Bono vs. Putin

A rumble in the Khimki forest leaves just one man standing. The question is, how many trees are left there too?

BY JULIA IOFFE | AUGUST 27, 2010

View a slide show of how Putin and Medvedev spent their summer vacation.

This week, there was a miracle in Moscow: Bono came to Russia and rescued a forest. The forest was in Khimki, just outside Moscow's northwestern edge, and, after years on the chopping block, it was in the process of being cleared to make room for a badly needed highway to St. Petersburg. Russian activists had been protesting the planned destruction of the ancient trees, a destruction that seemed spiteful and senseless, and one that Prime Minister Vladimir Putin and his cronies appeared to have decided on without consulting the people who lived there or considering any alternatives that would save the federally protected reserve. For years, the protesters were ignored, arrested, and, once, beaten half to death. Nothing worked and, this summer, the trees started to fall.

Until Wednesday night, that is. Bono's band took the stage at Moscow's Luzhniki Stadium and, in front of 60,000 people, he took out his black acoustic guitar and started to strum the opening chords of Bob Dylan's "Knockin' on Heaven's Door." And then he said, "Yuri?"

Out came Yuri Shevchuk, the frontman of the perestroika rock group DDT, with his scruffy beard and his glasses, and he started to sing along to the chorus. Like Bono, Shevchuk is no regular rocker. In May, he shocked Putin by engaging the omnipotent prime minister in a heated spat on the lack of social equality and freedom in Russia at what was supposed to have been a civilized lunch for the artists of St. Petersburg. ("Your words have weight, so use them," Shevchuk admonished Putin. "My weight is 76 kilograms," Putin snorted.)

The Sunday before Bono's concert, Shevchuk had thrown his political heft behind the campaign to save the Khimki forest with a benefit concert performed in Moscow's city center. The concert only drew 3,000 people and the Moscow authorities wouldn't let him hook up his sound equipment, so he played a mute set -- but it brought the protest to the heart of the capital. That didn't sit well with big shots in the Kremlin, nor were they overjoyed when Bono, who spent Tuesday strolling the sun-drenched boardwalks of Sochi with President Dmitry Medvedev, brought Shevchuk up on stage before thousands and gave him a hug the very next night. Bono had gotten an open letter from Shevchuk before the concert about Khimki, and he spent the hours before his Moscow show giving pre-concert interviews to Russian papers in which he said he wished he'd known about the Khimki forest so he could've brought it up with Medvedev.

ALEXEY DRUZHININ/AFP/Getty Images

 

Julia Ioffe is a writer in Moscow.

DEATHWARE

8:50 PM ET

August 27, 2010

Today

Eagle is god verify im politcs every you cool

sikis
pornolar

 

TIMPETERWALL

3:26 PM ET

August 30, 2010

Bono, bloody Bono!

Hi Julia,
I just think you got the wrong end of the stick here. Yes, I did read your story, but guess what: Bono didn't say ONE single public comment in support of the Khimki Forest defenders. A fact you somehow seem to miss, even though the story happily paints His Holiness Bono as the champion of Russian environmentalists. (As you point out, he seemed to be utterly unaware of the whole issue until they pointed it out to him)
If he had really wanted to, he could have then used the occasion of the Luzhniki Stadium gig, in front of tens of thousands of fans, to say 3 simple words: "Save Khimki Forest."
But he didn't.
And that's because he's just posing as a radical activist, but is actually just a "regular rock star" who likes drinking tea with presidents at their luxury dachas, but not really raising any dangerous issues with them.
What's different about Yury Shevchuk is that (regardless of what one thinks of his views) he actually has the courage to confront Vladimir Putin face-to-face on difficult issues.
Whereas Bono just kicks his carbon footprint down the continent to the next gig on his world tour.
I know your editor in the US wants to see the words "Bono" and "Putin" in the headline, but come on: It just doesn't correspond to reality.
If there WAS any victory, it was down to the thousands of people who showed they were sick of daily pollution, corruption and bureaucracy by turning up to Khimki forest protests and facing thuggish violence.
NOT bloody BONO.

 

HARVESTER1

5:10 PM ET

August 30, 2010

bravo timpeterwall!

I agree with Timpeterwall - Bono is the biggest hypocrite on the planet. Anything for free PR is the ONLY thing on his agenda. In reality he is the most selfish, obnoxious, self-centred pig that ever existed, along with his cohorts. I'm surprised that the leader of Russia even gave him the time. Doesn't he have an important job to do instead of grovelling to the PR agenda of a stupid rock star. Of course, it was that Irish moron who dubbed all politicians 'rock stars' - something any decent person would not be proud of, but which politician can be called decent these days?

Bono is nothing but a snivelling little coward who is trying to get himself a peace prize and all the gratuities of being labelled a 'humanitarian' while he pounds his own chest on the world stage. In REALITY, he is one of the most abusive psychopaths in existence.

It's good to know the truth around the piles of lies that the yanks pile out to everyone. Thanks timpeterwall.

 

SETABOS

3:20 PM ET

August 31, 2010

Whiners

@HARVESTER1 & timpeterwall

What constructive thing have you two pewling caterwauls ever done? Nothing except sit on your fat asses spitting hate and envy. Get a life!

I don't listen to Bono's music, but he seems determined to use his celebrity in a good cause. Who knows what changed the Kremlin's mind, and how long this decision will stick.

 

NICOLAS19

4:01 AM ET

September 1, 2010

no, you got it wrong

It's the other way around: Bono is using good causes to promote his image (read: being more of a celebrity). If you read the article (and others for that matter) it's clear, that Bono did not stand up for Putin. Didn't confront him about the wildfires at all, left some polite remarks, took full advantage of the photo-op, later paraded himself as the savior of all forests. And you bought it.

 

SETABOS

11:47 PM ET

September 1, 2010

No, I didn't

What is this? 'Tall Poppy' Day? You get to cut everyone down to your size?

At least you are more coherent than the first two posters.

Does a rock star have an ulterior motive for speaking out on social issues? Perhaps. Does some good come of it anyway? Perhaps, and where is the harm? I can think of many things worse.

For the record a quick search of Bono and Khimki turned up this gem:

"Bono, an outspoken activist on various social issues, said during a meeting with environmentalists that he regretted not raising the Khimki forest issue during talks with Medvedev in Sochi on Tuesday and promised to assist the forest defenders, environmental activist Yaroslav Nikitenko told Interfax." Moscow Times.

Doesn't sound like he is making a big deal of it to me. Unlike this article.

I 'bought' nothing.

 

SYNERGOS

6:56 AM ET

August 30, 2010

truth

I am Russian, but I am not a patriot. I am a patriot people and the truth. When I started reading a lot of fly back the Western press. I said to myself: "Finally the truth and democracy" And then I became disillusioned. It feels that 90% of journalists do not even know where Russia (although it is very big), and do not bother to check the information you write. For example: the abolition of deforestation in Russia voiced before the concert, Bono. With such a democracy and freedom of speech as you have, I can convince people that the sun was blue, and those who believe otherwise - a terrorist)