Neda Lives

The little-known story of Iran's other Neda Soltani and how a picture changed her life forever.

BY CAMERON ABADI | JUNE 14, 2010

Neda Agha-Soltan, the deceased protester, left; Neda Soltani, the political refugee, right.

Neda Soltani is the ordinary Iranian woman whose image spread last summer in an instant around the world. She's a symbol of the brutality of the Iranian regime and the resilience of Iran's movement for democracy.

She's also still alive.

A woman named Neda did indeed die last summer on the streets of Tehran, gunned down by members of an Iranian militia. Her full name was Neda Agha-Soltan. But mixed in with the tragic footage of that Neda's death, broadcast around the world in a viral video that galvanized world opinion against the Iranian regime, was a compelling Facebook snapshot of a smiling young beauty in a flowered headscarf.

Her name was Neda, too -- Neda Soltani.

What follows is the incredible story of what happened when the age of social media collided with political upheaval in a land behind a curtain -- and how it even forced a 32-year-old graduate student into political exile.

In her small apartment in the city of Offenbach, Germany, where she has been granted political asylum, Neda Soltani is working to piece back together her life. She looks older now than she does in her famous photo. Understandably: The past year has been an ordeal, one that was thrust upon her against her will.

Until last year, Neda Soltani was a teaching assistant for English literature at Tehran's Islamic Azad University, where she was doing graduate work on feminine symbolism in the work of Joseph Conrad. She wasn't a supporter of the regime, but she also didn't belong to any sort of active opposition group, even in the heady days after the disputed election. She was focused on her academic career above all else; while Iranians were marching in the streets, she was correcting her thesis. She led the prosaic life of Tehran's silent apolitical majority. "I worked for 10 long years to get my position at the university," she told Germany's Sueddeutsche Zeitung in February. "I was earning my own money, I had friends, I would go out and I had fun."

All that changed on June 20 of last year, when a choppy video appeared on YouTube depicting the gruesome and chaotic death of a young Iranian woman. Neda Soltani watched the clip, not knowing it was the beginning of the end of her own life as well.

The process began innocuously enough, resting on a foundation of journalism's most basic building block: competition for a scoop. Working only with the first name heard on the YouTube video, international news organizations raced one another to unearth more information on the young women who died on camera. Forgoing fact checks, editors in New York and London allowed small details to get lost in translation as they communicated with their reporters on the ground: "Agha-Soltan" lost its hyphen, "Agha" was dropped entirely, or "Soltan" picked up an "i". These errors even found their way into HBO's valedictory documentary airing tonight. In portraying the reporter from the Guardian who purportedly first determined her name, the film briefly includes a screen shot of his story from last June that  itself was published under a misleading headline: "Neda Soltan's family ‘forced out of home' by Iranian authorities."

That's where Facebook comes in. On June 21, eager Green Movement supporters decided to dedicate a page on the social networking site to the "Angel of Iran." Serendipitously, the martyr herself had a personal Facebook from which they could borrow her portrait. Framed as a standard passport shot, the photo showed an attractive young woman with a relaxed and innocent smile who wore a head scarf that revealed several inches of dark brown hair. It was a perfectly adequate resource for activists looking to inspire sympathy -- except for the fact that the likeness, like the Facebook page from which it was taken, belonged to Neda Soltani, the quiet, unbloodied scholar of English literature.

Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: IRAN, MIDDLE EAST
 

Cameron Abadi is an associate editor at Foreign Policy.

SKIPPYFLIPJACK

7:26 AM ET

June 15, 2010

How about a caption for the photos?

In an article about a tragedy of misidentified photos, wouldn't it make sense to identify the photos accompanying the article to help clear up people's misconceptions? In my recollection the photo on the right was of the woman who died, but how can I tell?

 

SKIPPYFLIPJACK

7:33 AM ET

June 15, 2010

And I would be wrong...

For the record, the living Neda Soltani is on the right; the deceased Neda Soltan is on the left.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/programmes/newsnight/8129083.stm

 

MATTPOLETTI

10:52 AM ET

June 15, 2010

The first page of this

The first page of this article has a caption for the picture, but not the second. As you said, the woman on the right is the living Neda.

 

DENTAL PLAN PROVIDER

5:29 PM ET

June 18, 2010

A case of mistaken identity?

This is a very unfortunate case for Neda Soltani for having been mistakenly reported as dead. Reporters should be more cautious with their reports because they have the capacity to change lives of people.

 

LITTLEESKANDARI

11:07 AM ET

June 15, 2010

The other Neda

This story broke on the internet and on twitter last year and was Tweeted by some of those very tweeters you saw fit to be critical off recently. Perhaps you should keep up and then your news won't be a year out of date.
http://www.inquisitr.com/27088/that-picture-of-neda-everyone-is-using-its-the-wrong-one/

 

MZ711

11:33 AM ET

June 15, 2010

I feel bad for her

This is really sad and I dont know what that guy means he "tips his hat to her". She was an academic trying to do what people all over the world want--to LIVE their lives they worked hard ot create. And imagine the horror of being asked to go center stage to say the killing never happened? So get real. She is not German, she wants to live in her home country. Imagine as an American if you were not forced to go to Germany, because it is too similar to the u.s. in many ways, but say, Kuwait. Would you be happy? NO! Germany is as different to Iran as Kuwait is to America. And the media did not correct this because they are so obsessed with hating Iran, any press against Iran is great press, to hell with reality. It is disgusting. They just used what happened in Iran as further fodder to fuel to hate and beat the war drums, no one really cares about the Iranian people, if they did, they wouldnt let the u.s. strongarm the security council to place a FOURTH round of sanctions on Iran which ONLY affect the average, ordinary people and make them suffer more. So drop the "care" act please. And stop letting israel ruin America by screaming bloody murder every 5 seconds and getting the u.s. sucked into all kinds of embarassing and life costing trouble. I cant believe Americans put up with this. It is YOUR country, not israels. Yes relevant, they DO in fact control U.S. media and the White House too. Get your country back Americans

 

KATHY RIORDAN

8:36 PM ET

June 15, 2010

I first reported this story a year ago

I first reported this story a year ago, just a few days after the Neda video went online:

Not That 'Neda' - How the Wrong Photo Became an Icon

http://open.salon.com/blog/kathy_riordan/2009/06/23/not_that_neda_-_how_the_wrong_photo_became_an_icon

I have known the real Neda Soltani since that time and have worked tirelessly to get her image removed from the media, including contacting a producer at CNN and an editor at the NY Times. When I have seen it appear, I have contacted people to correct it. In most cases, they have removed it, but not all.

We were in talks to have this story on The Rachel Maddow Show on MSNBC that same week to give it more exposure, but the death of pop star Michael Jackson eclipsed it.

To my mind the story of what has happened to the living Neda is one of the greatest tragedies of the entire story of the death of Neda Agha-Soltan, that a case of mistaken identity would rob an innocent woman of her life and her identity. The cost has been very high to a young woman who deserves better and is fighting to rebuild a life in a country not her own after even her own government has betrayed her.

I can see how the mistake was made by people eager to put a name and a face to the young woman who died in the video, but too few realize the cost of recklessly grabbing an image from the Internet in haste and what it has cost in human terms.

I continue to correct the facts of this matter whenever I see the error, and was myself concerned when I saw you place these images side by side again, as that can potentially lead to further confusion.

Thank you for giving this story more exposure.

 

DR. AMY L. BEAM

11:24 AM ET

June 20, 2010

First correction for using Facebook photo of living Neda Soltani

Within several hours of the video of the shooting death of Neda Agha-Soltan, I met the living Neda Soltani on Facebook and we became friends. I worked around the clock for days to remove the usage of her photo wearing the floral print scarf. Indeed, one year later, I still work at making the truth known, especially in light of the Iranian government's TV propaganda-documentary last week which tries to convince Iranians that the murder of Neda Agha-Soltan was a conspiracy.

My first contact was to Joe Johns at CNN, whom I have known 23 years. I sent him two SMS messages June 21 to his private mobile phone. CNN ran the wrong photo in spite of having been warned not to. A journalist from the New York Times interviewed me by phone. In spite of knowing the truth about the wrong photo, The New York Times ran it anyway the next day (over the dismay of the journalist who interview me and another one who interviewed Kathy Riordan).

The first website I could identify that used the photo was http://primarysources.newsvine.com/_news/2009/06/20/2951910-her-name-was-neda. Its time and date stamp was June 20, 2009, 7:52 PM EDT. The website newsvine.com is owned by MSNBC.com as stated on the bottom of the web page. After I wrote an inquiry to the journalist, the page disappeared, but I retain a screen shot of it.

One of the earliest stations to air the wrong photo was FOX TV. On June 21, 2009, it showed the photo of the living Neda Soltani and stated they had it "from a reliable source" that is was a photo of the woman who had been killed.

Beginning early on June 21, I began contacting websites that were erroneously using the wrong photo as that of the woman who was killed. However, the photo spread virally faster than I and others could notify people. Finally, I posted a blog at http://wipoun.blogspot.com. By June 22, Neda's photo wearing a black headscarf with a floral pattern was known to the entire world as the icon of the fight for freedom in Iran. Demonstrators all around the world held up signs with her photo next to the bloody face of the Neda who was killed. Soltani's photo was memorialized at altars with candles, on banners, posters, blog wallpaper backgrounds. People wrote songs for the dead Neda and used the living Neda's photo. Dozens of other people changed their Facebook photos and names to Neda Soltani.

By the morning of June 23, I informed Neda it was too late to put out the story. It would have to burn itself out over time. Neither of us knew then what an inferno of anti-government rage it would create on the streets of Iran in the coming days and weeks. Because I had greater access to the internet than she did, I realized with a deepening dread, sooner than she did, that her life as she knew it was over with. Neda told me she was afraid for her safety and thinking of seeking asylum.

On July 1, 2009, BBC News journalist, Siobhan Courtney, interviewed me about the mistaken photo. She ran a correction in BBC's News Night column July 3. By that time it was too late to save Neda's life as she once knew and loved it.

I flew to Greece to meet Neda Soltani on July 10, 2009. Here is a video with our meeting at second 32: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NXngt83BbIE .

As recently as a week ago FOX TV ran a documentary in which it again used the photo of the living Neda Soltani to portray the Neda who was killed. This is not only willfully irresponsible, it is, quite literally, criminal.

Neda waits for apologies that will never come from mainstream media outlets. I wait for her to gather her strength to tell her own story and sue for damages. I have the evidence of hundreds of screen shots and downloadeded videos in my possession.

 

KAMI

5:49 AM ET

June 28, 2010

I believe It is not true story!!! She made you fool.

I believe It is not true story!!! She made you fool. all at first was done by herself. I was her boyfriend last June when I saw the real Neda Photo that was shot in the street. I said ' neda do you know the one who had shot was Neda too!'. next day when we were sitting in a cafe in Karaj I said Neda i saw your photo on facebook and.... She laughed at me and said I think it is very interesting and unique event! I was shocking what was happening! I asked her just gave the password of her profile to wrote that she is alive and She is not the Neda agha soltan to stop it, but she denied. that night I called her and told her I saw her photo on VOA again she laughed and said she was not worry about it! ..... it is very sad to say I believe she made you fool too like me. when I saw the the other photos of her on VOA again she denied that she sent them to VOA and said someone has done this again. .... and all her story was made by herself !!! we are all were joking by her!!

 

KATHY RIORDAN

8:49 PM ET

June 15, 2010

The first to speak her name

Edited to add: The reporter at The Guardian was not the first to think Neda Soltani was her name; that is an error. I saw the provenance of that online in discussions on June 21st and now the origin of that. The first appearance of the name 'Neda' online came when someone I now know asked the person who first posted the video the name of the young woman, and he replied he thought her name was 'Neda.'

When pressed later, he said he thought it was Neda Soltan or Soltani. The Guardian later got that information, but that is not the origin. That is in error.

First mention of her name was 20 June at 23.26: "all I know her name is NEDA."

First public mention on Twitter was 20 June at 23.32: Je viens de contacter celui qui a mis la video en ligne de la jeune fille. Elle s'appelait Neda.

 

RSAFSOZ

2:50 PM ET

June 16, 2010

neda

i am missing neda :( sikis

 

BHUNZO17

3:39 AM ET

June 17, 2010

http://www.thelwordepisodes.com

It's really a difficult world out there

 

MCLARK1970

11:32 PM ET

June 20, 2010

Still Honored

I'm just glad to see that she is being honored after her death. She stood for great principles. When I was starting a preschool in my home I wanted to teach the children really good principles. Long live Neda.

 

DR. AMY L. BEAM

4:24 PM ET

June 21, 2010

This Neda is ALIVE

MClark: I am wondering if you read this article. It is about Neda Soltani, a woman who is very much alive and whose identify was stolen. While I appreciate your sentiments about honoring Neda who was killed, THIS story is not about THAT Neda. Your comment is exactly the sort of thing that continues to this day to confuse people. There were two Neda's who lost their life June 20, 2009. Neda Agha Soltan was murdered by a bullet. Neda Soltani is alive and was granted asylum in Germany in 2010. A really good principle to teach is to pay attention to details.

 

MCLARK1970

11:35 PM ET

June 20, 2010

Neda Still Lives

If you start a preschool like I did you'll want to make sure that good principles are taught and this a good example of how someone stood up what they believed and are still being remember for the good that she stood for.

 

TOMMIE NOEL

12:15 AM ET

July 14, 2010

Collateral Damage

Neda. This name immediately brings back memories of the pictures and the anger we witnessed last summer. Neda Agha-Soltan was the Iranian student who was shot dead on the fringes of a demonstration against the Ahmadinejad government. idaho flower delivery A mobile phone video captured the scene of her death, and Neda became the most well-known martyr of this uprising for freedom. Even today, her picture can still be seen all over the Internet, on posters and T-shirts – yet many media outlets are showing the wrong picture, one which they found on the Internet, the picture of a woman called Neda Soltani. This is not only an example of slipshod research, but for the real, living Neda Soltani, it is a tragedy, it placed her between all the frontlines and, eventually, forced her into political asylum in Germany. Kamran Safiarian reports on what is indeed a deeply sad story in every respect. Tehran in June 2009. When the 26-year-old student Neda Agha-Soltan was killed, chaos was reigning in the streets. kansas local flower shops The same was true for many media outlets’ editorial offices. Journalists were eagerly searching the net for pictures of the dead young woman and quickly come across the wrong photo. Posters commemorate the unsuspecting Neda Soltani as a martyr – the beginning of a nightmare.

 

JOANWMALLER

3:23 PM ET

June 26, 2010

The one of the right

Just in case no one has mentioned this, the living Neda is the picture on the right and exercise extreme caution when it comes to what you have to say about her, regadless of your own personal opinions.

 

KAMI

6:55 AM ET

June 29, 2010

Neda Soltani herself has started news and she made it at first!

It is very interesting that no one wants to know at very beginning moments I myself informed her what was going on but she believed it is a unique event in her life!
She herself emailed her photo to some News agencies like VOA..
She got Greek visa and did not escape to!
She took a loan from university and she did not spend her save!

 

GIGA34

2:21 PM ET

June 29, 2010

Working on this kind of

Working on this kind of issues is a real difficult task. But as recently as a week ago FOX TV ran a documentary in which it again used the photo of the living Neda Soltani to portray the Neda who was killed. This is not only willfully irresponsible, it is, quite literally, criminal and its not a birthday wishes
Thanks