Postcards from Hell

Images from the world's most failed states.

CAPTIONS BY ELIZABETH DICKINSON | JULY/AUGUST 2010

For the last half-decade, the Fund for Peace, working with Foreign Policy, has been putting together the Failed States Index, using a battery of indicators to determine how stable -- or unstable -- a country is. But as the photos here demonstrate, sometimes the best test is the simplest one: You'll only know a failed state when you see it.

Spencer Platt/Getty Images

1. SOMALIA
FSI score: 114.3 (out of 120)

Somalia has topped the Failed States Index for the last three years -- a testament not only to the depth of the country's long-running political and humanitarian disaster, but also, as James Traub writes, to the international community's inability to find an answer. After two decades of chaos, the country is today largely under the control of Islamist militant groups, the most notorious and powerful of which is al-Shabab. A second faction, Hizbul Islam, rivals the former in brutality -- it recently executed two Somalis for the crime of watching the World Cup. Off the coast, pirates such as the men pictured here torment passing ships, often holding them hostage for a high price. In 2009, Somali pirates earned an estimated $89 million in ransom payments.

Mohamed Dahir/AFP/Getty Images

2. CHAD
Score: 113.3

Chad's troubles are often written off as spillover from the conflict taking place in next-door Darfur, Sudan. But this central African country has plenty of problems of its own. An indigenous conflict has displaced approximately 200,000, and life under the paranoid rule of Chadian President Idriss Déby is increasingly miserable. Déby has arrested opposition figures and redirected humanitarian funding to the military in recent years. Matters might soon get worse as the U.N. peacekeeping mission in the country's east, where the bulk of the refugees reside, begins to depart on July 15. Pictured here, local Chadians in the village of Dankouche struggle to share scarce resources such as firewood with a nearby Sudanese refugee camp.

Olivier Laban-Mattei/AFP/Getty Images

3. SUDAN
Score: 111.8

The next year will prove a decisive one for Sudan, perhaps more so than any other since the country's independence in 1956. In January 2011, the people of South Sudan will vote in a referendum on whether they would prefer to remain an autonomous region -- or secede as an independent state. All analysts predict it will be the latter, but they are equally certain that it won't be so easy. President Omar Hassan al-Bashir is likely to cling close to his control of the South, where much of the country's oil riches lie. This is to say nothing of Darfur, where peacekeepers recently reported an uptick in violence with hundreds killed. In this scene, children crowd around a U.N. helicopter in the South Sudanese town of Akobo.

Peter Martell/AFP/Getty Images

4. ZIMBABWE
Score: 110.2

Life in Zimbabwe has undoubtedly gotten better since a power-sharing agreement between Robert Mugabe, who has ruled this southern African country since 1980, and Morgan Tsvangirai, his most prominent opponent and the current prime minister, entered into force in February 2009. Inflation is down from 230 million percent, goods are back on the shelves, NGOs are able to work again (though they are often still harassed), and the country is able to tap into foreign credit lines from regional banks and China. The bad news is that Mugabe has kept up his dictatorial rule as if nothing had changed; for example, he celebrated his 30th anniversary in office to the spectacular fanfare seen here, where children display militant loyalty to the ruling party. Mugabe and Tsvangirai operate autonomously, holding occasional talks to resolve disputes over cabinet appointments, land expropriation, opposition arrests, and media freedom -- among other things. With little sign of progress for months, both leaders are now looking forward to fresh elections as the "only way out" of the political stalemate, as Tsvangirai has put it.

Alexander Joe/AFP/Getty Images

5. DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF THE CONGO
Score: 109.9

The Democratic Republic of the Congo is the epitome of a country cursed by its resources. Blessed with perhaps the world's single most abundant, diverse, and extractable supply of minerals, Congo has been exploited from the moment its riches were known -- first by Belgian colonialists, then by miserable kleptocrats, and today by the Army and various rebel groups and militias. Meanwhile, miners, such as those seen here, work for meager wages. For all the country's mineral wealth, today it has little to show for it save one of the world's most desperate humanitarian situations. Although the International Rescue Committee's estimated death toll of 5.4 million since 1998 has been contested, no one doubts that hundreds of thousands, if not more, have died -- not from fighting but from disease.

Spencer Platt/Getty Images

6. AFGHANISTAN
Score: 109.3

To anyone who has followed the news over the last decade, Afghanistan needs no introduction. An ongoing U.S.-led military operation there is working town by town and safe haven by safe haven to defeat the Taliban, the Islamist movement that ruled the country until its overthrow after the September 11, 2001, attacks. But the weak and fraying government of President Hamid Karzai, reelected under dubious conditions last August and presiding over a deeply corrupt administration, has thwarted those efforts. Now, with the self-imposed U.S. deadline to begin pulling out troops just a year away, many are wondering if conditions will permit the international forces to leave. Here, women in the capital city of Kabul stand patiently -- even as a nearby explosion sends passersby into a frenzy.

Majid Saeedi/Getty Images

7. IRAQ
Score: 107.3

Iraq rocketed to the top of the Failed States Index after a 2003 U.S. military invasion ousted the dictator Saddam Hussein and set off a period of violent turmoil. Amid the explosion of sectarian killings and reprisals that followed, more than 2 million Iraqis fled the country, and many have yet to return. Although Iraq has calmed dramatically since the violence peaked in 2007, the country remains deeply polarized along ethnic and religious lines. Recent parliamentary elections were among the freest in the Arab world, but were marred by suicide attacks and allegations of fraud, and a new government has yet to be named. Any number of factors could prove destabilizing going forward: tension over oil rights, latent Sunni-Shiite hostility, the pullout of U.S. combat troops by Sept. 1. An April 23 attack in Baghdad is pictured here, on a day when 58 died in similar assaults throughout the country.

Ahmad Al-Rubaye/Getty Images

8. CENTRAL AFRICAN REPUBLIC
Score: 106.4

The Central African Republic should have calmed down by now; peace deals in 2007 and 2008 brought rebels into the government's fold. But banditry and violence are still common, and lately the country has played unintentional host to the Lord's Resistance Army, a legendarily brutal group of rebels that has been pillaging and abducting new "recruits" and hapless children after being chased out of nearby Uganda. Meanwhile, François Bozizé, a former army chief of staff who came to power in a 2003 coup, has drained the country's wealth for the benefit of his small cadre. The country has known little if any modernization since its independence from France a half-century ago.  Here, a man watches a burning village set aflame with the intention of warding off snakes and scorpions -- and boosting fertility.

Spencer Platt/Getty Images

9. GUINEA
Score: 105.0

The last 18 months have been a roller-coaster ride for this small West African country, with far more downs than ups. After Guinea's longtime president died in December 2008, a group of renegade soldiers seized power, naming a rogue Army captain, Moussa Dadis Camara, as president. Camara quickly proved to be a delusional, erratic, and violent ruler. In September 2009, Guinean troops massacred 150 opposition protesters at the country's national stadium, provoking international outrage. Months later, Camara was shot by one of his own guards, who claimed that the junta leader was forcing him to take the fall for the massacre. The injured Camara was flown out of the country for medical care and his deputy, Sékouba Konaté, took charge together with a civilian prime minister. Elections to seat a permanent government are promised for June 27 -- the first good news this heavily militarized country has had for a while. In this photo, tanks prepare to bring a 2007 general strike to heel.

Georges Gobet/AFP/Getty Images

10. PAKISTAN
Score: 102.5

Pakistan has more than once been described as the world's most dangerous country. Its wild northern reaches remain host to various branches of the Pakistani Taliban and likely to al Qaeda (Osama bin Laden is thought to be among them), while other militant groups make gains closer to urban areas. The bomb that went off here left six dead in Quetta, in the country's southwest. More than 3 million Pakistani civilians were displaced by "counterinsurgency" operations in 2009 -- the largest single movement of people since the Rwandan genocide. Meanwhile, President Asif Ali Zardari's democratically elected government looks hapless -- unable to gain any measure of civilian control over a nuclear-armed military obsessed with planning for a war with India, or an intelligence service that stands accused of abetting the Afghan Taliban.

Banaras Khan/AFP/Getty Images

11. HAITI
Score: 101.6

As 2010 began, Haiti was finally making progress: Donor funds were flooding in, the government was on its feet, and there was more optimism than at any point in the last two decades. And then, in the span of a few seconds, everything fell apart. The 7.0 magnitude earthquake that hit Haiti on Jan. 12 created one of the worst humanitarian disasters in recent memory. Today, some 230,000 Haitians are thought to have died, with more than 1 million homeless and 2 million in need of food aid. For the country's people -- such as the man seen here drinking street water from a makeshift straw -- as well as its government and donors, the temblor has been an epic tragedy, setting back years of painstaking development efforts.

THONY BELIZAIRE/AFP/Getty Images

12. IVORY COAST
Score: 101.2

They signed a peace deal in 2007, but today, the Ivory Coast's northern and southern regions are more divided than ever over how to share the country's resources. Elections to replace the current government, which took office in a 2003 power-sharing agreement, were scheduled to have taken place in 2005. A half-decade later, the country has yet to finalize an electoral list, and violence once again looms. Nor has the country been rebuilt; the houses pictured here were ransacked back in 2002. This young boy is malnourished -- as one in every five children in the Ivory Coast are.

ISSOUF SANOGO/AFP/Getty Images

13. KENYA
Score: 100.7

Kenya, like the Ivory Coast, has lately shown that power-sharing arrangements can be as divisive as the conflicts they are meant to end. In Nairobi, the country's president and prime minister have been perpetually at odds since their forced marriage in 2008. The government has done little to investigate or make amends for that year's explosion of election-related violence. An exasperated Kofi Annan, the former U.N. secretary-general who helped resolve the electoral dispute, has given the International Criminal Court names of people who are implicated -- because Kenya seems unwilling to try them itself. Meanwhile, for the average Kenyan, all this has proved a distraction from everyday concerns. Villagers in northeastern Kenya, pictured here, carry water amid a drought of the sort that often threatens regional famine.

Mike Goldwater/Christian Aid/Exclusive by Getty Images

14. NIGERIA
Score: 100.2

Nigeria's infamous political instability was in the news with unfortunate frequency in recent months, as the country's president fell ill, disappeared for medical care, and eventually passed away, leaving control to his vice president, Goodluck Jonathan. Meanwhile, a combination of  intercommunal violence in the country's middle belt (corpses from which are seen buried here), a flailing amnesty program in the oil-rich Niger Delta, police brutality, scathing poverty, and rampant corruption has kept this West African country in the ranks of the world's most dysfunctional states.

PIUS UTOMI EKPEI/AFP/Getty Images

15. YEMEN
Score: 100.0

Decades of conflict and insecurity have made AK-47s a status symbol in Yemen on par with the country's traditional dress. Attempted Christmas Day bomber Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab trained in Yemen, and despite U.S. military aid, there is little sign that the central government is capable of rooting out militant groups such as al Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula. Throw in declining oil revenues, failing water supplies, an internal rebellion or two (the destruction from which is manifest here), and an influx of Somali refugees, and the question becomes when, not if, Yemen's ticking time bomb will go off.

 

--/AFP/Getty Images

16. BURMA
Score: 99.4

Burma's ruling junta will hold elections later this year for the first time in two decades -- which would be good news were it not for a few stubborn facts: The democratic opposition won't be allowed to compete, the vote will be conducted under a Constitution that entrenches military power, and the ballot will undoubtedly yield yet another strongman in uniform. After crushing a brief 2007 uprising, led by monks and dubbed the "Saffron Revolution" in the international media, the junta has retrenched and shown little willingness to engage the wider world. But beneath the facade of stability lies simmering ethnic unrest; minority groups have staged ongoing rebellions for decades. Most recently, a cease-fire between the minority Kokang and the Burmese military broke down, sending refugees pouring over the border with China. Here, a girl carries a basket through a market in the northern part of the country.

NICOLAS ASFOURI/AFP/Getty Images

17. ETHIOPIA
Score: 98.8

When Ethiopians went to the polls on May 23, there was little doubt whose party would win: that of Meles Zenawi, the incumbent prime minister. Indeed, the ruling Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Front took all but two of the country's 547 parliamentary seats -- an unbelievably high tally given that many think the opposition may have won the previous vote, in 2005. This time around, Zenawi ratcheted up the repression, passing a draconian NGO law, barring public meetings, and intimidating would-be opposition voters. The opposition is challenging the win in court, but international condemnation has been muted. Politics aside, Ethiopia is no stranger to misery; more than a third of children under 5 in this famine-cursed country are underweight. The women pictured here are queuing to vote in the May 23 presidential election.

SIMON MAINA/AFP/Getty Images

18. EAST TIMOR
Score: 98.2

East Timor is arguably the most uplifting story on this dismal list. The country has now been largely violence-free since 2008 after years of turmoil that followed its formal independence from Indonesia in 2002. East Timor's president, Nobel Peace Prize winner José Ramos-Horta, told FP last year that he is working hard to reform East Timor's police force, pictured here, so that it can take over from U.N. peacekeepers when they depart next year. Meanwhile, the country's gas and oil reserves offer hope that the fledgling country will one day be able to stand on its own.

MARIO JONNY DOS SANOTS/AFP/Getty Images

19. NIGER
Score: 97.8

By Feb. 18, Salou Djibo had had enough of Niger's president, Mamadou Tandja. The Nigerien leader had been cynically seeking to use the Constitution to entrench his powers and prolong his term in office. So Djibo and his fellow military officers deposed him, held him captive, and called for democracy to be restored. Crowds cheered the new leaders on the streets, and democratic elections have been promised by February 2011. But whether the coup was really a step in the right direction might depend on how the junta handles an imminent food crisis. With the harvest in September still months off, 7 million are in need of food so far. Nearly half of Nigeriens have no access to clean drinking water, such as the boys pictured above. Extreme privation is nothing new to Niger, one of the world's poorest countries -- despite being one of the top uranium producers in the world.

HOANG DINH NAM/AFP/Getty Images

19. NORTH KOREA (tied with Niger)
Score: 97.8

Kim Jong Il's nuclear program and recent provocations may keep the world's last Stalinist dictatorship perpetually on the international radar, but it is his criminal neglect of his country's people that has guaranteed North Korea a high spot on the Failed States Index. This year threatens to be particularly grim: The regime's "currency reform" program in early 2010 devastated personal savings; the government has worked hard in recent years to shut down the illicit food trade; and cereal production is nowhere near what it needs to be -- even in a good year, more than a third of the country's 24 million people go hungry. This fittingly gray-tinged photo depicts a government office in Pyongyang.

PETER PARKS/AFP/Getty Images

21. UGANDA
Score: 97.5

Ugandan journalist Andrew Mwenda has a searing way of describing his government: "Corruption is not just an element of this system but is 'the system.'" In office since 1986, the country's president, Yoweri Museveni, has come under increasing criticism in recent years for his kleptocratic rule and reluctance to give up power. There's not likely to be much of a change in the upcoming 2011 presidential election; the opposition is already crying foul about alleged plans for vote-stuffing. Here, men rallying against Museveni burn a bus in protest.

Stringer/AFP/Getty Images

22. GUINEA-BISSAU
Score: 97.2

Guinea Bissau may well be Africa's first narco-state. Cocaine and heroin traffickers targeted the country several years ago and have since infiltrated every rank and file of the country's elite. Since the influx of cocaine dwarfs the country's annual GDP, it is easy to buy off military, customs, and political officials. Here, a soldier walks in former president's funeral procession; he was assasinated in March, 2009. The West African country's citizens will surely be the first to suffer, most already living in dilapidated circumstances.

Seyllou/AFP/Getty Images

23. BURUNDI
Score: 96.7

Burundi is home to one of Africa's most recent civil wars, ending in 2009 after 15 years of fighting. Now, with former militant groups converted into political parties, however, some of the nasty tactics have carried over, and political violence is escalating in the lead-up to presidential elections on June 28. Stability, if it comes, could do much for the small coffee-producing country of just 8 million -- that is, if its neighbor, Rwanda, is any guide; economic growth there has taken off following the 1994 genocide.

Roberto Schmidt/AFP/Getty Images

24. BANGLADESH
Score: 96.1

Bangladesh has improved significantly on the index over the last three years, from its high-water mark at No. 12 in the index to 24th today. Democracy was restored to the country in 2008 after the Army declared "emergency rule" a year earlier. The last two years of civilian authority haven't been seamless, to be sure -- a military uprising, for example, left more than 70 dead in 2009 -- but a daily calm has returned. Now, the greatest threats might come not from politics but from Mother Nature. Always prone to disasters, Bangladesh worries that climate change will push it over the edge as cyclones, floods, and mudslides grow more common. Coastal homes like the ones pictured here are among the most threatened.

Munir Uz Zaman/AFP/Getty Images

25. SRI LANKA
Score: 95.7

It should have been a moment to cheer. In early 2009, a 30-year civil war that pitted Tamil Tiger rebels against the government came to an end. But the final weeks of fighting took a terrible human toll, and on May 17, 2010, the International Crisis Group issued a report documenting war crimes committed by both sides during the last month of the war. Among the alleged government offenses were the deliberate shelling of civilians and hospitals, the cutting off of humanitarian aid, and the suppressing of Tamil voices and journalists during the conflict. (In a recent discussion with Foreign Policy, Sri Lanka's foreign minister denied any wrongdoing but failed to answer the allegations directly.) An election in January was also marred when, just days after President Mahinda Rajapaksa was reelected, he arrested his opponent, Gen. Sarath Fonseka. Here, a Buddhist monk is detained by police after holding a hunger strike to demand Fonseka's release.

Ishara Kodikara/AFP/Getty Images

26. CAMEROON
Score: 95.4

On the surface, Cameroon is a pillar of stability in a neighborhood that is anything but. The country has suffered no recent civil wars; U.N. relief agencies enjoy a friendly relationship there, using Cameroon as a base to provide help to nearby Chad; and the country's incredible rain forests attract a fair number of tourists each year (it earned $182 million from the industry last year). But stability can easily become stagnation. Paul Biya has been president for 18 years, during which time he has consolidated political power and co-opted the opposition. Meanwhile, the country's natural beauty has also become its greatest plague; poaching is prevalent and logging has stripped 81 percent of the country's un-protected forests according to the World Resources Institute. Above, villagers walk outside a nature preserve.

-/AFP/Getty Images

26. NEPAL (tied with Cameroon)
Score: 95.4

Amid a Maoist general strike (seen here), with civil war barely quelled, and up against a midnight deadline in late May, Nepal's feuding parties reached a deal to stave off the country's political collapse -- for now. Since a 2006 peace deal brought Maoist rebels into the government, Nepal has been anything but quiet. The Maoists became a political party and won the 2008 elections, and then subsequently pulled out of the government when implementation of the peace agreement stalled. Among the most contentious issues has been the integration of former Maoists into the country's military -- something that Nepal's generals have adamantly resisted. The country itself remains underdeveloped and volatile; in rural areas, just under half the population lives below the poverty line.

Prakash Mathema/AFP/Getty Images

28. MALAWI
Score: 93.6

Malawi's annual GDP is less than the United States plans to spend on robotic space missions over the next five years. A mostly agricultural country, Malawi produces a few cash crops, such as tobacco, sugar, cotton, and tea. Rather, the majority of agricultural workers are subsistence farmers. Drought and famine have left millions wanting for food in recent years. Almost 12 percent of the population is HIV positive, robbing the country of workers in their economic prime. Here, a corn farmer collects his harvest.

Gianluigi Guercia/AFP/Getty Images TK

28. SIERRA LEONE (tied with Malawi)
Score: 93.6

Trash overwhelms the eyes and nostrils upon arrival in Freetown, a capital city that expanded rapidly with refugees during and after Sierra Leone's decade-long civil war. Few of those safety-seekers have returned home, remaining instead in shantytowns on the city's outskirts and in the seaside capital's many flood plains. Public health is correspondingly poor in urban areas, with the fate of mothers particularly grim. One in eight dies in pregnancy and 43,000 children under the age of 5 perish every year. And what of the country's blood diamonds, now out of rebel control? They were enough to feed and arm a brutal rebel movement but are far from enough to fund a country, bringing in just $35 million in the first five months of this year.

Chris Jackson/Getty Images

30. ERITREA
Score: 93.3

Recently described by Human Rights Watch as a "giant prison," Eritrea stands alone for its repression in Africa. The country got off to a rough start, gaining its independence from Ethiopia in a bloody war that ended in 1993, but troops have often mobilized ominously along both sides of the border. Mandatory military service is the national pastime, with all citizens required to enter the army as young adults. Scarce food and fuel, generalized repression, and rampant poverty has sent refugees fleeing abroad. The near-empty streets pictured here have an eerie, lingering quality of solitude.

Peter Martell/AFP/Getty Images

31. REPUBLIC OF THE CONGO
Score: 92.5
Former rebels are demobilized in a 2008 ceremony in the capital city of Brazzaville. While the troubles of the Republic of the Congo pale in comparison to those of its larger neighbor, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, both countries have faced decades of sporadic conflict and are now struggling to rebuild.

GUY-GERVAIS KITINA/AFP/Getty Images

32. IRAN
Score: 92.2
Clashes broke out in Tehran after a disputed June 2009 election saw President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad claiming victory over his main challenger, Mir Hossein Mousavi. The protester seen here was one of thousands who formed the country's new opposition Green Movement in the wake of the disputed contest.

ALI SAFARI/AFP/Getty Images

33. LIBERIA
Score: 91.7
Children walk down a central street in Monrovia, the war-wracked capital that is now slowly rebuilding after decades of conflict. When the current president, Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, came to office in 2007, electricity, a water system, and even the most basic public services were completely absent.

GLENNA GORDON/AFP/Getty Images

34. LEBANON
Score: 90.9
This Palestinian refugee camp was devestated in December, 2009, when fighting between Lebanon's military and the militant movement Fatah al-Islam.

JOSEPH EID/AFP/Getty Images

35. BURKINA FASO
Score: 90.7
Many of the workers in this Ouagadougou gravel pit are children, laboring in difficult conditions at an age when their peers in more fortunate countries are attending school. Two decades after an international treaty banned it, child labor remains an enormous problem in this impoverished West African country.

Veronique de Viguerie/Getty Images

36. UZBEKISTAN
Score: 90.5
There is an eerie calm over the graves of the hundreds massacred in the eastern Uzbek town of Andijan in 2005, when soldiers loyal to President Islam Karimov opened fired on protesters. The government claimed the demonstrators were radical Islamists, but most observers think that Karimov's anti-terrorism rhetoric has been abused to legitimize a deeply corrupt and repressive state.

DENIS SINYAKOV/AFP/Getty Images

37. GEORGIA
Score: 90.4
The dramatic 2008 war between Georgia and Russia over the renegade Georgian province of South Ossetia sent Georgian refugees seeking cover, as seen here. Two years later, the status of the province remains a sore spot, with Moscow recognizing the breakaway republic as an independent state and Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili insisting on a full Russian withdrawal and restoration of Georgian sovereignty.

Burak Kara/Getty Images

38. TAJIKISTAN
Score: 89.2
Facing dismal job prospects and crushing poverty at home, countless young Tajik workers have gone abroad in recent years, looking for work in Russia and Kazakhstan. Many of the women and children who stay behind make ends meet through farming. The girl here jumps a creek in a cotton field in a village outside the capital, Dushanbe.

VYACHESLAV OSELEDKO/AFP/Getty Images

39. MAURITANIA
Score: 89.1
Western analysts have worried about terrorism in West Africa's Sahel region in recent years -- and suicide bombings such as the one pictured above have done little to reassure them. Mauritanian police cordoned off the route to the embassy of former colonial power France in the capital of Nouakchott following the attack on Aug. 8, 2009.

Watt Abdel Jelil/AFP/Getty Images

40. CAMBODIA
Score: 88.7
This young Cambodian mother is turning her infant over to the care of a safe house built for families of persons living with HIV/AIDS and run by a Canadian NGO. About 170,000 Cambodians are HIV positive.

Photo by Paula Bronstein /Getty Images

40. LAOS (tied with Cambodia and Rwanda)
Score: 88.7
When it is finished, the $1.45 billion Nam Theun Dam will be Laos's largest hydropower project and the single largest source of foreign investment. Critics worry, however, that the construction will have a devastating impact on villagers such as the girl seen here fishing in local waters. Despite grinding poverty throughout the mostly rural country, big gains have been made in fighting infant mortality and extending life expectancy in recent years.

Haong Dinh Nam/AFP/Getty Images

40. RWANDA (tied with Cambodia and Laos)
Score: 88.7

Rwandan soldiers return home after operations in the eastern provinces of the Democratic Republic of the Congo, where they participated in joint operations against rebel militias there. The country's president, Paul Kagame, himself a former soldier, has helped supercharge the Rwandan economy following the 1994 genocide. Many worry that political repression is setting in, however, as Kagame consolidates power.

LIONEL HEALING/AFP/Getty Images

43. SOLOMON ISLANDS
Score: 88.6

A building burns after riots in the capital city of Honiara in 2006. Australian troops were deployed to quell the violence that followed the inauguration of the then-new Prime Minister Snyder Rini.

Solomon Islands Government Communications Unit via Getty Images

44. EQUATORIAL GUINEA
Score: 88.5

A view of the capital, Malabo, is nondescript -- belying the country's bountiful oil wealth. Most of the spoils have remained in the hands of the government, leaving the country's people deeply impoverished. Life expectancy is a mere 50 years, and primary-school enrollment has actually fallen in recent years.

Rodrigo ANGUE NGUEMA/AFP/Getty Images

45. KYRGYZSTAN
Score: 88.4

Riot police form a barricade outside the capital, Bishkek, on April 20. Just days earlier, opposition forces ousted the country's president, Kurmanbek Bakiyev, installing a transitional regime in his place. The unrest sparked an orgy of ethnic unrest in its wake; here, troops protect against the looters who attacked mainly ethnic Russian and Meskhetian Turks' homes.

VYACHESLAV OSELEDKO/AFP/Getty Images

46. COLOMBIA
Score: 88.2

The streets of Commune 1, a shantytown in the country's second-largest city of Medellín, have been among the most violent in recent years. Drug gangs have fought out turf wars here, contributing to the ranks of the displaced -- still numbering about 3 million even after decades of internal conflict have slowly wound down.

RAUL ARBOLEDA/AFP/Getty Images

47. TOGO
Score: 88.1

Supporters of a defeated presidential opposition candidate protest the outcome of March 2010 election in the capital city of Lomé. The victor, President Faure Gnassingbé, is the son of the country's former strongman leader.

ISSOUF SANOGO/AFP/Getty Images

48. SYRIA
Score: 87.9

Demonstrations broke out in Syria last year as Israeli security forces began a hard assault on the Gaza Strip. In recent years, hopes that President Bashar al-Assad would bring change after his father's iron-fisted rule have proved largely unfounded.

LOUAI BESHARA/AFP/Getty Images

49. EGYPT
Score: 87.6

Members of the banned opposition Muslim Brotherhood protest outside Parliament in downtown Cairo in May after the country's prime minister, Ahmed Nazif, requested that a state of emergency law be extended for another two years. Already in place for almost three decades, the law has allowed President Hosni Mubarak to clamp down on the opposition, all but guaranteeing he will stay in power, as he said in 2004, "until the last breath in my lungs and the last beat of my heart."

KHALED DESOUKI/AFP/Getty Images

50. BHUTAN
Score: 87.3

A policeman and an elderly Bhutanese woman pass in the capital city of Thimphu in April, where a regional summit was being held. The impoverished country is one of the world's most isolated, but its ruling monarchy is relatively enlightened; King Jigme Khesar Namgyel Wangchuck favors his own metric, "gross national happiness," over the traditional GDP.

DESHAKALYAN CHOWDHURY/AFP/Getty Images

51. PHILIPPINES
Score: 87.1

Democratic elections will see power transfer from President Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo to her successor, Benigno S. Aquino III, at the end of June. Despite booming foreign investment, poverty is the dominant reality for the country's population. Here, a child walks between shantytown blocks built on tombs.

Noel Celis/AFP/Getty Images

52. COMOROS
Score: 85.1

Governance has ground to a halt in this Indian Ocean island chain over disputes on an election timetable for the country's next presidential vote. Much of the population depends on tourism and agriculture for their livelihoods. Here, a young Comorian boy fishes.

Tony Karumba/AFP/Getty Images

53. BOLIVIA
Score: 84.9

Coca plantations, such as the one being destroyed here, have become an increasing problem in Bolivia in recent years, according to the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration. Aside from growing links to the cocaine trade, the issue has sparked a series of diplomatic spats with Washington over how best to tackle the problem.

Aizar Raldes/AFP/Getty Images

54. ISRAEL/WEST BANK
Score: 84.6

A young Palestinian throws stones at Israeli troops, part of an ongoing protest against Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank. Such settlements have been a particularly thorny issue in the U.S.-Israel relationship in the last year, with Washington demanding a freeze in their construction as part of a move to restart peace talks.

JAAFAR ASHTIYEH/AFP/Getty Images

55. AZERBAIJAN
Score: 84.4

U.S. and Azerbaijani troops hold joint exercises in 2009 outside the country's capital of Baku. The country has become an important, if unhappy Washington ally in the war in Afghanistan, to say nothing of its role as a major energy supplier.

Adil Kazimov/AFP/Getty Images

56. PAPUA NEW GUINEA
Score: 83.9

Life expectancy among residents of Papua New Guinea barely exceeds 60, according to the United Nations Development Program, and only 58 percent of the population can read. Just a third of rural inhabitants have access to clean water. Here, Kiriwina islander children and elders take shelter from the sun in an airport terminal.

Torsten Blackwood/AFP/Getty Images

56. ZAMBIA (tied with Papua New Guinea)
Score: 83.9

Opposition supporters rioted following the 2008 presidential election after their candidate lost to Rupiah Banda. Following allegations of corruption in the government's Health Ministry last August, international donors like the Global Fund suspended millions of dollars in aid to fight HIV/AIDS, tuberculosis and malaria; they are only now beginning to restore assistance. Thanks in part to the HIV/AIDS epidemic, life expectancy in the country is a mere 38 years.

THOMAS NSAMA/AFP/Getty Images

58. MOLDOVA
Score: 83.8

Although Moldova was largely insulated from the global economic downturn thanks to a nationwide reliance on cold, hard cash, this former Soviet satellite remains locked in political crisis. The country will hold a referendum in September on whether the office of the president should be filled by parliamentary appointment or popular vote. Here, Moldovans walk by as police guard the presidential building in Chisinau, the capital.

Viktor Drachev/AFP/Getty Images

59. ANGOLA
Score: 83.7

Two years ago, Angola became Africa's largest oil producer at 2 million barrels per day. Resource wealth hasn't meant better lives for the majority of Angolans, however. The country still stands at 114th in terms of per capita GDP. The man pictured here makes ends meet by collecting recyclable material.

Gianluigi Guercia/AFP/Getty Images

60. BOSNIA-HERZEGOVINA
Score: 83.5

An April demonstration by war veterans in Bosnia-Herzegovina set fire to a federal government building. Despite NATO peacekeeping forces in the country, Bosnia-Herzegovina has recently teetered on the edge of political disaster, with the contesting factions of the 1992-1995 war still at odds.

Elvis Barukcic/AFP/Getty Images

 

Elizabeth Dickinson is assistant managing editor at Foreign Policy.

 

FP KID

11:37 PM ET

June 20, 2010

Too many countries to be meaningful

Putting 60 countries on a list of "failed states" is sensationalistic. Calling more than a quarter of the world's countries "failed states" removes the legitimacy from the label.

 

MAJA007

12:48 PM ET

June 21, 2010

Agree!

Should have stopped at 10. Iran and North Korea are not failed states, but states successful in achieving their misguided goals.

 

FAHAD

8:47 AM ET

June 22, 2010

only good for propaganda purposes

Having Pakistan at number 10 and India at number 87 is absurd. Taliban insurgency currently covers 2-5% of Pakistan's territory which is generally considered inaccessible and has never been legally governed by Pakistan in the first place. Approximately 10-30% of indian territory is under Naxal influence with a plethora of insurgencies all over the land mass. Poverty rate in Pakistan is 23% compared with India's poverty rate of 43% according to UNDP. Inflation rate is roughly the same in both countries which stands at 10% where as GDP per capita incomes are the same. Insurgency related deaths are almost the same in both countries and sectarian and religious conflicts are equally explosive in both places. Can anyone explain to me the huge difference. And how does India able to beat even countries like China.

 

FAHAD

8:48 AM ET

June 22, 2010

only good for propaganda purposes

Having Pakistan at number 10 and India at number 87 is absurd. Taliban insurgency currently covers 2-5% of Pakistan's territory which is generally considered inaccessible and has never been legally governed by Pakistan in the first place. Approximately 10-30% of indian territory is under Naxal influence with a plethora of insurgencies all over the land mass. Poverty rate in Pakistan is 23% compared with India's poverty rate of 43% according to UNDP. Inflation rate is roughly the same in both countries which stands at 10% where as GDP per capita incomes are the same. Insurgency related deaths are almost the same in both countries and sectarian and religious conflicts are equally explosive in both places. Can anyone explain to me the huge difference. And how does India able to beat even countries like China.

 

KROSEYCORN

11:31 AM ET

June 22, 2010

agree

Sensationalistic was exactly the word that I used. Come on, Media... so unreal.

 

RAGHAV

8:56 PM ET

June 22, 2010

Unreal but Pakistan fits in

Ya I agree. The list is stupid and unreasonable.
But Pakistan IS a failed state.
I would advise you to not to be motivated by your internal media. Pk is sitting on nuclear bomb almost been given to insurgents. Dictatorship, state biases, government playing games with US and taliban, ISI a symbol of debauchery, home land of taliban-pakistan, lashkar-e-taiba and so on, citizens going to countries all over world to countres like India, US, UK to plant bombs...
India is not the most successful country in the world but stop being paranoid about it and stop comparing to India.

 

BMEHMUD

2:58 AM ET

June 23, 2010

Propaganda

I agree 100% with Fahad

 

RANGER180

9:34 AM ET

June 23, 2010

lol

Exactly the point mentioned in the article: Why are you so obsessed with India?

 

MANISHLAKHANI13

11:35 AM ET

June 23, 2010

U seems to be

U seems to be pakistani.....and u r obsessed with India.
India is growing my dear friend.....it will achieve double digit growth in next 5 yrs.
Whatever militancy we are facing today is because of Pakistan.

 

OWEN81

1:22 PM ET

June 23, 2010

So hell is not having a car and 5 tvs?

When I saw how long the scroll bar was for this article, I naturally assumed there were a lot of comments. Until I started reading, and continued reading in awe at the characterization of 60 countries as "hell." I've visited a number of these places, and lived in the Philippines, and I can tell you, despite poverty and political wrong-doing, these places are not hell. The first 10 on this list are certainly failed or failing states, but give me a break!

I guess we should throw in quite a few America cities on the list of "hell on earths" due to their high crime rates, poverty and ineffective governments.

You have no idea what you're talking about.

 

TOMSON

9:31 PM ET

June 23, 2010

we are talking about Elizabeth Cockinson here..

she is the dumb of the dumb..Look at her name, you should know what her mom used to do before they have her.

 

SYZYGY

12:28 PM ET

July 1, 2010

facts are facts

I disagree. One cannot ignore the facts and the truth. No one should pretend to be blind simply to avoid the truth.

 

FIILFINSAGEN

5:51 AM ET

July 14, 2010

Such a wonderful topic,i read

Such a wonderful topic,i read this artilce and agree with this artilce.Thanks to talking us about this artilce.

Acai Max Cleanse

 

NAZIA

12:39 AM ET

June 21, 2010

Hell is a symbolic world

Hell is a symbolic world found in divine books to keep the people in alert mode for avoiding sinful attitude while they are passing real lives.
Inhabitants of failed state are victims of sinful attitude of corrupt government /local privileged class and their innate ignorance.They live here and die like that without knowing that good options are available to them.Only harder one among them can survive and they are thought to be best terrorist and criminals of any society.

 

BANDUNGBABY

3:30 AM ET

June 21, 2010

I find the inclusion of my

I find the inclusion of my country, Zambia, as well as several other countries on the list of 'Hell' to be highly amusing. While we have our problems we are not currently occupied(denied sovereignty), we are able to feed ourselves, we have a generally free press, we have a healthy opposition(generally cheated of victory)(the riots described were small and not a particularly big thing, sort of like a demonstration with a bit of life), the courts can be independent and frequently are, corruption isn't required to live, we are at peace with our neighbours, people who aren't formally employed can access land to feed themselves(because it is mostly tribal land and not private), the people are sharp and involved in politics(voter turnout is not participation as there are five years between elections to participate in); our AIDS rate is the worst thing we have along with poor education. But on the whole we are stable as, I suspect, are many other nations included. The first 20 make sense, after that we just get a list of countries where Westerners would never live but which function in their own ways and which their people can be proud of for many reasons without having to meet the criteria of a successful state. We seem to not say Victorian Britain was a failed state yet it appears to meet a fair number of the criteria, just look at how miserable the working poor and the Irish were.

 

NUTSHELL82

10:47 AM ET

June 23, 2010

True

Just created this account to say I agree with you.
Westerners tend to forget the meaning of the word 'different'. Not worse, not failed, but different. I wonder what the Americans are proud of. Or many 'white' nations, like for example mine.

 

PEEXX

10:52 AM ET

June 24, 2010

What other countries would

What other countries would you rather see on the list then?

Regards,
C.P

 

BANDUNGBABY

7:29 PM ET

June 27, 2010

The List

Maybe there shouldn't be a list drawn up by people who presume to know what works and what fails. Or you could just go for states that actually fail rather than try to round it out to 60. The main problem for most of these states is poverty and not anything else as people tend to only care about democracy once they have food on the table, roofs, shoes, pencils and work; until then democracy is just a nice idea and tends to lead to divisions that hinder rather than help a nation. Authoritarianism is bad when it gets extreme as in so many cases but we don't complain about Singapore's history and draconian laws because it does so well. This is just a pat yourself on the back for being lucky enough to be born in the West because everyone must be miserable sort of study; nothing really substantive to the conclusions when you actually walk around half these countries. And I've been to a few of them.

 

DOUBLEPLUSGOOD

1:41 AM ET

July 2, 2010

The metrics used are according to Western standards

I was also struck by Papua New Guinea's inclusion because of low life expectancy and other measures.

There is still this almost colonial mentality in the West where we insist that all countries function according to Western standards. However I think somewhere like Papua New Guinea has its own very unique culture that has developed completely independently of the Western world. It may not be somewhere that I would necessarily want to live, but the culture there suits its people and its environment.

By trying to force Western living standards on people in far flung places you are just asking for trouble. Environmental degradation, overpopulation, dependence on foreign aid to name just a few.

Just let them live the way they have been living, if they want to change, they will do it in their own time. Not everyone needs an iPad to be happy.

 

BANDUNGBABY

3:42 AM ET

June 21, 2010

First 20 or so countries, I

First 20 or so countries, I should clarify.

 

CJP1958

5:34 AM ET

June 21, 2010

FP content

You know, I think a lot of this FP content is designed for propaganda purposes to convince your American readers that their country is still the best place there is to be, ie freedom of speech high standard living and the like. Well, you know, what about the economic crisis or the BP oil spill for example? Do you think the people of Somalia, are really kicking themselves that they aren't Americans because of catastrophes like that?
I don't think so .

I'm not saying that there aren't a lot of places where well-off (dare I say 'white") people like me would prefer not to be. I would also prefer not to engage in superior head games and delude myself into thinking I was superior to anyone else merely by the virtue of luck or the colour of my skin.

All these pointless lists and conjectures do is reinforce the same tedious cliches about racial superioriity and the preference that struggling nations must have toward American so called democracy if they are going to be considered as human beings at all. It's not only unfair, but offensive to liberal honkies like me who remain firmly convinced of the rightness and dignity of the self-determination of others and unconvinced by such empty, imperialist rhetoric.

 

THAINA189

12:48 AM ET

June 22, 2010

100% Right

I created this account just to reply to your comment. As I was reading this I couldn't believe the countries that were put on here! I first read it shocked that someone would have the audacity to call any country hell, even an American. I really do believe that this spread was just a way to put down other countries and make the U.S. feel better about itself.

 

CJP1958

4:04 AM ET

June 22, 2010

so called states of failure

Hi Thaina, it seems that a lot of other people feel the same way.

I'm just an Australian babe in the woods, we're pretty innocent y'know but we aren't stupid and we don't go throwing our weight around like some people I could mention.

 

ASHER_B

3:24 PM ET

June 22, 2010

The US Should be on this List

I'm an American, and while I love my country, I think it should be on this list as it is a failed state - much more so than some of these listed.

Of course, that is my opinion based on what has happened in this country over the last few decades. I'd like to see the America that I remember fondly, not the current State.

When our Government cannot even deal with an internal disaster (think Katrina and now the oil spill) and refuses help from our allies because big business won't let them, it has failed miserably.

I'm not even going to comment on US actions in foreign countries that put said countries on the list above.

 

HISTORYBUFF

7:46 PM ET

July 16, 2010

Youngsters or clueless, which

I read with much dismay the posts regarding this thread. I don't know of any country that
has immigration waiting lists like America. There are people all over the world that are pouring into the U.S.
No we are not perfect, the rule of law still exists our judicial system is not perfect but suggest to me a better system in the world. I for one am tired of liberals (or anyone else)espousing their first amendment rights to freedom of speech to trash America. In several of these countries that are mentioned you would put to a horrible death for expressing your opinion against the government. You stand on the shoulders of many a real American Heroes to spew your rhetoric.
Step up and make your community better. You criticize but don't offer any suggestions to make life here better. America is still the best country in the world. I speak from experience. I have been to Spain,Italy, France, Egypt, Turkey, Israel, Africa and on and on. None compare to the good ole U.S. of A.
I would just guess that most of these posts came from people whom have never left these United States and are basing there viewpoints based on the liberal agenda that continues to trash America. Get up, get involved and do something about what you don't like about this country. If you don't or haven't voted in my opinion you have no right to complain. One person can make a difference. Rosa Parks, MLK, and many others.
We as a nation need to get back to what made us great. Family values are at the top of my list. Drugs are destroying our nation and if you use them you are part of the problem.
Get up and do something or sit around and complain your choice

 

SEMPRINI

11:38 AM ET

June 21, 2010

Why Bhutan on this list?

Really surprised to see Bhutan on this list. It is probably the farthest you could go from hell in South Asia. They are usually pin drop quiet. Many Indians go there to celebrate a quiet holiday or honeymoon.

 

BHARAT JAIN

2:33 AM ET

June 22, 2010

Bhutan, pray, how?

FP should explain how Bhutan fits the bill of a failed state. In fact, this is a country where the King voluntarily gave up his throne to bring in democracy - can you imagine that? To club it with political black holes like North Korea & Burma and impoverished nations like Haiti defies reason. In fact, Bhutan was named the "happiest country in Asia" by BusinessWeek.

Also, if law & order is one criterion, then the gun-culture ridden, violent U.S. should make it to this list. If economic stability is another, then Greece, bankrupt but for external aid, should be there in this list.

I think FP believes that the "rest of the world" (read outside the U.S., Canada, and Western Europe) has failed (how about the title of a mega failed state for this club of countries?) on various counts - like a political black hole, or is impoverished or is a place where people lack access to "McBurgers" & Coca-Cola.

I am a big fan of FP; however FP's lop-sided list does not make sense.

 

RAGHAV

8:58 PM ET

June 22, 2010

I agree

Bhutan is one most peaceful beautiful places I have seen.

 

ABRAHAMTHOMAS

1:07 AM ET

July 18, 2010

Bhutan or did FP mean Blues in Afg'ntan

I should say that FP really needs to make up its mind on should be the scale on which they have listed the countries mentioned. When 300 million Americans eat up what the entire world can eat and drink in a day, i am sure the problems seem to be elsewhere and not in one own tummy!

I think the entire destabilization of the world is part of an ongoing economic war on every country possible, and please spare Bhutan from your list. Its the last place you want to screw up!

I think the list can be titled " List of countries screwed up by "God Bless America - Policy"

 

JAY20

5:45 PM ET

June 21, 2010

how is "Israel/West Bank" a "failed state?"

because Israel in its internationally recognized sovereign territory is considered to be "first world" and nothing close to a failed state. The West Bank is not a state. If they wanted to somehow include the Palestinian Territories, they should have used that name, or even have used "Palestine," but to put Israel even in the company of Uganda, Zimbabwe, Bhutan, etc. is just hatred.

 

DINOBUDDY

7:13 PM ET

June 21, 2010

North Korea picture incorrectly labeled.

The North Korea pictures does not show a building in Pyongyang; the building is clearly labeled "???" or Namyang Station. Namyang is in the very northern tip of North Korea, on the border with China.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Namyang-rodongjagu

 

JFONSECA

2:49 AM ET

June 22, 2010

Timor-Leste, did you call it a hell?

I believe that people in the FP has done a hell of a work to put this together. It just was not clear to me as to their objectives. People in some of these countries are trying very hard to get their country a better live, by their own modest standard. The history of colonization, European exploitation and all have done no justice to them. They need all the support they can get to attain what they judge to be a better live for themselves and their countries. I do not know if this work of the FP is to encourage people these striving people to brand them worthless.
As for Timor-Leste, you can call it whatever you want. We were enslaved by the Portuguese, so then we were called slaves, we resisted against Indonesia for our dignity, so we were treated like dogs, you name it! But we did what we could to achieve what we wanted: freedom! Our morale is unshakable! Yes, we have problems, some which are due to what we were subjected to during the centuries of colonization, others are resulted from our own inabilities. But we learn to do better. Since the last blast in 2006, we have not had any major incident for four years.
You call this collection "postcards from hell". I have never been to hell, so have no idea what it is like, but having been in some major cities of the so-called peaceful and developed world, with the rate of criminality that came with it, I feel like I am in heaven whenever I am back in Dili.
Viva Timor-Leste!
JF

 

BRUCE DUNBAR

3:34 AM ET

June 22, 2010

That's just down right

That's just down right sensationalist, you know that right? Just making sure that we are clear here.

 

SUERTES

4:28 AM ET

June 22, 2010

Way too long a list

This list is, as pointed out by many, way too long, just as it was last year. A generation ago, many of the countries listed would have been 'underdeveloped', not failed. Failure means a country that has ceased to operate like a normal country would. A country like, say Bangladesh, is well and about. Its institutions are generally functioning and it is making significant progress economically. The same could be said for the Philippines, Cambodia and numerous others. People in these places live freely and can seek work whether at home or abroad. True, they may not be politically 'stable' but that does not mean that they are 'very unstable' either. And including a country like Colombia is a bit rich, given that in some respects such as the Bogota Transmilenio transit system they are technologically ahead of America.

 

FSILBER

6:40 AM ET

June 22, 2010

fsilber

I wonder whether living in these regions was really all that much worse in the days before European colonialist imperialism.

 

HISTORYUNROOTED

12:04 PM ET

June 23, 2010

Modern time is worst off

What European colonialist did was unrooted history, and destroyed a whole society knowledge. Most of these country in Africa is worst off now than they ever were before colonialism. People's history of the land, knowledge in how to cultivated it, and a sense of self-reliances have been destroyed. Now they speak, French and English (instead of the traditional language) learned the colonial history instead of their own ancestrial history, wear second hand clothes and waiting on hand outs from their form colonial countries. You can see the amount of waste that has been dumped into these country.

Just imagine if all the agricultural history destroyed, how would the people live? Former colonial power have an moral obligation to help these country - not with bags of rice second hand clothes - but they need to help these country obtain KNOWLEDGE.

Shame - how western imperialist destroyed the whole continent and now lament the fact that its has many failed state.

 

HISTORYBUFF

8:09 PM ET

July 16, 2010

African Continent

I believe the facts have been skewed a bit in the post about colonialism. East Africa the tourist areas the Africans speak English as well as their native language. Once you get into the bush it is very difficult to find an English speaking community. Few speak English and all are very self sufficient. Holding on to their ancestral rituals and way of life.
I have made many visits to the bush and finding English speaking guides come at a premium. The country is beautiful the people are graceful and I will be back as soon as I can.

 

NAIJACHICK

1:41 PM ET

June 22, 2010

Postcards from Hell

Come on! Who died and made FP God? This is ridiculous and nonsensical.

 

MYDAS

10:27 PM ET

June 22, 2010

humanizm

Human community of all individuals with the institutions of this Declaration always keeping in mind through education and training these rights and freedoms, respect for developing a growing national and international measures require member states' peoples, and both these states under the management of the country between the peoples of these rights worldwide effective recognition and implementation of effort to provide all peoples and nations in order to determine the extent of the common ideals of the Universal Declaration of Human rights declares. müzik dinle

 

BOREDWELL

3:11 AM ET

June 23, 2010

FP states it has drawn up

FP states it has drawn up this list based on 90,000 publicly available sources to analyze 177 countries and rate them on 12 metrics of state decay -- from refugee flows to economic implosion, human rights violations to security threats. Bhutan is poor but happy. And Moldavians will decide on whether the president will be elected by popular vote or appointed by parliament. According to your "metrics of state decay" how do these countries qualify as "failed? According to your "battery of indicators" notably missing from this list are Jamaica, Greece and Thailand .

 

NKOYO

10:30 AM ET

June 30, 2010

Hell?!!

Bordewell you are so right, Greece most certainly needs to be on this list, because it can no longer sustain itself financially. I live in one of the so-called failed states; Nigeria. Yes we are struggling to buil a nation were there is justice, equity and prosperity, and in some ways we succeed in other ways we fail. The point is we keep trying. Our late presidents abscence was a real problem, but we have been able to move past that. All the talk of rotational presidency being in our countries constitution is false, it is a convention of the ruling party (PDP) which they even consider dumping. We have very good opposition and yes corruption is rampant but, boy are we fighting it. I don't feel like I live and work in a failed state, just one that needs a lot of work.

 

BMEHMUD

3:16 AM ET

June 23, 2010

Reply to Raghav

* I would advise you to not to be motivated by your internal media.
ANS: We not only see our internal media but international media as well.

* Pk is sitting on nuclear bomb almost been given to insurgents.
ANS: Not true in anyways, we have a control authority and thousand of troops to protect our assets. Further, nuclear assets are not easy to assemble by a single person or a lawless militant group. A typical warhead weighs thousands of pounds which can only be fitted on a ICBM or fighter plane.

* Dictatorship, state biases, government playing games with US and taliban,
ANS: No dictatorship now. There is an elected government in hold. US and taliban are not children which can be fooled by someone. Both have huge resources and technology.

* ISI a symbol of debauchery, home land of taliban-pakistan, lashkar-e-taiba and so on,
ANS: ISI is a government owned agency and ruled by the Army. Taliban and Lashkar are self generated group of people which are not free to do everything in country.

* citizens going to countries all over world to countres like India, US, UK to plant bombs...
ANS: Referred individual is a self motivated person which has accepted all allegations and his acts are a result of on going US drone attacks on Pakistani territory. Not a single defense person or individual is allowed to travel to foreign to do terrorist acts.

India is not the most successful country in the world but stop being paranoid about it and stop comparing to India.
ANS: In my opinion both Pakistan and India place close to each other in ranking due to the fact both have democratic elected governments and ongoing insurgencies in their territories, keeping in view economic conditions and poverty issues.

 

LOVEPEACE

4:40 AM ET

June 25, 2010

Reply to BMEHMUD

Dear BMEHMUD,

Let us assume this list to be of most prospering nations in the world and you find Pakistan at number 10, would you still go down to look for the rank of India. And if you find India so deep down would you really shout in favor of India. If yes, then you deserve to be a good friend of mine.
If not, then stop comparing Pakistan with India and being hypocrite. You seem to be a true Pakistani and you have all very rights to raise your voice in favor of your nation. REMEMBER – A true Pakistani should not always mean to be a true enemy of India.

 

VK48

4:22 AM ET

July 2, 2010

You siad "In my opinion both

You siad "In my opinion both Pakistan and India place close to each other in ranking due to the fact both have democratic elected governments and ongoing insurgencies in their territories, keeping in view economic conditions and poverty issues"

This is typical thinking and opinion, result of brainwashing done by your leadership. Would you mind comparing with other countries, for your happiness think India is 11th or 9th (around Pak) in the listing.

As Indians we are not happy being in in 87th position, be positive see countries ahead of you, we are not happy Pak is way behind us either.

Hope you got the point

 

GRANT

3:44 AM ET

June 23, 2010

I have to seriously question

I have to seriously question whoever made this list. Who in their right mind would put Iraq as more of a failed state than Haiti? Why should Guinea even be on this list, in my opinion it hasn't displayed the generally agreed upon marks of a failed state. Burma, for all its faults, certainly isn't a failed state except in the sense that the Burmese government has ceded authority to local warlords in exchange for not fighting the military while it focuses on other groups. Too often the writer manages to confuse a lack of democracy for a failure of the state. This list is not one of failed states, it is one of struggling states which is a completely different matter.

 

LANGER2040

4:45 AM ET

June 23, 2010

Why Colombia?

I disagree with this list, too. It is true that Colombia has some problems, but how can you compare it with countries like DRC and Rwanda? Why don't Venezuela and Cuba appear in this list? And why did FP publish the worst photo they could ever pick? Please don't think all Colombia is like that.

By the way: there is a country with a recent financial crisis that left thousand of people in the streets; a country unable to counter the effects of hurricanes, floodings and oil spills; a country that has thousands of homeless people and refugees; a country where power is shared by only two political parties, and the media has been held hostage to people with money. Yes: it's the UNITED STATES. Enjoy.

 

STOPTHEDEMAGOGUE

7:07 AM ET

June 23, 2010

please show me exactly how

please show me exactly how many us refugees are seeking asylum in any of the previos countries, including colombia and how many asylum seekers are trying desperately to find a better life in the us?
i haven't been to the majority of these countries but yes, i do believe that despite not being american, greek or even thai i would chose living in those three countries anytime before chosing a country from this list.

and btw, blaming the european colonisation for africa's and the third world's current problems is just rubbish. these countries have had 50 years to catch up and the majority hasn't been able to produce anything else but warlords, civil war, failed health and educational systems and so on. do your own homework and don't expect anybody else to resolve them.

 

GRANT

11:32 AM ET

June 23, 2010

In re. to LANGER2040: The

In re. to LANGER2040: The United States has well established rule of law. Despite what conspiracy theorists and fringe politically minded have claimed, neither party has resorted to the use of force or corruption to remain in power. Compared to many nations throughout Africa, South America and Asia our homeless are not that bad*. The United States is not even remotely close to being a failed state.

In re. to STOPTHEDEMAGOGUE: Please note that the U.S and the U.S.S.R did make things worse than they should have been, but I will agree that there is a good deal of blame being placed on the U.S for things that were the fault of their own leaders.

*I expect to be demonized for this, however compared to the condition of the homeless in many nations here they can expect somewhat better standards. The U.S still has a great deal to do to get anywhere near the standards of some European states, but it could be worse.

 

BILLG

12:19 PM ET

June 23, 2010

US?

The US obviously has its issues and is by no means a model democracy or welfare state, but its not in the same league as a "failed state". Don't kid yourself there.

 

STOPTHEDEMAGOGUE

4:25 AM ET

June 24, 2010

re GRANT: there is a saying

re GRANT: there is a saying "each country has a leader it truly deserves". i am personnaly fed up with the third world's constant whinging.
singapore, malaysia, japan, china, etc. all great examples to follow how to build a prosperous country out of nothing. and yes, it sounds cruel but failed states and poor people always existed. droping the debt, the continous financial aid and the other bullshit does nothing just kills the natural surviving instinct of these countries and feeds their corrupt elite.

 

BILLG

11:21 AM ET

June 23, 2010

Makeshift straw?

I definitely don't dispute Haiti's inclusion on a failed state list, but it looks to me like that guy is drinking water which is freely flowing through that pipe. The pipe looks to be about an inch in diameter so he can't be using it as a straw (who has that much lung capacity?). Its probably not the cleanest water in the world, but you write as if he's sucking it out of the gutter.

 

THELIGHT

12:39 PM ET

June 23, 2010

Wake up

Instead of arguing what country is where in 'line" try to take a look at your own life for once and start to make a difference for others. Help and support those who are less fortunate. There are endless ways to do so.

 

TEVINCAMBELL

7:42 PM ET

June 23, 2010

completely agree

effects of hurricanes, floodings and oil spills; a country that has thousands of homeless people and refugees; a country where power is shared by only two political parties, and the media has been held hostage to people with money. Yes: it's the UNITED STATES. By the way: there exhaust systems is a country with a recent financial crisis that left thousand of people in the streets; a country unable to counter the effects of hurricanes, floodings and oil spills; a country that has thousands of homeless people and refugees; a country where power is shared by only two political parties,

 

HISTORYBUFF

9:24 PM ET

July 16, 2010

Jealousy

SOOOOOOOOOOOOOO an oil spill caused by a foreign oil company, Several natural disasters, Two political parties, and then you repeat yourself.

What is your point?
I missed the people left in the streets. Where do you get your information from MSNBC?

There are thousands of people who are homeless compared to millions in some of the mentioned countries.

Again you repeat yourself,as long as we are ramblingI like to go fishing.

Got a real post lets see it

God Bless The U.S.A

 

AJAX3715

5:31 PM ET

June 25, 2010

Philippines, Colombia: Failed States?

This is the problem with subjective analysis-making. Anybody could provide his own "analysis" even without having firsthand knowledge of the facts on the ground.

P.S. FP magazine: having problems in a certain parts of a country (e.g. Sulu or Basilan in Mindanao, Philippines or FARC-controlled country in Colombia) does not mean that the whole country is falling apart.

By ranking them higher than say, Bosnia, West Bank or PNG, are you in fact claiming that there is a higher possibility of implosion in the Philippines and Colombia than in the aforementioned states/regions?

Be fair and balanced, it's the least you can do as journalists.

 

INTERIORLIFE

1:00 PM ET

June 27, 2010

Too long and Innacurate

This list becomes meaningless after 10. There are also some inaccuracies which means that this was not researched. For example, for Cameroon, it states President has been in power 18 years. This is incorrect. He has been in power for 28 years. Could be typo but just one example of many many errors and lack of seriousness.

 

BANDUNGBABY

8:07 PM ET

June 27, 2010

Refugees

Zambia has a lot of refugees who are counted on this list: none of them are ours, they're all in our country from the Congo, Zimbabwe or Angola. Wonder if that was factored into the 'study'.

 

CURTD59

2:51 AM ET

June 28, 2010

A third, a third, a third

The first twenty are arguably failed states.

The next twenty are subjective.

The last twenty I don't think fit the bill unless you're holding them to irrational standards.

Pakistan and North Korea are not failed states. They are states we disagree with. Pakistan is an identity-state with massive ignorance problems but tepidly making progress. North Korea is a racist state. So is Israel. But those states fulfill their objectives. Zimbabwe and a host of others mentioned are simply in early stages of consolidation. It takes decades if not centuries to create the habitual institutions that make a polity possible.

But the real problem in the list is post-colonialism, and the harsh reality of tribalism combined with over population and under education.

(Personally, I'd love to teach something valuable over there, if only I could feel relatively safe while doing so.)

 

JTJT

6:25 PM ET

June 28, 2010

Dear Just About Everyone Who's Commented

Good news! Congratulations! Since you are adament about these countries not being hellish or failed I would like to be the first to suggest that NO FOREIGN AID ever be sent to your countries again...since you are all doing so fine and dandy on your own.

Now, back to reality... Despite your foolishness, I do care about these people in the photos and will continue sending what aid I can to impoverished and corrupt countries like the ones listed.

 

BIDHAAN

4:42 AM ET

June 29, 2010

Somaliland election: Peaceful expression of popular will, say ob

Progressio, the Development Planning Unit of University College London (UCL) and Somaliland Focus (UK) congratulate the people of Somaliland and the National Electoral Commission on a peaceful expression of the popular will at the conclusion of their mission to observe Somaliland’s presidential election on 26 June 2010.

The three organisations were invited in January 2009 by Somaliland’s National Electoral Commission (NEC) to act as coordinators of the international observation mission for the election in the internationally-unrecognised republic. In the event, 59 international observers visited polling stations in all six Somaliland regions, working alongside a group of 19 observers from the US-based International Republican Institute.

The mission is pleased to note many positives around the conduct of the poll, an especially noteworthy achievement given significant past difficulties. Polling day saw massive enthusiasm from the great majority of Somaliland’s electorate, particularly from female voters. There was a high turnout in many areas despite threats from Islamist militant groups to disrupt the process, which thankfully came to nothing. Overall, the election seems to have met conditions for a free and fair expression of the popular will of the people of Somaliland.

Particular congratulations are due to the National Electoral Commission. The general competence of its staff, especially those at the polling station frontlines, was impressive, especially given its short time in office and the huge challenges it faced.

There are indeed many positives. However, the mission has some concerns, which we suggest require the NEC’s attention. These include reported misuse of public resources, including vehicles, and active campaigning by civil servants and national public media by the incumbent party during the campaign. There were also reported instances of bias in the private media, although it should be stressed that reporting by most media remained balanced.

Of particular concern are issues alleged to have taken place in Sool and eastern Sanaag. In those areas, some portions of the electorate were unwilling to participate in the poll. Turnouts were low, instances of ballot box confiscation were reported and, tragically, violence in Sool resulted in the death of an NEC official. Nevertheless, Commission staff seemed to do a good job where voting did take place in these and other regions.

Other areas of concern requiring the NEC’s attention centre on the Borama district. There, observers witnessed underage voting and open distribution of voter ID cards by unauthorised agents. International observers also noted that NEC officials in certain polling stations did take effective action against these irregularities, suggesting that they may not have influenced the result of the poll. Nonetheless, these are concerns that require attention.

The mission now looks forward to a speedy and clear result in the election that is accepted by all parties. Notwithstanding the concerns outlined above, we express our confidence that the election process to date is likely to result in a free and fair expression of the popular will.

 

DAVE123

5:01 PM ET

June 29, 2010

This has to be made up.

This has to be made up. Everyone knows that there are no worse conditions anywhere in the world than in the Palestinian territories. Why else would the world focus so much on them and almost nothing on these other areas?

 

DAVE123

5:14 PM ET

June 29, 2010

Look at thse "postcards" from

Look at thse "postcards" from Gaza and tell me that isn't hell compared to 1-54.

Gaza
http://nyc.indymedia.org/images/2009/12/108755.jpg
http://rochester.indymedia.org/usermedia/image/8/large/3_gaza_market.jpg
http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_uPzsiWdvLoQ/TB40JUgkRGI/AAAAAAAACtA/ErJbiA_g0Uc/s1600/beach2.jpg
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_uPzsiWdvLoQ/TB4ycjmWr8I/AAAAAAAACso/8flImr1zFuA/s1600/super2.jpg

The New York times has some great coverage of the desperation in Gaza and the Westbank

West Bank
http://travel.nytimes.com/2010/06/06/travel/06next-1.html?ref=travel

Gaza
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/13/weekinreview/13bronner.html?partner=rss&emc=rss

 

THE MEDITANT

5:08 AM ET

July 1, 2010

Oh no. FP (Fine Propaganda)

Oh no. FP (Fine Propaganda) doesn't wanna go there. Because any pictures of the hell of Gaza immediately points a finger at the one in charge of that Nazified hell-on-earth ghetto.

 

AMUTHARASAN

6:10 AM ET

June 30, 2010

Sri Lanka is a shameful country

I did not expect this statement //It should have been a moment to cheer.//

Sri Lankan government and its president is responsible for the Tamil Tiger to carry their weapons. As it is mentioned it is not civil war for the last 30 years, but it is for more than the 60 years. Initially Tamilians went for Hunger strikes in most democratic manner. But the government is the one who takes arms and weapons to kill its own citizens.

As Mao said, Enemy is the one who makes you to decide on choosing your weapons.

An year ago, Sri Lankan President conveyed that he will be giving politial solutions to Tamils in next few monts. And it is yet to propose....

 

WHODRSWNS

6:30 AM ET

June 30, 2010

Where is Mexico on this list?

Where is Mexico on this list? and where is California? oh I forgot, they are one in the same. How come there are no pictures of the border towns with the U.S. and Mexico?

 

SIDDHARTHA MUKHERJI

8:40 AM ET

June 30, 2010

RELOOK AT THE THE WHOLE ISSUE

Two aspects we need to look at, I think.
1] Who decides what is good for the people of a country? For example, big daddy USA seems to feel that its brand of Democracy is good for Iraq and Afghanistan. Wrong! The middle eastern and Asian countries have historically have faith in monarchy. You serve the monarch, and the monarch takes care of you. The monarch in most cases was thought of as incarnation of God himself. It worked for thousands of years. and worked well. What is wrong with monarchy?

2] Why is USA not included in he list of failed states? Its citizens have become a fat, lazy, over-consuming lot. They remind me of the Romans before the downfall of the empire. Signs are already on the horizon of that happening to USA! Their government is afraid to force a limit to the over consumption. [And, surprisingly, the government of USA insists on interfering in the business of other countries, taking on the role of big brother, and telling these countries how to run the show!! That's hilarious]

 

HISTORYBUFF

9:52 PM ET

July 16, 2010

Not an American

This mode of communication you are using came from one of those so called fat,lazy,over consuming lot. The television you viewed this lot on came from one of the lot. The vehicle you drive came from that lot. I could go on for ever but your animosity towards the Americans is very obvious. Why are people so jealous?
Every country protects its foreign interests. Last time I check the so called lot explored and located and drilled the oil wells in these now very rich countries.
What do we get in return, the Saudis flew airplanes into our buildings and our pentagon, They would still be riding camels if not for their oil reserves.
I am not even getting started on the billions of dollars that the U.S. has doled out to other countries.
I could go on for ever but I have a pastry To get to

 

ULIS

5:13 PM ET

June 30, 2010

Failed States

The politics of this list is inescapable and where it has a modicum of accuracy in getting it right isn't it a terrible indictment on the wealthy nations.

Two of the countries in the top ten are there directly due to the interference of two tyrant states the USA and its puppet the UK who desperately want to hold on to Afghanistan to finish their beloved gas pipeline and Iraq to ensure a steady supply of oil to the West.

Iran might make the top ten next year if Israel decides its time to bomb their "Nuclear" facilities as it concludes an agreement with King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia to open their skies to Israeli war planes and everyone in the world can give testament on the savagery and paranoia of this failed state that you don't seem to consider.

It holds a nation in the biggest jail in the world and lays siege to it for untold year bring a once thriving state to its knees, it disobeys every UN resolution. It conducts acts of piracy and murder on the high seas. It batters a MK Arab Israeli for expressing her views and considers stripping her of her nationality. It is culturally racist as it steals Arab homes in East Jerusalem and gives them to Jews only. It practices ethnic cleansing proportionately on the same scale as Rwanda. What more does it need to do to be included on your list.

 

HISTORYBUFF

10:08 PM ET

July 16, 2010

Failed states

Here we go again, there are so many people who despise the U.S.
I don't really believe the U.S. would go through two very costly wars just for a pipeline. You must consider the hundreds of billions of dollars spent on these wars.
In reality the U.S. attack afghanistan because it was under the control of those who attack the U.S.
Get a grip on reality!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

THE MEDITANT

5:03 AM ET

July 1, 2010

The purpose of FP's lists

That white folks do everything right and black & brown folks do everything wrong. That is the message. Dig into anyone of these postcards, follow the blood tracks and you will either end up on at the capital buildings of the squeaky clean western hubs and/or Wall Street. Take Haiti for instance. It dares to list Haiti without any dialogue whatsoever of direct US complicity in all that poverty and misery - overthrow of a DEMOCRATICALLY-ELECTED GOVERNMENT by the USA as well as the kidnapping and exiling of its head-of-state? So take what this clownish propaganda website says with a grain of salt. FP=Foreign Propaganda

 

BIDHAAN

6:48 PM ET

July 1, 2010

Opposition wins Somaliland vote

Opposition leader Silanyo won 49.59 per cent of all votes casted in Somaliland elections

Ahmed Mohamed Silanyo, the leader of the opposition, has won presidential elections in
the breakaway region of Somaliland, northwest of Somalia, electoral officials said.

The head of the Tulmiye (Unity) party won 49.59 per cent of all votes cast, while the party of Dahir Rayale Kahin, the incumbent president, managed just 33.23 per cent, the National Election Commission (NEC) said on Thursday.

The Justice and Welfare party was third with 17.18 per cent of the vote.

"There's a lot of jubilation on the streets today as the country is also celebrating 50 years of independence from Italy," Al Jazeera's Mohamed Adow, reporting from the Somaliland capital of Hargeisa, said.

"[Silanyo] is a very well-known figure and somebody who is clearly held with high esteem since he won the majority of votes in the elections.

"He is an economist who graduated from the University of Manchester and also has a degree from the London School of Economics.

"Afterwards he joined the government of Somalia in the capital Mogadishu, but then led the Somali National Movement, a rebel group which liberated the northern territory on which Somaliland now stands."

'Step towards democratisation'

International observers said the election had been largely free and fair despite some irregularities, such as the ruling party using public funds, state media and vehicles for its campaign.

"This is an important election for the people of Somaliland. It is also one more step toward the democratisation of the country," Essa Yusuf Mohammed, the NEC chairman, said in announcing the results.

"The election was free and fair as witnessed by the international observers and this is a step that will lead to the recognition of the country."

Somaliland, colonised by Britain while the rest of Somalia was under Italian administration, declared independence in 1991 as the remainder of the country disintegrated into anarchy.

Despite its relative stability and the establishment of democratic institutions, Somaliland has yet to be recognised internationally but hopes a smooth transition of power will help its international image.

There were 1.09 million registered voters in the region of 3.5 million people, and 538,000 valid votes were cast.

The supreme court must endorse the results within 15 days and the incumbent president hand over within 30 days.

 

GREGH

3:03 PM ET

July 7, 2010

Hell with potential

It may be hell, but the African continents draws much potential. In a recent Times article, it was cited that Africa will be one of the most populous continent of grown working men. With its vast land mass exposed to the sun, it may also be an important continent where solar energy can power the continent and an important source of alternative energy. Africa also needs to learn from China to tap into its women population versus undermining them. I think it may be hell now, but it sure has a lot of potential if it can get its act together - Greg

 

SNSHAH

2:23 AM ET

July 8, 2010

Nepal

Just few years back, Nepal was peaceful country with full of natural beauties. Let us not forget that in 70s this country was among food grain exporting countries. But unfortunately, the deficit area is increasing every year. It is no more agro-major country. It is very sad to say that the present situation has been brought up by our narrow vision politicians, who only fight to hold lucrative posts for their personal benefits. The most threatening challenge is the Nepalese youths being misused by politicians, which results unsocial activities. It can be recovered if there is no developmental works for few years but it will be very hard to reform the society if social values and social structures are disturbed. Let us prey to god that our leaders are blessed with vision, honesty, and determination to save Nepal from turning into Failed State.

 

SNSHAH

2:48 AM ET

July 8, 2010

nepal

Just few years back, Nepal was peaceful country with full of natural beauties. Let us not forget that in 70s this country was among food grain exporting countries. But unfortunately, the deficit area is increasing every year. It is no more agro-major country. It is very sad to say that the present situation has been brought up by our narrow vision politicians, who only fight to hold lucrative posts for their personal benefits. The most threatening challenge is the Nepalese youths being misused by politicians, which results unsocial activities. It can be recovered if there is no developmental works for few years but it will be very hard to reform the society if social values and social structures are disturbed. Let us prey to god that our leaders are blessed with vision, honesty, and determination to save Nepal from turning into Failed State.

 

JMALAPITAN

7:37 AM ET

July 8, 2010

a truly sad reality

Yes, I agree. These states have failed and I don't mean the readers of foreign policy.com but their own people. This feature piece is to inform us of how badly these countries have failed their own people and why their leaders should be ashamed. The worst part of it is being reminded of how bad life is for over two thirds of the world and how bleak the prospects are for change.

 

UHA1

4:22 AM ET

July 10, 2010

prosper

isn't that clear yet? the only way you help poverty on the word is through -sincerely- feeling their helplessness and suffer to help them. that is how 'helping people' becomes the main point of your actions. And I believe, although West has all the material or economic power to be the cheer leader of less privileged countries of our world, there is no real help at all. Because there is always a catch on whatever western organization are behind at. I am saying this as a non-wester student who studied in the most prestigious western universities and volunteered for some hundred of hour volunteer work.

 

NSANYI23

8:51 AM ET

July 14, 2010

incredibile

Great collection... If we see the situation objective we can found more than 60 countries...

 

WEBDESIGN-WEBTON

2:48 PM ET

July 14, 2010

reaction

Even it looks very bright and colorful I believe New York is a real hell. Just try to live without money for a week.

 

WAQAHI

7:48 PM ET

July 16, 2010

What a sad list and what a cynical criteria.

You can be an absolute monarch sharing the wealth of your people with the powers of arrogance and their global companies and your country will be spared this ominous list. You can be a dictator heading a military family in charge of one of the wealthiest nations but if you say to London and Washington DC; uncle!, your country will spared this ominous list. You can be a nation of thieves displacing five million people from their towns, villages, and farms into scattered refugee camps, then follow these refugees into their shanty homes; call them terrorists, murder them, and worry not about getting into this ominous list. So Iran is more of a failed state than either Malawi, or Cambodia? One of the articles in this website is titled: "Why Do So Many Defectors Get Homesick?"; I swear by the All Mighty, God, that Shahram Amiri was KIDNAPPED in an immoral operation conducted by the CIA and the Saudi authorities while in Madinah, Saudi Arabia while performing pilgrimage. Allah is my witness and I understand that I will be held accountable to this oath in the hereafter.

If we use the principles of justice and put the treatment of the arrogant powers of the poor inhabitants of this planet the USA and the UK will be the number one and two most failed nations in human history.

 

NARINDERATFP

9:08 PM ET

July 16, 2010

I checked all 61 and didn't

I checked all 61 and didn't find India. Strange and funny at same time.

I am from India and I know what its like.

State sponsored pogroms carried out on people of minority religion make it THE most failed state because it was STATE that had the hand behind it.

Kashmir is boiling, Maoists are toiling hard, ULFA is there and what not....

And then there come people bragging on some IT sector sales, which is nothing but MNC's grace that are using Indian labor and market.

I am disappointed with the compiler of this, needs more insight.

 

JIMONTHEBEACH

10:56 PM ET

July 16, 2010

Failed states

I was appalled by the number of failed states especially in light of the billions of dollars the USA has poured down these rat holes to prop up incompetent, rapacious dictators.

I was also surprised to see that Mexico is not on the list. Mexico is a narco-state now governed by violent and ruthless drug cartels. It is a country with many of it's citizens living in conditions of grinding poverty, ignorance, and disease so bad that tens of thousands flee to the USA every year. The government is corrupt as are most of the state institutions. Surely, Mexico qualifies as a failed state.

 

ARBYUU

11:34 AM ET

July 17, 2010

failed states?

how about, Arizona and Michigan? our own American missery.

 

FLORIA1234

2:43 AM ET

July 22, 2010

great post

I guess we should throw in quite a few America cities on the list of "hell on earths" due to their high crime rates, poverty and ineffective governments.

 

FASHIONLOVE

3:08 AM ET

July 23, 2010

The list of failed states

We should re-consider the said list in the near future because each of them always try to improve and change day by day. We hope that every countries will be better.

ban sim

kinh mat thoi trang

kiem viec

 

MINDALAY

11:27 AM ET

July 23, 2010

A majority of these countries

A majority of these countries are NOT failed states, however for FP having the audacity to call over 60 countries "Hell"... versus what, the heaven that is US? I can't take such a sensationalistic list seriously. To me it seems to be meant to pander to the US audience (akina Joe the plumber and middle America) by reinforcing the all time propaganda the US is it, the rest of the world stinks.