Ethiopia's Democratic Sham

A government clampdown has rendered the outcome of Sunday's parliamentary elections a foregone conclusion. Washington doesn't seem to mind that its ally, Prime Minister Meles Zenawi, is assured a win.

BY NATHANIEL MYERS | MAY 21, 2010

I first glimpsed the depth of suppressed urban anger toward the Ethiopian government a few hundred paces into the annual 10-kilometer Great Ethiopian Run in Addis Ababa in November 2008. An immensely popular fun-run organized by Ethiopia's most famous marathoner, it is one of the very few occasions when the government still allows citizens to gather en masse. And the runners took advantage; as we surged through the city's main artery in matching red race T-shirts, anti-government slogans began to rumble across the crowd around us. The chants rose in volume and intensity whenever we passed a bastion of federal power -- the Justice Ministry, the Supreme Court, the presidential compound. One recurring refrain combined a demand for the release of a popular political prisoner with a rhythmic, insistent, "O-bam-a!" It had been just a few weeks since Barack Obama's election, an event that had inspired many in Addis to hope that change would come not just to the White House, but to its approach toward their country and eventually to their own government.

On Sunday, May 23, Ethiopians will be out politicking again -- this time heading to the polls to vote in parliamentary elections. But few will harbor any illusions about the likelihood of voting in a change. In the 18 months since that race, there has been no meaningful revision in U.S. policy toward Ethiopia, and there is today even less reason to anticipate change in the country's leadership. As one opposition leader has put it, the question is not whether the ruling Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Front (EPRDF) will defeat its intimidated and harassed opponents, but whether this will turn out to be the election in which Ethiopia takes the last step toward becoming a truly one-party state.

This is what passes for democracy in Ethiopia today. As the election has drawn closer, the government has done everything it can to push the result in its favor, waging what Human Rights Watch called in March a "coordinated and sustained attack on political opponents, journalists, and rights activists." That was the same month that Prime Minister Meles Zenawi took  aim at one of the few independent sources of news still available, comparing the Amharic-language Voice of America programming to the genocidal Radio Mille Collines of Rwanda and ordering its broadcasts jammed. Journalists have fled into exile at an escalating pace over the last year, while civil society has been effectively neutered by a deeply oppressive NGO law. Political activists on both sides have been killed in recent weeks, and the government has publicly accused the opposition of planning violence, raising fears that it might be laying out a pretext for a crackdown.

All this has revealed a deep-seated unwillingness on the government's part to even contemplate sharing political power -- an instinct that emerged out of the last set of parliamentary elections in 2005, when Meles was dangerously close to forfeiting his majority. That proximity to losing -- and the subsequent crackdown that ensured he didn't -- has hung like a cloud over Ethiopia ever since. Indeed, as this year's election approaches, memories of that vote are pronounced. On election night, Meles banned public demonstrations. Then, as the vote count proceeded and protests grew, he assumed direct control over the security services, which, in separate incidents over several months, killed nearly 200 demonstrators. At least 30,000 people were detained, and much of the opposition's leadership was arrested on charges including treason and "attempted genocide." When the official results were finally released nearly five months later, the opposition had been awarded just a third of the country's parliamentary seats -- while the EPRDF won with a comfortable majority.

SIMON MAINA/AFP/Getty Images

 

Nathaniel Myers is a writer and international development consultant.

F1FAN

9:57 AM ET

May 24, 2010

Wait

So Ethiopia is MORE of a democratic sham than our other allies? I don't believe that.

 

MAIGARI

2:18 PM ET

May 24, 2010

EHIOPIA'S RIGGED ELECTION

It is neither suprising nor unexpected that the US is "silent" on the recent elections in Ethiopia/ First and foremost, Melas Zenawi is a US friend. Do not forget his poor country was pushed to kick-out the Union of Islamic Court government from Somalis. This is essentially to put in place the inefffective but US sponsored Provisional government. Forget about the so-called AU rwcognistion; this would have come to nought without US approval! As a result, the Workd lost a chance to put Somslia back on the map since the ouster of US backed Siad barre.
The UIC have suceede in bringing an end to the piracy and was in the process of consolidating when Ethiopia was used to throw them out. With or without oil/natural resources, they have succeeded where the US failed - topple a government that dares to use the label Islamic. Besides how many US allies are really democratic in the developing world; especially the 'third world"?

 

NICHOLAS WIBBERLEY

3:57 PM ET

May 24, 2010

Rigged?

Elections for the US are rituals designed to produce political results it can live with; rigged elections are simply those that produce troublesome results.

 

SEAN212

5:16 AM ET

June 20, 2010

Ethiopia's Elections

This was Ethiopia’s first election since 2005. In that election it was reported that about 200 protestors were gunned down by police following a highly contested election in that year. tx home insurance In this year’s election the opposition claimed there had been fraud and irregularities in some areas of the country. The current sitting prime minister, Meles Zenawi, who won this year’s election, has ruled the country for the past 19years. He has been criticized by the opposition and some international observers for suppressing press freedom, as well as the activities of the opposition parties and human rights groups. The AU commended the election as free and fair. However, United States and European Union observer mission criticized Prime Minister Zenawi for narrowing political space in the country. fort worth home ins As there were no reports of violence this time, Africa Today asks if perhaps, the election has reversed the cycle of mistrust in the country’s democratic system?