Pulling a Putin

Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili may be preparing to steal a play from his archrival's playbook in order to keep his grip on power.

BY MAGDALENA FRICHOVA GRONO | OCTOBER 4, 2010

More than two years after their violent short war, Russia and Georgia have forged a cold peace. But it's a bitter, fragile one: Russia exerts ever stronger influence over Abkhazia, the larger of Georgia's two breakaway provinces, and has effectively swallowed South Ossetia. Tbilisi considers Russia an occupier of its territory and deeply resents what it sees as Moscow's bullying policies in its near neighborhood and authoritarianism at home.

Which makes it all the more ironic that Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili, a sworn enemy of Russian Prime Minister Vladimir Putin, appears to be seriously thinking about emulating the political sleight of hand performed by his antagonist in Moscow. Under this scenario, Saakashvili would force through changes to Georgia's Constitution, paving the way for him to swap the presidency for a greatly empowered premiership and hence remain in charge in Tbilisi once his second and final term expires in 2013.

At the heart of the speculation is Saakashvili's constitutional reform process, which began in the spring of 2009. In what he claimed was an effort to bridge the antagonism between the ruling and opposition parties that has deepened since the authorities' violent crackdown on anti-government demonstrators in November 2007, the president proposed a multiparty constitutional commission. Its task was to draft changes to the constitutional amendments that Saakashvili had pushed through in 2004, which concentrated power in the presidency. But most figures in the opposition opted against participating, seeing the process as an attempt by Saakashvili to create an illusion of consensus when none existed.

The opposition's decision to cede the political field to Saakashvili, together with the ruling party's overwhelming majority in Parliament, has given the president a free hand to alter the rules of the game as he sees fit. The reforms currently on the table also might offer a hint of his future intentions: The amendments would endow the prime minister with significant new powers in foreign and domestic policy and make him a de facto chief executive, at the expense of the president who would retain the role of the head of state and commander in chief. The largely toothless Parliament would only get marginal new powers. The proposed changes were introduced into Parliament in late September and are expected to be passed before the end of October, despite strong pushback from opposition parties.

Saakashvili denounces critics who assert that he intends to entrench himself. He insists he will put reform first and that the proposed changes will not enable any one individual to grab power. Yet he has also conspicuously refused to rule out becoming prime minister. In June he told Le Monde, "I've been thinking about that possibility [of becoming prime minister], but too many uncertainties remain for now. Who knows what the economic situation will be in two years, or condition of constitutional reform, or my mood and political rating?"

VANO SHLAMOV/AFP/Getty Images

 

Magdalena Frichova Grono has worked on conflict and governance in the South Caucasus for the past decade, including as Caucasus project director for the International Crisis Group.

Facebook|Twitter|Reddit

AR

8:02 PM ET

October 4, 2010

Will sakoshitvilli overplay

Will sakoshitvilli overplay his hand a 2nd time? If he does, it will be the end of his political career for sure.

 

DANILA

5:06 AM ET

October 5, 2010

Oh, another Putinoid. Mind

Oh, another Putinoid. Mind your own business. In 2011 all the reserve founds will be over and the democrats will throw out your liliputin to jail and Russia will be free and prosperous country without thugs! As for Saakashvili, come visit Georgia, I promise you will die from envy. This people here have built a state. What has Putin done to us Russians? NOTHING. He is stealing people's money and raping our country's resources. /:

 

MALICEIT

5:28 PM ET

October 5, 2010

Hehehehe

Modernized economy so well that they attacked the one of the world's most powerful states with disastrous results. Russia will never throw out Putin because he is the most prominent leader in today's world. The only thing Saakashvili did is to create a fully authoritarian state. Ive been in Georgia 3 month ago and it is a dying country as it was 9 years ago. Putin did more things to Russia then Saakashvili will ever archive. Besides Putin doesn't need to chew on his tie prior to interview.

 

DANILA

5:00 AM ET

October 5, 2010

Article is stupid...

MAGDALENA, I am a Russian born immigrant to Georgia. I am a journalist, liberal and a democrat. I've been living in many western countries too but decided to settle in Georgia and work from here on what is left from free media in Russia... nut much, not much.

I have rad your article and in the best case (if nobody payed for it) all I can say is sometimes it is better to be quiet, especially if you can't see the very simple basic things. If you don't see the difference between Saakashvili and Putin, you are far more than stupid.
I envy Georgians, their pluralism, their freedoms and their political system. Even now it is light years ahead of anything post Soviet. As for the likes of you all I can say is mind your own business, Georgians and Saakashvili are doing everything right. WHICH I CAN'T SAY ABOUT EU or US. You surely don't care if we (Russians) live in a free country, but why do you have to act so disgustingly towards the Georgians? They live in a free democratic country and I wish I will be able to one day return to Russia when we will also have a democratic leadership. As for Saakashvili he has stated many times that he WANTS a TEAM of REFORMERS to stay in power. I FULLY SUPPORT YOU MR.PRESIDENT! (Why? I have been in Georgia in 1999 and it was a broken state rampaged with corruption and today it is far more European than many members of EU. It is a brave country with values and I am proud to be it's new citizen!)

 

GIORGIIO

5:28 AM ET

October 5, 2010

Danila, you are too rude man.

Danila, you are too rude man. As much as I support Saakashvili she does have some good points and cut it out, she is not payed by anybody...

P.S.

I hope that one day Russia will be democratic too. :)

 

GIORGIIO

5:50 AM ET

October 5, 2010

having said that, I disagree

having said that, I disagree with comparison of Saakashvili and Putin too... they are just too ridiculously different in every way.

 

DANILA

5:16 AM ET

October 5, 2010

"At the heart of the

"At the heart of the speculation is Saakashvili's constitutional reform process, which began in the spring of 2009. "

- This is just dumb and idiotic. you know when you write something you should at least try to understand what you want to write and not copy from my other Russian colleges that unlike me work for thug Mr.Putin.

1) In the new reformed constitution, the president stays strong, but the PM gets more balanced power. it is not like the president is getting weak with the OM getting his powers.

2) The venetian commission has reviewed the constitutional reform of Georgia, UPON A REQUEST OF THE GEORGIAN GOVERNMENT:
http://www.civil.ge/eng/article.php?id=22638

 

TAMARA

5:59 AM ET

October 6, 2010

I think the article is quite balanced

Yes, the author did compare Saakashvili to Putin, but on the surface it does seem Saakashvili is trying to mimic his main rival's step. Whether it will be like that, we will only see in 2013. Yes, he said he is committed to preserve the team of reformists, but I think, for that case he can serve as an adviser and not necessarily as a prime minister - unless we admitt he is THE ONLY reformist in the whole country. Whatever the reason behind this whole constitution reform (and I do support the reform process in general), I am a bit tired of re-adjusting the Georgian constitution to certain persons. Again: it looks bad! And undemocratic.

But, in general, I agree, that Saakashvili has accomplished a lot- Georgia indeed is a different country - and I take pride in it anytime I visit any post-Soviet republic. However, I would appreciate a bit more transparency and may be a bit more merit in the fundamental decisions, such as the Constitutional reform.

That being said, constructive criticism does not mean I am anti-Georgian, or anti-Saakashvili. And I hate that in this country we are somehow divided into either or categories. Well, that does speak something about pluralism.

 

STEVE_O

8:51 AM ET

October 6, 2010

Danila is a tipical Saakashvili supporter

No-one in their right mind would attack a neighbor like Russia. Saakashvili did. Even the Western media admitted that. He might be not the worst Georgian president, but he is definitely a psycho. It seems to me he is only capable of shouting and screaming . if he has done something besides ugly rhetoric - good for Georgia.