Oleg Kashin's Horrible Truth

A journalist is beaten nearly to death in Moscow. Is this a deliberate crackdown, or something more subtle -- and more sinister?

BY JULIA IOFFE | NOVEMBER 6, 2010

The paramedics reached 30-year-old journalist Oleg Kashin Saturday morning at 12:40 a.m. He was lying outside the door to his apartment building in central Moscow, his face bloodied, his legs mangled, the ground covered in blood. "He showed his hand to the doctor so he could see it was all broken," a neighbor told TV reporters. The toll, tallied by various news sources, was chilling: two broken jaws, one broken leg, a fractured skull at the temple and a heavy concussion, blood in the lungs, fingers partially torn off at the joints, one of them later amputated. By the time Moscow woke up to the news on Saturday, Kashin was already in an artificially induced coma.

At Kommersant, the newspaper where Kashin works, no one doubted that the attack was related to his journalism. "The thing that bothers me is that at the moment of the beating, they broke his fingers," the editor in chief said in a radio interview. "It is completely obvious that the people who did this did not like what he was saying and what he was writing." Kashin's iPhone, wallet, and other personal belongings remained on his person, untouched.

There was no shortage of theories about why Kashin was targeted. Many pointed instantly at United Russia's youth wing, Molodaya Gvardia, which openly threatened Kashin in an August article on its website. It was titled, in the hyperbolic, hyphenated language of early Soviet propaganda, "Journalist-traitors need to be punished!" "They have betrayed their homeland, they have spit on their civic duty!" it blared, adding Kashin to a list of others needing to be punished. Kashin's sin was daring to interview one of the radical anti-fascist protestors who attacked a local government building while protesting the cutting down of the Khimki forest this summer. That interview was not particularly inflammatory -- in fact, Kashin took a stern line with the young hoodlum -- but it brought the police to Kommersant's offices, asking the paper to turn over Kashin's email.

Russian journalists are usually killed or attacked because they threaten powerful financial or economic interests. The chopping down of the Khimki forest to make room for a highway between Moscow and St. Petersburg has exactly those interests behind it: It was being financed by Arkady Rotenberg, Vladimir Putin's judo buddy, and Putin proclaimed this summer, amid growing protests, that "all decisions have been made." That is, the road would be built as planned. (This remains the silent consensus in Moscow, despite Medvedev's August moratorium.)

Moreover the attack on Kashin seems to fit a disturbing pattern. Only a few days ago, Khimki activist Konstantin Fetisov was attacked with a baseball bat when he got out of his car in front of his Moscow home. The left side of his head was bashed in. His wife later found a fragment of the bat that had splintered off from the force of the blow. Like Kashin, Fetisov remains in an artificially induced coma and in serious condition.

Kashin's case most resembles a far earlier one, however. In the spring of 2008, Mikhail Beketov, a local journalist in Khimki who sought to expose the corruption behind the road, was beaten and left unconscious and bleeding in front of his house. He too slipped into a coma. There are eerie similarities between this attack and Kashin's: Beketov's legs were so brutally beaten that one had to be amputated, and he suffered such severe brain damage that he can now barely speak. But his hands were the most symbolic, chilling target. Three of Beketov's mangled fingers had to be amputated. Whoever got Beketov, and whoever got Kashin, wanted to make sure they never wrote again.

Max Avdeev

 SUBJECTS: RUSSIA, EASTERN EUROPE
 

Julia Ioffe is Foreign Policy's Moscow correspondent.

STEFKO1

12:51 AM ET

November 7, 2010

Oleg Kashin's Horrible Truth

Has any journalist murdered since Putin came to power in Russia (he still is imho) ever resulted in the murderer being found and charged by the Russian Justice System? Or were the only ones ever charged just "fall guys"?

By the way, Nashi and Moloda Gvardiya should be banned in Russia. But then again what can one do if these organizations take up the slogans of the legal parties in Russia? Zhirinovsky, despite vitriolic xenophobic language, does not get banned but becomes Deputy Speaker in Russia's Duma, while liberals and democrats have had to fight just for renting halls for political gatherings. What a sad abysmal society has been created under Chekist Putin. Lucky us Russia is modernizing its nuclear arsenal in spite of all the myriad domestic problems and crises. That is prioritizing.

 

CAMAELJAX

12:55 AM ET

November 7, 2010

Inhoffe's liberast martyr narrative

"And, unlike the journalists who have been killed, attacked, or harrassed in Russia during the last decade, Kashin is not a fringe or opposition figure. When I first met him, in the winter of 2006, to interview him about the politics of young Russians -- his specialty -- he struck me as a Kremlin apologist. Kommersant is Russia's most prominent daily, a mainstream paper owned by Medvedev buddy and mining mogul Alisher Usmanov.

I was, of course, wrong about Kashin. He is not an apologist but is, in the best traditions of his generation, simply hard to categorize. He covers youth movements for his paper, and he is equally unsparing in his coverage of both the pro-Kremlin organizations, like Nashi and Molodaya Gvadia, and the opposition ones, like the Yabloko and Antifa movements.

Julia Inhoffe never likes a Russian citizen unless she can shoehole them somewhere into her martyred liberast - against the evil Kremlin internal narrative...Kashin, it is a tragedy what happened to you, but on the upside - now that your have been beaten nearly to death and she has found a way to utiliize you as a non-responsive tool into her anti-Kremlin crusade , Julia Inhoffe likes you! See its not all bad, is it...every cloud has a silver lining :P

 

GENNY

3:21 PM ET

November 8, 2010

"Wir weben, wir weben"

as a German romantic said sometime.
***
Among other recent manifestations of savegery in the Russia, one of the most prominent and almost equaling to the beating of Oleg Kashin, was the reaction of Madam Matvienko to the clash between an ex-cop who took revenge against lady teacher for broken lip of his daughter: "He should be turned out of Leningrad". All the criminals of any sort could quitely enjoy the hospitality of the city, but the wayward ex-cop.

 

OTUS

3:39 PM ET

November 8, 2010

Beware

Ms Ioffe is not very a terribly accurate journalist.

"...a holiday weekend that was once intended to celebrate the anniversary of the Bolshevik Revolution, but is now called, inexplicably, National Unity Day"

Quite explicably, Julia, quite:

- the Bolshevik Revolution happened on November 7th, 1917;
- the regular Polish troops were expelled from the Moscow Kremlin by the All-Russian Militia on November 4th, 1612.

So, the National Unity Day commemorates the united stand of all Russians against the invaders. Didn't you know about this? Didn’t you, really?

Speaking journalists in Russia in general, they get killed from time to time... for very different reasons. Twice less frequent than during Eltsin's time, by the way.

It is an utter lie of Mr Stefko1.

Khlebnikov, an American journalist of a Russian descent, was murdered by Chechen criminals after he wrote a book named Interview with a Barbarian (devoted to the Chechen criminals and terrorists).

Zimin was killed by a Moldavian guy who accepted invitation into Zimin's flat but did not like an offer of having sex.

Politkovskaya was likely to be murdered by a gang of Chechen and Russian criminals. They are found and are under investigation.

Listyev's murderers are found. The organizer is not but following the Quid prodest rule he may possibly be found in London (Listyev banned advertizing on his TV channel and one of the guys residing in London had conflicting commercial interests; soon after the murder the ban was lifted).

So on, so forth.

Speaking about Kashin in particular, the best we can do is to wait and see. Ms Ioffe's desire to use the tragedy in her own interests by making allegations not grounded on the facts is, in my view, quite disgusting.

 

GENNY

4:14 PM ET

November 8, 2010

Good statistics

"Twice less frequent than during Eltsin's time, by the way" - I like this. And may be twenty times less then in road accidents at any time. But you missed the symphonic finale: We all die!

 

OTUS

4:36 PM ET

November 8, 2010

symphonic finale

are favoured by those who cannot present facts.

How about that, Jenny?

 

STEFKO1

7:48 PM ET

November 8, 2010

gimme a break

You believe Politkovskaya's killers have been found and/or those who organized it? Why don't you ask the late Anna Politkovskaya's family if they are satisfied with the investigation? Russia has an independent criminal judiciary? News to me. All power is Vertical with the Khan at the top, as in old days.

OTUS, let me guess: you may be one of those who believes all Russian Television News is fair and independent? When was the last time Russian T.V. ever reported a Negative Story on Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin? Most Russians get their news from Russian Television which you surely must know follows the line of Good Czar Putin. In the U.S., American Television will criticize Democrats and Tea Partiers alike. On Russian T.V., negative coverage of Putin is off-bounds. Yeah, some will listen to Ekho Moskvy radio, but most rely on T.V. and way too many Russians of the Soviet State remain stuck in the mentality of Homo Sovieticus, quick to defend the Chekist/Oligarchic Regime now running Russia.

I see you feel the bloody Bolshevik coup and Revolution of October 1917 should remain a holiday and that one can also mark the victory of the Muscovite Tsar in the same holiday when the Reds who killed the Czar. Yes, Red Czar or White Czar: it is all the same - Great Russian Imperialism - to people in such pro-Kremlin youth groups like Nashi.

OTUS, what do you think of youth groups like Nashi in Russia? Putin bristles at the suggestion of moving the killer LENIN from his place of honor on the Mausoleum in Moscow, and Putin lays flowers at DENIKIN's grave. These are today's Russia's heroes: not democrats, humanitarians, but a Red Killer and a White.

 

OTUS

9:09 PM ET

November 8, 2010

1. Relatives are often not

1. Relatives are often not satisfied. However, as far as I know, the chief editor of her newspaper has no serious complains about investigation.
2. No, Russian courts are not fully independent (the same is true with regard to almost any other country). However, political influence is a minor problem – the main problem is lateral and vertical “connections” and bribery.
3. Your guess muffs a shot. Don’t speak like an infant. I do not watch TV. The US TV is, by the way, no better than Russian - apart from The Daily Show.:)
4. I see you pretend to be not understanding of what I was speaking about: the Russian people, not Tsar, freed the country form the bloody invaders. That happened 400 years ago. However, we keep the memory of those who organized and led the militia – Minin and Pozharsky. Their monument is on the Red Square, come and see.
5. Great Russian Imperialism? What about Great British Imperialism, Great French Imperialism, Great American Imperialism, Great German Imperialism, Great Spanish…? Were they better or may be worse? Was it Russia who captured India and both Americas murdering millions and millions? Was it Russia who started wars at the end of 18 century and 2 World Wars? Let’s count the times when the West invaded Russia and then the times when Russia invaded the West, will you dare?
6. I do not like Nashi and I do not like ne-nashi – they are worth each other.
7. I do not like Lenin but, like Putin, I believe that we should respect the feelings of millions of old people who respect Lenin and that there is no rush to move him out of Mausoleum – in fact, just a small group of idiots demands this to be made promptly.
8. Denikin was a hero of WWI –and a leader of the legitimate force in the Civil War. He lost. He then supported the Red Army in its fight against Hitler. I respect him.

 

GENNY

4:55 PM ET

November 9, 2010

The facts are what we do

it's about that

 

ROFFRED

6:59 PM ET

November 8, 2010

Otus, you obviously have all

Otus, you obviously have all the answers. The fact that 30 journalists have been beaten up this year in Russia is just trivial and people who report on it should be sneered at.

KInda like Putin who laughed at Politkovskaya's death.

 

ROFFRED

7:00 PM ET

November 8, 2010

Otus, you obviously have all

Otus, you obviously have all the answers. The fact that 30 journalists have been beaten up this year in Russia is just trivial and people who report on it should be sneered at.

KInda like Putin who laughed at Politkovskaya's death.

 

OTUS

8:30 PM ET

November 8, 2010

Roffred, you obviously know what I have

better then myself.

No, I do not have all answers. I have vrain. It helps.

Roffred, using demagoguery is a clear sign of loosing a dispute. You are the looser.

No, 30 beaten journalists is not trivial (although I suspect that you might be cheating by adding those who were beaten as a result of crimes not connected with their professional activity). And there are many "not trivial" facts, for instance, 21,371 murders of Russian citizens in 2009 (but this number IS going down: compare with 33,553 in 1998). So what? You kinda slept 20 years and woke up yesterday? You want Mr Medvedev to make it all nice for you by tomorrow?

Sorry, it will, perhaps, take another 2 generations.

 

STEFKO1

11:12 PM ET

November 8, 2010

Objecting to OTUS's Sovok Propaganda

OTUS, before dealing with your 10 Point Sovok Power Presentation praising the White Russians, the U.S.S.R., and the Tsars all in one post, it bears sticking with the subject about which Julia posted: the murder and assault on Russian journalists who speak the truth to power. I don't believe one journalist in Russia has ever been killed or beaten for praising F.S.B. spook Putin, whom you state you like (gee, surprise, surprise). Indeed, today another journalist in Russia has been assaulted as we post on this story:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-11711132

As to your Russian Soviet drivel comparing the U.S. to Putinstan, well, as broken as it may seem, the rule of law holds the day in the West and the judiciary is independent. There is a division of powers in the U.S., and the legislative branch came close to impeaching the executive under Clinton. In Russia, it is all Vertical Power. Ever heard of corruption in the Russian militia, police, F.S.B.? What did Yuri Shevchuk say to Putin's face? Are you from Moscow?

Yes, you praise Denikin. O.K. do you praise the Black Hundreds? Hey they were Russian! What about Kolchak who believed in the Elders of the Protocol of Zion: is he a Russian hero? Your country recently made a big film about him. Russian hero?

Your comparison of the press in Russia to that in the West is farcical. Russia has no diversity of opinion as U.S. t.v. news has from Fox to MSNBC. I quite enjoy Russian T.V.s version and conspiracies as to the whys behind such stories as the Anna Chapman spy saga (really does remind one of the old Soviet agitprop). In the U.S. a journalist say from the New York Post is not killed one week in downtown N.Y. for something the journalist wrote against the President, followed a week later by a beating of a Chicago Sun-Times reporter next week who wrote same, and on. But this stuff happens in Russia to brave journalists. I am so glad you take Putin's side. Such courage on your part. Follow the Tsar.

You like the Lenin Mausoleum, eh? Well, why not a statue to the Founder of Putin's favorite Soviet organization: the Secret Police, namely Cheka founder Feliks Dzherzhinsky? Moscow ex-mayor Luzhkov wanted to erect same to please Putin? Speaking of monuments, where are the monuments in Putin's Russia to the millions upon millions killed by the Russian Communist Regime. Where are the plaques? Nothing: it is a sick society that honors Lenin while authorities raid the offices of organizations such as Memorial dedicated to exposing and remembering the millions of lives lost at the hands of your Lenin and Stalin.

World War Two? Gee, why do they call it the Great Fatherland War in Russia (1941-45), avoiding 1939-41 when Soviet Russia supplied Nazi Germany with raw materials and a naval base for the Nazis to kill the Brits and French? What was the N.K.V.D. doing this time in the Baltics, Poland, western Ukraine, and attacking Finland? Ever heard of Katyn?

Enough of your sovok trush, and let's hope less Russians think the way you do. It is up to Russians to stop finally defending every single bandit who occupied(s) the Kremlin. The PutinJugend is training a new generation in this technique which bodes ill for Russia's future.

 

OTUS

6:29 AM ET

November 9, 2010

STEPKO1

I have no interest in discussing any further with a childish liar like you, sorry.

Just a few examples from your post:

1. "Yes, you praise Denikin. O.K. do you praise the Black Hundreds? Hey they were Russian!"

Hey, you praise (suppose) George Washington? Do you praise slavery and slave-holders? Hey, they were Americans!

What is a connection between a liberal-minded self-made general and the Black Hundreds? I bet much less than between Washington and the slave-holders.:)

Yes, Kolchak is a hero – one of the best Navy officers fighting in WWI, a famous Arctic explorer, a patriot and a man of dignity; no matter what he believed in and what mistakes he made, absolutely unimportant what you think or tell about him – his name is in the history and on the map. But still, you are lying again. The truth, my dear liar, is quite different. For instance, a Jew was the Chairman of the Temporary Government of the autonomous Siberia – that is one of the top officials of the Kolchak’s administration...

2. “You like the Lenin Mausoleum, eh?”

My words: “I do not like Lenin… but believe that we should respect the feelings of millions of old people”

3. “In the U.S. a journalist say from the New York Post is not killed one week in downtown N.Y. for something the journalist wrote against the President, followed a week later by a beating of a Chicago Sun-Times reporter next week who wrote same, and on.”

This does not happen in Russia too. If I am not mistaken, starting from 2000, 22 journalists were killed in Russia. It is a bad track record (just to compare: 4 in the USA, 20 in Colombia) but far from what you are saying. Not all of them were killed in connection with their professional activity, some of them were killed at war (Yatsina - kidnapped, tortured and murdered by the Chechen "freedom fighters"; Yefremov - killed by a land mine; Scott - joined a gang of Chechen terrorists, illegally crossed together with them the Georgian-Russian border and was killed during a fight with Russian troops - frankly, that one received what he was begging for) and none of them (apart from Scott) was killed by the State. I gave the names, the facts and the figures – you reply with clumsy exaggerations and a pointless bla-bla-bla. You look shallow. Bye-bye

 

GOIKO

7:54 AM ET

November 14, 2010

On Young Guard

I like the passage about the Molodaya Gvardia and fashist march. The writer wants just to mix everything together to make a story. First of all I am not a fan of Young Guard, but this organisation is nothing to do with Nationalist march and just has a different ideology, maybe not good enough but not fashist. Second about Mr. Fetisov. I wish him a fast recovery and my prayers are with him as well as with Oleg. But my collegues however seen Mr Fetisov on a hard-liners march holding flag of his liberal party (bizzare enough) Secondly he spoke about creating some cooperation with hard-line DPNI anti-immigration group. Funny enough for such strange bed fellows.
Tell you something also I myself including many other reporters attacked Oleg on the blog, distrubuted by his writing, because he is a provocative. I also have his book about former Soviet officials as one of the best journalism pieces. So I dont think that some guys in Molodaya Gvardia who wrote bizzare pamphlets wanted him to be killed. You just one of those a la Latinina people who want to see Putin everythere. This is sad.

 

CRIIS_ALFONSO

11:51 AM ET

November 15, 2010

Let's wait until Putin

Not all of them tatil were killed in connection klip izle with their gazeteler professional activity, some of them were killed at war (Yatsina - kidnapped, filmcin tortured and murdered by the Chechen