Mikey Weinstein's Crusade

Meet the man who's trying to purge evangelical Christianity from the Pentagon.

BY STEPHEN GLAIN | MAY 25, 2010

"Good morning Mikey, you f*** Jew. Let me be the first to call you a f*** Jew today."

Michael L. "Mikey" Weinstein shares his hate mail with both friends and strangers the way elderly people show off photos of their grandkids. He has plenty of it to share. For the past four years, the founder of the Military Religious Freedom Foundation (MRFF) has been doing battle with a Christian subculture that, he believes, is trying to Christianize the U.S. armed forces with the help of a complicit Pentagon brass. He calls it the "fundamentalist Christian parachurch-military-corporate-proselytizing complex," a mouthful by which he means holy warriors in contempt of the constitutional barrier between church and state.

"The scary thing about all this," Weinstein says, "is it's going on not with the blind eye of the Pentagon but with its full and totally enthusiastic support. And those who are not directly involved are passive about it. As the Talmud says, 'silence is consent.'"

You may recall the headlines in January, when a company called Trijicon, the lead supplier of rifle scopes to the U.S. military, was found to have inscribed them with coded references to passages in the New Testament. That was Weinstein -- his organization threatened to sue Trijicon, which eventually agreed to discontinue the practice and distribute kits that would enable troops to retroactively secularize their scopes. Weinstein grabbed headlines again last month by pressuring the Pentagon to withdraw an invitation to the Rev. Franklin Graham, known for his Islamophobic oratory, to speak at a National Day of Prayer Task Force service. That provoked a stiff rebuke of Weinstein and his group from Shirley Dobson, wife of conservative Christian leader James Dobson and the task force chairwoman.

Built like a cinder block, with a bare cranium shaped like a howitzer round, Weinstein -- a former Air Force judge advocate general -- has the air of a born fighter. This battle is personal for him: Nearly 30 years ago, as a Jewish cadet at the Air Force Academy in Colorado, he was twice beaten unconscious in anti-Semitic attacks. (There wouldn't have been much of a choice of targets -- only 0.3 percent of the members of the U.S. military identify themselves as Jewish. Ninety-four percent are Christian.) Visiting his son, Curtis, on the eve of his own second year at the academy in the summer of 2004, Weinstein was stunned to learn little had changed; over lunch at McDonald's, Curtis told his father that he had been verbally abused eight or nine times by officers and fellow cadets on account of his religion. Weinstein filed a complaint, in response to which the Air Force launched an investigation that revealed a top-down, invasive evangelicalism in the academy. Among other things, it revealed that the commandant of cadets taught the entire incoming class a "J for Jesus" hand signal, that the football coach had draped a "Team Jesus" banner across the academy locker room, and that more than 250 faculty members and senior officers signed a campus newspaper advertisement that proclaimed: "We believe that Jesus Christ is the only real hope for the world." Weinstein has been a First Amendment vigilante ever since.

Although he is frequently attacked for waging a war on Christianity, all but a fraction of Weinstein's clients are practicing Catholics and Protestants of mainline denominations who claim to be targeted by proselytizing evangelical superiors. The root of the problem, Weinstein believes, is a cluster of well-funded groups dedicated to Christianizing the military and proselytizing abroad. They include the Navigators, which, according to their website, command "thousands of courageous men and women passionately following Christ, representing Him in advancing the Gospel through relationships where they live, work, train for war, and deploy." There is Campus Crusade for Christ's Military Ministry, which has a permanent staff presence at U.S. military academies and whose directors have referred publicly to U.S. soldiers and Marines as "government-paid missionaries." Such groups, Weinstein argues, "are the flip side of the Taliban. They're like Islamic officers exercising Quranic leadership to raise a jihadi army." (A spokesman for the Navigators said the group had had no interaction with Weinstein and no comment on his activities. Military Ministry representatives didn't immediately respond to inquiries on the subject.)

DAVID FURST/AFP/Getty Images

 

Stephen Glain, a Washington-based freelance journalist, is writing a book about the militarization of U.S. foreign policy.

ACNONPRO

10:13 PM ET

May 25, 2010

This isn't new news

great article on Mickey's work from Harpers with a lot more sickening details

http://harpers.org/archive/2009/05/0082488

 

RACHEL TABACHNICK

8:21 AM ET

May 30, 2010

Need more news on activities of people like Col. Jim Ammerman.

The author of “After the Storm," Colonel E. H. (Jim) Ammerman, writes proudly about exploiting the first Gulf War to proselytize thousands of U.S. soldiers stationed in Saudia Arabia (and local Muslims) to his brand of charismatic evangelical Christianity. The first chapter is titled “A Christian Holy War” and he writes that the U.S. was there for "spiritual warfare" against demonic principalities in order to convert millions and "begin a revival among Islamic nations."

This is the same Jim Ammerman who still serves as the endorsing agent for “270+ Military Chaplains/Chaplain Candidates and180+ Civilian Chaplains/Seminarians” according to his Chaplaincy of Full Gospel Churches website, and the same Ammerman who produced videos with “The Prophecy Club” in the 1990s (still marketed) in which he promoted “New World Order” conspiracy theories. He claims that the U.S. is under imminent threat of military attack by millions of foreign troops stationed on our bases and in our national forests, and that our financial markets are controlled by a demonic Jewish/Illuminati cabal who gave orders to the Clintons. (Like many spreading anti-Semitic New World Order conspiracy, Ammerman presents himself as a supporter of Israel and a Christian Zionist. He is also a close friend of John Hagee, founder of CUFI.) A military memorandum from 1997 stated that Ammerman encouraged military personal to affiliate with organizations that are prohibited due to their "supremacist viewpoints" and that his video and interview [radio] have a "suggestion of a military overthrow of the United States government." www.talk2action.org/story/2009/6/22/115820/165

Despite this, Ammerman still heads the chaplain endorsing agency and is a leader in a sector of the evangelical world, serving as board member (with Chuck Norris) of the National Council on Bible Curriculum in Public Schools and as an Apostle in C. Peter Wagner’s International Coalition of Apostles, the top tier of the New Apostolic Reformation.

Mikey Weinstein is one of the few people who have been willing to challenge the aggressive proselytizing and abuse of our military. He is fighting for the rights of the men and women in uniform who do not share Ammerman's goal of manipulating the U.S. military to promote an evangelical holy war against our own troops and the people of other nations.

 

KIESELGUHR KID

8:33 AM ET

May 26, 2010

America could use a better spokesman...

Weinstein's cause is the greatest. The military has a really, really serious establishmentarianism problem. As a non-Christian soldier I feel that almost daily and, boy, I wish the chaplain corps didn't exist. More people should recognize the danger Weinstein's organization has, and should be fighting hard alongside him.

That said, from my (admittedly slight) experience, Weinstein's a hell of a bad spokesman for that cause. He is constantly in buffoonish self-promotion and fundraising mode, and his organization is hooking up with or disseminating ideas from people who do not share their (admirable) goal of promoting religious freedom so much as in promoting atheism or anti-Christian mockery (note that atheists should be welcome an protected too in the military, and I'm no Christian: I just think, well, that's not religious freedom either). Weinstein's site is a bit loopy.

I don't know that I can blame him, mind you: I can imagine the crap he is subjected to, I suspect the poor guy gets some pretty serious threats, and well, I'd probably be a lot more loopy under the circumstances.

So, well, two cheers for Weinstein, and I'm looking hard for, well, some similarly focused but more even-keeled group to emerge, or maybe more people to join up with Weinstein and stabilize things a bit.

 

CHAD BERMAN

12:40 AM ET

June 24, 2010

Military Religious Freedom

The Military Religious Freedom Foundation is the brainchild of Michael L. “Mikey” Weinstein, a graduate of the Air Force Academy and a 10-year Air Force veteran. The Military Religious Freedom Foundation is dedicated to ensuring that all members of the United States Armed Forces fully receive the Constitutional guarantees of religious freedom to which they and all Americans are entitled by virtue of the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment. new york local florists Since he launched his watchdog organization few years ago, Weinstein’s web site has been bombarded by thousands active duty and retired soldiers, many of whom served or serve in Iraq, who pleaded for the Foundation’s help as they were pressured by their commanding officers to convert to Christianity, or face other consequences. If you think this is just a fight over some abstract principle, with ramifications only for atheist, Jewish, Buddhist and other cadets who may be “offended” by fundamentalist God talk, I urge you to check out Weinstein’s book or website (militaryreligiousfreedom.org). new york city flower delivery He documents a chilling phenomenon: The whole U.S. military, up and down the chain of command, is coming to be dominated by members of a small, characteristically intolerant sliver of Christianity who truly regard themselves as Christian soldiers, on a God-appointed mission to harvest souls and battle evil.

 

LAL QILA

9:33 AM ET

May 26, 2010

Three cheers to Weinstein; good work

Three cheers to Weinstein; good work

Religion and the army do not mix. They should not mix at all:

Not with Judaism in the Israeli army;
Not with Christianity in the American army;
Not with Islam in the Pakistani army;
Not with Hindooism in the Indian army.

Religion and the army should not mix at all. All our modern problems stem from this unholy mixing of the two.

http://lalqila.wordpress.com/

 

ERIC.

12:00 PM ET

May 26, 2010

This guy is a joke, and just

This guy is a joke, and just another person looking for attention, which he will get. Our modern problems don't stem from the two, they stem from corporate greed.

 

JKOLAK

12:29 PM ET

May 26, 2010

"The Defense Department

"The Defense Department "places a high value on the rights of military members to observe the tenets of their respective religions. [It] does not endorse any one religion or religious organization, and provides free access of religion for all members of the military services." "

and

"Fundamentalist Christianity in the military is like magma," he says, "and every hour or so it bursts up like a little volcano and you have to beat it down."

From my experience in the military, I'd say both of these statements are true. Mostly I experienced the former, with all very good and proper. Evidence of the latter makes work like Weinstein's important.

The main thing I don't want to see from all this is secularization of the military. Soldiers deserve access to their faith in times of danger.

 

KIESELGUHR KID

12:37 PM ET

May 26, 2010

Except when it doesn't

Well, not to pry, jkolak, but are you Christian?

As a minority religious adherent I feel pretty oppressed in the Army, at least weekly. I suck it up, but it's there, and I am getting my kids the hell away from the post and Army kids' activities for that reason (and so there's a related issue about support for families): they've heard some stuff I really regret their hearing. At three posts I've asked the chaplains for help finding local services/communities, been told to leave my contact info and "we'll get right on it." Never has it happened, and the info was easy to get in the end if one looked. At most mandated events I hear chaplains give explicitly sectarian prayers.

Again, I think Weinstein's a bit of a nut, and supported by some flat-out nuts. But I think it's difficult to overstate the extent to which the Army pushes Christianity on its members.

 

EZEQUES

5:36 PM ET

May 26, 2010

The Framers

If you care to check it this country was founded by primarily deists who were very adamant about the separation of church and state. They were trying to escape the religious persecution in Europe at the time. But this concept has been gradually eroded since then. In the 50’s “In God We Trust” was added to the currency and “so help me God” was added to the pledge and continuing to the last few decades when this is has even been accelerated starting with the first Bush administration and even more with the second Bush.

 

EMILY860

6:11 PM ET

May 26, 2010

what loss of freedom?

I'd really like to know what "loss of freedom" even exists in the military. From the time they are considering the military, to the quandaries which inevitably arise in the service, there are pastors and chaplains at their service. But guess what, kid? Your church , synagogue, or mosque ain't the only one, despite what your fantasyland of a church told you. There are even those who don't believe (gasp!) in God.

Respect your comrades-in-arms. *That* is what the military teaches (at its best, anyway)

http://emilyscoffeespot.blogspot.com

 

MORTARMAN

10:50 AM ET

May 27, 2010

Seriously?

Really? Did you really just ask, "what loss of freedom even exists in the military"? I'm not sure what/if you're reacting to something in the article, or another forum post, but if you're seriously asking that question then you either know zip about the military and/or have never served; I'm willing to bet on both. For your information, you certainly DO lose freedoms when you join the military.

I am currently an Air Force officer, and was previously enlisted in both the Air Force AND the Army. I can attest to the need for Mike Weinstein's work. I consider myself a secular Christian, however the degree to which fundamentally Christian religiosity pervades the military is abhorrent to me as an officer, a civil libertarian, and an American. I fully and enthusiastically support an individual's right to observe their religion, except where it compromises the capability of the military to execute its mission.

I support Mike's work, for there IS a pervasive and large fundamentalist Christian element in the military, which retains attitudes and creates an atmosphere that, unless changed, I fear will create a day that mission planning will devolve to the inanity of "God's Will will see us to success". While I say that only half in jest, the basic point is that religion, by it's very definition, involves relinquishing reason and logic to faith, ergo abandoning critical thought on matters controlled by one's faith. If the overwhelming majority of serving Christians were able to remain open-minded and critically thinking on topics spoken to by their religion, rather than dogmatic, there would be far fewer issues created by religion in the military than there are. Unfortunately, dogma usually prevails.

I would contend that the degree to which Christian proselytizing is both tolerated and tacitly encouraged by fundamentalist Christian officers and NCOs within the military creates an atmosphere of intimidation, and chills the airing of candid perspectives on issues - which is vital to successful policy development, mission planning, and daily operations - for fear of somehow offending the religious sensibilities of more senior personnel, with the attendant negative impact to one's career. Such an atmosphere fully compromises every other facet of effective military planning and operations, and we as Americans, tax-payers, and possibly relatives of, or actively serving members of the military should be not be willing to tolerate any compromises that may potentially cost us treasure and blood.

 

BISBONIAN

8:31 PM ET

May 27, 2010

"Nearly Thirty Years Ago"

Minor quibble: "Nearly 30 years ago, as a Jewish cadet at the Air Force Academy in Colorado, he was twice beaten unconscious in anti-Semitic attacks." I read that, and thought...that's odd...I was there nearly thirty yeas ago, and I don't remember anything like that, or even his name. So I looked him up. "Mikey" graduated in 1977, 33 years ago. If he was being beaten, I'll bet it was as a freshman, more like 36 years ago.

 

SCOTERPIE

1:47 PM ET

May 28, 2010

Christian nation

As long as the Christian bigots and haters insist that America is a Christian nation, and that its laws are based on the coined term "Judeo-Christian" ethics, we will be ruled under the iron fist of organized religion disguised s peace and love.

Americans of all sexual persuasions pay taxes, yet not all are afforded the same civil rights. Why gays still frequent churches (just to be told they;re going to hell), I have no clue. Nor do I understand why there aren't rigorous demonstrations against bigotry against the very government that is supposed to protect us all - paid to do so through ALL of our taxes.

When religion is reduced to rubble, so will hatred and war.

When I was a Christian (no more), I was told that "homosexuals" are to blame for most of the word's ills. Gays were also referred to as "sodomites." How nice.

 

JOELREINSTEIN

5:02 PM ET

May 28, 2010

Losing Civilian Control

Weinstein is crusading against something intertwined with another military problem: the insanely pompous, arrogant, ignorant and dangerous officer class. It seems that much of our officer class - ROTC graduates who've never been scrubs - see themselves as being qualified to make policy decisions, especially at higher ranks. Given that, it should be no surprise that a small group of officers think they're allowed to mix church and state, ignore religious freedom, and proselytize like all our souls depend on it.

We need to look at this holistically. Ideally at least, the separation of church and state is protected by a certain kind of faith in the system: among officers, realizing that they are public servants rather than public masters. (Yes, Officer Class, our politicians and bureaucrats are eminently more qualified to make policy than you. There are things you don't know and aren't being paid to know. Of course politicians and bureaucrats are corrupt; my $600 toilet seat here says that you've been part of the con.)

A key part of American democracy is strict civilian control over the military. With this civilian control under assault from the military-industrial complex, a small group of officers can more easily subvert our most basic and fundamental principles (like freedom of religion).

Anyway. Go Mikey Go. Don't listen to those nitpicky goofballs calling you "crazy;" they're stuck in the fantasy-land of cable news and TIME Magazine articles, where "confusing" is synonymous with "wrong," and there's never more than one right way to do anything.