Trouble Down South

Why did Kyrgyzstan suddenly erupt into violence?

JUNE 14, 2010

Four days after violence erupted in southern Kyrgyzstan, the embattled interim government is still unable to control the ongoing fighting between Kyrgyz and Uzbek groups in the provinces of Osh and Jalalabad. At least 120 people have died and thousands have been injured during the four days of unrest. According to the Russian media, up to 75,000 refugees have begun crossing the Uzbek border.  Local NGOs believe the real number could be much higher. Short of troops, equipment, fuel, and reliable communication devices, the Kyrgyz military has been ill equipped to quell the violence. The new government, which took power in a violent uprising just three months ago, has found itself over its head and called for military support from Russia over the weekend. But Moscow declined the plea, declaring the violence to be an internal Kyrgyzstan issue.

While the violence has captured the world's attention, outside observers seem unsure about why it has suddenly erupted and the conflicting explanations offered by the participants haven't exactly helped matters. Local officials say the unrest broke out as news spread of a fight between young patrons at a casino in Osh. The groups of young Kyrgyz patrolling the streets of Osh and Jalalabad blame Uzbeks for starting the fighting as part of a plot by neighboring Uzbekistan to wrest control of the region.

Adding more uncertainty to the mix, the Kyrgyz provisional government has accused deposed President Kurmanbek Bakiyev -- who draws much of his support from the Southern Kyrgyz --  of instigating the unrest through proxies as a way to disrupt a planned constitutional referendum on June 27. The referendum would have given the country's new leaders a foundation for establishing legitimacy.

Kyrgyz military officials say that agents of Bakiyev dispatched well-trained mercenary snipers to Osh and Jalalabad who shot indiscriminately at locals to spread chaos. While it's not surprising that the new government would seek to pin the blame on its predecessor, there is compelling evidence to suggest that the unrest may have been carefully orchestrated. These include attempts by unidentified armed groups to seize control of TV channels, universities, and local government buildings during the fighting, unlikely targets for a mob driven purely by ethnic animosity.

One might think that Kygyzstan's southern region would be a tinderbox for ethnic confrontation. Uzbeks are the largest ethnic minority in Kyrgyzstan after Russians, making up over 13 percent of the population. In Osh and Jalalabad, however, Uzbeks constitute the majority of the population. The Uzbek minority is largely excluded from Kyrgyzstan's political system, though they dominate the country's merchant class. Disputes over water and land use between the Uzbeks and Kyrgyz are common in the south. The Soviet Union spent decades trying unsuccessfully to suppress ethnic nationalism in the area and in 1990, when the Soviet military was unable to put a stop to a three-month-long inter-ethnic battle between Uzbeks and Kyrgyz in Osh that resulted in hundreds of deaths, it was taken as a sign of Moscow's diminished power over its regions.

STR/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS:
 

Erica Marat is a Washington-based Central Asia analyst and the author of The Military and the State in Central Asia.

MALICEIT

9:31 PM ET

June 14, 2010

RE:

So after Tulip revolution failed ol' dog here tries to grab onto power with whatever means necessary. Also he's probably using the same "NGO's" to cause unrest in the region, that propelled him into his presidency.

 

MUSTNOTSLEEP14

1:54 AM ET

June 15, 2010

The situation on the ground

The situation on the ground could be the start of genocide unless action is taken immediately.

 

LT COL SARFRAZ HUSSAIN

7:04 AM ET

June 15, 2010

Another Flashpoint of Burning Humanity

Superpowers both of past and present would do a great favour to their countries if they stop lighting fire all over the globe.

 

FELINE74

9:23 AM ET

June 16, 2010

Old saying of mothers the world over.

"If you can't share it, then none of you can have it."

I read another article on this subject which mentioned that the Ferghana valley was originally an independent state that Stalin divided up. Instead of trying to make Stalin's borders (which seem purposefully designed encourage this sort of bloodshed) work, why not save everyone some heart- and headache by joining the valley back up into an independent state?

Probably a naive question, but it can't be worse than what they've already got, can it?

 

RSAFSOZ

2:53 PM ET

June 16, 2010

where is Moscow?

Moscow government on this issue will not do anything? Indeed, they are all responsible. sikis

 

TOMMIE NOEL

1:29 AM ET

July 14, 2010

Kyrgyzstan

The ousting of Kyrgyzstan’s President back in April by violent anti-government protests was followed by more violence in June, as the Uzbek minority found itself a convenient scapegoat for the economic woes facing the country. hp q2612a cartridge In the aftermath, at least 2,000 Uzbeks were dead and some 375,000 displaced. Hundreds of Uzbek businesses and homes were also looted and burned to the ground. As a result, some fear a Rwanda-type situation is brewing. If so, does that mean it is up to the typically indifferent international community to intervene? In Kyrgyzstan in particular, peace armies could act as a protective force, escorting and defending targeted minorities like the Uzbeks. Nonviolent Peaceforce has already sent an exploratory team to the southern Caucasus, where there have been multiple interstate and ethnic conflicts in the recent past. hp q2612a cartridge With an invitation from the new Kyrgyz government, and international support and funding, Nonviolent Peaceforce could get to work in southern Kyrgyzstan and help the country transition – peacefully – into a parliamentary democracy.