Can Anyone Govern Japan?

Prime Minister Naoto Kan is shaping up to be another miserable failure. What's going wrong?

BY JEFF KINGSTON | JULY 9, 2010

In office just one month so far, Japanese Prime Minister Naoto Kan has already messed up badly. The country is holding upper-house parliamentary elections on July 11, and Kan -- who began his tenure with a relatively buoyant 60 percent approval rating -- has managed to convince voters that his policies are as hapless and ad hoc as those of his predecessor, Yukio Hatoyama.

What's happening to Japan is bigger than Kan the man. After a series of short-lived, ineffectual leaders, many are wondering if the country itself has become, in essence, ungovernable. Kan is an astute politician with considerable skills, and voters seem to like his tough-love message for kick-starting the economy. Many agree with him that the old policies of vast public-works spending and deregulation have not worked and have instead left the country saddled with debt amounting to a whopping 200 percent of the country's annual GDP. But voters are still skeptical that Kan can make real change. And what it boils down to is a loss of faith in political leaders after two decades of recession and growing social malaise. In an atmosphere where leaders are expected to fail, can anyone run Japan?

Kan got off to a bad start with the electorate when he proposed raising comsumption taxes -- rarely a smart political move. Yes, polls show that the public is ready for an increase in consumption taxes, and media editorials supported the idea. But when Kan outlined his proposal, calling for a doubling of the consumption tax from 5 to 10 percent, he got nailed. As the prime minister was dragged into a debate about the details of his plan, he backtracked and zigzagged, looking far too much like his aimless predecessor. Hatoyama met his downfall for exactly this sort of flip-flopping, over a plan to relocate the Futenma U.S. military base away from Okinawa -- and just about everything else. Japanese voters are searching for a resolute leader in the mold of Junichiro Koizumi, prime minister from 2001 to 2006. So far, Kan looks like yet another waffler.

Japan's leadership crisis couldn't come at a more inopportune time. This election is going to be about bread-and-butter issues such as unstable jobs and declining household income. The ruling Democratic Party of Japan (DPJ) has drawn attention to the swelling ranks of the precariat -- workers without secure jobs, decent wages, or benefits -- who now make up 34 percent of the workforce. Unemployment, at 5.2 percent, is quite high by Japanese standards, where 2 percent is the usual benchmark. The DPJ argues that the government can best address this issue, channeling tax revenues into expanded social programs. The next two most popular parties, the Liberal Democratic Party (LDP), which dominated Japanese politics for more than five decades, and the upstart Your Party want the government to get out of the way -- they argue that deregulation, more flexible labor laws, and lower corporate taxes will generate growth, profits, and better jobs.

Even if they are sympathetic to Kan's agenda (and many are), voters have found it hard to ignore his party's short record in power so far -- which is abysmal. Since Hatoyama swept the LDP from power in September 2009, campaign-financing scandals have dogged leading DPJ figures, the U.S. alliance has frayed, and the party has yet to show any policy successes. There was a brief window after Hatoyama resigned in June for Kan to make a fresh start. He was the new face of the party, a social activist from a middle-class family who joked to reporters that he is a good debater thanks to constant bickering with his wife. He is known as Ira Ira Kan, a reference to his fiery temper, and unlike Hatoyama, he is a leader with a record of passion and toughness. And the initial signs were promising: He extended the olive branch to Washington over Okinawa and to the business community in Japan, trying to convince both that they can rely on the DPJ despite its previous stumbles. That's where the good news ends, however. The tax gaffe sent his approval rating plummeting, deep-sixing any hopes that he would rise above the politics of the past.

Pollsters now expect the DPJ to lose seats in the Diet's upper house on Sunday, where half of the 242 seats are up for grabs. The DPJ has 54 seats going into the vote and is aiming for 60, which would give it an outright majority. But given how things have been going of late, the party will be lucky even to hold onto its current number. That won't necessarily be fatal: The party still holds a commanding majority in the more important lower house and can remain in power until 2013, but it will need to find a coalition partner to form a working majority. And that won't be easy. The DPJ would like to form an alliance with Your Party, which shares the DPJ's affinity for budget austerity, but its leader, Yoshimi Watanabe, has repeatedly rejected suggestions to that effect. So whatever coalition does result will be fraught by awkward compromises and policy paralysis. If the DPJ does badly enough, winning less than 50 seats, the scandal-tainted Ichiro Ozawa, who was forced to relinquish his previous role as DPJ secretary-general in June, might try to unseat Kan in the party leadership contest slated for September. That would unravel Japan's ongoing political realignment, and the leadership crisis will intensify.

Foreign relations are another stumbling block. After Sunday's election, the government will continue nurturing better relations with China, despite a variety of festering issues such as disputed gas fields, overlapping territorial claims, food safety, transborder pollution, and China's relentless military buildup, one conducted in the absence of reassuring transparency.

But the DPJ's biggest problems are with Washington, which held firm on a 2006 deal between the United States and Japan over Futenma. Hatoyama had pledged in his campaign to relocate the base, but backed down under intense U.S. pressure. Okinawans felt betrayed, and the reversal exposed the prime minister as feckless, precipitating his sudden downfall in June.

Kan has sought to defuse tension by saying that he will abide by the 2006 agreement. But anger over the DPJ's backtracking and ineffectual leadership has undermined the party's credibility. Barack Obama will visit Japan while Okinawa has gubernatorial elections in November, raising the risk that the U.S. president will get embroiled in Japan's increasingly lively domestic politics.

And lively they are indeed. Voters in Japan were once loyal and predictable, keeping the LDP in power for more than 50 years. But now that they have thrown the bums out of office, they are feeling more feisty and ready to do so again. In the last few elections, voters have swung dramatically to the party that convinced them it was the party of reform. And each time, their expectations have been crushed. As Japan enters its third decade of stagnation, the public is desperate for far more drastic reforms than any politician is offering them.

Will Kan at last be the man whom Japan is longing for? The prospect of a hung parliament and a fractious coalition certainly doesn't bode well. The DPJ won't have to hold Diet elections again until 2013, leaving a painfully long time for Japan's massive fiscal problems and economic stagnation to fester. Yes, the DPJ inherited this mess, but it now "owns" the economy, one that China is set to overtake sometime later this year -- a poignant reminder of how fast and far Japan is slipping. Here's hoping that Kan can be the one to pull the country back from the brink.

POOL/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: POLITICS, JAPAN, EAST ASIA
 

Jeff Kingston is director of Asian studies at Temple University, Japan, and author of Contemporary Japan: History, Politics and Social Change since the 1980s.

STORMWALKER

8:20 PM ET

July 9, 2010

interesting standing point of view, but we have no clue about

About Futenma:
It is really sad that I cannot access and browse www.usmc.mil/. So in my case, I don't have some of basic informations about US Marines. I guess there are some other Japanese who cannot watch Marines' site. I have no clue the reasons why I cannot browse, but it is really frustrating.

So what makes me worry is we cannot get some basic information about Marines, yet, our votes tomorrow will decide some of their units' situation for the next three years. I must admit I am just civilian and not US citizens, so there may be no legal basis to demand the information.

Oh by the way, I'm logging from Japan, and I'm Japanese citizen. And I can access most of other DoD sites and government organizations' site.

It is very nice of you to introduce Japan to US, as there is not so much interest among US citizens about Japan and Futenma. I really thank you, sir.

 

OOFLOOM

8:06 PM ET

July 10, 2010

No idea about the military

No idea about the military site, but thanks for making us Americans feel a little better about our own sorry government. Misery loves company! All our government is good for these days is providing jokes for comedians.

 

STORMWALKER

1:41 PM ET

July 11, 2010

to OOFLOOM

It is very nice of your country to have been good friend and ally for the past several decades.

And most of the time, US shows decent interests toward Japan. Although I have different opinion with author, but it also tells our political situation to some extent.

But this perhaps strategic communication stratagems won't make things easy. Actually it could backfire.

I must admit there is quite a good chance of me misunderstanding about Marines if I could have browsed their sites. But in most cases, I could find my faults by myself and I will rectify my faults.

The more I will learn about Marines, the more I will wonder what their intentions in western rim of Pacific. And all those talks about defense cuts makes me wonder, how long they would support Okinawa Marines.

I must also admit some of Marines predicament is due to Japan's abysmal economies. It is sad fact but the more Japan lose confidence, the more China gain it. Although Japan has no intention to compete with them, they will flex muscles.

 

JOSHSTU101

4:32 PM ET

July 12, 2010

@OOFLOOM You're right. Most

@OOFLOOM

You're right. Most of their talks give doubt to everybody that's why actors/actresses make funny lines out their statements. They need to be serious on acting improvement in the government to be true to the public.Josh Stu

 

LUCKZE

6:50 AM ET

July 10, 2010

Louis Vuitton Outlet

Louis Vuitton has affirmed itself over the past decades as a world leading brand name in the fashion industry. If a Louis Vuitton handbag is a sign of fashion trends, it is also a symbol of social status and recognition. At http://www.louisvuitton4love.com/ You can find full product details of the newest
Louis Vuitton release, the latest price information and Louis Vuitton sale events, the most helpful shopping guild and buying tips. You may also share your experience and post your opinions by reviewing the items or joining the discussion with other LV fans, we surely hope you will enjoy your stay. Everyone loves Louis Vuitton Outlet. On our Discount Louis Vuittonstore, you can definitely buy anyCheap Louis Vuitton Handbags, wallets at incredible low prices. So why don't you let your Louis Vuitton handbags dream come true today?

 
 

RAMIS

8:47 AM ET

July 10, 2010

me

i can govern. :)

porno sex video porno film

 

NICHOLAS WIBBERLEY

8:05 PM ET

July 10, 2010

DEbt and GDP

A country with debt at 200% of GDP is effectively insolvent. An insolvent democracy is almost by definition ungovernable since on the one hand its creditors pull its strings while on the other it cannot provide what the electorate wants. Taking a somewhat Swiftian view, Japan’s is not an inconvenient condition from a US perspective. After all, it secured Okinawa.

 

STORMWALKER

1:50 PM ET

July 11, 2010

what makes situation a little bit better is

Most of creditors are Japanese finance institutions. Not foreign ones. So Japan is borrowing money from its citizens.

But, yes, Japan government cannot afford much these days. In fact, it was only in early 90's that government afford to pork barrel budgets to rural communities.

This past several years, government cut almost every ministry's budgets, including defense ministry.

 

YUEXIANG

8:16 AM ET

July 11, 2010

rtt

Dear customers, thank you for your support of our company.
Here, there's good news to tell you: The company recently
launched a number of new fashion items! ! Fashionable
and welcome everyone to come buy. If necessary, please
input: http://www.onseeking.com/ We need your support and trust!!

 

MUSTNOTSLEEP14

7:30 AM ET

July 12, 2010

5% unemployment with a

5% unemployment with a massive trade surplus and they have managed to rack up 200% GDP deficit. That is not easy and shows clearly why spending to end recessions does not work. Somebody should tell this to that moron Obama.

 

FRE

8:03 AM ET

July 12, 2010

bgfbghg

Ladies and gentlemen,

http://www.jordanto.com brand shoes,handbags,clothes,watches,caps,jeans,perfume,sunglasses,jackets,t-shirt,jersey,belts,purse,wallets,shawn,scarf,bikini,and so on.
1)High quality. the tags and style code number are 100% correct.
2) Safety. If the goods seized by our customs, we will resend them to you.
3) Quick shipment. We have agreement with some International Express
Corporation, the products will be shipped within 24 hours after we received your payment. And the parcel will reach your side in 4-7working days.
4) Lowest price. We can give you the best price based on equal conditions in China.
5) We are very serious seller, assure you that we can have very perfect cooperation.

We are willing to build mutual benefits and long term business relationships with all customers
if there is any question of our products,pls don't hesitate to contact me at your free time,we will try our best to help you.

credit first,Best severce,fast delivery,high quality

http://www.jordanto.com ,”’?????.’,”’,,’,.”,,’,”,.
?????”o’,”’,,’,.”.”,,’,.
?????? ”,,’,.’,”’,,’,.”
??????????????????

 

POSSIBILUS

7:26 PM ET

July 12, 2010

Japan

First nike66 should be banned for a waste of space.

Mr. Kingston:

Regarding whether Japan is ungovernable though, my own take on it is that since WWII and even the economic acension of Japan in the 80s to 90s, that Japan as a predominately homogenous and extremely consensus drive nation and culture, has almost purposely, although not necessarily fully consciously, developed a political system that is in a cycle of short-lived prime ministers and administrations. Elections occur, new PM is sworn in, vote of no confidence ensues, resignation with "deep regret" ad inifinitum ad nausea. Why? Because this apparent instability allows Japan to continue to focus mostly on internal and economic issues and excuses this nation from its proportionate responsibilities on the world stage, except by cash contributions. It is actually a guise of political shakiness in exchange for domestic and economic self interest, and it will continue until Japan realizes that it too can offer more than cash to the international community...that is...given its unique cultural and historic lineage: invader and vanquished, poor and rich, isolationist and participatory, that perhaps it has solutions, both material and intellectual, to help create a greater security and prosperity for more nations. Essentially, like many other nations, Japan needs to grow up and assume its appropriate international responsibilities, and it will take a PM who acts based on intelligence, intuition, a worldly outlook, and willingness to follow his or her conscience rather than lead a flock of think-alikes.

 
 
 

POONBEE

9:30 PM ET

August 3, 2010

This article is very

This article is very interesting. Thank you very much for sharing . iPad Converter m2ts files converter from m2ts converter