Mr. 'Zero Problems'

Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu sat down with Foreign Policy's managing editor Blake Hounshell in Doha, Qatar, this fall to discuss his side of the Iran-Brazil-Turkey triangle. Edited excerpts follow.
The FP Top 100 Global Thinkers
The ListThe FP SurveyTake the SurveyThe Book Club

INTERVIEW BY BLAKE HOUNSHELL | DECEMBER 2010

Blake Hounshell: This year, one of the most dramatic events in world politics was when Turkey and Brazil joined up to cut a fuel-swap deal with Iran over its enriched uranium. And that was seen by many as a watershed moment: Here you have two rising powers taking matters into their own hands and trying to solve an important global problem. Obviously it hasn't succeeded yet. Why not? And what is your response to critics who say that Turkey and Brazil were naive in thinking that Iran was willing to do a serious deal?

Ahmet Davutoglu: First of all, "taking matters into their own hands" -- this phrase should be clarified. Turkey and Brazil, both of these countries are members of the United Nations Security Council. When we were being elected to the Security Council, our commitment to the world community who elected us was that we will be working hard, we will be doing everything possible in order to make sure that there is no tension in international relations, that there will be no threat of war, and we will be working for diplomatic solutions. This was our commitment, both for Turkey and Brazil. So it was not something we decided. It was our commitment.

Secondly, we did not decide alone. This idea of a swap deal was discussed between the P5+1 [the five permanent Security Council members plus Germany] and Iran before our initiative. And former IAEA Director-General Mohamed ElBaradei developed this formulation and approached us to ask whether Turkey could work with both sides in order to store Iran's 3.5 percent enriched uranium in Turkey as a confidence-building [measure]. And we consulted with our allies. All of them agreed; Iran agreed; and so we started this initiative. And we worked very hard, together with Brazil, over eight months of hectic diplomacy from October to May. At the end of the day Iran accepted the swap deal, and we announced the agreement in Tehran.

And I always said this was not the success only of Turkey and Brazil, but this is the success of President Obama's policy of engagement and multilateralism. If there was no policy of engagement and multilateralism, this agreement would not have been possible.

BH: Do you think President Obama is moving away from engagement and trying to build new relationships in the world?

AD: I don't think President Obama has abandoned the policy of engagement. Even on the day when the U.N. sanctions were passed against Iran, President Obama declared that the diplomatic track is still on and they are ready to negotiate with Iran.

I always like Winston Churchill's phrase: It is not the end. It is not the beginning. It is the end of the beginning. All these processes are ends of the beginning.

BH: Who would you say has had the biggest impact on your thinking as an intellectual and as a foreign-policy practitioner?

AD: Of course as intellectuals there are many people who really had an influence on me. For example, Plato in his dialogues has interesting things to say about ideals and practice.

BH: A Turkish foreign minister citing a Greek thinker.

AD: Yes, of course! For us, he is not only a Greek thinker; he is our thinker, because if you read the works of Ottoman scholars of the 16th century, all of these Greek scholars were addressed as "our masters." So for us, they represent the history of all traditions, and theirs are the values of humanity.

And of course I'm influenced by many other leaders like Gandhi, as a practitioner and as a visionary trying to use unconventional new methods to achieve political objectives. In order to achieve peace, you have to be creative.

In 2003, when I became chief advisor [to the prime minister], in one of the first interviews I gave I said, "We have to have zero problems with our neighbors." Many people thought, "Typical utopian academic. How, given the reality of Turkey's relations with its neighbors, can you achieve this?" And, in the last eight years, under the leadership and political stability of Prime Minister Erdogan, it has been proven that it's not a utopian idea. It is a reality today; nobody expects any crisis between Turkey and any neighbor.

Illustration by Edel Rodriguez for FP

 

Ahmet Davutoglu is Turkey's foreign minister.
Blake Hounshell is managing editor of Foreign Policy.

OSPLANT

12:39 PM ET

November 30, 2010

Winston Churchil's phrase

Never was so much owed by so many to so few was a wartime speech made by the British Prime Minister Winston Churchill on 20 August 1940. The name stems from the specific line in the speech, Never in the field of human conflict was so much owed by so many to so few, referring to the ongoing efforts of the Royal Air Force pilots who were at the time fighting the Battle of Britain, the pivotal air battle with the German Luftwaffe with Britain expecting a German invasion. With the battle won a few months later and German plans postponed, the Allied airmen of the battle ultimately became known as "The Few".

Mr. Davutoglu, the above Churchil's saying was taking place when your country was playing diligently the role of the evasive neutral and was fully aligned with German axis forces. I am curious to know where the Turkish pilots were fighing and how they were protecting the Strategic Depth you describe in your book. Be advised there is another book, American author, The Evasive Neutral, it will provide you useful information on how to manage foreign affairs as previous Turkish collegue did.

 

DJTOLGAR

4:51 PM ET

November 30, 2010

Mr Osplant

The Turks absolutely destroyed the British and Australian forces in Galipoli during the 1st World War. Don't be scoreboarding Turkey on Great Briatain's accounts. Belkieve me that doesn't work. And don't feel the need to teach the Turk their own history. Believe me, they already know it, and they're proud of it.

By the way, how evasive were Turkish troops during the Korean War when they were saving the lives of Americans while battling the Chinese? Tell me Mr. Osplant, how evasive is that?

 

OSPLANT

5:01 AM ET

December 1, 2010

Winston Chuschill's phrase

Can you tell me when your country declared the world against German axis forces? This is a key requirement to understand why Turkey did it. It was necessary to become an establishing member of the UN. If you know it reply if you do not ask, some one else who knows. To help you the year was 1945 well far off after the collapse of Germany. Please, complete: dd/mm/1945
You should know that Churchill's nick name was "father of the victory"

 

OSPLANT

10:24 AM ET

December 1, 2010

The Gallipoli peninsula;

The Gallipoli peninsula; Greek: ?????????) is located in East Thrace), the European part of Turkey, with the Aegean Sea to the west and the Dardanelles straits to the east. Gallipoli derives its name from the Greek "??????????" (Kallipolis), meaning "Beautiful City".[1] In Antiquity, it was known as the Thracian Chersonese (Latin: Chersonesus Thracica, Greek: ??????? ??????????). The battle of Gallipoli took place when your compatriots slaugthered brutally 1.500.000 Armenians in Boz Ntag. Have you heard about?

You have not replied me however, about the date of the declaration of the war from your country against nazis? There was no need because you were allied.

 

OSPLANT

10:37 AM ET

December 1, 2010

The Evasive Neutral

This review is from: The Evasive Neutral: Germany, Britain and the Quest for a Turkish Alliance in the Second World War (Hardcover)
It deals with diplomacy throughout the Second World War when Turkey was a non-belligerent but not an ineffective bystander. Though she bound to Great Britain and France in mutual assisatance treaty since October 1939 broke her pledge to them and to all allied forces and declared war against Germany and Italy on February 1945 just before Yalta Conference when the fighting was all but over to be qualified in her inclusion of United Nations Organization. Thirty years later the Turks invaded Cyprus and revealed that, after all they had been dissastisfied with what diplomacy had gained for them. The book is very instructive for policy makers and leaders of the world and should have a reading copy of this outstanding book to better understand that diplomacy in nowadays should observe standards of honesty and integrity.
Mr.Davutoglou should read it and get some real learned lessons

 

BUNYAMIN

8:42 PM ET

December 1, 2010

Now it is; never was so much owed by so few to so many!

Hi Mr. OSPLANT!
Let me refresh your mind a bit
We-Turks have administered the world justly, fairly long before you exist!

During 1580’s we’ve helped you with your fight against Spanish armada and you’ve won that war.
See Queen Elizabeth’s letter pleading for help to the Ottoman Sultan!
Mr D. Cameroon has got a copy of that letter.

“Never was so much owed by so many to so few”!
Now it is; never was so much owed by so few to so many!
We-Turks never looted the continents! Smuggled its resources, wealth!
And never have genocide aborigines! Africa, America, Australia. Looted and genocide by you! Pay back time will come soon!

If Today; Slavs, Greeks, Jews, Armenians, Kurds are existing and speaking their own language it’s owed to us! We have preserved and protected them.
We have real, true respect to a human kind, and its values!
And we know the history and how to serve it!
So, you are the least person to tell us-Mr Ahmet Davutoglu what to do or how to do!

bunyamin

 

OSPLANT

8:49 AM ET

December 5, 2010

Winston Churchill's phrase

You need to read and understand history.
Do not be satisfied with garbages you are repeating for consolidation.

 

OSPLANT

8:52 AM ET

December 5, 2010

Yes, the Turks the only that

Yes, the Turks the only that know to manage is to destroy

 

PJRODDYJR

4:05 PM ET

November 30, 2010

Strategic Depth

Has Mr. Davutoglu's book been published in English? If so, by whom and where can I purchase it? Amazon.com did not appear to carry it.

Thanks.

 

EREYYUP

8:45 AM ET

December 1, 2010

To: PJRODDY

As far as I know That book didnt translated to English Book but He has another two book you can see belowing lines. from Turkey (ereyyup@hotmail.com) Alternative Paradigms" ve "Civilizational Transformation and the Muslim World" isimli iki eseri yay?nland?.