Sri Lanka's Vindictive Peace

A year after the final battle against the Tamil Tigers ended, the war is far from over.

BY SOMA ILANGOVAN | MAY 17, 2010

Last May, Sri Lankan soldiers captured the final piece of land held by the separatist Tamil Tigers, killing hundreds of rebel fighters, including the group's leader, and definitively ending a 26-year civil war that claimed as many as 100,000 lives.

On May 19, the first anniversary of the war's end, however, there is little to celebrate. As many as 93,000 Tamils remain in detention camps and transit centers, while 11,700 more (of which 550 are children) are being held as ex-combatants without charges, denied access to an attorney or their families. Conditions in the camps and prisons are appalling, with human rights groups documenting cases of torture and rape, in addition to poor housing, health, sanitation, and education facilities.

This is not what peace is supposed to look like. And the centers and camps are only the most visible symptom of the Sri Lankan government's apparent disinterest in genuine reconciliation. Far from ending the root conflict, the end of fighting has left the island as ethnically divided as ever, undermining the prospects for a durable peace and regional stability. In many ways, Sri Lanka has simply traded the horror of war for conflict of another, more tedious, continuous sort: a two-tiered society in which Tamils are kept at the bottom.

The evidence is everywhere. Outside the detention and transit centers, there has been little significant reconstruction or development in the Tamil regions of the country. Citizens believe that vital aid to rebuild war-torn communities is being siphoned by the government for its own budget priorities, including investment in tourist projects in the former warzone. More than 1.5 million landmines contaminate the north of the country. Few job programs have been launched, and infrastructure has been neglected, leaving many Tamils unable to return to communities where homes, schools, hospitals, businesses, and churches were destroyed. Land seized during the conflict has not been returned, and fishing rights have not been restored.

More ominously, President Mahinda Rajapaksa's government has made no headway in advancing the essential freedoms and political reforms necessary for true reconciliation, like political power-sharing and decentralization. Such changes could help eradicate the Tamil disenfranchisement that inspired the insurgency in the first place, for example by giving the Tamil-dominated north a stronger voice in the country's government.

But instead of launching those sorts of conciliatory programs, as Rajapaksa promised he would do in his successful reelection campaign in January, the government has done exactly the opposite. After the election, Rajapaksa's administration arrested his opponent and accused him of plotting a coup. The government continues to intimidate the press and restrict freedom of movement and speech. It is discouraging Tamils from returning to their homelands and instead pushing the resettlement of majority Sinhalese in the north and east. In short, the policy smacks of an official campaign to engineer the island's demographics and diminish the Tamil culture. Instead of ending discrimination, the government's actions too often institutionalize it.

Ishara S.KODIKARA/AFP/Getty Images

 

Soma Ilangovan is a member of the Tamil American Peace Initiative, a group of Tamil Americans formed to advocate for lasting peace, justice, democracy and good governance in Sri Lanka. 

EUREKA

5:49 AM ET

May 18, 2010

Internal colonialism of 62+ years must be ended

47 years after this:
CEYLON : A DIVIDED NATION, B H Farmer(1963):
Since those saddening days of 1958 Ceylon has had its share of trouble.....The truth, though unpalatable may be to some, is simply that nobody unacceptable to the present Sinhalese Buddhist nationalism has any chance of constitutional power in contemporary Ceylon.
29years after this:
Ethnic Conflict and Violence in Sri Lanka - Report of International Commission of Jurists 1981: ‘’The fate of the Tamils in Sri Lanka remains a matter of international concern''.

We are still here. Why?

Sri Lanka has been an expert in damage control. The rest of the human rights violators have a lot to ''learn'' from Sri Lanka:

1.http://blog.unwatch.org/?cat=43
Sri Lanka’s Ex-Ambassador: “I blocked UN rights council from investigating our war”, 1 November 2009

http://blog.unwatch.org/?cat=43
New low: U.N. rights council praises Sri Lanka after mass killings, UN Watch, 27 May 2009: ‘’Today’s U.N. Human Rights Council special session on Sri Lanka ended in disgrace, with the U.N. lavishing praise on the very government it was meant to hold to account.’’

2.http://www.caribbeannetnews.com/news-19359--6-6--.html
CMAG needs to be reviewed and strengthened, Maja Daruwala, Executive Director, Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative, 20 October2009:
‘’... For example in the case of Sri Lanka, reports of large scale civilian deaths, impunity and stifling of human rights in Sri Lanka continued to emerge throughout 2008 and 2009 but CMAG has refused to put Sri Lanka in its agenda. The additional irony is that Sri Lanka itself continues to serve as a member of CMAG during this period for a third consecutive (two year) term contrary to the 1999 Durban Communiqué that limits a country to a maximum of two consecutive terms. ...’’

The oppressive Sri Lanka is ''lucky'' to be an island(where a lot of things can be hidden or evidence thrown into the sea) in a geopolitically strategic location - pitting China against India. Pitting Southern Hemisphere against Northeern Hemisphere.

 

NIMBLEHUMAN

9:31 AM ET

May 18, 2010

In other words...

...the Sinhalese establishment is acting in the very same way that caused the Tamils to rise up in armed revolt against the Sri Lankan establishment in the first place.

Acting out of reflexive bigotry is only going to create more of the same. It looks like the Sri Lankan government is trying to emulate the Israelis' treatment of the Palestinians.

So don't be surprised if the next phase of the Sri Lankan civil war involves a group even more vicious and decentralized than the Tamil Tigers.

 

INDIAN

1:19 PM ET

May 18, 2010

role of india

i think more than the states , india has to take an agressive role in its neighbourhood and needs to figure out a foreign policy mechanism to enforce sri lanka to act upon these deficits that will degrade their own society and there by hindering india's own national security !! .... if anyone has more effect on sri lanka on both sides its india, and india should act upon it immediately

 

JFERDY5

2:37 PM ET

May 18, 2010

Tamil Nationalism (Fascism) is the Root Problem

Tamil fascism is the root of the problem. Tamils are told by Tamil Nationalists to self segregate, and that they have a "right to self determination," which are code words for ethnic cleansing. In Malaysia, Tamil Nationalist groups have asked for their own "homeland" to be carved out of Malaysia through an extremist party called HINDRAF, which is now banned in Malaysia. Tamils are also more known for their criminal behaviour and poor academic performance than anything else in Singapore, where they fill the jails at disproportionate rates. In India, the Tamil extremist party the DMK, with their leader "Vaiko the Psycho" calls for "race wars" (another myth propagated by Tamil nationalists is that other South Asians are from a "different race"). In Canada and the UK, transnational ethnic Tamil gangs like the VVT and AK Kannan extort, mame, and kill Tamils who do not support the LTTE or its segregationalist, genocidal demands for a "homeland." Tamil Nationalists actively discriminate against Tamil Muslims because they are not "Tamil" enough. Numerous accounts of Tamil controlled areas expelling Muslims pepper Western media. All of this comes from the ideology of Tamil Fascism and Nationalism, which preaches segregation and hatred rather than brotherhood, and that anyone different has "colonized" (a key Tamil nationalist code word for justifying ethnic hatred) the "Tamil Homeland." There is no Tamil nation-state, and Tamils have many homelands, which are also populated by other people. Tamils need to drop this 19th century ideology and live in the 21st century.

 

AVOCADO

9:23 AM ET

May 19, 2010

Common sense is not so common

You should consider, very seriously, about educating yourself about the problems that has exited for decades in Sri Lanka. Fascism? You shouldn't talk about things you don't really understand. And, so much bitterness, and animosity...you're an example of present day collective sinhala mass racism and ignorance.

 

BLACKPRINCE

6:34 PM ET

May 18, 2010

JFERDY5 is a racist!

Tamils in Toronto, Canada, where I am from do very well in terms of academic performance at least. Yes there were gangs but this is a minority. As a (purely anecdotal) example: My parents are both practising medical doctors, and I'm a final year medical student.

Its attitudes like JFERDY's that make some Tamils think that the govt/Sinhalese ppl are against them!

 

JFERDY5

11:12 PM ET

May 19, 2010

Tamils are not a Race

Being Tamils is not a race. It's an ethnicity. You've committed one of the cardinal sins of Tamil nationalism: racializing politics. So technically you're the one being "racist." Just because I dislike Tamil Nationalism does not make me Sinhalese. If you want to try and shut down debate by playing the race card, you might want to do it more convincingly.

Anecdotal evidence isn't really evidence, so here's some statistics. If you doubt my claims about Tamils underperforming, here's a link to a report published in the Star about performance in English:

http://www3.thestar.com/static/PDF/080613_school_achieve.pdf

Note that Tamils perform BELOW average. They also drag down the overall performance of South Asians (Hindi and Bengali speakers perform better than the average). The same is the case in Malaysia, where Tamils are more known for criminal activity and radical politics (HINDRAF) than their accomplishments. This isn't because Sri Lankan Tamils are criminals or incapable of academic achievement. It's because Tamil Nationalism makes them waste their time hating others, and radicalizing young Tamils. Indian Tamils excel in virtually everything they do because they aren't wasting time trying to bring the LTTE back to life and carve out a "homeland" through decades of violence.

Tamil Nationalism is the root of the problem, and no peace will come until this 19th century ideology is abolished. I hope you realize that before your people destroy themselves.

 

BLACKPRINCE

7:22 PM ET

May 20, 2010

JFERDY5

Your argument that Tamils underperform is stupid and doesn't add value to the debate. Clearly you didn't go to university...

Its like Larry Summers' comment that women aren't in the sciences and maths in higher level graduate programs and it must be looked into that they are genetically inferior. It may be true perhaps, I don't know, on average maybe, but its ultimately meaningless, adds nothing to the debate and yes IS SEXIST!

Btw the whole concept of race as a biological framework is meaningless, but that doesn't make the word meaningless. Racism is defined as discriminating against a different ethnicity or culture. Hence, Sunni on Shia prejudice would be a form of racism, as would Swedish on Italian prejudice.

Any generalization such as "Indian Tamils excel in virtually everything they do" , any statement as broad as that can only be made by someone with a small mind - or an Indian Tamil nationalist...

I'm done debating with you mate, because your arguments are crap and appear racist against Tamils. Btw I would agree that most Tamils in Toronto (where im from) ARE idiots, and know nothing abotu the war, but then I'd argue the same about most SInhalese, and wait, most people in general too!

The corollary to being high-achieving is that everyone else is low-achieving, and this is the case with most people compared to myself, and apparently yourself too!

 

BLACKPRINCE

7:24 PM ET

May 20, 2010

OF COURSE THEY PERFORM WORSE IN ENGLISH YOU MORON!!!

Most Tamils in TO are from refugee families and their parents don't speak english so of COURSE they wont' do as well as other ethnicities.
You are seriously the dumbest fucking person I've ever had the displeasure of debating with. I've never met anyone as essentialist and biologically determinist as you who likely isn't a doctor nor a scientist.

 

BLACKPRINCE

7:29 PM ET

May 20, 2010

Your anecdotal arguments against tamils

that are biologically essentialist and locale-dependent are LAUGHABLE, Ferdinand! LIke really now...did a Tamil boy steal your girlfriend/boyfriend or something? Geez louise, you are the type of person the tea party would love to have: someone with enough time on your hands to be outraged, and yet not enough initiative to do something to fix your situation, and someone who is willing to hate on other cultures when he himself likely lacks any significant accomplishment!!!!!!

 

BRYAN THOMPSON

6:37 AM ET

June 16, 2010

Sri Lanka's peace

But a year after the guns fell silent, Sri Lanka's ethnic divisions remain deep and many questions raised by the war are still unanswered. One of them is what happened in those horrific final months of conflict when almost 300,000 Tamil civilians were sandwiched between the rebels and advancing Government troops. xerox phaser 8550 solid ink Because the Sri Lankan military didn't allow independent journalists and most humanitarian workers near the war zone, the claims and counter claims made by both sides during that last phase of fighting could not be verified, especially those concerning civilian casualties. The bitter ethnic conflict dominated the island nation's politics and economy for two generations and killed at least 70,000 people. phaser 8550 solid ink sticks The war effort stunted the economy and drained the government coffers. Indeed, one study found Sri Lanka's economy would be 30 per cent bigger if not for the war.