Where does your city rank? This year Foreign Policy teamed up with management consulting firm A.T. Kearney and the Chicago Council on Global Affairs to produce our second ranking of Global Cities. The 2010 Global Cities Index looks at 65 metropolises worldwide, measuring how much sway a city has beyond its borders -- its influence and integration with global markets, culture, and innovation (for more about methodology and a complete listing, click here). If you don’t have time to visit all 65 cities, take the FP whirlwind photo tour.
1. New York
In recent months, plans to construct a mosque near the former site of the World Trade Center have attracted public controversy. Mayor Michael Bloomberg responded on Aug. 3 with a passionate defense of his city's diverse culture. Above, commuters wait for their train in the Union Square subway station on March 9.
Mario Tama/Getty Images
2. London
London, a commercial center since the Roman Empire, is now in the midst of another building project: preparing for the 2012 Summer Olympics and an estimated half-million visitors. Here, a man walks past a puddle with the reflection of Big Ben's clock tower on July 14.
Oli Scarff/Getty Images
3. Tokyo
Tokyo is the world's most populous city, home to some 36.7 million people. But today more than one-fifth of its population is over age 65, leading to increased strain on health-care system and other facilities. Above, shoppers walk along Takeshita Street in the city's Harajuku area on May 25.
Mark Kolbe/Getty Images
4. Paris
A pedestrian shelters from the sun under an umbrella on the Pont des Arts bridge on July 8. Paris is celebrated for its art and architecture, but traffic and pollution problems threaten its image and lucrative tourism industry. Now, Paris is vying to create the world's largest public rental system for electric cars, dubbed Autolib and due to launch in September 2011.
PATRICK KOVARIK/AFP/Getty Images
5. Hong Kong
A British colony until 1997, Hong Kong retains much of its Western character despite now being controlled by China under an arrangement known as "one country, two systems." Above, a bird's-eye view of residential and commercial property in Hong Kong July 8.
MIKE CLARKE/AFP/Getty Images
6. Chicago
Chicago is a global city in the heartland of America. More than one-third of Chicago's population speaks a language other than English at home, and every year the city recognizes as an official holiday the birthday of a Polish brigadier. Here, visitors walk out on The Ledge, a new glass cube that juts out from the 103rd floor of the Willis Tower (formerly the Sears Tower), on July 1.
Scott Olson/Getty Images
7. Los Angeles
Passengers ride a Metro Link train at a station near high-rise loft buildings under construction on Dec. 14, 2006. Hollywood, the city's signature industry, last year earned a record $29.9 billion in box-office revenue -- about equal to Kenya's entire GDP.
David McNew/Getty Images

8. Singapore
One-fifth of the world's cargo passes through Singapore's port. This makes the crowded Singapore Strait a highly strategic passageway, and sometime bottleneck, for global trade. Pictured above, a view of the Marina Bay Sands hotel development June 21.
ROSLAN RAHMAN/AFP/Getty Images
9. Sydney
A third of all Sydney residents are immigrants to Australia; after British nationals, Chinese make up Sydney's largest minority community. Former Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd earned plaudits for his fluency in Mandarin. Above, a light artwork illuminates the Sydney Opera House on May 27.
Lisa Maree Williams/Getty Images
10. Seoul
South Korea leads the world in household broadband penetration. In Seoul, plans are under way to provide all residents with a wired network fast enough to download a full-length feature film in 12 seconds -- that's about 200 times speedier than the average Internet connection in the United States. Above, people stand in front of the photo wall at city hall on July 18.
PARK JI-HWAN/AFP/Getty Images
11. Brussels
Even though it's the seat of the European Union, language and cultural differences remain sources of friction in Brussels. Formally, the city recognizes both Dutch and French as official languages; however, Brussels is largely a Francophone municipality in the Dutch-speaking Belgian north. Here, spectators hold Flemish flags at Brussels's Grand Palace on Flemish Community Day, on July 11.
JORGE DIRKX/AFP/Getty Images
12. San Francisco
San Francisco has been called the gay capital of the world, with 15.4 percent of the city's population identifying as gay, lesbian, or bisexual. When San Francisco's Mayor Gavin Newsom began issuing same-sex marriage licenses in 2004, nearly 3,200 couples lined up to get hitched. Continuing domestic political battles about gay marriage have kept the city in the global spotlight. Above, a cable car makes its way down a hill on March 3, 2005.
Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
13. Washington
The global headquarters of Foreign Policy magazine, the greater Washington area is also home to U.S. President Barack Obama, the Pentagon, and Arlington National Cemetery. Above, a Segway tour stops near the U.S. Capitol on Aug. 2.
Tim Sloan/AFP/Getty Images
14. Toronto
About half of Toronto's citizens are foreign-born. As the city ages -- about one-fifth of locals are 60 or older -- Toronto is likely to become more dependent on its immigrant community to revitalize its workforce. Above, the sun sets over the Toronto skyline.
Photo Undated/Carlo Allegri
15. Beijing
The 2008 Summer Olympics marked Beijing's breakout moment on the world stage. In preparation for the event, officials spent $40 billion to update the city's infrastructure. Above, a pedestrian rides his motorcycle past a construction site on July 12.
Franko Lee/AFP/Getty Images
16. Berlin
Twenty years after the fall of the Berlin Wall, the city has turned Cold War history into a tourist attraction. At Checkpoint Charlie, the best-known crossing point between the former East and West Germany, visitors can now pose for pictures with uniformed actors and have their passports stamped as they cross from one side to the other. Here, people walk with their umbrellas during a rainstorm on Aug. 3.
JOHANNES EISELE/AFP/Getty Images
17. Madrid
The bullfighting capital of the world, Madrid is home to Spain's largest bullfighting ring, known as Las Ventas. Bullfighting revenues make up some 1.5 percent of the country's GDP, even though the region of Catalonia recently banned the sport. A person walks past graffiti reading in Spanish "No to the labor reform" on June 29.
DOMINIQUE FAGET/AFP/Getty Images
18. Vienna
Vienna's city center, once home to such celebrated composers as Mozart and Haydn, was named a UNESCO World Heritage site in 2001 for its historic role as Europe's music capital. Above, a man rests in his horse carriage in front of the city hall* on Feb. 23.
*This corrects language that originally described the building as the Hofburg Palace.
JOE KLAMAR/AFP/Getty Images
19. Boston
The greater Boston area houses more college students per capita than anywhere in the United States. In 2009, Harvard, MIT, Northeastern University, and Boston University together enrolled more than 14,000 foreign students. Here, a lone pedestrian braves snowy conditions Jan. 14, 2008.
Darren JcCollester/Getty Images
20. Frankfurt
A young skateboarder practices outside the headquarters of the European Central Bank on April 29. Perhaps best known as Germany's financial hub, Frankfurt is also home to dozens of museums. Nearly three million people will descend on the city in August for its annual Museums Riverbank Festival, a three-day gala celebrating the end of summer.
Thomas Lohnes/AFP/Getty Images
21. Shanghai
China's most populous city is also its most technologically advanced. Shanghai became the world's first city to open a commercial high-speed maglev train in 2003. The rail line can reach top speeds of 267 miles per hour. Above, people stand next to traffic lights on the Bund area on Aug. 10.
PHILIPPE LOPEZ/AFP/Getty Images
22. Buenos Aires
Known to some visitors as the "Paris of the South," Buenos Aires shares a longstanding cultural affinity with Europe. More socially progressive than its neighbors, Argentina in July became the first country in Latin America to legalize same-sex marriage. Here, a tourist looks at Caminito Street from a window on Aug. 18.
DANIEL GARCIA/AFP/Getty Images
23. Stockholm
Tourists wait for the changing of the guard at the Royal Castle on May 24. Stockholm's tranquil image has recently come under fire. In July, local Internet service provider PRQ drew attention when one of its clients, the controversial whistle-blower website, WikiLeaks, released more than 75,000 U.S. military documents online, many of them classified.
Olivier Morin/AFP/Getty Images
24. Zurich
Zurich's residents boast the world's greatest earning power, according to Forbes magazine. On average, the city's workers make $22.60 an hour after taxes. That's 73 percent more than what a Berliner makes, and 50 percent more than a Chicago resident. Here, people walk on Bahnhofstrasse on Dec. 2, 2009.
FABRICE COFFRINI/AFP/Getty Images
25. Moscow
Moscow summers are generally mild, with average temperatures hovering near 70 degrees Fahrenheit. This year, however, a record-setting heat wave has left the city scorching, and nearby wildfires have destroyed a fifth of Russia's grain crop. Above, a woman watches supporters of the Russian Communist Party march on May 1, 2009.
Dmitry Kostyukov/AFP/Getty Images
26. Barcelona
Barcelona is emerging as an international hub for medicine: This year, more than 1,000 people from 30 countries will descend on the newly opened Barcelona Biomedical Research Park to conduct studies in human genetics, epidemiology, and clinical pharmacology. Above, solar panels adorn the top of graves in a municipal cemetery on March 19.
Jasper Juinen/Getty Images
27. Dubai
Dubai's reputation as a millionaire's paradise took a hit following the worldwide economic downturn that caused credit to dry up in the Arabian emirate. Despite its troubles, however, Dubai is expected to make some $8 billion this year in tourism and energy revenues. Here, Emirati competitors sail in the gulf during the Al-Gaffal sailing race on May 29.
KARIM SAHIB/AFP/Getty Images
28. Rome
The Cross is alighted in front of Rome's Colosseum on Good Friday, April 2. All roads, it seems, are crumbling in Rome. Showing its age, Rome is not only literally falling apart but the city is quickly sliding down the world GDP rankings.
ALBERTO PIZZOLI/AFP/Getty Images
29. Amsterdam
Despite the city's reputation for religious and racial tolerance, tensions have increased in Amsterdam in recent years. An influx of Muslim immigrants has The 2004 murder of controversial Dutch film director Theo van Gogh is the most notable example. Here, bikes are chained along a canal on May 9, 2009.
Mark Dadswell/Getty Images
30. Mexico City
Mexicans dance at the "Monumento a la Revolución" on Oct. 26, 2008. Most recent news out of Mexico has been grim -- drug violence, earthquakes, murdered political candidates -- but there is at least one bright spot. Thanks to concerted government efforts, air pollution in Mexico City has decreased dramatically, allowing city dwellers to regularly enjoy views of surrounding volcanoes rarely visible even a few years ago.
Ronaldo Schemidt/AFP/Getty Images
31. Montreal
A horse carriage is shown going through the streets in old downtown Montreal on March 8, 2005. Before Vegas stole the nickname "Sin City," that title went to Montreal, once the destination for Americans journeying north to enjoy the vices outlawed in the Prohibition-era United States. Montreal now has another claim to fame: The city has become headquarters for many of the world's leading video-game developers.
TIMOTHY A. CLARY/AFP/Getty Images
32. Geneva
Geneva attracts international businesses and NGOs, as well as vacationers, to its famous scenic lake. Above, cafe culture in the old town.
Mike Hewitt/Getty Images
33. Miami
More than half of Miami's population was born outside the United States, and more than two-thirds speak a language other than English at home. The human links between Miami and Cuba are a source of cultural vibrancy, and sometimes political friction. Here, a vintage Buick sits on the curb on Sept. 26, 2009.
ROBERTO SCHMIDT/AFP/Getty Images
33. Munich
Once a small Bavarian outpost, Germany's southern manufacturing powerhouse is home to Siemens, BMW, and four other Fortune Global 500 companies. Above, a woman walks along a striped pedestrian area between terminals of the Franz Josef Strauss airport on June 12.
CHRISTOF STACHE/AFP/Getty Images

35. Sao Paulo
A giant sign made of plants lays beside an Indy 300 race track March 12. Brazil's most diverse city has prospered as the nation's economy has taken off, but Sao Paulo still suffers from high crime, widespread corruption, and a low per capita GDP.
Nelson Almeida/AFP/Getty Images
36. Bangkok
Long a beacon of relative prosperity in Southeast Asia, Bangkok's economy flatlined this year when anti-government "red shirt" protestors decamped in the city center, leading to violence and at least 90 deaths. Above, a Thai labourer pushes a cart through rows of temporary stalls while setting up a night market, Aug. 4.
CHRISTOPHE ARCHAMBAULT/AFP/Getty Images
37. Copenhagen
Already recognized as the greenest city in Europe, Copenhagen's has pledged to become the first carbon-neutral capital city by 2025. Pictured above are boats and colorfol houses in the Nyhavn district, Aug. 12.
JOHANNES EISELE/AFP/Getty Images
38. Houston
Long famous for its energy companies, Houston is now striving to also be a leader in medicine. The Texas Medical Center in Houston, renowned as a top-flight research center, reportedly conducts more heart surgeries than anywhere else in the world. Here, a man walks through driving wind and rain after Hurricane Ike, Sept. 13, 2008.
Mark Wilson/Getty Images
39. Taipei
With the second-largest per capita GDP in Asia, Taipei's wealthy residents have helped underpin the city's transformation into a major regional shopping mecca. Shopping malls and high-end restaurants now dot maps of Taipei. Here, a worker walks past a wall made of recycled plastic bottles at the Flora Expo construction site on April 13.
SAM YEH/AFP/Getty Images
40. Atlanta
Atlanta's airport has been the busiest in the world for 11 consecutive years, with more than 90 million passengers passing through in 2008. Home Depot, Coca-Cola, UPS, and Delta Airlines are all headquartered in Atlanta. Above, traffic crawls through downtown on May 9, 2005.
Barry Williams/Getty Images
41. Istanbul
A Turkish boy jumps into the Bosphorus on July 23, 2007. Istanbul, once known as Constantinople, has for centuries been a meeting place between East and West. Today it has another distinction -- the largest share of billionaire residents of any city in the Muslim world (13), according to Forbes.
LOUISA GOULIAMAKI/AFP/Getty Images
42. Milan
Long the fashion capital of a country known for its love of luxury, Milan is currently one of the world's most expensive cities to live in. Hoping to outdo Shanghai's performance this year, Milan is now preparing to host the 2015 World Expo. Here, people walk past sales displays on Jan. 4.
Vittorio Zunino Celotto/Getty Images
43. Cairo
Cairo, a historic center of literature and ideas, is today one of the most densely populated cities in the world and also the largest publishing center in the Middle East. Above, the minaret of the Sayyidna al-Husayn mosque looks down on the Khan al-Khalili bazaar on Feb. 24, 2009.
David Silverman/Getty Images
44. Dublin
A man walks past a sign outside a pub in the Temple Bar area of the city on Oct. 15, 2009. Dublin's fate has risen and fallen with Ireland's economic boom and bust over the last decade. Once largely homogenous and better known for sending its citizens abroad, Dublin now is home to a large immigrant population from all over the world.
Chris Jackson/Getty Images
45. New Delhi
India's capital of New Delhi is getting richer and more often in the global spotlight, but the dilapidated infrastructure in much of the city is still a hurdle for many of the foreign companies doing business there. Above, an Indian Muslim man and child break their fast on the first day of Ramadan at Jama Masjid, New Delhi's historic mosque on Aug. 12.
MANPREET ROMANA/AFP/Getty Images
46. Mumbai
Indian commuters wait to board a train on Feb. 23. Mumbai, once primarily known for its low-tech textile industry and large seaport, is now home to India's two major stock exchanges, as well as Bollywood, the world's most prolific film industry.
Pal Pillai/AFP/Getty Images
47. Osaka
Renowned for its local cuisine, Osaka is known as the kitchen of Japan. Once Japan's largest commercial center, Osaka is now overshadowed by Tokyo's larger population and economy. Here, an elderly woman has lunch at a noodle shop in Nishinari ward on March 17, 2009.
RICHARD A. BROOKS/AFP/Getty Images
48. Kuala Lumpur
A motorcyclist rides past portraits of Malaysia's former prime ministers on July 29. Islam meets modernity in Kuala Lumpur, and sometimes sparks fly. One of Malaysia's hit TV shows filmed in the capital, Imam Muda, is a reality show similar to American Idol, but the contestants strive to become a Muslim cleric.
SAEED KHAN/AFP/Getty Images
49. Rio de Janeiro
Beloved for its beaches and food, Rio de Janeiro is the happiest city in the world, according to a 2009 issue of Forbes. But city leaders are also struggling to combat crime as they prepare to host the 2016 Summer Olympics. Pictured above is the Christ the Redeemer statue on Corcovado hill on June 30.
VANDERLEI ALMEIDA/AFP/Getty Images
50. Tel Aviv
Locals relax on a beach on Aug. 5, 2006. Tel Aviv may not be the official capital of Israel, but its economic clout in the country is unmatched. Tel Aviv has become a center for cutting-edge technology research and a major entrepreneurial hub.
DENIS SINYAKOV/AFP/Getty Images
51. Manila
In today's Manila, those who can, leave. Remittances from the 9 million Filipinos working overseas amounted to approximately $15.8 billion last year -- 11 percent of the country's GDP. Above, shoppers rush to do their Christmas shopping on Carriedo Street on Dec. 21, 2009.
NOEL CELIS/AFP/Getty Images
52. Johannesburg
A skyline view from Ellis Park Stadium on June 12. Johannesburg is sub-Saharan Africa's wealthiest city. As the host city for the 2010 FIFA World Cup's opening and closing games, Johannesburg showcased the South Africa's recent relative prosperity.
GIANLUIGI GUERCIA/AFP/Getty Images
53. Jakarta
This densely populated capital city is also the financial and commercial center of Indonesia -- the largest economy in Southeast Asia. It also suffers from some of the worst traffic in the world, and a 2007 study found that the ubiquitous traffic costs the booming city $3.5 billion a year in lost productivity and wasted fuel. Here, a street vendor prepares fish for customers on March 1.
BAY ISMOYO/AFP/Getty Images
54. Bogotá
A populous neighborhood seen June 16. Colombia turned 200 this year. To mark the bicentennial, the Bogotá Archive will be opening a hundred-year time capsule on Oct. 30. Nobody knows what the chest contains, as it was sealed by the Honorable Council of Bogotá in 1911, but once the contents have been made public, another time capsule will be created.
JUAN BARRETO/AFP/Getty Images
55. Caracas
A man stands in the stairwell in the pro-opposition neighborhood of Altamira on Dec. 6, 2007, after opposition supporters defeated a referendum on changes to the Constitution proposed by Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez. Facing one of the highest murder rates in South America, Caracas's desperate city council in 2007 bought three zeppelins to monitor criminal activity from the skies. Printed in bright red on the side were the words, "We watch over you for your security."
Mario Tama/Getty Images
56. Nairobi
Nairobi city leaders are supporting plans to build a major highway to ease traffic congestion. But their biggest opponents come from a gated community for the rich that opposes the construction. The deadlock with government officials -- who say the land had been earmarked for public use even before it was developed -- is the latest sign of growing public-private tensions in Kenya. Above, a supporter of Kenyan President Mwai Kibaki waves from a tree during a rally in downtown Nairobi on Dec. 24, 2007.
Roberto Schmidt/AFP/Getty Images
57. Guangzhou
In recent months, Guangzhou has become a battlefield in a brewing culture war. Half of Guangzhou's population of 14 million speaks Cantonese as a first language -- but when a local official last month proposed forcing the city's TV stations to broadcast only in Mandarin, China's official dialect, more than 1,000 people took to the streets in protest. Here, trolleymen wait for business on June 12, 2003.
Peter Parks/AFP/Getty Images
58. Bangalore
Nicknamed "the Silicon Valley of India," Bangalore is still no high-tech paradise for most of its residents. Providing adequate electricity, water, and housing to the city's 5.4 million inhabitants remains an immense challenge for local officials. According to the Indian Institute of Science, the city's water supply could be nearly depleted within the next five years.
Dibyangshu Sarkar/AFP/Getty Images
59. Lagos
People struggle for space between public transport buses and trucks at the bustling Oshodi bus stop, on Feb. 6, 2006. The seventh fastest growing city in the world and the financial heart of the most populous country in Africa, this densely populated city continues to see a flood of people arriving from all over the continent, looking for work. Lagos is booming, but it still lacks the basic infrastructure needed to adequately integrate this influx.
Pius Utomi Ekpei/AFP/Getty Images
60. Karachi
Pashtun migrants from the North-West Frontier Province -- many of whom share links to the Afghan Taliban -- have been known to battle violently in Karachi with the city's majority ethnic group, the Mohajir. Pakistani men ride on a wood-laden donkey cart in the British-era Lea Market on Jan. 28.
Asif Hassan/AFP/Getty Images
61. Ho Chi Minh City
A fruit vendor walks past a wall of TV sets and refrigerators on display outside a shopping center in downtown Ho Chi Minh City on April 26, 2005. International investors think highly of Ho Chi Minh City: In the last seven months alone, the municipal government attracted nearly $1.2 billion in foreign direct investment. The figure marks a 15 percent increase over the same period last year, according to state officials -- evidence of Vietnam's ongoing (if somewhat wobbly) experiment with capitalism.
HOANG DINH NAM/AFP/Getty Images
62. Shenzhen
Shenzhen, a major factory hub just north of Hong Kong, is experiencing growing pains. The city made headlines this summer when at least 10 people leapt to their deaths from atop a local factory owned by Taiwanese tech contractor Foxconn. Here, a lone house stands in the middle of a construction site in Shenzhen on April 14, 2007.
WOODY WU/AFP/Getty Images
63. Kolkata
Kolkata, once known to the West as Calcutta, was the home of Mother Teresa and the seat of British power during the time of the Raj; it is now the commercial center of eastern India. Above, an Indian porter carries clay pots that have been brought into the city from rural villages and offloaded on the banks of the river Ganges River on Aug. 4.
DESHAKALYAN CHOWDHURY/AFP/Getty Images
64. Dhaka
In this photo, Bangladeshi Muslims offer Friday prayers on the street in Dhaka on June 26, 2009. More than three million factory workers in Bangladesh churn out shirts and other products for Western retailers such as Walmart, JCPenney, and H&M. This summer, the capital city of Dhaka saw violent protests as textile laborers destroyed equipment to protest an insufficient increase in the minimum wage.
MUNIR UZ ZAMAN/AFP/Getty Images
65. Chongqing
Above, workers weld on the roof of a building on the Guanyinqiao Pedestrian Street on May 6, 2008. Nestled in the mountains of southwest China, Chongqing was the Nationalist capital during World War II. Since then, the former backwater has struggled to catch up to its fast-growing coastal brethren -- but now Chongqing is making up for lost time, its GDP growing at nearly twice China's national average.
China Photos/Getty Images




(65)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE
SONGSHU
12:38 AM ET
August 16, 2010
Really?
Boston and Frankfurt have more influence and integration with global markets than Shanghai?
Do they have a team of monkeys working over at A.T. Kearney?
CODY101
11:21 AM ET
August 17, 2010
Not only global markets
Here is some of the criteria that was used, according to the acticle. It seems to easily answer your question.
"To create this year's rankings, we analyzed 65 cities with more than 1 million people across every region of the globe, using definitive sources to tally everything from a city's business activity, human capital, and information exchange to its cultural experience and political engagement. Data ranged from how many Fortune Global 500 company headquarters were in a city to the size of its capital markets and the flow of goods through its airports and ports, as well as factors such as the number of embassies, think tanks, political organizations, and museums"
SONGSHU
2:20 AM ET
August 19, 2010
Yes
This does indeed easily answer my question. It's a study based on creating a data-set with such unambiguously quantifiable inputs as "cultural experience" and "political engagement".
Whatever happened to qualitative data? Or common sense?
Wouldn't these particular conclusions signal a need to reevaluate the methodology used to compile the results, as opposed to the compulsion to simply chuck them into a finished product and slap a bow on it?
HELION
4:06 AM ET
August 21, 2010
Madrid, Berlin, Vienna, Boston hmmm..........
Well, to get back to cody, Shanghai has its fair share of Fortune 500 companies, the second-busiest port after Singapore, large concentrations of consulates, academic think-tanks, sixth largest stock market, and a fast-growing large economy.
So, I am a little confused too why would Madrid, Berlin, Vienna, and Boston would be placed so high. Of these 4, only Boston beats Shanghai in GDP size (according to the rank, which I suppose neglects PPP value of the yuan). Other than GDP size, Boston pretty much has nothing to offer, really. Port? International organizations? I suppose MIT and Harvard University can be counted in, but I thought they are in Cambridge, MA, which technically ain't Boston proper.
RICARDO CASTRO
2:56 PM ET
August 21, 2010
Really Really?
Ok Cody, your list of criteria cannot possibly explain how Buenos Aires is at 22 while São Paulo is at 35. Do you even know the two cities and their business community?
Plus, São Paulo may not be top 10, or even top 20. But would anyone think it has less global influence than Munich? Vienna? Geneva, for Christ's sake?
I definitely agree with songshu: the list must have been assembled by monkeys throwing darts. Not that the world should stop on its tracks due to that. But ATK and FP should be ashamed.
CHRIS GRAYSON
2:33 AM ET
August 27, 2010
Yes, Much Absurd
As a New Yorker, I'm perhaps biased in thinking we were appropriated ranked. Otherwise, this list seems about as arbitrary as throwing darts.
However, in defense of Boston -- it exerts a lot of soft influence. Excluding all other factors, simply as the home of Harvard (Cambridge), the most influential University in the world, it is worthy.
Consider the conduit of power that runs through that one institution to international power-centers in both the public and private sector in every international city on the map. How many movers and shakers in Hong Kong and Shanghai have a degree from Harvard? I'll answer that: A Lot. There is a "Harvard Club," serving the alumni in every major city in the world, including both Shanghai and Hong Kong (HC of HK boasts a membership of 1800 alumni on their website). How many relationships are nurtured within those walls? By extension, that's the type of influence Boston has around the world. Every one of those alumni is a connection back to Boston, many of whom are power players in their sphere, and their relationships with their former classmates are a backdoor to the halls of power in every city in the world.
But I agree, the list is certainly heavily Western centric.
My 2¢
RECADERO
6:15 AM ET
August 31, 2010
Mhmm
which kind of discussion style is that as initiated above (Monkeys). Every ranking can be critized, but there is no need to personally attack the people doing it - what can be attacked is not to publish the detailed methodology.
Influence might be valued different, the political capital of China is Beijing while Shanghai is the economical capital, New York might not be the political capital of the U.S.A, but has the (factual) HQ of the United Nations (Geneva might be the nominal one) while being a econimic and cultural hub in the U.S. From a Shanghai perspective- as outlined here - why is Beijing ranked higher (guess the economic aspect was not the single deceisive)? Frankfurt is the economic centre of the mainland european banking and stock market and HQ to the European Central Bank. Vienna has the the HQ of OPEC and the third one of the United Nations, including the IAEO. As stated the ranking gives an idea of the city's influence on and integration with global markets, culture, and innovation. So, don't forget e.g. the cultural part (opera houses, muesuems etc) and that politics play a big part in influence.
AARON_WEE
4:26 AM ET
August 16, 2010
surely just a little western-centric more than necessary?
I can understand the criteria for some of the Euro-cities - high penetration of foreign nationals. But surely, amongst the data, one would find that the penetration of foreign nationals is no doubt helped by the EU's labor laws. That does not necessarily mean higher global influence in a sense beyond the EU's borders. So yes, stronger intra-EU ties but not a truly global impact.
ASCHOPS
3:16 AM ET
August 17, 2010
Stupid
Photo essays always make the stupidest articles at FP's, and that's saying something.
NICOLAS19
6:11 AM ET
August 17, 2010
New York, really
Sure it is a landmark city, but it's just getting over the top, claiming every now and then that NYC "is the best city in the world". I'm pretty sure that for example Beijing has more global impact than the ever-hailed NYC.
FREETRADER
1:55 PM ET
August 20, 2010
Huh?
I don't think it would be very easy to make a case for any city other than New York if one were giving out a title for the "Commercial and Cultural Capital of the World". Beijing is simply not in the same league - politically important for China, perhaps, but not particularly economically powerful, especially globally, and hardly diverse.
ROBERT SCHUSTER
6:55 AM ET
August 17, 2010
Vienna
the description for the picture to Vienna is misleading - the building that you can see in the back is the town hall, the imperial Hofburg palace would be behind the photographer
PASSPORT ADMINISTRATOR
10:02 AM ET
August 26, 2010
Error Corrected
Thanks for pointing out the mistake. It has been corrected.
PBEGLES
8:55 AM ET
August 17, 2010
New York and London
I think New York and London just have a lot of influence in the financial market. In New York there are also a lot of big non government organisations and other world political parties placed. So it hasn't really any thing to do with thedesign or something like that.
SIMONSLT
9:46 PM ET
August 17, 2010
Los Angeles picture
Why would you have a picture of a commuter rail for Los Angeles when it is famous for being a city that heavily relies on personal automobiles? I'm not sure what you were trying to capture here with your photos but I think you totally misrepresent the character of Los Angeles by having a picture of a commuter rail line. The New York picture was already of it's subway anyway. I would have hoped the Los Angeles picture would be something more like Edward Burtynsky's photos of Los Angeles from the "Oil" collection, published on foreignpolicy.com last October, which capture the character of Los Angeles much better than this photo.
ROBERTISSIMUS
12:26 AM ET
August 18, 2010
It is true that not many
It is true that not many people take trains in Los Angeles, but the multilingual nature of the city is arguably best appreciated on public transit. Take any bus down Wilshire Boulevard and you will find people readings newspapers in Farsi, Korean, Russian, Spanish ...
DLYTTON
3:19 AM ET
August 25, 2010
Picture is Los Angeles' future
The caption reads "Passengers ride a Metro Link train at a station near high-rise loft buildings under construction on Dec. 14, 2006 . . . "
First of all, it is a Metro Rail Blue Line train. Metrolink is a commuter train service to the suburbs while Metro Rail is a rail rapid transit system.
Secondly, LA's future as a world city is contingent on achieving two of the things that the caption mentions - building more rail transit and increasing density.
The former will likely get speeded up via the Mayor's 30/10 initiative which will use an infrastructure bank type process to build a large amount of rail transit (perhaps the largest amount built in the US since NYC early last century) in 10 years.
The later is happening apace in Downtown and Hollywood and is expected to follow the Westside subway extension.
If either of these initiatives fail LA will not be a world city but just a cooler version of Dallas or Phoenix. Thus, the picture is quite prescient.
KSHAH
12:54 AM ET
August 27, 2010
The bigger picture.
Los Angeles future as a world city is really not that much in jeopardy.
Examine the facts: Los Angeles remains a top notch Research & Development center in the area of BioTech, communications/media and Aerospace (still to the day). Los Angeles has great universities it is among a handful of US Metro area with 3 top 25 US universities in it's mist (UCLA, USC, CAL Ins of Tech). No other US city has more museums. Many innovative business concepts & trends are hatched in the greater Los Angeles area. The city is the largest on the west coast and remains the most strategic business gateway/interface to China and many other Asian and Pacific Rim nations. Los Angeles is a vastly diverse city. The city represents an enormous amount of human capital in terms of ideas, culture and influence. Los Angeles biggest challenge is also one of its main assets: Hollywood. Hollywood's star shines so brightly that it covers many other things up. Additionally, as mentioned already,Los Angeles should continue to speed it's move into higher density/ rapid transit/ bicycle forms of living and transportation.
NWINNWIN
9:59 PM ET
August 17, 2010
Ho Chi Minh city ???
Would love to see the actual idea that got this place, that looks more like a giant village, on this list. Well, there are probably more than a few other odd entries on this list as well.
Or is this more of a potential investors' teaser/reminder list about the potential potentials ?
Or the survey simply had to choose one place per each big country that sort of resembles "metropolis" ?
1 million people ? - sure
business activity ? - sort of, definitely potentials
human capital ? - definitely potentials (but very poorly nurtured)
information exchange ? - ???
cultural experience ? - ??? define culture (as in yoghurt ?)
political engagement ? - ??? (not really apreciated unless looking for trouble)
size of its capital markets ? - pathetic, but definitely potentials
flow of goods through its airports and ports ? - definitely potentials
number of embassies ? - consulates
think tanks ? - ??? helloooooo (unless looking for trouble)
political organizations ? - still only one & in charge, sort of
museums ? - pathetic beyond description, actually very very very sad
What about:
infrastructure & traffic ?
power supply ?
ADDISABABA
12:33 AM ET
August 18, 2010
Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Index my a**, it sure sells magazines and drives web traffic. That is for sure, how could you have ignored Addis Ababa, as Africa's diplomatic capital with its influence in Africa and the Middle East.
FAIZA30
9:04 AM ET
August 18, 2010
KARACHI
HI,really u could nt find a better picture of karachi?.there are many beautiful images in karachi which could have been captured,but well what do u expect from a prejudiced western media.and please check your facts, the mohajirs are not the major ethnic group,thats just propaganda created by the political party MQM consisting of this ethnic group,.infact there are more pashtuns ,in karachi then thier are mohajirs,not only that.all pashtuns are not necessarily linked to the afghan taliban, the majority of pashtuns living in karachi are peace loving poor people just trying to earn a living for thier families.so i found the 2 lines describing karachi higly prejudicial. u could have also written that it is the biggest city in pakistan,which generates 70% of the tax revenue in pakistan.
RAINMAKER
6:41 PM ET
August 18, 2010
global cities
what rubbish. FP is becoming a tabloid caricature of FA!
i have to wonder how you came up with this ranking. it doesn't surprise me that it is biased towards American cities, but some of your ranking just makes no sense.
Shanghai? come on, it should be in the top 5. and whatever you think of Dubai, it personifies "global" almost more than any other city. and Singapore?
surely, you are not going to rank Baghdad as a major global city just because there are 1000s of foreign soldiers there. i wouldn't be surprised if you did!
FREETRADER
2:00 PM ET
August 20, 2010
Hardly
You kidding? Dubai? A bunch of sheiks with (formerly) more cash than sense throwing money around the desert in riduculous vanity projects does not a global city make. If they are successful in turning Dubai into a regional hub, it might make the top 50 in 10 years.
Shanghai is an important export and manufacturing center for China, and it certainly is vibrant and international - for China. But, let's face it, China still has no globe trotting multiantionals. Maybe someday.
Singapore seems to be about correctly ranked - since it is independent it is likely a better candidate than Hong Kong for 'Asia's Global City.'
HELION
4:14 AM ET
August 21, 2010
freetrader, you kidding?
"But, let's face it, China still has no globe trotting multiantionals. Maybe someday."
Sir, I just checked the Fortune Global 500 list, and I discovered that 3 of the top 10 in this year's list are Chinese (they got 46 total vs. 139 for the US). I don't think Shanghai should be in the top 5, because the city's financial market is, well, closed to the outside world thanks to Chinese capital control. But, given its achievement so far and further potential to grow, it deserves somewhere to be between rank 10 to 15, imo.
MASON0507
8:07 PM ET
August 18, 2010
The recently launched ghd IV
The recently launched ghd IV styler is the ideal solution.
DAMO
10:14 AM ET
August 19, 2010
Beatiful picture of Rio
The Rio de Janeiros's statue of Christ is beautiful. One of the world's icon.
JAKE RANDOLPH
11:17 AM ET
August 19, 2010
Not surprised at all
Not surprised at all that NY is number 1 on the list. It would take another half a century for any asian country to be on the very top of the list.
Great pic on london btw!
GANYMED
5:50 PM ET
August 20, 2010
Vienna
Mozart's home was Salzburg and the building is the city hall (Rathaus) and not the Hofburg. Maybe you should have mentioned that Vienna has emerged as a major business hub for eastern Europe since the EU enlargement. FP you can do better.
PASSPORT ADMINISTRATOR
10:24 AM ET
August 26, 2010
Error Corrected
Thanks for pointing out the mistake about the city hall. It has been corrected. Although Mozart was born in Salzburg, he did spend many years in Vienna.
LANGER2040
5:06 AM ET
August 21, 2010
Isn't this North-Western-oriented, or what?
Look, fortunately FP didn't say anything bad about Bogota, but couldn't you pick a less crappy photo? We're talking about an 8-million people city that has become a financial and services hub, that has gone through a huge face-changing development process in the last 20 years, and with crime rates dropping at the same time. We still have a lot to do, but we're on our way.
But no, you had yo put a crappy photo and a comment about the city being old. Most of the cities are even older, and some of them are crappier. Why don't you publish a photo of a NYC's ghetto, or a Paris suburb filled with poverty and discrimination? Do you know that Washington has higher crime rates than Bogota?
I really like FP, but your country / city index reports are even worse everytime. It's a pity.
BARTOFSKY
9:33 AM ET
August 21, 2010
Metropolis Now, When and How...
Messrs Fung & Mondschein published an assemblage of words, which is bias, narrow-minded, unbalanced, unscientific and ultimately meaningless...
HOKIEFAN
3:16 PM ET
August 21, 2010
This ranking is Fubar
I'm sorry, I don't want to sound rude, but this listing is horrible! Brussels and Chicago beats cities like Shanghai, Beijing, Sao Paolo, New Delhi, Mumbai and Moscow? I like to consider myself a red-blooded American - I definitely agree that NYC and London should hold the 1 and 2 slots - but even I think this listing reeks of blatant Westernism.
And as an aside, I'm going to guess that you didn't take PPP into consideration?
HELION
6:09 PM ET
August 21, 2010
Brussels and Chicago
Brussels = capital of European Union.
Chicago = ..., well I guess that's where Obama comes from, so it must be very important.
DALEWATT
10:10 PM ET
August 21, 2010
Chicago
As a Chicagoan who has visited Shanghai, Beijing, New Delhi and Mumbai within the last 5 years, I have to say that this list is not at all FUBAR or is blatantly western.
Chicago is a transportation, communications, and industry hub with dozens of Fortune 500 companies like Boeing based here. It's one of the largest convention centers in the world and has a massive economy with 12 million people in Chicago's metro area. I can tell you that Chicago deserves to be higher than any of the cities you listed.
In any case, nobody could make a list like this that everyone agrees with. I think Washington should be higher, but I don't work at FP, so I don't get a vote.
HOKIEFAN
2:03 PM ET
August 22, 2010
Brussels and Chicago > Beijing and Moscow: No not really
Boeing may be based in Chicago but that is only its headquarters. The majority of their operations (Engineering R&D, final assembly, flight testing) is still done in Seattle. Picking a city because of the tax credits it offers, does not a global city make. Chicago does have a larger economy than Shanghai, although that lead drops when PPP is taken into account. Chicago is more an economic focal point for America whereas Shanghai is China's central economic gateway to the world (Hong Kong lost this attribute recently).
Ugh, the EU. Just because Brussels is the capital of that unwiedly, oft ineffectual extra-national entity, does not vault it past capitals like Beijing or Moscow, both of which have larger economies than Brussels (not to mention COMPLETE control over their global-affecting nations).
And yes I definitely agree Washington D.C. should have been ranked far higher.
Again this listing needs extra work. Too many intangibles and far too much focus on Western resources.
TADMUIREN
10:49 AM ET
August 27, 2010
Chicago
Here are a few hints as to why Chicago is ranked so highly.
(1) In FP's table, "The Global Cities Index 2010," note the "Rank by GDP" column.
(2) Note FP's page on the methodology of their ranking, "Global Cities Index Methodology."
(3) There is a ranking of cities in MasterCard's "Worldwide Centers of Commerce Index" (which can be google'd). The top 15 cities in MasterCard's ranking of 75 cities in 2008 (the latest published) are:
(1) London; (2) NewYork; (3) Tokyo; (4) Singapore; (5) Chicago; (6) HongKong; (7) Paris; (8) Frankfurt; (9) Seoul; (10) Amsterdam; (11) Madrid; (12) Sydney; (13) Toronto; (14) Copenhagen; (15) Zurich.
See the body of the document for extensive detail on the methodology used for this ranking.
(Hope this helps.)
TADMUIREN
11:20 AM ET
August 27, 2010
Chicago
Here's a little more background on Chicago's position in the FP ranking.
Chicago's strengths for the ranking include: the presence of major capital markets, a highly educated work force, an ability to attract international students to its universities, the presence of a number of Fortune 500 company headquarters, and the size and diversity of its immigrant population.
Chicago moved up to #6, from #8 in FP's previous ranking, due to: increases in major corporate headquarters, increases in business and international conferences, and improved rankings in air freight and in visual and performing arts. Regarding the arts,...
On the front page of London-based Timeout's "worldwide" website, there are links to separate websites for 61 different cities. Seven of those links are shown in bold font, and four of those seven are shown in enlarged bold font. Those four are links to Timeout's websites for these cities: London, New York, Chicago and Sydney.
TADMUIREN
1:24 AM ET
August 28, 2010
Chicago
Chicago is also the only American city to have won championships in all four of America's major professional sports during the past quarter century.
FASHIONLOVE
10:26 PM ET
August 21, 2010
think again
http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2010/08/16/metropolis_now
MOTSTYLE
7:45 AM ET
August 22, 2010
collection
??
STONY FEI
8:35 PM ET
August 22, 2010
Hofburg?
Is it just me? The Vienna photo looks more like the City Hall, instead of Hofburg.
PASSPORT ADMINISTRATOR
10:15 AM ET
August 26, 2010
Error Corrected
Thanks for pointing out the mistake. It has been corrected.
UJJWAL007
8:46 PM ET
August 22, 2010
Shoddily put together
How can one just mention some irrelevant tit bits and totally ignore listing out the key points which actually make the city global. Also as they a picture speaks more than a thousand words. I have seen a child click better pictures (check esp. some of the Asian cities like New Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata, Osaka, Vietnam, some chinese cities) and ironically the title says "Stunning images of the world’s top global cities." Even the ghettos in NY won't make a pretty picture.
JIMMYDIDI
2:40 AM ET
August 23, 2010
No need to build a Mosque in New York
Sometimes American government needs to learn a little bit from the dictator China, for its calm-down policy for controversial issues.
Muslim becomes more a sensitive word, and everything relevant is sensitive, you should not break their traditions, you should not joke their clothing, cuisine habits, or their holy icon, otherwise you'll wait for revenge, protest, cyber hackers, flesh bombers, threat mails.
it is not good, the more you respect them ,the more they want. Islam as a religion is itself an unilateral one, no tolerance to other regions, not like buddism, or any other Asian religons.
Wang a mosque, how about let Obama eat muttons from then on. will they feel more respected they would never bomb any more?
SDUB
3:09 PM ET
August 25, 2010
Do cities deserve the hype?
There’s been much talk about the glorious coming of a broad urbanization age, but discussing the reality with a friend yesterday brought out realization of the possibilities of resultant disasters. One thing for sure is that the increased competition encourages progression in all commercial outlets, but is that necessarily the best thing for us?
http://seanrwatson.blogspot.com/2010/08/do-cities-deserve-all-hype.html
TADMUIREN
10:47 AM ET
August 27, 2010
Why Chicago is ranked so highly
Here are a few hints as to why Chicago is ranked so highly.
(1) In FP's table, "The Global Cities Index 2010," note the "Rank by GDP" column.
(2) Note FP's page on the methodology of their ranking, "Global Cities Index Methodology."
(3) There is a ranking of cities in MasterCard's "Worldwide Centers of Commerce Index" (which can be google'd). The top 15 cities in MasterCard's ranking of 75 cities in 2008 (the latest published) are:
(1) London; (2) NewYork; (3) Tokyo; (4) Singapore; (5) Chicago; (6) HongKong; (7) Paris; (8) Frankfurt; (9) Seoul; (10) Amsterdam; (11) Madrid; (12) Sydney; (13) Toronto; (14) Copenhagen; (15) Zurich.
See the body of the document for extensive detail on the methodology used for this ranking.
(Hope this helps.)
TADMUIREN
11:25 AM ET
August 27, 2010
Chicago
Here's a little more background on Chicago's position in the FP ranking.
Chicago's strengths for the ranking include: the presence of major capital markets, a highly educated work force, an ability to attract international students to its universities, the presence of a number of Fortune 500 company headquarters, and the size and diversity of its immigrant population.
Chicago moved up to #6, from #8 in FP's previous ranking, due to: increases in major corporate headquarters, increases in business and international conferences, and improved rankings in air freight and in visual and performing arts. Regarding the arts,...
On the front page of London-based Timeout's "worldwide" website, there are links to separate websites for 61 different cities. Seven of those links are shown in bold font, and four of those seven are shown in enlarged bold font. Those four are links to Timeout's websites for these cities: London, New York, Chicago and Sydney.
TADMUIREN
1:25 AM ET
August 28, 2010
Chicago
Chicago is also the only American city to have won championships in all four of America's major professional sports during the past quarter century.
JENNYKANG
4:29 PM ET
September 3, 2010
Architecture in Tokyo
Architecture in Tokyo has largely been shaped by Tokyo's history. Twice in recent history has the metropolis been left in ruins: first in the 1923 Great Kant? earthquake and later after extensive firebombing in World War 2 Because of this, Tokyo's current urban landscape is one of beautiful and contemporary architecture, and older buildings are scarce.
ALEX PATERSON
9:04 PM ET
September 4, 2010
Australian cities
Interesting to see Sydney so high on the list (as in top ten). Whilst it is arguably the financial capital of Australia I feel that its place in global politics is somewhat distorted by both Australians and foreigners alike. But what I'm more interested in is how Sydney placed so well in this and Melbourne did not. PS I'm Australian and live in neither Sydney or Melbourne.
BOWL WEEVILS
7:33 PM ET
September 15, 2010
sydney & melbourne
It's cause Chicagans can unnerstand youse Australians when youse say Sydney, but not when youse say Melbourne :)
ALIGEMBA
1:11 AM ET
September 9, 2010
Stunning images of the world’s top global cities
Thanks for sharing stunning images above of the world’s top global cities. As one said "Whilst it is arguably the financial capital of Australia I feel that its place in global politics is somewhat distorted by both Australians and foreigners alike. But what I'm more interested in is how Sydney placed so well in this and Melbourne did not." Search for current sports news. An interesting comment
ALIGEMBA
1:12 AM ET
September 9, 2010
Stunning images of the world’s top global cities
Thanks for sharing stunning images above of the world’s top global cities. As one said "Whilst it is arguably the financial capital of Australia I feel that its place in global politics is somewhat distorted by both Australians and foreigners alike.
WESTHIGHLANDER
5:15 PM ET
September 9, 2010
Boston
Actually, I would place Boston no lower than 3rd and possibly 2nd only to London:
1) Histoy of the US -- modern democracy was invented in Greater Boston -- the beginnings of the American Revolution began here
2) History of industry -- the modern industrial revolution first transplanted itself from UK to Grate rBoston
3) History of technology -- Telephone, Fire Alam Telegraph, AM radio, remote controlled vehicles, real-time computing, air traffic control radar system, use of ether in surgery, first organ transplant (kidney transplant), predecessor to the Internet, Apollo Guidance Computer, first astronomical phoograph, to name but a few firsts
4) History of finance: venture capital#1 --Mass Bay Company, VC#2 whaling and china trade, venture capial #3 American Research and Development created Digital Equipment Corp. -- when Silicon Valley was just an orchard, Mutual Funds (Massachusets Financial Services, money Market Funds,
5) won't even bother to mention today's leading medical, educational, orchestral, new American Art wing of the Museum of Fine Arts, etc.
6) Few others, public park in city(Boston Cmmon) metopolitan parks (not Royal preserves), metropolitan water supply, metroplitan highway system, industrial parks, electric traction for public transpotation, all invented here
Throw in a few dozen Nobel Prizes (more than most advanced countries), some of the most involved and complex filling and reshaping of the land, the Big Dig and the New England Autumnal display of folliage
And since it is the eve of mIT's 150th birthday -- the equivalent output of ALL of the companies started by MIT graduates exceeds the GDP of China
Open to a challenge match!
BOWL WEEVILS
7:45 PM ET
September 15, 2010
seriously?
For the most part, your list seems to be "important intellectual, financial, and political stuff happened here in the past" for the most part. Under that criteria, I would have to place Athens, Rome, Cairo, Xi'an, Baghdad, etc. Because they have at least 3000 more years of such important things having happened in them than Boston has.
Hell, if you want to pick the nexus of important intellectual, financial, and political activity, I would pick Jerusalem.
And as a fellow East Coaster, it is only people from Boston who think that "modern democracy" was invented there.
BOWL WEEVILS
7:45 PM ET
September 15, 2010
seriously?
For the most part, your list seems to be "important intellectual, financial, and political stuff happened here in the past" for the most part. Under that criteria, I would have to place Athens, Rome, Cairo, Xi'an, Baghdad, etc. Because they have at least 3000 more years of such important things having happened in them than Boston has.
Hell, if you want to pick the nexus of important intellectual, financial, and political activity, I would pick Jerusalem.
And as a fellow East Coaster, it is only people from Boston who think that "modern democracy" was invented there.
BOWL WEEVILS
7:46 PM ET
September 15, 2010
really Boston
For the most part, your list seems to be "important intellectual, financial, and political stuff happened here in the past" for the most part. Under that criteria, I would have to place Athens, Rome, Cairo, Xi'an, Baghdad, etc. Because they have at least 3000 more years of such important things having happened in them than Boston has.
If you want to pick the nexus of important intellectual, financial, and political activity, you might want to pick Jerusalem.
And as a fellow East Coaster, it is only people from Boston who think that modern democracy was invented there.
DDEVLYN
7:39 AM ET
September 11, 2010
World city list
Remind me to keep the name ATKearney in mind.
Shanghai so far down the list. Sydney top ten and no Melbourne at all. Australia's busiest sea port, Olympic city and sporting capital with a grand slam and a formula one. Please do your research better next time lads. Have a look at a map of Australia and you will see something south of Sydney mentioned in all other Alpha, Betta and Gamma lists.
MICHAELTURTON
9:02 PM ET
September 13, 2010
Gotta go with everyone else saying this list was western-centric
No cities in South America?
Toronto, Chicago and Frankfurt rank higher than Shanghai? Buenos Aires? Cairo? Mumbai? Bangkok? Istanbul? Moscow? Mexico City? Jakarta? Osaka? Jo-burg? Nairobi? Seoul? The list goes on. Obviously the factors ranking the international cities are thoroughly skewed. Maybe do some soul searching and redo it, eh?
DUDE91
12:14 PM ET
September 14, 2010
Dubai
The progress dubai as a metropolitan town has made is nothing short of phenomenal. But the downside of this rapid growth is sky rocketing inflation and empty coffers. Its become public now that dubai does not really have much money left and is borrowing from the capital state Abu Dhabi for the money.
Abu Dhabhi is the state with 97 % of the oil and hence is the most well off .
I personally prefer to get all my Resveratrol Review . Its one of the life saving drug.
NAIUY
7:03 AM ET
September 15, 2010
History of industry -- the
History of industry -- the modern industrial revolution first transplanted itself from UK to Grate rBoston." Search for m2ts converter ? flv to wmv converter. Hulu Downloader The fact that the government hires militias like the Salwa Judum to spy and intimidate ordinary people is clearly a prescription for disaster. How can any civilized government justify empowering militias to hunt and kill fellow citizens.
NAIUY
7:03 AM ET
September 15, 2010
History of industry -- the
History of industry -- the modern industrial revolution first transplanted itself from UK to Grate rBoston." Search for m2ts converter ? flv to wmv converter. Hulu Downloader The fact that the government hires militias like the Salwa Judum to spy and intimidate ordinary people is clearly a prescription for disaster. How can any civilized government justify empowering militias to hunt and kill fellow citizens.
HECTAGON
7:54 PM ET
September 15, 2010
Spotted!
Would it be possible to amend the caption for Washington D.C. to read "Above, a group of idiots stops near the U.S. Capitol on Aug. 2."? I mean, seriously, what self-respecting person would ever even go within five metres of one of those things? Perhaps this was a team shot of the researchers who put together this list...
There's so much that's already been said so well above, but just to take two of (so) many possible examples; Rome more important than Sao Paulo? Atlanta more important than Cairo??? Well, thanks for the sport that so many people (myself included) have evidently got from this article!
POLO
6:00 AM ET
September 22, 2010
Re: MADRID
Sorry but the biggest bullfighting ring in the world is not in Madrid, it is in Mexico City.
Fact checking is but a couple of mouse clicks away.
I'm surprised by the mistake.
Is this the new FP?
POLO
6:05 AM ET
September 22, 2010
Error
My mistake. The article states that it is the biggest ring in Spain, which it is, not in the world.
My apologies