Gaza's Great Tunnel Recession

Battered by Israeli and Egyptian military strikes and undermined by the easing of the blockade on Gaza, the once-booming tunnel industry is a shadow of its former self.

BY THEODORE MAY | AUGUST 13, 2010

RAFAH, Gaza—It's a clear sign that an industry is well established when cafes spring up to cater to the workforce. In the best of times, Café Abou el Nour relied on just this business model, supplying a place to rest and talk for the busy workers in Gaza's tunnel industry. The smuggling zone extends across both sides of the border separating Egypt and Gaza, and is split down the middle by a low Egyptian border fence outfitted with manned guard towers several hundred meters apart.

Once, there were more than a thousand tunnels on this patch of land. These days, however, squeezed by the Egyptian and Israeli governments and the easing of the Gaza blockade, the tunnels have dwindled to as few as 200, according to tunnel workers. Café Abou el Nour also sits empty, save for a 10-year-old worker snoozing in the corner, a few stray cats looking for a handout, and the establishment's preoccupied owner, Ahmed Abou el Nour. "There is no work these days," he says, "because the tunnel business has been very bad."

Khaled Baraka, a 20-year-old native of Rafah, was one of the workers who benefited during the tunnels' boom time, which began in 2007 following Hamas's armed takeover of the Gaza Strip. Neither the Israelis nor the Egyptians had cracked down on the industry yet, and the Israeli blockade imposed after Hamas seized power guaranteed that the tunnels would be Gazans' primary lifeline for basic necessities.

Hamas nurtured the tunnel industry and continues to view it as an important source of revenue. The party issues licenses for the tunnels, charging Gazans up to $6,000 for the privilege of beginning construction. It then taxes each tunnel $200 per month, according to Baraka and another tunnel worker. In return for these fees, the municipality of Rafah oversees the tunnel trade -- helping to resolve disputes between tunnel owners, imposing labor laws, and providing emergency rescue support in the event of a collapse.

When Baraka began his career in the tunnels as a digger, he was working three or four days a week and making up to $200 per day. While the volume of goods passing through the tunnels made the industry seductively lucrative to Gazans, workers lived in fear of tunnel collapses, Israeli airstrikes, and Egyptian military raids. He quickly rose to the position of tunnel manager, overseeing workers in a tunnel. In the middle of 2009, he purchased a 20 percent stake in the tunnel, paying for his portion largely in labor.

But the industry had already begun its decline. After its nearly monthlong war with Hamas concluded in January 2009, Israel managed to convince Egypt that the success of its strategy to isolate Hamas depended on Egyptian help in shutting down the Islamist party's primary source of goods and weapons. In response, Egypt ramped up its efforts: Over the last year and a half, workers say, Egypt has been responsible for far more tunnel closures than the Israeli air raids.

AFP/Getty Images

 

Theodore May is a freelance journalist who has written for GlobalPost, USA Today, and National Geographic.

TRUTH NOT PARTISAN

8:30 PM ET

August 13, 2010

When all is quiet on the

When all is quiet on the western front make sure people are aware of their "suffering".

Does FP really need to stoop so low, or make sure people come back to their site to get their daily fix of a sorrow story from Gaza?

First the blockade was horrible, now easing it is cause many Gazans to lost jobs. Which would FP prefer or the author? Open borders with many people buying Israeli goods, which are cheaper and higher quality? Or an illegal network of tunnels that even Egypt isn't too fond of.

Egypt is aware of the double edged sword these tunnels create. Yes they make them look good in the eyes of the Arab League, they allow them to operate, but at the same time rockets might be launched from Sinai like last week.

As the Hamas man said, Egypt is smart, not stupid. There is a reason they crack down on the tunnels and make it hard. They do not want it but they will put up with it little by little until it goes away. Without any Israeli involvement.

 

AVNER STEIN

10:25 PM ET

August 13, 2010

I wish I could live in Gaza

Free food from the UN, all-expenses paid by the Palestinian Authority and European Union, olympic size swimming pools, endless attention from the media.

Pretty good considering the fact that your leaders are terrorists.

If anyone can prove to me Gazans are starving please do. We've all seen the photos of fatty Gazans munching in candy and groceries.

http://www.paltoday.com/arabic/News-64161.html

Look at those poor poor Gazans!!!!

And you can't say it's Israel propaganda because that's Palestinian media, probably edited by Hamas too!

 

TRUTH NOT PARTISAN

12:50 AM ET

August 14, 2010

Ippon, you are so delusional

Ippon, you are so delusional you are even starting to put "prison camps" and "diet" in quotations. You know it isn't true soo much that you can't even believe it yourself.

secondly, you make some sort of claim which I couldn't really find anywhere with any proof, be it pictures or statements.

Yet, I can find proof of Gazans dancing in the streets after the 9/11 attacks. Care to explain the discrepancy?

 

TRUTH NOT PARTISAN

11:12 AM ET

August 14, 2010

you fail to mention the lack

you fail to mention the lack of proof.

or Gazans dancing after 9/11. How quickly we forget.

Also the UN blamed Lebanon for the recent clash up North and is going to blame Hizbullah for murdering ex PM Hariri. As well as even in your holy Goldstone report blamed Hezbollah almost as much as Israel. I can start quoting all sorts of horrible things, yet you will say they aren't true. Correct?

 

TRUTH NOT PARTISAN

2:36 PM ET

August 14, 2010

I never said your links didnt

I never said your links didnt work. I said that the article had no picture back up or personal back up. They made a claim without any proof. Your'e telling me that a journalist went, saw and did not bring a camera and wasn't about to take a picture?

What I am saying is that you never seem to criticize Hamas. You always blame Israel for Operation Cast Lead even though a large amount of the crimes and the reason for the deaths was on Hamas.

Plus Goldstone is not a prominent Zionist. At all. sorry to burst your bubble.

If some extremist right wingers danced when Bedouins living illegally were told to move again, does that justify the rockets and suicide bombings, kidnappings and murder of Israelis inside Israel proper?

Israelis dancing didnt work btw. not at all.

 

TRUTH NOT PARTISAN

8:12 PM ET

August 14, 2010

so i just read the article

so i just read the article and saw that the video was just a propaganda video of the same article. Throughout the whole article nothing conclusive at all came up. There were no pictures of smiling Israelis, no proof that they were behind the attacks, in fact there the expert said they were there to monitor Islamic extremism.

What a fail of an article and video. Of course you would subscribe to it.

 

TRUTH NOT PARTISAN

3:21 AM ET

August 15, 2010

So now you are telling me

So now you are telling me that only Israeli's filmed 9-11. Everyone filmed it! its a reaction people have. CNN filmed it, FOX filmed it, a myriad of tourists filmed it. You arguments are becoming worse and more extremist.

And you have not been able to show me but one picture, one video. All you have is one women claiming to see a happy look on 5 israeli faces. Compared to hundreds of smiling, dancing Gazans holding victory signs actually filmed and aired around the world.

 

AVILLA

3:19 PM ET

August 14, 2010

Definitely a catch-22.

The blockade of civilian items Gaza was illegal, immoral, and downright wrong. It needed to end. Yet because Israel continues to restrict people in Gaza's freedom of movement (again illegally), by easing the blockade they have destroyed one of the only job opportunities in the land. But what other option is there? Continue to "put the Gazans on a diet", as the Israeli official so charmingly said? That isn't a solution. This will have to do for the moment, even if it is harsh. And ah, I see the usual geniuses are here defending policies of Israel that even Israel itself admits are wrong. Tsk tsk.

 

ANYA KHAN

8:01 PM ET

August 22, 2010

OK Avilla, Give me a solution

OK Avilla, Give me a solution that doesn't lead to a daily attack on Jews and I'll agree that the legal blockade could be lifted.

I did ind the picture of the worker dressed like a 90s era thug funny and sadly telling

 

LALACHAN

7:07 AM ET

August 25, 2010

In adition to this article I

In adition to this article I want to remember the 33 miners stacked in Chile in a mine. I hope they're rescued soon. Albergues en Barcelona