The War Over Germany's Imams

Sent by Turkey as a check on Western influence as well as Islamist radicalism, Germany's holy men are at the heart of the battle over the future of Islam in Europe.

BY PAUL HOCKENOS | JULY 2, 2010

For decades, no one in Germany took much notice of the imported Islamic holy men in their midst. Turkey's Presidency of Religious Affairs sent imams inconspicuously, on four-year postings, to minister to the spiritual needs of West Germany's Turkish migrant workers and their families -- while keeping them in line with Turkish cultural norms.

But today, Germany's Turkish imams find themselves square in the public spotlight. Berlin and Ankara are wrapped up in a fierce battle -- and it's not just about religion. Both countries are vying for the allegiance of the 3-million-strong Turkish diaspora in Germany, a population that represents two-thirds of the country's Muslims. And both sides see the imams as the lynchpin to Germany's Turkish community. The imams are uniquely trusted authority figures among the Deutschtürken (German Turks) who first came to Germany as Gastarbeiter -- cheap, imported labor -- in the 1960s.


There are three directions the imams could take with Germany's diaspora Turks, each with huge consequences for the future of Islam in Germany and Europe: Do the preachers encourage diaspora Turks to integrate into secular Germany, do they push them in a radical extremist direction, or do they keep the majority of Germany's large Muslim population an essentially foreign community for as long as they can?

In a book recently published in Germany, religious scholar Rauf Ceylan, himself the son of Kurdish labor migrants from Anatolia, offers the most explicit, penetrating examination to date of Germany's foreign-born imams, showing exactly how crucial they are to Europe's fate. "Ultimately," he writes, "they determine whether young Muslims will endorse a liberal, conservative, or extremist Islam." His book, however, Die Prediger des Islam: Imame -- Wer Sie Sind und Was Sie Wirklich Wollen (The Preachers of Islam: Imams -- Who They Are and What They Really Want) is not optimistic.

It's not that the imams are breeding potential terrorists -- in fact, quite the opposite. When it comes to fundamentalism, German and Turkish interests overlap. The last thing Ankara wants is the German Turks reimporting radical strains of Islam back into the Ataturk republic. Of Germany's Islamic holy men generally, fewer than 1 percent are extremists, according to Ceylan, and those young, media-savvy leaders operate outside the purview of established mosques and often beyond the reach of both German and Turkish authorities. Germany has only narrowly escaped terrorist attacks like those in Madrid and London, and Ceylan warns that this "new quality" of fundamentalism has powerful, destructive potential.

But most of Germany's imams are "traditional-conservative," or, as Ceylan labels them, "the Prussians among imams." These preachers are overwhelmingly Turkish civil servants -- employees of the Turkish state -- on postings, most placed in parishes through Germany's largest Islamic organization, the Turkish-Islamic Union for Religious Affairs (DITIB), known in Germany as "Ankara's long arm."

Sean Gallup/Getty Images

 

COMRADE RED

8:17 PM ET

July 2, 2010

Hah

Turkey sure is 'secular' all right.

This sort of behavior should prove that Turkey is far too dangerous for EU membership, and that it handled in the same way the west handles other problematic Muslim countries such as Pakistan and Saudi Arabia.

 

COUNTCHOCULA1011

12:10 AM ET

July 3, 2010

No Liberal, Moderate, or Conservative Islam

This entire mentality that there is such a thing as liberal, moderate, or conservative/radical Islam is ridiculous. Either something is Islam or a deviation from Islam. Killing non-combatants=deviation. Endorsing homosexuality=deviation. Muslims need to stop allowing Western governments to determine what it means to be a Muslim. According to the West, the only "moderate" Muslim is a Muslim who doesn't believe in the right to defend oneself, doesn't support the shariah, and who doesn't believe in the ummah and all that it entails (which includes political unity--it is haram for Muslims to have two leaders)

 

MARS

5:15 AM ET

July 7, 2010

UHM

Islam is not monolific. There is the difference between Shi'a and Sunni Islam. There are several different schools of interpretation within Sunnism which are more or less conservative or liberal, for example the Hanbali or Hanafi schools. Further, Islam has no overarching leader to tell everyone how to think (like the Catholic Pope). Due to all these differences and how one interprets these differences, it is quite possible to get different types of Islam.

 

TURAN K.

7:44 PM ET

July 3, 2010

I would want to learn more if

I would want to learn more if Mr. Ceylan's concern for Turkey's involvement is the nature and future of Islam in Europe (conservative versus liberal) or these imams' acting within Turkey's interest on some political issues. These two are different questions, and he seem to conflate them.

Also, Caylan's account seem to put the blame of the lack of integration on Turkey and Turkish minority rather than on German institutions' inability to accommodate. Why did Germany wait this late to train imams? Why did they wait so long to allow second and third generations to acquire Germany nationality? I would not trust Turkey's dealing with the situation, but I will be equally skeptical about Germany's handling the situation.

 

RSAFSOZ

11:54 AM ET

July 5, 2010

yes

i know what feeling thats man.
porno
sex videolari
porno film

 

MUSTNOTSLEEP14

9:02 AM ET

July 6, 2010

Religion = the absence of

Religion = the absence of free thought. It is just a tool to control populations and nowhere is that more apparent than in Islam, the primary religion of submission.

 

JKOLAK

11:53 PM ET

July 6, 2010

Progress

"Study after study shows the Turkish community poorly integrated, failing in German schools, and unable...to advance past the lowest rungs of the social ladder."

They will continue to be unable to advance as long as they keep themselves immersed in Turkish and Islamic culture. Integration is the key to their future success.

Islamic studies in German universities may help German Islam to shop a free market of ideas, but Islam will continue to have internal problems as the religion was conceived and propogated in violence. While only minorities of Islamic communities support Islamic extremism, the seeds of future terrorists and jihadis are contained within the religion. The Ummah needs to sort out these problems in order for Islam to survive as a modern religion.

 

CADILLACTIGHT

1:38 PM ET

July 7, 2010

 

SIDROCK23

6:31 PM ET

July 8, 2010

who cares about europe

with the current economic condition of europe, its weakend and ineffective military capabilities, Turkey does not need to worry about EU membership anymore. europe preferes the likes of greece,spain, and italy, well hope u r enjoying them. Europe is a has been and never was. good bye europe. have fun amongst yourselves.

 

JAMESGH

4:40 AM ET

July 13, 2010

"Study after study shows the

"Study after study shows the Turkish community poorly integrated, failing in German schools guy cams , and unable...to advance past the lowest rungs of the social ladder."

They will continue to be unable to advance as long as they keep themselves immersed in Turkish and Islamic culture. Integration is the key to their future success.

Islamic studies in German universities may help German Islam to shop a free market of ideas, but Islam will continue to have internal problems as the religion was conceived and propogated in violence.