Triumph in New Delhi

Critics have assailed Obama's Asia trip as a failure. They're ignoring the strategic victory that the president won in India.

BY ASHLEY J. TELLIS | NOVEMBER 16, 2010

If U.S. President Barack Obama was hoping for some quick victories during his trip to Asia after the "shellacking" that his Democratic Party took in the recent midterm elections, he might have come away disappointed. During the G-20 summit in Seoul, the much-anticipated U.S.-South Korea free trade agreement fell through, partially over fears that a newly hostile Congress would scuttle it. And while Obama had harsh words for China's decision to keep its currency artificially low, he was thwarted in his attempt to rally the world's largest economies to pressure China to change its policy. Even in Indonesia, where the president is hailed as a homecoming king, some locals grumbled about his decision to cut short his visit due to eruptions from a newly active volcano.

In response, some pundits have dubbed Obama's Asia tour a failure. In fact, the exact opposite is true. In India, where the stakes of the trip were highest, the president's visit was a ringing success -- and one that will have repercussions long after these temporary setbacks have been forgotten.

Although the White House advertised the visit as being largely about securing American jobs through increased Indian imports, Obama's words and actions confirmed that he was pursuing a broader agenda: affirming India's importance in the emerging Asian order, affirming its role as a global rather than as a local South Asian power, and deepening its inclusion in the institutions of global governance.

The visit marked the first time that Obama himself provided clear and unmistakable judgments about India. "In Asia and around the world, India is not simply emerging," Obama said both at a news conference and in speaking to India's Parliament. "India has emerged."

Responding to this reality, Obama endorsed, for the first time ever, India's claim to a permanent seat on the United Nations Security Council. His support for India -- over treaty allies like Germany and other claimants such as Brazil -- spoke volumes about the importance that the United States places on its alliance with India as an emerging power. "It can be said definitively now: with US President Barack Obama's India visit, the long shadow that the Cold War cast on India-US ties has been dispelled," the Times of India responded in its lead editorial. "Instead of looking to the past, the relationship has been recast for the 21st century."

Obama also announced a far-reaching initiative that expands India's access to U.S. high-tech equipment. In exchange for an Indian commitment to continually upgrade its export control system, an important step toward tightening the global nonproliferation regime, Obama declared that the United States would permit India to purchase previously restricted commodities, such as systems useful for defense and space applications. He also pledged to support India's membership in the four critical global nonproliferation regimes so that India could become part of the rule-making institutions that oversee commerce in nuclear, missile, chemical, and military technologies.

Daniel Berehulak/Getty Images

 

Ashley J. Tellis is a senior associate at the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. This article is adapted from newly published report, “Obama in India: Building a Global Partnership: Challenges, Risks, Opportunities.”

SHIVEH

12:34 PM ET

November 17, 2010

Empires come; Empires go . . . arrogance leads.

So we are prepping India to stand up to China. England used this strategy till she realized every country they tried to control has surpassed them.

Starting a military buildup in India will force China to speed up its own buildup. Pretty soon we’ll be forced to divert even more resources to our own military. Spending money we do not have and wasting resources we need to just stay afloat in this global economy will eventually lead us to where England is now.

On another note, FP should start billing people who use the site for free advertisement?

 

MILANOCHIL

9:11 PM ET

November 18, 2010

Empires come

Spending money we do not have and wasting resources we need to just stay afloat in this global economy will eventually abtronic x2 lead us to where England is now.

 

OPSUDRANIA

12:24 PM ET

November 19, 2010

Obama's Asian Trip

I would agree with Ashley Tellis. He is an accompliced author and an expert on South Asian issues with a deep insite into terrorism related problems in this subcontinent.

Although I agree with him but with a note of caution to India that all is not gold that glitters. US is itself a dubious nation like Pakistan and India should not ignore her own interests especially security related issues coming from across her northwestern borders. China is far more reliable as she is a clever neighbour as compared to a lunatic other one.

Unless and untill US gives up her obsession with Pakistan, India should exercise caution. Having said so, I have no doubts in the sincerity of Mr Obama.
God bless
Dr. O. P. Sudrania