Battle in Belgrade

Is Serbia Really Ready to Join the European Union?

BY JAMES KIRCHICK | OCTOBER 11, 2010

BELGRADE, Serbia — To the 500 or so Serbian gays and their allies who marched here last weekend, the riots engulfing the rest of the city were a world away.

Sunday, Oct. 10, marked the first time that a gay rights demonstration has been held successfully in Serbia, a deeply conservative, Orthodox Christian country that is slowly moving beyond a history marred by war and ethnic conflict. Its pro-Western president, Boris Tadic, is keen on bringing Serbia into the European Union, but must first transform the popular perception of his country as one that is xenophobic and intolerant, out of step with the European Union's reigning liberal ethos.

A crucial part of that effort is to improve the status of Serbian minorities, gays among them -- an agenda that has gone over badly with the country's still-powerful right wing. In 2001, ultranationalist hooligans violently disrupted a gay civil rights march, and one planned for last year was canceled at the last minute when government authorities told organizers that they could not guarantee the safety of participants. Tadic's critics, both left and right, accuse him of pandering to the European Union, and to U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, who is due to visit Belgrade Tuesday, Oct. 12, to discuss Serbia's EU accession process, the whereabouts of fugitive Serbian general and accused war criminal Ratko Mladic, and the status of Kosovo.

Regardless of the government's motives in supplying 5,000 police officers to protect the parade -- and sealing off a major section of the city to let it happen -- Sunday's event was entirely peaceful, at least for parade goers. Indeed, Belgrade was two cities: a ghost town and a war zone. Riot police set up successive cordons on major thoroughfares and side streets to monitor attendance in the march, which started with a rally in a downtown park, creating a wide radius through which one had to seek permission to pass. At some point I lost count of the number of checkpoints I crossed, showing my press credentials and undergoing a pat down at each one.

About an hour before the rally began, small disturbances began between anti-gay protesters and police just a half-mile or so from the rally. Running toward the noise (which alternated between chants of "Kill, kill, kill the gays" and other crude slogans), I was passed by two police officers, one visibly injured. Moments later, as I tried to take a picture of the ensuing chaos, a screaming hooligan ran up to me, smashing my camera hard into my face. I ran from the scene before I could see what, if anything, the police did to him in response.

The march itself was largely uneventful. It lasted all of about 15 minutes, traveled the length of a few blocks, and competed against a background of sirens and the whirring of a police helicopter. By the time marchers had made their way to a downtown event hall for a party, reports of the violence engulfing Belgrade had begun to penetrate the bubble. "There is fighting all over the city," Jasna Cicmil, a 33-year-old Serbian woman, told me between frequent checks of her cell phone for text messages. "They tried to get into the hospital where injured policemen were put."

The gay Serbians relishing in a temporary victory over their more reactionary compatriots got a reality check immediately upon stepping outside the event hall, where a line of armored paddy wagons had lined up to drive them home. Police gently escorted parade-goers into the back of the trucks, shut a metal gate to lock them in, and sent them on their way.

Hearing reports of the riots dispersed across the city, I turned down a well-intentioned Serbian friend who had invited me into one of the trucks and ventured out on my own. I soon realized it would be impossible to get back to my hotel; there was a small-scale war going on between police officers and hooligans on one of the major streets leading up to it. The pleasant boulevard of Knez Mihailova, lined with clothing shops, cafes, and fancy stores, was being used by the anti-gay protesters as a fall-back point in their war against the security forces. Bricks and Molotov cocktails crashed near my feet, and the sting of tear gas hit my eyes. Behind me, I heard an elderly woman cry, "Fight brothers! This is traditional Serbia!"

Several hours later the violence came to an end and the costly toll had come in: some $1.4 million in estimated damages, nearly 150 (mostly police officers) wounded, the headquarters of Tadic's Democratic Party burned. As for the message that Sunday's event will send to Europe and the world, it's unclear. No matter how much effort the Serbian government made to ensure the safety of the parade, the very fact that it required 10 police officers for every marcher demonstrates just how far Serbian society is from reaching the point where it could become a full-fledged member of the European community.

AFP/Getty Images

 

James Kirchick is writer at large with Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty based in Prague, a contributing editor of the New Republic and a columnist for the Advocate.

JGDEUTSCH

7:43 PM ET

October 11, 2010

Post-communist countries and conservatism

As someone who has spent a lot of time in China, I have seen a lot of information about anti-gay sentiments in this semi-post-communist country. It is interesting to see that as, according to Freedom House, Serbia continues to democratize, public support for gay rights increases. Homosexuality was considered a psychological disorder and even criminal offense in Beijing just 20 years ago. Now there are gay bars here, and while the law does not specifically recognize gay rights, the government's proscriptions against HIV/AIDS counseling for gays here is loosening.

 

DRAGAN NENADOVIC

2:00 AM ET

October 12, 2010

I personally have nothing

I personally have nothing against gay people but, if their march is to block the lives of 2 million people ( there were only about 200 gay activists ) then I do. On Sunday 2 million people could not do their business ( every street was blocked ) because of the parade of 200 people. I do not think it is democracy. If almost total population is against something, then their opinion should be respected and not forcefully crashed.

As to the Serbs wishing to join EU, I will tell you something sir. Most of us do not wish that, but nobody ask us anything about it either.
Most of us despise Western nations because of their regimes’ evil done against us in the near past. They ethnically cleansed ½ million of us from Croatia ( not even Nazis could have succeeded in that ), forced 2 million of us in Bosnia to be what we do not want to be ( Bosnians ), stole Montenegro from our union in false results of referendum of separation, and at the end committed something to us that not even Turks nor Nazis could have succeeded, stole Kosovo from us by ethnically cleansing us from there.

Because of above foresaid, and many other lies used against us Serbs by your media and politicians, thank you for your EU. Keep it to yourself. It is bankrupt anyway, and will get even worse in the future. We live better them ½ of EU even now. Good easy life we have, so why would we change that for a bankrupt club called EU.

p.s. Serbia is the only country of former Yugoslavia where there is still substantial proportion of minorities in it. In all other republics of former Yugoslavia all minorities were ethnically cleansed long time ago.

 

NICOLAS19

6:08 AM ET

October 12, 2010

protecting gay rights is not about parades

I don't agree with the police on allowing and barricading the parade. It was clear to all that there would be an enormous uproar against the march. So the police had three choices.
1. Ban the march. It would've been the easiest, however, that was precisely a signal Tadic wouldn't want to send..
2. Let the marchers march, the protesters protest. It was sure that the parade was going to be disrupted, but widespread violence could've been avoided.
3.Confront the majority in favor of the minority. How could a government hope that by suppressing the majority it will change their feelings?
Barricaded demonstrations are not a sign of strength and tolerance but that of a weakness. If a society would be open to the parading group, no barricade would be necessary. If its not open to them - no parade. No police baton ever changed a society's true feeling.