Rise of the Hungarian Right

With Web-savvy "radical nationalism" -- and a dash of anti-Semitism and Roma-baiting -- firebrand politician Gabor Vona has touched a chord among Hungary's disaffected and disillusioned young voters.

BY MICHAEL J. JORDAN | JULY 13, 2010

Gyongyos, Hungary -- While running for a parliamentary seat in Hungary's April elections, far-right candidate Gabor Vona made one campaign promise that was controversial even by his standards: If voted into parliament, the 31-year-old extremist would report for duty wearing the insignia of his outlawed paramilitary organization, the "Hungarian Guard" -- a taboo symbol that, with its ancient, red-and-white-striped emblem, bears a striking resemblance to the flag of Hungary's Nazi-era fascist party, Arrow Cross.

The suggestion was intolerable to many Hungarians. Arrow Cross's brief period of political dominance, during which the party murdered thousands of Hungarian Jews and shipped many tens of thousands more to concentration camps outside the country, is still a painful subject. More to the point, the insignia itself is illegal. Vona's announcement directly flouted a court decision banning the Hungarian Guard, and it provoked the outgoing Hungarian prime minister into asking the Justice Ministry to investigate.

But the controversy appeared only to reinforce the popularity of Vona's far-right, Web-savvy Jobbik party, which went on to win a stunning 16.7 percent of the vote -- the best performance of any hypernationalist party in post-communist Eastern Europe. And Vona kept his word: At the May 14 inauguration, he took off his suit jacket to reveal a black vest with the Hungarian Guard's emblem.

Vona's intransigence may have been shocking, but it wasn't surprising. Central Europe may be two decades removed from communist dictatorship and ensconced in Western institutions such as the European Union and NATO -- but few people are cheering. Promises of a glorious new post-communist life have resulted only in rising prices, growing unemployment, and endemic corruption. And resentment is fueling a greater appetite for right-wing extremism across the region, according to a new survey by the Budapest-based think tank Political Capital. In Hungary alone, right-wing attitudes have leapt from 10 to 20 percent since 2003.

"It's been constant disillusionment that many people [in Hungary] are susceptible to. They're bitter about the whole system," says Alex Kuli, a Political Capital analyst. "That's what Vona is responding to and manipulating -- this deep-seated disillusionment."

Vona came of age amid the post-communist collapse of industry and agriculture, which was particularly devastating in his native northeastern Hungary. The young Vona, a good student in the small town of Gyongyos with a strong interest in politics and debate, was fascinated by Hungarian history, which was often distorted by the communists. Most obvious was the 1920 Treaty of Trianon, which punished Hungary for its role in World War I. The victors lopped off two-thirds of Hungary's territory and one-third of its people -- including five of its 10 largest cities. Desire to recover those lands would help drive Hungary into the Nazis' arms during World War II. But that national trauma, which resonates even today, was glossed over in communist-era history books.

Vona took notice. "He felt history was written by the winners," says Vona's cousin, Viktoria Laczhazi, herself a Jobbik volunteer in a city near Gyongyos. "And because we were the losers, our history wasn't being told."

At university in cosmopolitan Budapest, Vona explored history and psychology and reportedly planned to become a history professor. His strident politics, though, swept him in another direction. In 2003, dissatisfied with the political spectrum available to him, Vona and his comrades founded a new party, Jobbik, to fight for "national radicalism."

Jobbik snared just 2 percent in the 2006 elections. Later that year, however, the party caught a lucky break and exploited it fully. In September, then-Prime Minister Ferenc Gyurcsany -- a communist-turned-millionaire whose Socialist Party is heir to the old communist party -- was caught on tape admitting his Socialists won reelection by lying to voters "morning, evening, and night" about the country's economic health.

Bloody riots erupted in the streets of Budapest. Protesters, portraying themselves as patriots seeking to overturn an illegitimate government, rehabilitated the red-and-white "Arpad stripes," derived from an ancient royal coat of arms, but now associated in Hungary with the Arrow Cross flag. Suddenly, the insignia was back in fashion.

And Jobbik, whose members were the ones wearing the stripes, came into fashion too. Under Vona's leadership, Jobbik has adopted the enduring trauma of Trianon, epitomized by the 2.5 million or so ethnic Hungarians who today live across Hungary's borders -- mostly in Romania, Slovakia, and Serbia -- as a cause célèbre. Images of "Greater Hungary," which extends the borders to those of the old monarchy, were a rarity in the 1990s. Today, they're ubiquitous on bumper stickers, posters, and T-shirts. It has also stirred tensions with Hungary's northern neighbor, Slovakia, much of which was once part of the Hungarian kingdom.

ATTILA KISBENEDEK/AFP/Getty Images

 

Michael J. Jordan, a Bratislava, Slovakia-based journalist, has covered Central Europe for most of the past 17 years as a correspondent for the Christian Science Monitor and other publications. He blogs about Central Europe for The Mantle and at jordanink.wordpress.com.

Facebook|Twitter|Reddit

NICOLAS19

5:25 AM ET

July 14, 2010

Interesting article. However,

Interesting article. However, as a Hungarian I feel that you are barley scratching the surface, and turning Jobbik into something more than it really is. Deep down it is no more than a populist party, which promptly recognized the amount of support for the „radical” ideas might command. When the winds change with economic growth – already started, and I hope that the capable ruling party that has absolute majority will be able to accelerate it – Jobbik will change too. Two reasons. Firstly, there were signs for that. The stubbornly anti-EU Jobbik party (which declared in 2006 that it would never ever take an EU position) simply rushed to the Parliament. With the expansion that followed the recent elections, many civil figures appeared on the list, many of whom might’ve been unimaginable before. Jobbik is getting softer. Secondly, we’ve seen this before. It was called SzDSz, Free Democrat Alliance, a party that started the regime change in ’90 as a flaming anti-socialist, nationalist „party of new beginning”; then in '94 it quickly entered into coalition with the socialists and became an anti-nationalist, liberal party, loyal ally to the socialists ever since (well, to their disintegration, this year). Jobbik has the same path before them. Vona's parliamentary action was no more than a publicity stunt. They aren't the threat everyone like to picture them to be.

 

ZSUZSIE

11:01 AM ET

July 14, 2010

@Nicolas19

And as another Hungarian who participated at peaceful walks that were disrupted by stone throwing from Jobbik members, I do think they are indeed a threat.
They might not prove to be one in the classical sense - ie., they will never govern the country (knock-knock); but they are definitely making a huge impact on people's mind. Their popularity has sky-rocketed in a very short period of time; they have a crazy number of followers who follow and agree to whatever they say.
Also, if we suppose that our society is supposed to go in the direction of "national reconciliation, peace and agreement" as decreed by Viktor Orban (even though his act is slightly ridiculous to me), Jobbik is not helping this process AT ALL, sowing hate and discrimination among the population. I think their real danger/threat is capturing people's "minds and hearts" and thereby dividing an already dysfunctional and fragmented society.

 

ULDIN

12:27 PM ET

July 14, 2010

Rise of the Hungarian Right?

"Rise of the Hungarian Right"? It is true that they are right from the ultra left liberals, who are liberal about the freedom and the future of Hungarian People... The country has a genocide on the ethnic Hungarians and the minorities which are not favored by the Jobbik might have something to do with it... Worms are chewing out the hart of the Nation. The Nation is dying while they multiply like maggots and building wealth over the destruction of their host. A parasite system, that lasted 20 years and looks like they have 4 more years to finish the job... All the "accomplishments" like joining NATO and the EU, signing the Treaty of Lisabon happened without the participation of the Nation, it was against the law. It was done by minority governments who's tactics was based on the psychology of the ex communist system and those who executed it, came (were trained, prepared) from the communist era. The red and white striped flag resemblances, but not the same as the flag of the arrow cross. The American flag also resembles, but not the same... It is coming from the old Viking flag check it out if you do not believe... The Hungarians were in alliance with the Vikings... I am sure that the red and white colors in the US flag also has something to do with this... The banning of the Hungarian Guard was unconstitutional and also against basic human rights. The "maggots" tried to prove they are still holding the country.. Is not resembling that situation to a fascist system? Why are we always crying about the hurts of the Jews while we are denying that basic rights to other nations??? Is not that looking like a decoy, false justification?
Trianon punished the Hungarian roll in W.W.I. ??? It has little to do with the war, it was created with a Bolsheviks 2 years after the war... , after a Bolshevick blood bath in Hungary... Our sin was that a Serbian terrorist killed the Austro-Hungarian Archduke??? and we responded to it? "Victors" ??? where did we loose the battle? I do not remeber..., it was an inside job, by the "maggots" who were already around... To understand history is a right wing extreemism??? Some newswriters need adjustment of their views and understand the history more in details, to be sensitive enough to others... If the democracy is a working system, the Jobbik must win the 2014 elections and the rights of the Nation needs to be restored. What we see right now is a comedy show... (but tragic...) This is my opinion... www.magyarsag.org

 

STEVEN DEDALUS

12:32 PM ET

July 14, 2010

Arpad stripes

"red-and-white-striped emblem, bears a striking resemblance to the flag of Hungary's Nazi-era fascist party"

Someone better alert the Hungarian government! The official Hungarian coat of arms contains the same red and white "Arpad stripes" that Jordan claims are Nazi symbols! So does the official seal of the Interior Ministry! Call the UN! Call NATO!!

It's hilarious that after 20 plus years, Americans can still make a living writing about a horrible and looming right-wing threat just around the corner! But I suppose it is just this kind of salacious hysterics that sells among ill-informed American readers who always want to believe that the "others" are savages and beasts. That must be why they love bombing other countries so much. One might expect more from a publication called "Foreign Policy" but I suppose that is too much to wish for...

 

SHAUNRANDOL

1:50 PM ET

July 16, 2010

Chasing Gabor

Mr. Jordan reports on what it was like to try and land an interview with Gabor on The Mantle. Check out the article for an interesting sidebar to this essay:

The enquiry questionnaire even included a donation box...

http://www.mantlethought.org/content/chasing-gabor