Echoes of the Drug War

Even in Mexico's most elite locales, it's impossible to escape the reverberations of cartel violence.   

BY CHRISTINA LARSON | NOVEMBER 17, 2010

Puebla, MEXICO-My hotel on the outskirts of Puebla, a city of 1.3 million in central Mexico, looks out over a rolling golf course lined with palm trees and beyond that a busy highway flanked by Mazda and Mercedes car dealerships. The historic downtown has colonial Spanish architecture. Newer areas of the city boast gated subdivisions, Home Depot outlets, and strip malls. I came to attend a technology conference, "Ciudad de las Ideas," now in its third year and featuring such international luminaries as Malcolm Gladwell and Chris Anderson as speakers. This is first-world Mexico, as swanky and cosmopolitan as anywhere in the United States or Europe. The slice of elite Mexican society at the conference sports iPhones and Chanel bags, sips Starbucks coffee, and, upon hearing that I'm American, waxes on about vacations in Miami and San Diego.

In other words, I'm not in newspaper Mexico: the Mexico that has been so obviously ravaged by the country's brutal drug wars over the past half decade. Mexico's chattering classes are removed not just geographically but, it would seem, psychologically, from the more grisly images we've seen on the news this year, mostly from northern Mexico: 13 young people slaughtered at a birthday party in the border town of Juárez; teenage drug-cartel recruits wielding machetes in homemade torture videos; beheaded bodies left on the white-sand beaches of Acapulco; the bullet-ridden corpses of six blind-folded former drug-runners rotting beside a coastal highway with hand-written notes from the killers (a tactic to intimidate rival gang members). Since 2006, an estimated 30,000 people have died in violence arising from the activity of increasingly powerful Mexican drug cartels. "It is not only the amount of violence that's terrible; it is the spectacular nature of the violence -- the elaborate style of the executions," Mexican journalist Sergio Sarmiento told me. In the largest outbreak of violence since the Mexican revolution 100 years ago, both the recruits and the victims appear to be getting younger -- giving rise to talk of a "lost generation." 

About 90 percent of the violence has taken place in a handful of northern counties, far away from the swimming pools and gated villas of Puebla. Yet, these two Mexicos -- the privileged and the desperate -- are not so far apart as it may seem. Drug violence doesn't often come to Puebla, but drug cartel leaders -- like other successful Mexican businessmen -- do. In September, one of the country's most notorious cartel leaders, Sergio "El Grande" Villarreal Barragan, was arrested in Puebla by 30 Mexican marines. "Puebla is perceived as a place that is largely free from violence -- which, surely, must be as attractive to a drug lord as it is to me," Pedro Ángel Palou, a Puebla-based novelist, wrote in the New York Times. Yet that perception is changing: "We too, in a sense, are trapped in Puebla. In my neighborhood, where the roads are still unpaved, we live behind high walls and electrified or barbed-wire fences ... no matter the lengths we go to preserve our tranquility, violence infringes." 

In Mexico City, I spoke with Gabriella Gomez-Mont, an artist and senior TED fellow, who explained the cultural echoes of drug violence this way: "To see death and violence every day on the TV and newspapers, you think it doesn't affect people? Some people feel directly threatened, but for others it simply opens up an imaginarium of violence. There is a sense of impunity people feel. Even crimes not related to drugs ... are becoming more violent." 

Getty Images/Spencer Platt

 SUBJECTS: MEXICO, LATIN AMERICA
 

Christina Larson is a Schwartz fellow at the New America Foundation and a contributing editor at Foreign Policy.

ZXXVII

10:55 AM ET

November 17, 2010

DRUG WAR: Ciudad Juárez, 2008-2010. A photographic testimony

Dear Friends,

I am trying to raise awareness about what is going on here in Ciudad Juarez. I work as a professor at Universidad Autonoma de Chihuahua in Juarez, and I have met many persons affected by this sad situation. Less than a month ago, a young student was shot by Federal Police officers during a march.

If it serves your interests please share the links below; if not, please excuse my nerve and kindly disregard this message.

The inhabitants of Ciudad Juarez repudiate the violence that has plagued our city for the past 30 months.
Men and women of good; we have seen friends and relatives succumb to the bullets, we have seen our neighbors closing down their businesses and losing their means of living. We are afraid to drive through our streets. We feel constant fear, now we distrust each other.

We cannot resort to the authorities, throughout this time we have been victims of their greed and abuse. Our leaders are indifferent and incompetent. They only simulate a void interest and do little to remedy the situation. With empty words they present, as an official version, a picture outside our everyday reality, while making every effort to hide the shameful events that repeat day after day in this border town.

Our only recourse is to raise our voice to the international community. To submit our testimony and show to the world the extermination acts of which we are victims today.
We want men and women from all countries to know what is really happening in Ciudad Juarez.

I have spoken before students and professors; If you are interested, I can offer a presentation.

Thank you for reading. Feel free to contact me should you have any questions.

Guillermo Cervantes, Ph. D.
zxxvii@gmail.com

Feel free to print or publish any information from these links:

Ciudad Juárez, México. 2008-2010,

A photographic testimony of our pain: http://www.ciudadjuarez2008-2010.com

Un testimonio fotográfico de nuestro dolor: http://ciudadjuarez2008-2010esp.blogspot.com/

 

BENDAVIS6

10:15 PM ET

November 17, 2010

Victims of policy

I am surprised by the statement that "Others argue that the violence would have shot up regardless of the president's policies, due to the existence of an estimated 7 million "ni nis" -- young people who neither work nor study and have little opportunity to make money outside of cartels -- victims of both Mexico's sluggish economy and predatory drug bosses."

The proliferation of "ni-nis" is in fact a direct result of the policy of the Calderon administration (as well as former governments of both PAN and PRI) of keeping wages low by systematically (and often violently) suppressing democratic trade unions, to stimulate exports. In the past this policy was partially offset by migration to the US; since 2008 this safety valve has closed, increasing social pressure. The government has therefore resorted to increasingly violent repression, particularly of the mineworkers' union (see http://imfmetal.org/index.cfm?n=663&l=2). Unfortunately, the security forces that are supposed to be fighting the drug war are instead devoting a significant amount of their time to repressing worker rights.

 

CANKATX2

9:21 PM ET

November 18, 2010

DRUG WAR: Ciudad Juárez

We have seen our neighbors tatil closing down their businesses and losing their means of living. We are afraid to drive through fix it pro our streets. We feel constant fear, sinema now we distrust each other.

 

ROWLEY

7:26 PM ET

November 22, 2010

Mexico

Mexico sealed it's fate when it went down the socialist /communist path and nationalized it's resources and allowed the Communist Unions power.
With the natural resources and free enterprise capitalism, Mexico had every chance to become as affluent as the rest of North America.
Corrupt dictatorial ideology was their own ruin.
So sad to see such promise lost.