Hezbollah's Boy Scouts

Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad was greeted upon his arrival in Beirut by a rapturous crowd. Thanassis Cambanis takes us inside the organization that teaches Lebanon's children to love the Islamic Revolution.

BY THANASSIS CAMBANIS | OCTOBER 13, 2010

The 2006 war between Israel and Hezbollah gave the world its clearest indication yet of the surprising strength of the "Party of God." Over more than a month of combat, Hezbollah was able to frustrate Israel's stated aims, allowing Hezbollah Secretary General Hassan Nasrallah to declare a "divine victory" after the conclusion of fighting. Thanassis Cambanis traveled to Lebanon to tell the stories of Hezbollah's supporters, and to understand the roots of the party's strength. In this excerpt from his newly-published book, "A Privilege to Die," Cambanis visits Hezbollah's youth movement in south Lebanon.


A Privilege to Die
Inside Hezbollah's legions and their endless war against Israel              By Thanassis Cambanis

In the year since the war, the Mahdi Scouts had nearly doubled its national enrollment to 60,000. They had run out of capacity to admit more, he said, but they were expanding as fast as they could. Hezbollah policed its community tightly, but not without concern for its mental well-being. Constant warfare (or mobilization for such) took its toll, especially on children and on the families of martyrs.

One goal of the scouts was to comfort the afflicted. The scouts tried to maintain a state of normalcy -- at least as Hezbollah defined it -- for its most vulnerable members. If left to their own devices, [the chief of Hezbollah's scouts] Bilal Naim said, the children of martyrs would isolate themselves and develop emotional problems. "We try to raise the children in the community and find new husbands for the widows," he said. "Otherwise the children become complicated, and develop unhealthy behaviors like aggression."

On a rainy Sunday in December, we drove to Khiam to visit the scouts in action. We were an hour late because we had trouble with military intelligence when we tried to enter the border region. The former Israeli occupation zone of South Lebanon remains officially off limits to foreigners. Anyone wishing to visit the area -- including foreign passport holders of Lebanese descent who have family homes in the South -- must get special permission from Lebanese military intelligence. Mine had expired the day before, and we had to call in a favor from a sympathetic officer who let us through the checkpoint at the Litani River.

Mohammed Dawi, the sweaty and plump scout leader, met us at the entrance to Khiam town. He was a redhead with freckles, and looked more Irish than Lebanese. The younger scouts were waiting in the basement of a high school a mile or so from the prison. The troop leader led them in a chant of welcome. Most of them wore blue shirts with epaulets, white scarves, and oversized badges featuring a photograph of a scowling Ayatollah Khomeini. Two boys who looked about ten wore full military fatigues.

It seemed the day's activities had been planned with my visit in mind. The children marched downstairs single file and broke up by age group. The "buds," six or seven years old, assembled for a puppet show, emceed by a man in a worn panda suit who sang lines from Nasrallah's speeches. The "sprouts," eight to ten years old, sat around tables at the rear of the room drawing pictures, their ideas inspired by a chubby and soft-spoken young woman named Malak Sweid. She was a graphic design student and zealous party apparatchik.

In "guided drawing," the kids drew pictures of Israelis weeping in defeat, denoted by Stars of David on their helmets, or of Israelis stepping on Lebanese. Other children, with evident direction by Malak, depicted crosses and crescents, symbolizing the Lebanese Christians and Muslims, chained by vicious Stars of David. Other pictures spoke less to the conflict with the Jews than to Islamic values. One child's picture showed women in low-cut gowns holding martini glasses and cigarettes in old-fashioned holders. "Smoking Harms Your Health" was the title.

JOSEPH EID/AFP/Getty Images

 

Thanassis Cambanis teaches journalism at Columbia University’s School of International and Public Affairs. He was previously the Middle East bureau chief for The Boston Globe and a Middle East correspondent for the New York Times.

Excerpted from
A Privilege to Die by Thanassis Cambanis. Copyright © 2010 by Thanassis Cambanis. Excerpted with permission by Free Press, a Division of Simon & Schuster, Inc.

MORALHAZARD

9:05 PM ET

October 13, 2010

Brainwashing

From this article it is clear that Hezbollah took one of the major steps necessary towards establishing totalitarian control over their country. They have control of the youth, and therefore the future of their country.

 

MALICEIT

11:36 PM ET

October 13, 2010

A Pledge of alligence

and boy scouts is exactly the same thing.

 

JOE7PACK

5:02 PM ET

October 14, 2010

Collateral Damage

I just love the way we sanitize these things. Those kids will be the human shields standing in front of the brave Hezbollah fighters. They make great propaganda material when their mangled bodies are displayed to the world. I feel sorry for these kids, they're too young to appreciate the 70 virgins that await them after martyrdom.

 

WHATSYOURBIAS

5:44 AM ET

October 14, 2010

Cheap Characterization

It is a cheap and manipulative tactic of Cambanis to make Dawi seem ludicrous or animal or unsympathetic because he eats candy. At the very least, Dawi seems to be a gracious host and offers the author decent access to what he is requesting. To distract from these basically human characteristics, Dawi goes out of his way in each described episode to make Dawi sound like an animal, like something with a disdainful compulsion and a "prodigious maw."

All those comments don't belong in a good story. They do belong in a piece of propaganda.

Whatever is wrong with Hezbollah and brainwashing children, don't stoop to a level where you make everyone of its members seem less sympathetic with careful diction that many readers won't notice even as it influences their perceptions. That's disingenuous and cheap.

It's the same as beginning an article with the photograph of a child making a salute that reminds most people immediately of a salute to Hitler. This sets a strong tone and subconsciously prepares readers for a story about monsters before any arguments are made.

These tactics make me fundamentally distrust this man and his "scholarship"--as if referring to groups of Hezbollah followers as "legions" hadn't already betrayed this man's linguistic bias.

Boo.

 

WHATSYOURBIAS

10:49 AM ET

October 14, 2010

Sure

Yes. They are people. Monsters don't exist. Convincing people that monsters do exist (like the Nazi's did with Jews, like the hutus did with tutsis) is a divisive way that strong communicators manipulate less intelligent people into advancing their political agendas--and, often, into participating in or condoning violence.

Cambanis deliberately filled his article with comments totally unrelated to politics that make Dawi sound gluttonous, creepy and unsympathetic. He did that to make it easier for himself to present an entirely one-sided piece of pseudo journalism.

Bad professor.

I'm not taking sides in the professor's argument. I'm saying that he's using high school level character defamation when it isn't called for. What if Dawi picked his nose or stuttered, maybe we should write about that, too. It would make it that much harder for him to fall within the circle of empathy that safeguards one human from another.

 

NSC LOS ANGELES

11:51 AM ET

October 14, 2010

Bother, I forgot to say...

"Legions" is also unfair? The Hezbollah boy scouts have 60K members trained from birth to wage war with Jews. Does that not meet the criteria necessary to be called "legions?"

 

LKRIER

3:35 PM ET

October 14, 2010

Perception

Interestingly, I thought these types of comments really humanized Dawi. I certainly perceived that he seemed gracious and welcoming.

 

WHATSYOURBIAS

5:01 PM ET

October 14, 2010

valence/bias

"Legions" isn't unfair, it's just a highly valenced word more likely to conjure demons and hordes than, a community, a party, a people, followers, soldiers, etc.

I'm just pointing out that scholars, historians, and people sincerely interested in sharing the truths that they discover with the mature world of thinking people are careful not to let their opinions pre-load their language with judgments. You know, "We report. You decide." : )

And I was disappointed to see this piece in Foreign Policy because of this.

 

NSC LOS ANGELES

7:28 PM ET

October 14, 2010

Communal, perhaps.

Hezbollah may be communal in nature, but the existence of the group appears to be largely devoted to the business of killing Jews. In that sense I don't consider them "soldiers" who represent a sovereign nation against any enemy and therefore deserving of the moniker "army" or even "militia." They are self-proclaimed exterminators, so to me, legion seems a fair handle.

 

GWALD89

6:08 AM ET

October 15, 2010

Ignoring Reality

The candy tidbits are supposed to be endearing--Cambanis is showing how imperfect, almost playful daily habits cohabitate uncomfortably with uniform, militant doctrines. Cambanis explicitly says Dawi comes from an older, more skeptical generation and is bit bored by stress placed on teachings. Pointing out minor flaws is about as humanizing a literary trick as I can think of.

 

JOEGO

12:29 PM ET

October 14, 2010

Islam's steady march

I'm sure to be politically correct this whole process has nothing to do with Islams core beliefs not just to Jews but to all non-believers. As Pres. Obama says America will never be at war with Islam. Whats this war called again? I'm confused.

 

NSC LOS ANGELES

7:25 PM ET

October 14, 2010

FP Censorship is heavy these days...

I'll be curious to see whether or not his comment remains or is removed. It's a shame to see both authentic discourse and amusing pissing matches removed from the comments section.

Sidenote, my comment about the tremendous admiration for Hilter appears to have been removed. This assertion is fairly well documented. Is FP as opposed to simply stating facts these days, as unpleasant as these facts may be? There's a place for you in the Netherlands, FP.

 

Q80IAN

10:14 PM ET

October 15, 2010

with such a level of access, it could've been a good article

i agree with WHATSYOURBIAS

the writing of the article is so bad that it wouldn't pass an English 101 class, the writer was either writing for high school level kids or his/her level of understanding is as deep as high school kids.
the writer tried so hard to reflect Dawi as a pig neglecting any other qualities that he could have had and this to show how flat is Hezbollah and the people running its youth division.
this among other very apparent biasness against the party RUINED what could have been a very good informative article about the party that at least delayed the creation of the new middle east scheme if reports are to be believed.