The End of Christianity in the Middle East?

The brutal bombing of a church in Baghdad may be the final straw for this 2,000 year old minority community.

BY EDEN NABY, JAMSHEED K. CHOKSY | NOVEMBER 2, 2010

Screaming "kill, kill, kill," suicide bombers belonging to the Islamic State of Iraq, a militant organization connected to al Qaeda in Iraq, stormed a Chaldean church in Baghdad on Sunday. A spokesman for the group subsequently claimed they did so "to light the fuse of a campaign against Iraqi Christians." The assailants' more immediate grievance seems related to a demand that two Muslim women, allegedly held against their will in Egyptian Coptic monasteries, be released. When Iraqi government forces attempted to free approximately 120 parishioners who had been taken hostage, the terrorists -- who had already shot dead some of the churchgoers -- detonated their suicide vests and grenades, slaughtering at least half the congregation.

But the massacre in Baghdad is only the most spectacular example of mounting discrimination and persecution of the native Christian communities of Iraq and Iran, which are now in the middle of a massive exodus unprecedented in modern times as they confront a rising tide of Islamic militancy and religious chauvinism sweeping the region.

Christians are the largest non-Muslim religious minority in both Iraq and Iran, with roots in the Middle East that date back to the earliest days of the faith. Some follow the Apostolic Orthodox Armenian Church. Others subscribe to the 2,000-year-old Syriac tradition represented mainly by the Chaldean Catholic Church in Iraq and by Aramaic speakers widely known as Assyrians in both Iraq and Iran.

Iraqi and Iranian Muslim leaders claim that religious minorities in their countries are protected. In September, former Iranian president Ayatollah Akbar Hashemi Rafsanjani reassured the patriarch of the Assyrian Church of the East that religious minorities are respected and safeguarded in Iran. Yet members of Iran's Christian denominations, like their Jewish, Zoroastrian, Mandean, and Baha'i counterparts, don't feel safe. A member of the National Council of Churches in Iran, Firouz Khandjani, lamented in August, "We are facing the worst persecution" in many decades, including loss of employment, homes, liberties, and lives, he said, "We fear losing everything."

In Iraq, Chaldean and Assyrian Christian communities have witnessed increasing violence by militant Muslims against their neighborhoods, children, and religious sites since the U.S. invasion. Even pastors are not safe -- two died in the recent Baghdad bombing; many have been killed by Sunni and Shiite Iraqis since 2003. In Iran, other clergymen, including members of the Armenian, Protestant, and Catholic churches, have been arrested, kidnapped, imprisoned, tortured, or even summarily executed, over the past three decades.

"Many Christians from Mosul have been systematically targeted and are no longer safe there," said Laurens Jolles, a UNHCR representative, in 2008, after Chaldean women were raped while their men, including Archbishop Paulos Faraj Rahho, were tortured and killed in warnings to Christians to abandon their homes and livelihoods. In Iran, Christian clerics have been targeted -- Tateos Mikaelian, senior pastor of St. John's Armenian Evangelical Church in Tehran was assassinated in 1994, as was Bishop Haik Hovsepian Mehr, who headed the evangelical Assemblies of God Church.

Why Christians? Of the many justifications offered by al Qaeda and other fanatical groups in Iraq, and by hard-line mullahs in Iran, one is repeated most often: These indigenous Christians are surrogates for Western "crusaders." As early as 1970, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini issued a fatwa accusing Christians in Iran of "working with American imperialists and oppressive rulers to distort the truths of Islam, lead Muslims astray, and convert our children." Fearing a backlash against their institutions and lives, Christians have often made efforts to prove their loyalty, as when Iranian Assyrians wrote to Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei in September denouncing American Christians who wished to burn Qurans as "enemies of God."

But the roots of Christian decline in the Middle East actually date back centuries. In Iran, intolerance toward all non-Muslim minorities took a sharply negative turn from the 16th century onward with the forced Shiification of Iran by the Safavid dynasty. The early 20th century saw pogroms against Armenian, Assyrian, and Greek Christians in the Ottoman Empire and northwestern Iran. Under the Pahlavi shahs, Assyrians, Armenians, Jews, Zoroastrians, and Baha'is regained some of their rights and came to represent the modernizing elements of 20th century society. But the Islamic Revolution of 1979 undercut all those advances. Prejudice and oppression now occurs with impunity.

The numbers speak for themselves: The population of non-Muslims in Iran has dropped by two-thirds or more since 1979. From Iran, these groups flee to Turkey and India -- often at risk to life and limb through the violence-ridden border regions of Iraq and Pakistan. The number of Assyrian Christians in Iran has dwindled from about 100,000 in the mid-1970s to approximately 15,000 today, even as the overall population of the country has swelled from 38 million to 72 million people over the same period. In Iraq, Christians are fleeing in droves. U.N. statistics indicate that 15 percent of all Iraqi refugees in Syria are of Christian background, although they represented only 3 percent of the population when U.S. troops entered in 2003. The U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees estimates that between 300,000 to 400,000 Christians have been forced out of Iraq since 2003. And Christians have left because the message from Sunni militants and Shiite ayatollahs is crystal clear: You have no future here.

There is now an alarming possibility that there will be no significant Christian communities in Iraq or Iran by century's end. Christian schools, communal halls, historical sites, and churches are being appropriated by national and provincial governments, government-sponsored Muslim organizations, and radical Islamist groups. Economic and personal incentives are offered to those who adopt Islam. Last month, the Vatican convened a major summit to find ways of mitigating this crisis, noting that "Christians deserve to be recognized for their invaluable contributions ... their human rights should always be respected, including freedom of worship and freedom of religion."

There is a faint glimmer of hope. On Aug. 5, the U.S. Senate adopted Resolution 322 expressing concern for religious minorities in Iraq. The quick, though unsuccessful, attempt by the Iraqi government this weekend to rescue the Christian hostages appears to have been in response to such American pressure -- no official Iraqi interventions had occurred in previous attacks.

In Iran, however, the persecution of Christians continues unabated. Two Protestant pastors, arrested in post-presidential election crackdowns, face the death penalty. An Assyrian pastor was arrested and tortured in February 2010 and faces trial too.

The Senate resolution noted that "threats against the smallest religious minorities … jeopardize … a diverse, pluralistic, and free society," words applicable in full measure to Iran as well. Will Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's government heed this call? It's doubtful. But one thing's for certain: If the world doesn't champion religious freedom openly and vigorously, he won't have to.

MARWAN IBRAHIM/AFP/Getty Images

 

Eden Naby is a cultural historian of the Middle East. She has taught at the University of Wisconsin and Harvard University. Her book on Assyrian Christians will be published in 2011.
Jamsheed K. Choksy is professor of Iranian and international studies at Indiana University and a member of the National Council on the Humanities.

JACOB BLUES

8:04 AM ET

November 3, 2010

Quick, where's Claude Raines when you need him

The authors are "Shocked? Shocked!" that Christians are fleeing the Middle East due to anti-Christian bigotry and hostility from the Muslim majority.
.
Why the surprise? 60 years ago, the Muslim population did the same thing, quite completely, to its Jewish population.
.
And even today, with a bare remnant population in a few nations, you see the same threats and violence towards such minorities to the point that in Yemen, which had a total Jewish population of approximately 200 people, not only had extremists murdering Jews in the streets and kidnapping their children to become forced converts, but the inability of the national government to protect this community, even after uprooting the remaining families and putting them in the equivelent of protective custody in the capital.
.
Rather than just focus on Iraq, the authors should examine the events that are occuring to the Coptic community in Egypt that are mirroring the situation in Iraq.

 

THAT BLACK GUY

8:33 AM ET

November 3, 2010

oh yes

The religion of peace strikes again!.

(yeah yeah i know they arent all like that, spare me the rhetoric)

 

EGADS

12:08 PM ET

November 3, 2010

Correction

As appalling as the Christian persecution in Iran may be, it must be noted that the Baha'is are actually the largest religious minority in Iran, and have suffered far more at the hands of the Muslim regime than any other religious group. This is not just my opinion - it is well-documented. A report is available right from this article - click on the words "dropped by two-thirds" on page 2 of the article.

 

GUYVER

12:12 PM ET

November 3, 2010

Reality is..

Despite Al-Qaeda’s best efforts, Arab Christians are an integral part of the Middle East and Arab Muslims support their Christian brothers and sisters. Just look at all the condemnations of attack on the Iraqi church in the Arabic media.

 

GUYVER

12:17 PM ET

November 3, 2010

One more thing..

The majority of Christians who left Iraq at the peak of the violence are still in the Middle East; in Syria and Jordan.

 

AVILLA

5:49 PM ET

November 3, 2010

Egypt, too.

My mother is from a Copt family, and she still has many cousins who live in Egypt. The population there is in the tens of millions, I believe. But Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, and Jordan are all a lot better off than Iraq and Iran at the moment. There is a lot of anti-Christian sentiment there (throughout the whole Middle East, really, but especially there) due to the American invasions. It reminds me of what happened with the Phalangists in Lebanon, back in the 80s. There were "retaliation killings" throughout the entire Middle East. Similar things are happening now, I suppose.

It's quite sad. I wish I could say "all that needs to be done is ____", but I can't. The best thing for Christians in Iraq, Iran, and Afghanistan (are there any Christians in Afghanistan anymore?) is honestly to seek asylum elsewhere, even in neighboring countries. It's just not safe anymore.

And to answer the article itself, no, Christianity is not ending in the Middle East. As I said, there are still millions of Christians all through the area, living good and productive lives. But in certain countries in the Middle East? It is conceivable that the Christian populations there could be gone within a couple of generations if the warring continues.

 

AGSOBA83

2:58 PM ET

November 3, 2010

Iraq Invasion

This would not have happened if we had not invaded Iraq. Christians and Muslims were leaving together in peace until we attacked and let loosed the crazy's.

 

SALEEMWARDANI

4:57 PM ET

November 3, 2010

We are All the target

The authors' analysis of the recent tragedy of the Iraqi Chaldean Church in Baghdad misses the point. Just today Iraqis suffered under a horrendous wave of suicide attacks targeting Shi'a communities in Baghdad, with four hundred killed or injured. The culprits in both cases are members of Al-Qaeda. With their wahabbi ideology, their goal is not only to destroy Christians, Jews and people of other faiths, but also Shi'a Muslims and any other Muslim sect that differs from their deviant, extremist ideology. Their reach is not only the Middle East, but rather is global.

Resolution 322 is not the solution. If you want a real solution, pressure your congressmen and government officials to confront the enemy at its source: Saudi Arabia, a state that was founded on wahabbism as its official creed. Until they do so, all other procedures - from airport controls, to legislation such as Resolution 322 - will only be bit-part measures doomed to fail on their own.

 

AEHSAN

2:37 AM ET

November 4, 2010

second that

hear hear

 

WATERSBLESSINGS

2:53 AM ET

November 4, 2010

"end of christianity in the middle east" story oddly incomplete

Thank You for this very illuminating article. But it raises a huge question.
Why is there no mention of Israel's purging of Christians, as well as Muslims, from the occupied Palestinian territories in its quest for exclusivist, ethnocentric Jewish supremacy in Palestine? If Saudi Arabia is guilty of ethnically cleansing Christians, so too is Israel.
This is something honest historians around the world have been protesting for decades, yet the U.S. media buries this story at every level, thanks to the influence of what Walt and Mearsheimer called The Israel Lobby in their book of the same name.
Jerusalem and Bethlehem are Christianity's holiest cities, yet they are being carved up by a policy of driving out the original Palestinian inhabitants -- some descended from the earliest Christians -- and by illegal colonial "settlements" and by the apartheid wall that the International Court of Justice ruled illegal because five-sixths of it stands not on the border between Mandate Palestine and Mandate Israel but on occupied Palestinian lands, in violation of the Geneva Accords and the UN Charter, as well as several other international covenants Israel has signed. The world's fourth mightiest army is slowly, sneakily, dispossessing the indigenous people of Palestine (who even include Jews as well as Christians and Muslims) of their ancestral homelands.
That "separation" wall [the meaning of the Afrikaaner word "apartheid" is the same as the Hebrew word used to refer to the separation wall), designed to separate Palestinians from their land resources and from their loved ones, schools and jobs, was constructed by Israel to expropriate coveted resources as well as to make life so miserable for Palestinian Christians, as well as Muslims, that they will choose to leave for foreign parts rather than continue to be subjected to the gross humiliations of hundreds of checkpoints, curfews, home demolitions, arbitrary and discriminatory laws and military orders, as well as targeted killings, university closures and bombings of hospitals, houses of worship and even United Nations refuge centers.
Once the Christians, and Muslims, of Palestine are driven out, then the Jews can take over their lands with the appearance of doing so legally and nonviolently.
Your exclusive focus on intolerance of religious diversity in extremist Muslim-run states belies the significance for the entire Middle East and its U.S.-subsidized puppet governments of the Jewish excusivism in their midst, also subsidized, more richly than all the others, by the U.S.A., whose Congressmen are mostly bought or intimidated by Israeli spies and lobbyists who seem intent on adding another point to every five-pointed star on the U.S. flag.
I encourage your readers to read the work of Palestinian sociologist Bernard Sabella, which clearly spells out the consequences of Israel's Zionist agenda for Christians of the Holy Land.
American Christians ought to know how pro-Israeli propagandists have been pulling the wool over our collective eyes for decades.
In case anyone imagines my challenge to your readers smacks of anti-semitism, just go to Jewish Voice for Peace for a very clear analysis of the very huge difference between honest Judaism and the state of Israel's colonialist-racist Zionism.
Christians who care about their holy sites in Palestine 48 as well as 67 kid themselves if they imagine Israel has good intentions towards Palestinian Christians any more than the ayatollahs are friendly toward Christians metntioned in Eden Naby and Jamsheed K. Choksy's article,important as it is.
If American Christians knew about this, they'd be unlikely to have nearly as much respect for Israel's spokespeople as they so far have shown.

 

THAT BLACK GUY

4:03 AM ET

November 4, 2010

Well played

I typically dont read longer posts because they tend to be uneducated rants that dont even pertain to the topic being discussed. However you were spot on, and what Walt and Mearsheimer had written is quite interesting ( I read it my first year of grad school). So i may take some time out of my day and look into some of the readings to suggested.

-TBG

 

HANCOCK1

7:54 AM ET

November 5, 2010

Politically correct nonsense.

Politically correct nonsense. Manna for the willlfully blind and willfully blinkered. There is but one apatheid in the ME, it is called dhimminitude and is symbolized by the jizya. And it has been going on unabated for the last 1300 years. And it is a blight upon all Jews, Christians, Zoorastrians, Hindus, Bahais, atheists and gays in the ME. The single exception is Israel. That country has the only stable and growing population of Christians in the ME. The Bahais, a peaceful offshoot of Islam which has the additional misfortune (besides being peaceful) of having its prophet come after Muhammed has long been persecuted by the Iranians, and took the step of having its founders remains reinterred in guess where--Israel. There is an Israel Arab who is a member of Israels Supreme Court, Muslim Israelis receiving tenure at their most prestigious universities--oh my these stubborn, inconvient facts spoiling "the Narrative." Maybe that is why American Christians respect Israel . Not to mention that the standard of living of Israeli Muslims is higher than any and all surrounding Muslim Arab states (which is all surrounding countries).Oh yeah, a recent Reuters article somehow made its way out of the ME--in the Palestinean territories , in Bethlehem, the Christians businessmen are leaving because the Palestinean Authority is not recognizing their deeds and they are being shaken down for a protection tax. I wonder how many other American Christians know of, much less respect, this development.

 

OHREALLY

9:41 AM ET

November 25, 2010

Given your assertion that

Given your assertion that non-Jews in Israel are at least as badly off as those in the Muslim countries of the region, maybe you can explain to me why Israel is the only country in the Asian Middle East (whether the Coptic population in Egypt is also growing is a secret known only to the Egyptian government) whose Christian population is actually increasinig (from about 34,000 in 1948 to about 140,000 today) and has been since the restoration of the Jewish state in 1948. Israel also houses the world headquarters of the Ba'hai faith .

On the other hand, the Christian population in the West Bank, especially in formerly Christian-majority cities like Bethlehem has been dropping for more than half a century, dating back to the two decades during which the area was a part of Jordan. An excellent example would be the comparison of the Christian population in Jerusalem in 1948, which was over 31,000 to the Christian population in 1967 (when the former Jordanian part of Jerusalem was annexed to Israel) whch was less than 13,000. As of 2005, the number of Christians in Jerusalem stood at nearly 16,000. Contrast this to the 1995 Christian population of Bethlehem (the first year that fell under the control of the Palestinian Authority) of around 20,000 and its current Christian population of around 7,500.

Clearly, you are more interested in Israel bashing than in dealing with facts.

 

ANYA KHAN

4:43 PM ET

November 4, 2010

Bigots

And the first comment was racist, a few more and we have a totally anti-semetic rant, with a bigot telling them how great they were.
Idiots

 

DAVID31415926

11:39 PM ET

November 4, 2010