How Soccer Defeated Apartheid

As South Africa prepares to hosts the World Cup, it is also coming face to face with its own history.

BY NICHOLAS GRIFFIN | JUNE 7, 2010

Imagine an alternate reality of the United States in the 1960s, where the collective experience of the political elite had been formed in all-black baseball leagues. The country is led by President Jackie Robinson, Vice President Satchel Paige, and Secretary of State Willie Mays. Sounds crazy? Replace baseball with soccer, and you've got South Africa, a country that has given new meaning to "political football."

Much attention has been paid to President Nelson Mandela's role in South Africa's 1995 Rugby World Cup triumph, captured in the film Invictus. But Sean Jacobs, a Cape Town native, historian, and author, describes that tournament as "a blip" in South Africa's history of racial conflict. "The real story," he says, "is soccer."

And the real story begins several miles from the site of Cape Town's swanky new stadium -- on Robben Island, which will be clearly visible to billions of TV viewers as they tune in to this month's World Cup. The island prison colony was home to thousands of South Africa's political prisoners during the apartheid era. Of the men who played in the prison's soccer league, an astonishing number would go on to become important figures in shaping post-apartheid South Africa.

Their ranks include current President Jacob Zuma, opposition leader and former Defense Minister "Terror" Lekota, Minister of Human Settlements "Tokyo" Sexwale, and Kgalema Motlanthe, who completed former President Thabo Mbeki's second term. Mandela never participated; he watched the early games from an isolation block until the authorities built a wall to obstruct his view. Zuma had the distinction of doubling as a referee. Leave it to a future president to play one weekend and arbitrate the next.

More Than Just a Game, written by Chuck Korr and Marvin Close, revealed that Robben Island's inmates had two favorite books from the shelves of the prison library: Karl Marx's Das Kapital, and Denis Howell's Soccer Refereeing. After years of steadfast petitioning, prison authorities finally agreed in 1967 to let the inmates establish their own soccer league, the Makana Football Association. The prisoners spent their weekdays breaking rocks in the quarry, but two hours of every Saturday were reserved for soccer matches. Sunday evening was for talking about the game, Monday to Wednesday for dealing with breaches of rules, and Thursday and Friday for choosing squads and strategizing. The thought process among the players, according to Jacobs, was: "If we can run a league in these extreme conditions, then maybe we can run a country."

The Afrikaner officials of the apartheid regime never embraced soccer. They loved rugby and cricket and funded those sports generously, but saw soccer as a game for Africans. At first, they ignored the sport -- then they began to ban some matches. In April 1963, at the Natalspruit Sports Ground in Johannesburg, authorities locked the gates and left a note saying the day's games had been canceled. Fifteen thousand supporters scaled the gates, carrying an extra pair of goal posts to replace a set that had been removed. The matches went ahead.

The government would later try a new tack, organizing an annual match between black and white players. The plan, however, backfired: It merely emphasized the inequitable and racist nature of the country's political system. The matches did, however, succeed in undermining the apartheid regime in crucial ways. In 1976, the government allowed a mixed-race team to play against a visiting Argentine squad in Johannesburg. Black and white South Africans lined up together on the pitch, though the stands were still segregated. The home team won 5-0, including a hat trick for a then unknown black player named Jomo Sono. When he scored against Argentina, his teammates, black and white, did what teammates have always done: hugged and shook hands. This feel-good victory was overshadowed only a few weeks later, however, when approximately 500 black South Africans were killed in the Soweto uprising -- including Ariel Kgongoane, a prominent player for the Kaizer Chiefs.

Apartheid's opponents quickly seized on the potential of using soccer to rally support and raise funds. The African National Congress (ANC), then a banned underground movement, quickly realized that wherever there was soccer, there was a crowd. Political meetings suffered a blanket ban from 1976 onward, but it was far harder to prevent several members of a political party from sitting together in the stands, amid thousands. Zuma, for instance, would emerge from hiding to attend the matches of the Zulu Royals and confer with other politicians. And it's no coincidence that when Zuma returned from exile in Zambia in 1993, his first residence was at the home of the owner of the Orlando Pirates, one of the largest soccer teams in South Africa.

By the 1980s, activists commonly organized themselves into soccer squads to confound the regime. They could travel easily across international borders, and matches represented a valuable source of money for underground anti-apartheid organizations. Peter Alegi, a historian and author of African Soccerscapes, told me that as early as 1944, the revenue from soccer matches was being handed over to the ANC. Patson Banda, a former player for the Orlando Pirates, remembers one game that was played across the border in Zimbabwe in front of more than 100,000 paying fans. Again, the ANC received the proceeds collected at the gate.

Streeter Lecka/Getty Images

 

Nicholas Griffin, a term member of the Council on Foreign Relations, is writing a book on sports and foreign policy.

LARRY CLAASEN

6:31 AM ET

June 8, 2010

What do you know about South Africa?

Mr Green, at least have the decency to make up something to justify your dribble.
My country is not perfect but we are functioning democracy.
I remind you that the Middle East "Peace Process" and the negotiation to end Ireland's troubles began about the same time South Africans began to bring an end to Apartheid.
Almost 20 years later, these other conflicts have yet to meet their end but South Africa is hosting a major sporting event.
So I ask you kindly to show us some respect and not to talk down our achievements.

 

SMARG

2:58 PM ET

June 9, 2010

How Apartheid is Not So Evil After All

Looking at Zimbabwe and S.A. now, and how the countries are almost complete wastelands of crime, savagery, disease, rape, murder, etc....

My God, they were much better off under apartheid. The mainstream media, the same ones who adore Odumbo, vilified the Whites back then. They're trying to do the same to Arizonans, who don't want to become another failed state like California. Go figure.

 

LARRY CLAASEN

5:36 AM ET

June 10, 2010

No. We were not better off under Apartheid.

By every conceivable measure South Africans are better of than they were 16yrs ago.
If you don't believe me read the latest edition of The Economist which spells out the progress SA has made.

And comparing SA to Zimbabwe is like comparing the US to Mexico. Just because we share a boarder does not mean we share a destiny.
And who is Odumbo?

 

SMARG

7:29 AM ET

June 10, 2010

Are you daffy?

Look at S.A.'s President...a corrupt rapist. HIV/AIDs infests the land. Power outages. Capital structures crumbling.

What silly world do you live in?? Here, click on these...

http://www.afrol.com/articles/26036
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crime_in_South_Africa
http://www.nationmaster.com/country/sf-south-africa/cri-crime

These are only a few. Enjoy.

 

SMARG

7:30 AM ET

June 10, 2010

Odumbo is Our Hapless American President

Also known as Hussein or Obummer. He's the only one left hooked on hopium now.

 

MCLARK1970

11:06 PM ET

June 20, 2010

Soccer Brings Hope

Soccer brings hope to the world, nations, communities together, there is no doubt that it has helped South Africa.

I visited J'burg once when I was considering starting a preschool for the local kids and watching them play soccer really was amazing. So much dedication. I can see why it would be a good motivator against oppression.

I'll be rooting for them during the World Cup this month.

 

TEVINCAMBELL

7:46 PM ET

June 23, 2010

invictus

just rent the movie of the now exhausted prime minister nelson mandela and his great victory over auto aristocrats