The Spy Who Came in by Amtrak

Why is Russia spying on Khrushchev's great-granddaughter?

BY NINA L. KHRUSHCHEVA | JULY 14, 2010

The recent story of the Russian spies sent to infiltrate the highest reaches of American society -- starting in Montclair, New Jersey -- has once again confirmed the old maxim, "History repeats itself, first as tragedy, then as farce." The 12 Russian agents sent by the former KGB's international branch, now the SVR, seemed to have spent more time on Facebook than uncovering secrets. Like Dan Aykroyd and Chevy Chase in the old spoof Spies Like Us, these real-life Karlas are a bit goofier than their imaginary Cold War precedents.

I speak from my own experience with a spy who came in from the cold -- from the chilly streets of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, that is. For three years, Richard Murphy (a.k.a. Mikhail Kutzik, a.k.a. Vladimir Guryev), a part-time student of International Affairs at the New School, came to visit me in my offices there. We weren't exchanging state secrets or whispering in corners about "ferrets," "wheel artists," or other long-forgotten spy jargon -- instead, I was his academic advisor. We discussed his courses, his progress, and his interests. At first, I thought of him as a student like any other, but there was something odd about this man, with his strong Russian accent and his Irish-American name.

Richard Murphy was clearly a Russian. Beyond the basics, there was the fact that he complained constantly: about his grades (which were fine), his papers, everything, no matter what I tried to say to soothe him. He had the alertness to injury of a Muscovite used to getting cut in line, not like my other optimistic, eager-to-impress American grad students. Moreover, despite the fact that we were both Russians, he never tried to speak Russian with me, and he never asked me any questions about my great-grandfather, Nikita Khrushchev, though that would have been natural for someone from his part of the world.

Still, I never pried. I assumed that he had some good reason to want to keep his private life private. He graduated in 2005, and I forgot all about him.

Ironically, it's probably because I myself have become less Russian -- that is to say, less suspicious and paranoid, more respectful of privacy -- that I didn't ask the questions that might have allowed me to blow his cover five years ago. (Not that the FBI needed help with those incredibly inept spies, who were under surveillance almost from the moment they arrived in America.) Instead, I heard along with everyone else about the spy ring and slowly put the pieces together about my former advisee.

EMMANUEL DUNAND/AFP/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: RUSSIA, INTELLIGENCE
 

Nina L. Khrushcheva teaches international affairs at the New School. She is the great-granddaughter of former Soviet Premier Nikita Khrushchev.

EBEN

5:30 AM ET

July 15, 2010

Tom Clancy????? Ian Fleming??????

What is the most interesting aspect of Ms. Kruscheva's involvement is that Murphy never acted in a manner which in any way showed an interest in her from the standpoint of espionage. It therefore reasonable to conjecture that she was in no way a part of his mission; that his connection with her was either purely coincidental; or, if premeditated, personal. Perhaps Murphy was, as a Russian, interested in getting to know the great granddaughter of a man he admired; perhaps he was curious as to what she might say to him without encouragement. Perhaps when Ms. Khruscheva has taken more time to reminisce, rather than simply pushing out an article when the times indicated it would be more easily publishable, she might remember things in her conversations with him that might have been more inquisitive than she thinks at this moment. If she chooses to write more on this, I hope she'll delve more into her perception of the Russian espionage establishment, and let us know if, after further consideration, she still thinks Mr. Putin so shallow that he would consider the characters created by Fleming and Clancy as role models for his espionage establishment, former or present. My guess is that the group of sleepers had no duties at all assigned them over and above integrating themselves into the society and waiting for further instruction. If that was the case, I can think of no better way to be situated for later action than with a solid set of Facebook friends.

 

KEITH E. MCINNIS

12:05 AM ET

July 18, 2010

What did Russia really get?

Sat. July17 2010
With so much airtime and column space (print and virtual) being expended on how inconsequential the Russian spies were I am wondering at some facts and possible alternatives.

If they were so inept and unimportant why did Russia step in so quickly on their behalf to get them back to Russia? If they had been inept and had not established any contacts of value why bother with them? If they were so inept and had contributed nor established nothing in their time here why trade back to us such very high value convicted former Soviet agents? Russia gave us a great deal for having gotten what everyone is saying was nothing of value in return. That doesn't seem very Russian to me.
By getting their people back in country quickly we were deprived of any opportunity to dig deeper into their long term contacts, associations and activities. I'm reminded of stories by former Columbian drug cartel leaders about how they would intentionally turn over valuable shipments to tie up American resources so they would know where the resources were and what they were doing and use that moment to get something of real value through.
It seems too easy and comical. We got too much in return for having given apparently nothing.
All the reports from agencies and media are spending a great effort detailing how little the Russian agents accomplished while paying scant attention to the other side of the equation--the value of the convicted Soviet-Russian agents they turned over to us.

 

EATBEES

9:45 AM ET

July 15, 2010

Title Piques Interest, Article Doesn't Deliver

Ms. Krushcheva's article doesn't answer the question posed in the title: Why is Russia spying on her? Indeed, it doesn't even answer the question IF Russia is spying on her.

Maybe such a provocative title is unsuited for the article? Maybe the article itself doesn't say much worth saying? It seems to mostly be an account of some lazy hours spent chatting.

P.S. Please monitor and remove the horrible spam comments that are ruining the comment boards here.

 

JKOLAK

11:24 AM ET

July 15, 2010

Nice

Nice commentary.

Can someone do something about the spam?

 

DAVOD

12:04 PM ET

July 15, 2010

The New Cold War

Edward Lucas's The New Cold War - Putin's Russia and the Threat to the West, suggests a less rosy picture than that espoused by Professor Khrushcheova.

I would also recommend Putin's Russia by Anna Politkovskaya. Politkovskaya, a journalist and an outspoken critic of Putin's Chechnya policies, was gunned down in October 2006.

As for "Not that the FBI needed help with those incredibly inept spies, who were under surveillance almost from the moment they arrived in America.) Instead, I heard along with everyone else about the spy ring and slowly put the pieces together about my former advisee."

I may be wrong but it was my understanding that these spies may have been outed by a spy who worked at the UN and defected in the 2000's. The defector died of a heat attack recently, just after the White House was informed of the spy ring.

 

GENNY

2:44 PM ET

July 15, 2010

"In reality we are no longer enemies" ????

Not pretending to belong to high "rings": my eyebrows raise. In LIVE reality husband and wife today kiss each other, tomorrow divorce.

 

AR

4:01 PM ET

July 15, 2010

This article is a joke as the

This article is a joke as the first poster pointed put and nina is even more of a joke. It's a shame for the Kkrushchev family that she 'represents' them.
Other than your last name, there is nothing Russian about yout nina.

 

ABHICHO

9:44 PM ET

July 16, 2010

Nothing New

The game of sending spies to other countries has been going on for yours. We must not forget that these spies were living in America for years.
Just has Russian spies were caught in America, I am sure there are many American spies in other countries.
Just hope that countries treat the spies humanly when they are caught.

Peugeot Pepper Mill