A Short History of a Bad Metaphor

Working with Russia isn't necessarily a bad idea. Reducing it to a catchphrase is. 

BY JOSHUA E. KEATING | JUNE 16, 2010

As policy initiatives go, the "reset button" didn't exactly have the smoothest of rollouts. On March 6, 2009, Secretary of State Hillary Clinton presented her Russian counterpart Sergei Lavrov with a literal button meant to symbolize the Obama administration's intention to repair frayed ties with Russia. Unfortunately, one misplaced syllable on the Cyrillic label meant that the button actually said "overcharge," not "reset," and Clinton was subjected to a few days of media mockery in both capitals.

But despite (or perhaps because of) the initial gaffe, the phrase caught on. More than a year later, and just ahead of Russian President Dmitry Medvedev's visit to Washington next week, "reset button" has become shorthand for the administration's entire Russia policy. Virtually every big-think article or op-ed written on U.S.-Russia relations since that day has referred to the reset button either admiringly or disparagingly.

What's more, the phrase has gone viral. Commentators have invoked the reset button in discussions of U.S. policy on Iran, Afghanistan, Turkey, Israel, Islam, Britain, Latin America, BP, climate change, Africa, health care, the economy, the war on drugs, and even the Obama presidency itself.

Now, when hostile leaders like Venezuelan strongman Hugo Chávez talk about reaching out to the United States, they say they're "willing to press the reset button." When Obama makes a major policy address on a controversial topic like the Gulf oil spill, the question pundits ask is whether he will be able to "hit the reset button."

One might almost get the impression that the U.S. political and media establishment has become one giant tech-support line, where the first response to any problem is, "Have you tried restarting the machine?"

"It definitely became a much bigger metaphor than was originally intended," said one senior administration official who spoke on condition of anonymity. "It was not a conscious thing that we were going to go out and create this image. It's since been codified. Not by us, by the way."

The phrase, in verb form, actually dates back to the presidential transition period when then President-elect Obama told NBC's Tom Brokaw that "it's going to be important for us to reset U.S.-Russian relations." But it entered the popular lexicon when Vice President Joe Biden used it during a widely touted foreign-policy address at a security summit in Munich in February 2009.

"The last few years have seen a dangerous drift in relations between Russia and the members of our alliance," Biden said, referring to NATO. "It is time -- to paraphrase President Obama -- it's time to press the reset button and to revisit the many areas where we can and should be working together with Russia."

The basic premise of the strategy is that on the major priorities of U.S. foreign policy -- containing Iran, fighting international terrorism, and reducing the risk of nuclear weapons -- there's no reason for the United States and Russia to be at odds. By focusing on these areas, there's potential for "win-win" outcomes rather than "zero-sum" competition. "This was a fairly radical notion in U.S.-Russia relations," says the administration official.

FABRICE COFFRINI/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: MEDIA, RUSSIA
 

Joshua Keating is an associate editor at Foreign Policy.

GEORGEKZ

1:16 AM ET

June 18, 2010

*But to critics, it has often

*But to critics, it has often looked like the United States is selling out Russian democracy or traditional allies in Eastern Europe in favor of bigger foreign-policy priorities*

One should wonder what America has to do with Russian democracy. The biggest problem with American foreign policy in the global age is that it has been so often misled by this obsolete ideal of defending democracy all over the world, even in places it has no soil to grow from. First, democracy is not universal, second, it may be a thousand times different from what some American interventionists believe it to look like.

Agreeing with the article, I may just add that this whole 'reset' thing is a treasure-trove for hungry journalists hyping their publications by calling to reset everything at a time. You cannot reset your past and even present. You have to admit them. The Bush era is gone, but its heritage makes our living. We cannot erase Putin, as this strongman happened from the outset to embody a self-confident person able to talk to America not in the state of drunkenness, like his predecessor, but from the position of an equal, reasonable partner who can say no when he wants to. Let us just forget this reset nonsense and quit squandering our time and littering our brainboxes.

 

RSAFSOZ

3:01 PM ET

June 19, 2010

politic

Political relationships that must be done in an operation 20 years sikis

 

SIRCUCUMBER

10:38 AM ET

June 20, 2010

origin of reset button

...and all this time I'd thought the term came from my nintendo...

 

DIGGYHOW

9:31 AM ET

June 21, 2010

Nice

Wow that is cool. Those Russians are amazing!

Lou
www.Anonymous-VPN.de.tc