Why I Still Miss Yitzhak Rabin

Fifteen years after the Israeli prime minister's assassination, Israel needs his guiding spirit more than ever.

BY DAVID MAKOVSKY | NOVEMBER 3, 2010

As a journalist, I covered Yitzhak Rabin for the better part of eight years, from 1987 to 1995. During that period, I interviewed him when he was defense minister and in the political opposition, and I covered him when he was prime minister of Israel, during the zenith of the peace process.

Fifteen years ago, on Nov. 4, 1995, Rabin was gunned down by Yigal Amir, a right-wing extremist Jew, as he was leaving a mass rally in Tel Aviv in support of the Oslo Accords. I will never forget where I was when I heard the news of his assassination. While every Israeli was glued to their television and engulfed by grief, I drove through the Israel's deserted streets, from Jerusalem to Tel Aviv, in the middle of the night to the Defense Ministry as the cabinet convened an emergency session to secure the transition of power.

Rabin had extraordinary faith in the people of Israel, even when it led to a fatal misjudgment. I remember attending a tiny cabinet briefing the Sunday before the assassination. It would be Rabin's last. One cabinet minister and Rabin confidant, Binyamin Ben-Eliezer, who had recently been the target of an assault by right-wing extremists himself, begged the prime minister to wear a bullet proof vest while attending the upcoming peace rally.

Ben-Eliezer would subsequently recall a similar Cabinet meeting a few weeks earlier. "I came and pounded on the Cabinet table and warned that a murder could take place," he said. "They silenced me and Rabin came to me, hugged me and told me, 'A Jew that would murder a Jewish minister? That's impossible!'"

Tens of thousands of Israelis commemorated this year's anniversary of Rabin's assassination in Tel Aviv's Rabin Square on Oct. 30, where Israeli President Shimon Peres exhorted the crowd to sustain Rabin's legacy. "We are more determined than the enemies of peace, and therefore we will win," Peres said. "Because we vowed to bring an end to war, for us and our neighbors."

Reporters always loved to cover Rabin: His shyness was masked by his gruff demeanor -- chain-smoking and blunt-speaking - and he was incapable of telling a lie. He would begin answering a question by saying, "Well, I don't want to get into this, but...." I once counted 15 separate news stories that resulted from a relaxed session with journalists, of the kind that Rabin favored when he traveled.

The Middle East has too often been defined by leaders who think that toughness is saying hard things only to the other side. In no small measure, Rabin's greatness lay in his ability to deliver tough truths to his own people. He spoke directly to his public about the need to change national priorities in order to avoid radicalization and achieve peace with Israel's neighbors.

He also challenged Israelis not to take self-pitying comfort in international isolation. He sought to reshape a culture that too often was content with yiyeh b'seder -- "it will be OK."

Rabin was also an avid student of the Middle East. Part of his success in bonding with Jordan's King Hussein came from their visceral understandings that, given the rising wave of radicalism throughout the region, fellow moderates needed to navigate difficult challenges together. He was a master at identifying regional trends and determining their meaning -- long before they became apparent to many other members of Israel's political class.

For example, in the aftermath of the Cold War and 1991 Gulf War, Rabin immediately realized that tectonic shifts presented a remarkable opportunity for Israel. Like nobody else, he cut through the classic diplomatic conundrum: "If you are weak, you cannot afford to compromise and if you are strong, there is no need for compromise." He understood that it was in Israel's best interest to reach peace with the Palestinians at the peak of Israel's power, which had then been facilitated by regional and international change.

DAVID AKE/Getty Images

 

David Makovsky is the Ziegler distinguished fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, where he directs the Project on the Middle East Peace Process. He is also the co-author of Myths,Illusions, and Peace: Finding a New Direction for America in the Middle East.

SAWADEE

4:08 AM ET

November 4, 2010

Not to change the subject...

...but I often will see stories like this, but I have never seen one that asked, "Why I Still Have Never Seen A Palestinian Yitzhak Rabin".

And, it rhymes. So, that's something, too.

 

JACOB BLUES

8:11 AM ET

November 4, 2010

Israeli's have a more nuanced view of their own history

Shmuel Rosner wrote an insightful piece today. It's worth reading:
.
http://www.slate.com/id/2273370/

 

JACOB BLUES

2:56 PM ET

November 4, 2010

Lol, slow moving coup

I guess that's what you call several democratic elections where the voters actually choose their political leadership.
.
Nice.
.
Of course, you cannot imagine Israel defending its own history when faced by more lawfare conducted by the Arab states. After all, if Jews are allowed to protect their own history, soon they'll be demanding a state of their own, and where would that lead?!?
.
That the idea of Israel being concerned about Palestinian plans to call the Tomb of the Patriarchs and Rachel's Tomb, mosques, misses the reality, that when Joseph's tomb was handed over to Palestinian control after a firefight back in 2001, they immediately razed the structure, burning sacred Jewish texts, and did, turn it into a mosque, claiming that there was no Jewish presence there.
.
But hey, what else should we expect from someone who can view Jews in their homeland as "Aliens", and is preparing his own nuclear holocaust, when shots aren't even being fired.

 

BENIYYAR

8:16 AM ET

November 5, 2010

Rabin was the worst Prime Minister in Israel's history

Rabin is now considered by most Israelis to have been the most divisive, religiously and culturally ignorant, least charismatic, and emotionally cold Prime Ministers in Israeli history. Even Rabin's own family now tries to put across the idea that Rabin, even before his assassination, was planning on putting an end to the Oslo Accords experiment. Rabin was a confirmed alcoholic, this according to his good friend President Ezer Weitzman, and Rabin's foul, coarse, and abusive language towards his political rivals and even Israelis who opposed his policies, would seem to bear this out. Rabin was famous for cursing anyone who disagreed with him and once publicly proclaimed that he did not "give a damn" about the "mere 2% of the population" of Israeli settlers, even referring to their protests as having no more meaning than "spinning propellors!" Indeed, during the three nightmare years that Rabin held power, and Israeli Jews were being slaughtered by the hundreds by Palestinian terrorists, the Rabin government never sent a minister or government representative to a single funeral, shiva, or the shloshim of an Israeli Jew murdered by Palestinians. In fact, when a Jewish settler was murdered in cold blood by a Palestinian terrorist while shopping in a Palestinian shop, Rabin cynically and publicly asked, "What was he doing shopping there anyway?" rather than condemn the unprovoked killing. Indeed, the Rabin government barely lifted a finger to protect Israeli Jews from the Arafat terrorist onslaught. The catastrophic and blood soaked Olso Accords could only have been negotiated by a confirmed and out of control drunk like Rabin, no sane or sober person would ever have committed such a lunatic travesty. Especially with Yassir Arafat, easily the greatest danger and the biggest mass murderer of the Jewish People since Adolf Hitler. But Rabin didn't just make a deal with Arafat, he actually brought Arafat's Palestine Liberation Army into the heart of Israel, supplied, subsidized, and helped train that terrorist militia, which immediately turned it's rather formidable arsenal on innocent Israelis men, women, children, and babies murdering hundreds and maiming thousands. Rabin was a divisive, polarizing, and abusive Israeli politician whose reign was instrumental in destroying his Labor Party, but Rabin was also a delusional drunk who negotiated the worst, most dangerous, and certainly most lethal agreement the Oslo Accords, which left thousands of Israelis dead and maimed for life, with Israel's most despicable enemy Yassir Arafat and the PLO.
If David Makovsky really misses Yitzchak Rabin he is terribly and fundamentally misinformed about the Rabin the man, the politician, and the diplomat. For most Israelis, at least those of us who managed to survive the Rabin era alive and mostly intact, there are no words too bitter, no curses too mean, and no punishment too severe for Rabin.

 

ABRAHAMCILD

11:01 AM ET

November 15, 2010

Rabin was the worst Prime Minister

More over Oslo obligated klip izle the Palestinians to provide gazeteler security for the Israeli Occupation, and Arafat was willing to go out and seek funding to train his goon filmcin squads who terrorized the people and kept tatil them in line