iranians, even middle and upper-middle class Iranians, although perhaps not to his extent. But Britain, particularly since the Iranian presidential election of 2009 and in the age of a likeable Barack Obama, has to some degree replaced the U.S. as the Great Satan (it was always labeled the "Little Satan," along with Israel) for Iranian supporters of the Islamic system. As if reading my thoughts, though, the driver then said, "Of course, I'm not saying we don't have problems here in Iran; not at all."

Hooman Majd

 

Hooman Majd, a New York-based writer, is author of The Ayatollah Begs to Differ and the forthcoming The Ayatollahs' Democracy.

NSC LONDON

7:28 AM ET

May 7, 2010

post card from moronistan

Allah closing Britain's airports, earthquakes caused by women who don't wear robes... this primitive civilisation is absurd at best.

 

IAN

11:25 AM ET

May 7, 2010

Nice to see a non-western opinion

For once. A good show put on by someone from within Iran that definitely describes something completely different to what the US and Israel want us to believe.

To NSC London - If you actually read the article, you would have noticed that he mentions the populace mocking the earthquake thing. There are always absurd people in any country. There are people who believe that we never landed on the moon, or the Holocaust never happened, or global warming isn't actually happening.

As well, for strictly religious people, why wouldn't a volcano be caused by Allah, or God or Zeus or Shiva or whoever? Just as you believe in the science of tectonic plates and pressure pushing against the crust, they believe everything happens by the hand of Allah. Hence their government's fear of a large earthquake in Tehran. What happens to a government run by religion having a bad time and suddenly a large natural disaster hits. I'm guessing the whole Green movement thing would jump out saying Allah must be angry for (insert reason here), time to change the leaders.

 

JACOB BLUES

11:29 AM ET

May 7, 2010

Comments like that are hardly surprising NSC

Allah closing Britain's airports are one of those, "So Good, its Karma" sort of toss off comments that are made around the globe. And as for sin resulting in natural disasters, there is no shortage of comments made by the truly ignorant or nasty to make comments like that. Remember, similar comments were made about 9.11, the Pacific Tsunami that killed tens of thousands in Indonesia, among other places. Earthquakes in Hati, Iran, Pakistan, Turkey, Greece, etc. Hurricaine Katrina.
.
Everyone is looking for a rationale, a reason, to point to for those who were unfortunate enough to be in the path of mother nature's devestation, rather than work with the idea of it was just bad fortune that occurred to be in that time and place. Again, just aonther means of thinking "there but for the grace of God, go I".
.

 

PIROUZ

7:28 PM ET

May 7, 2010

Great piece, Hooman. I

Great piece, Hooman. I particularly enjoyed the anecdotes.

When will the new book be out?

 

MATHEWH

5:32 AM ET

May 8, 2010

Excellent piece as always

I always enjoy reading Hooman Majd's articles. He provides a realistic picture of what is going on in Iran and the opinions of people from different strata of the country.

In this country the main stream media and the Iranian dissidents who have painted a totally different picture of what is taking place among the Iranian populace. Iranians are no different than the rest of the world in wanting a better economic situation. and more rights. This does not mean they are asking for a revolution or an overthrow of their government.

I speak to many Americans from working class families who have the same issues and grumble about how the U.S. Gov. has not taken care of their problems and needs; rather the rich have gotten richer while the masses are still struggling to make a living.

It's about time for our government to stop imposing its will and dictates on other countries and learns what true diplomacy and engagement is all about. We have not tried diplomacy with Iran even though we continue to repeat it as if we have.

Thank you Mr. Majd for an excellent article.

 

QLINEORIENTALIST

3:22 AM ET

May 9, 2010

Khatami, military dictatorship, etc.

Majd writes that the regime considers Khatami "mamnoon-e khorooj", which literally means they'd be glad if he'd leave. What he meant, of course, is "mamnoo-e khorooj".

As for the piece itself, it reminds me of the writings of American journalists like Robin Wright back when she was still "explaining" the Islamic Republic to the West. There are good observations of the Iranian zeitgeist combined with just plain political obliviousness.

Iran is not heading to military dictatorship? Well, of course not. Just ask Majd. No troops on the street. This is the art of carefully missing the point. Iranian observers have long pointed to the rise of influence of the Revolutionary Guards in Iranian politics and economy.

Wright has long given up her task. But her mission is in good hands with Majd.

 

SHEYDA

1:02 PM ET

May 10, 2010

Islamic Republic of Lies and deception

All this article trying to impy are pure lies. When the Islamic Republic's leaders bluntly liie in public about anything and deny the repression of their theocrocy, it's not surprising to see an agent spread the same lies. I'm so sorry to see that after all the pictures and movies of brutality shown all over the world last year, there are still those who choose to ignore facts and accept what they like to believe. People such as the writer of this article distort facts delibrately to justify the most unhumane and brutal regime existing at the present time. Looking the other way and ignore what's happening in Iran is the same mistake that western people did when Nazi regime took power in Germany or genocide took place in Lowanda. Executing five innocent Kordish citizens is the latest act of brutality that is going on for over 30 years all over Iran. These people were only executed for their different beliefs. I know it's hard for non-Iranian to believe this, but as an Iranian-American who travel to Iran frequently and have many connections, I assure you fact finding about what is really happens in Iran is not difficult at all. This is inspite of all scensorship imposed by the regime. I wish all those who might reject what I'm saying based on their prejudice, could travel there and spend a few days. If you want to have a clear conscience, do a little research and find for yourself.

 

AA

3:34 PM ET

May 10, 2010

Great article but last paragraph was nuts!

how can you rule out the attack option?
http://middleast-west.blogspot.com/2010/05/is-it-still-worth-reading-foreign.html

 

HUMANIST_2

4:06 PM ET

May 10, 2010

I wish Hooman was a bit more analytical

I have been reading Hooman’s writing or watching his interviews with MSM. especially since the June 2009 Iranian election.

This post card, as typical of Majd's work, is a nice poetic essay portraying his pleasant character...and more.. it is also a testimony of his subtle evolution toward more literacy in the complex political arena.

Probably now his eyes are curiously opened wider, he is finding out The Green was a plot concocted outside Iran mainly by powerful enemies of Iran... and the assertions of “Fraud” in election by them were a “BIG LIE”

He was a panelist in a live video conference where the statisticians of University of Maryland (WPO) showed why the election was legitimate and how no one in the dark neocon world has ever presented a single evidence of fraud in that election including those who rum polling activities in the US corrupt media.

The two part, 2 hours long video of that conference can be watched here:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NKG-hUyk1_0

I wish he now accepts the fact that statistically well-designed polls are very reliable and are capable of detecting contradictory proclamations and questioning himself why so many covert and overt establishments spend millions of dollars every year for polls in the Middle East (including Iran).

I wish he now concentrates on who were those who so effectively spread that big lie of fraud ...a lie that fooled nearly everyone in the world.

 

GEMMBA

8:21 PM ET

May 10, 2010

Great Article.

Well wriiten and clearly pointed. Thanks for sharing. Find more world best news headlines

 

MALA

8:26 PM ET

May 10, 2010

Worth reading.

Great post. As one commented I have always enjoy reading Hooman Majd's articles. He provides a realistic picture of what is going on in Iran and the opinions of people from different strata of the country.

 

PTEHRANI

9:36 PM ET

May 11, 2010

Only non-Iranians would agree with the content of this article!

This article is not truthful!
The author might have the best intentions in the world but his background or his political inclinations regarding the Iranian Dictatorial regime make him blind!

We (the people of Iran) hate this regime and have done so for 30 years! This regime has killed the Iranian soul, 3000 years of culture and civilization!

No-one in Tehran says "God keep the leader in good health". This is a joke!

Iranians especially in the capital absolutely hate the regime and the corrupt mollahs that do not represent Iran nor the Iranian people.

But hopefully soon this regime will fall and the entire world will see the true face of Iran and Iranians. We are friendly, fun-loving people who crave for better relationship with the world. We have suffered too much under this regime and want freedom!

Thank you in the western world for supporting the Iranian people.

Parviz

 

HUMANIST_2

12:46 PM ET

May 13, 2010

To Parviz

I understand your feelings, IRI is a backward, medieval regime, its past records are appalling....

Yet .....watch carefully what is going on in the political arena......who are the powerful enemies of Iran who are determined to destroy its defense, factories, etc

I ask you to study reports such as:

http://iran2009presidentialelection.blogspot.com/

on the Iranian election. There was no fraud..... neocons (as Kenneth Timmermann revealed) used Iranians as their pawns making them believe the election was "stolen" from them.

Be patient, the existence of IRI is against the tides of history, it will crumble, but its demise should not be masterminded by psychopathic neocons

Now neocons are pushing the West towards another Iraqi style war with Iran.
Now is the time to accept the will of majority...Ahmadinejad is the legitimate president of Iran. On February 11, 2010, even the atheists marched to show the West / Israel “we are not fools”

 

HUMANIST_2

1:21 PM ET

May 13, 2010

To Parviz......An important note

According the Geolab Satellite Images, the march on the last "Revolution Day" (February 11, 2010) was probably the largest ever. (Maybe larger than the day Khomeini returned from exile?)

Think about it...why it was the largest....impartially study it.......then you'll understand why you shouldn't have written

"Thank you in the western world for supporting the Iranian people"

I am a ultra-pacifist, anti-violence, humanist atheist, yet on your "thank you west" I agree with the Iranian left (refer to:
counterpunch.com/sasan02182010.html )

Maybe you are young and you can’t envisage the immense pains Iranians endured during the Shah’s rule..

 

AMIR_IRANI

4:39 PM ET

May 26, 2010

TO Humanist _2 and to Auther

I`m Iranian and I live In Iran. I'm not young and to you Humanist Maybe you did n`t lived in Iran for many years? I think You`re not vary aware of Iran`s internal situation, So maybe it`ll help you to know the situation.
First I apologize to you and anyone, because my English Is poor, Then because I live in Iran and I can`t send A replay while I use Proxy. I Can`t answer You because I may be captured By government, and if it looks strange i should say Contacting with Foreign Enemy medias is forbidden in Iran, at last if they say Foreign Policy is a Media of America and against us they enough reason to imprison me.
About What you said I try to answer I start with Ceremony of February 11. First about Streets well I don`t know you heard it or Not but Greens had a plan (Not all part of them) named Trojan Horse ( If you search Ebrahim Nabavi and Trojan Horse you get it) their plan was to go under cover with nothing to show that their Greens not Pro Governments, in the Streets., Tehran`s anniversary Ceremony heart is Azadi Sq. where President Has a speech any year, So,Greens Idea was to go there and then start to show who they are and say their words. well this hadn't happened, they did n`t let us enter square, and closed that street that leads to square. instead ( Because they know this plan) only certain people who where in that square from night stood there, it`s the reason in satellite pics, you find streets full, but square not completely full. check it on web, and the truth we`ll be revealed.
About People in Iran and Israel and US your wrong, I`m sorry but it`s what you have no sense of it. well Israel Is n`t important to us infect people are tired of seeing anything we have is used for Palestine, not all but many people, and about Us it`s the same, We had problem, but hatred of government even make US more acceptable for Iranians.
and about people who mentioned in Iran. I may use wrong word because I don`t how should I say it in your Language the government did not spread Fear it Installed Fear, any body scares to say a word in Taxi bus any place any body scares that other maybe a Government Spy I say why later. So even someone who says he comes from America maybe a fear specially because He speaks Persian, he may think: well, he is not against Government because they can`t return because if they returnn they will be captured at airport, ( and it is what happens realy if you acted against regime in foreign countries) Or you're some one who work for government so it`s danger. I don`t speak about this Taxi driver what I say is why you can`t expect people to say anything against regime,from 100 man you see man maybe 10 man be pro government but what can you say about other 90 silent ones? who even don`t dare to speak? and more important even if you ask me about government in real world I would say well, Janam Fadaye rahbar, (MY Life is devoted To Rahbar :Mr.Khamenei) any other answer even silence may show you I am against Regime. Well, I give you an Example. thonk about Robin Hood. if you asked anyone in Nottingham about Prince John They would Say a very Good King Righteous Rightful King, ... who can you trust? 2 man has been executed before, 4 man and 1 woman had been executed recently, and 6 others has the same future, others? some of them yet have open case, some has longtime prisons, and No one who was captured in winter will be released (official announcement of government: Google about words of Abbas Dolat Abadi about them). This is fear and people try to avoid danger yes they do fear, but it differs with accepting Governments word of US ( I really think you heard This about Atheist People march against US in Pro Government Site, it`s their favorite words even the ... said down with US, Even.... Said Down With Israel. they really love to find American Sites or Men who say something against US or in their favorite: for example if any channel in Us say anything against US government even if it`s a newspaper with 1000 readers Iranian TV has News about it, Or For example They said FUKUYAMA spoke about shia and said Shia is the strongest thought in worked or is a bird that America can`t get and ... ( I don`t Know that Fukuyama said it or not it is what are TV said he said). This Style of Atheist Even is Iranian Government`s Usual they wanna say anybody is with us.
I don`t know You heard anything about Basij Or not? they are a military group that has near 1 million Nearly Half of Them believe Mr. Khameneyi is the successor of Imam Mahdi ( Shia`s 12th Imam and in Shia Imam is Successor Of Holy Prophet Mohammad and Imam and His Successor is someone who should (Not have the right: should) to roll the Muslims) well for them killing people and shooting and using buttons is not even a good job, It`s what they should do defiance of Mr. Khamenei is a sin ( Welcome to dark ages). They have very faith in their believes and do anything for it, for example in Anniversary ceremony some of the came from across country to Tehran ( Google Saeed Ghassemi`s speech ( A sepah`s general and Pro Government, who even in one of his speache he says they canceled anniversaries in other cities in Tehran state which always had a ceremony in this 30 years( Tehran City is Capital City of Tehran State) and transported People to Tehran. I even suggest you to Google ( if you have an Iranian friend to do it in our language) about basij members from other parts of country even with 800 Kilo Meters distance. Yes they really believe and a believer is very strong and very dangerous if he has a gun too. if you spread 100000 basiji` sin town like Tehran there is always a possibility that while you say something against regime one of them hears it, and they really think the good thing ( No even What they should do) is to give you to government, It`s a very good way to silence anyone, scare to speak scare to trust.
Today Iran is a behalf Country some people are Pro Government, Some against, and nearly all Iranian`s are very attracted to policy ( well not always very Pro,, but always Politics is a speech between Iranians, If it was not this days of fear you could see any place Politics is the most important and usual course of speech.) The pro Government Group Has Media to send their favorite news to world, not even 1 foreign journalist had right to report iran`s for example Ghods Day Protest to world, Why? because they will have Maziar Bahari`s ( Google Him) destiny. so maybe you have Analysis by Protesters But You Can`t Have Videos or pics by, all of thevideos we have of Iran are citizen`s, Cellphone`s cameras. it`s how Government controls News. you can`t Know what was in February 11 from satellite by details and only close view videos was Government`s it`s how the truth can hide. Easy no? Pro Government has all Political Power, they have Courts too, and Military Power Because basij and Sepah are groups for them. What Other group has is all their quantity, but it`s not always enough people may believe what the government says is wrong but they don`t think they have power to change the situation. Don`t Expect them to risk their lives from every 100 man one man we`ll do it. Others won`t.
So this is the situation you see a government who has power by force and people who are scared to die ( and i think they have right to do it) and a world who gets News from most Untestable Source about it : The Government itself.
Well Humanist_2 I think you`re Hatred of NeoCons makes you say anything against them even if NeoCons ( whom I don`t like too) defend good thing you try to show that the thing that they defend is bad. cause you scary to find them right in even one single decision. I saw that blog too. Look man try to be realistic. This viewpoint you have is a very dangerous one Always try to find hidden dark man behind ( O OOH scary song).I f I have your point of view I should say:UMMM. Yes America worked with Iran`s Regime NeoCons Tried to make Iranians Protesters Reputation bad, and Hooman Writes this to support Regime for money or.... and You Humanist_2 you are one of the Regimes Members who you are paid to write any where the election was not fraud, and this web logs are like you and .... Try to exit the Cold War age man. Cold War is ended For US and Israel yes Even Israel its better that Iran`s Government change, it maybe true. But Mr.Ahmadinejad Was president for 4 last years, and belive any day was bad. but what? No street Protesters. It was not him or US who did it it was fraud Election. People were angry, I don`t know you heard about reasons of fraud Election or Not, but Mr.Moosavis team has 370 pages document released in web. Read. It`s not that 4 line in that blog. and more important don`t belive what you read in this blogs. For Example I only read this paragraph yet and this BIg lie don`t expect me to trust it:
No significant discrepancy was found, and the candidate whose representatives had observed the recount (Rezai) withdrew his complaint three days later. LIE,LIE LIE:
Why: National TV: after this observation Rezai`s Representatives this blog says. Rezai`s Brother Omidvar Rezai and his Agent Says:
I saw 70 percents of votes with one pen one hand writing and One name: AHmadiNezhad. after this Kadkhodai Spokesman of shoraye Negahabn High council who they did this Observation says (In National TV): these acts are acts that Courts Should React to them this is Spreading lie. after it Omidvar Rezai Became Silent: You Name It Acceptance? and Rezaie withdraws.
You Know I don`t know about this blogs who think they should do anything against US government maybe their source is Iran`s Government Or maybe they just wanna do this to do against US with no responsibility of consequences of their acts anyway: READ EVERYTHING not only this kinds I`m Iranian I Live here. at last That Blog is filled of lies or untrue data.
Good luck. and sorry that I can`t stay to answer. I even Risked My life to post it.

 

KOUHYAR

9:02 AM ET

May 27, 2010

Questionable Article

In a country where no media correspondent or political observer is allowed to travel and report, it is very interesting that Mr. Majd is not only travels to Iran but also sends a "postcard" with explicit messages to US Secretary of State and US foreign policy establishment. It's not surprising that such "postcard" paints a very rosy picture of what's taking place in Iran politically and what the Iranian public thinks of the Supreme Leader & Co! You don't have to be a political expert on Iran to sense this. A little common sense suffices.

As an Iranian-American who has followed Iranian politics for the past 15 years and has been following news about Iran after their presidential election on daily basis for the past year, I couldn't agree more with other Iranians who have made comments above about this article. I won't reiterate their points as they have clearly indicated them. I will add to them just to give non-Iranians reading this article more food for thought.

I don't know Mr. Majd's agenda in writing this report, but I characterize his intention misguided at best. I was giving Mr. Majd the benefit of the doubt until I came across his assertion that Iran's regime is not a military dictatorship. Just because one sees no security forces in mass at the airport, doesn't make a country free and democratic. I don't need to remind Mr. Majd that Iran's entire military is under command of a single, unelected "leader" that in addition overseas the regime's broadcast networks, media, the judiciary branch, and the guardian council that is tasked to vet any candidate running for any election and disbars thousands of candidate each election period just because these candidates are not 100% aligned with the leader! The leader is the only person receiving financial reports from the Revolutionary Guards, which by now has monopoly on every worth-while contract that the Iranian government places for bidding. The leader is also the only person receiving financial reports of so-called Bonyad's (government-run organizations that have factories, hotels, and many other businesses under their umbrella and make millions of dollars per year by collecting the proceeds from these businesses) without reporting a dime of it to the people. I wonder what else a regime should do to be branded dictatorship by Mr. Majd!!

I wouldn't worry about articles such this if it wasn't the fact that US foreign policy apparatus tends to be affected by "experts" like Mr. Majd when making policy decisions regarding the brutal regime of Iran. Like other Iranians commented above, I believe it's not hard to find the truth about Iran these days. Just check out youtube, Facebook, twitter, or other social media networks. For those who tend to ignore the real news and instead pay attention to "postcards" like this, I can't force them to open their eyes.

 

ADRIAN888

1:34 AM ET

June 4, 2010

An excellent article

Well written post. Thanks for sharing. Find more political articles