A slick of carcinogenic benzene, which can cause leukemia and other blood-related cancers, flows down the Songhua River in the
northern city of Harbin on Nov. 24, 2005.
What is the point of a slide show of images of China, emerging in its own fast-forward version of the Industrial Revolution?
Simply to arbitrarily air a handful of photos, some dating back several years, as if this motley collection can be passed off as 'current affairs'?
Or to allow we in the West to *tut-tut* at the known degradation of the environment that accompanies that sort of massive steam and steel-based industrialization?
As if the US, UK and many parts of Europe have not tracked through decades of the same slate-skied gloom and oil-slicked rivers, in our own eager clamber up the material consumption slope?
We can tut sagely and sympathetically all we like; meanwhile, a nice irony is emerging as our global sweatshop-banker hustles to dominate the clean energy technologies sector (and Africa)... Tut on !
The reason why you see more and more pictures of suffering Chinese has more to do with the insecurity of the Western nations than the actual "declining" conditions of the Chinese population. The Western audience are threatened by China's rise and could not do much to stop it. Instead of wanting to learn how China is solving its problems, the western audiences would much rather be constantly told that China is not a superpower, that Chinese people are suffering, etc.
The truth is that the lives of the average Chinese is a lot better than it was 30 years ago. Back then China has much less pollution. Because the manufacturing industry was still in its infancy, Chinese people were also starving and lived in North Koreans. While Western audiences may be happy to see that the Chinese are not doing well today in terms of pollution, Chinese themselves are likely to see the pollution as a necessity to the modernization which China desperately needs.
The good news is that China is investing heavily on green technology today, while many Western politicians openly declare global warning to be hoaxes.
I agree with you. What country doesn't have their own 'cesspool' photos? I am getting really bored with obsession in the west of putting down China. I respect the place and bet they will get a handle on their mess before Australia does.
You're right, it can be found in some of the commentaries on China's pollution crises (although I am hard-pressed to find any in this particularly terse selection of photos-sans-essay).
However, your comments also seem to have more to do with your own insecurities than with these photos. I guess asking fenqing to calm down (in regards to ANY article that mentions China, in even the most incidental sense) would be like asking flies not to lay their eggs in rotting meat.
Some of the photos have a stark beauty about them. Good photography!
P.S.: 2005 wasn't really very long ago; I can empathize with the photographer wanting to include photos of a variety of places and particular environmental abuses. The coal-town pictures from Shanxi are the focus, however, being germane to the related article (here on FP) about the environmental showdown in Cancun.
"The Western audience are threatened by China's rise and could not do much to stop it." Speaking from the America's in particular the United States (but not for the remaining 'west') The word 'audience' must be implied as anything but the majority of the 350 million who live in the US. Most Americans couldn't find China on a map let alone succumb to anything that provides awareness to other persons of the world - vision in the US is as blind as ignorance!
These images make me want to immigrate to China forthwith. I'll bet all the people are constantly chanting equations or some other chant for the day. We are number 1! Whom do you work for John Binary?
This photo essay barely scratches the surface. I was expecting at least one photo of Suzhou, a city that would be beautiful if not for the glowing green canals everywhere that smell like they look.
Here in Ft. Worth, Texas as in the most of this planet we are daily bombarded by "POISON PLANES" dropping tons of Aluminum Oxide and Barium that turns our skies white. Chemtrails are sickening us. Most of the population is suffering upper respiratory problems and the gardens don't produce due to the high level of Aluminum in the soil. We have poison (FLUORIDE) put into or water supply and our money is almost worthless and phony trillions of debt to the NWO/Fed will assure our children of being debt slaves... unless we arrest the thieving criminals. Eugenicists (mass killers) claim to want 85% of the people to die. Time to outlaw governments, they are the threat and the problem!
The amount of pollution the Chinese have allowed in order to sustain positive economic growth models is staggering and still unchecked. As some of the pro-China pollution commenter have mentioned of course there have been thousands of incidents in the west. The difference is that in the west these are being cleaned up and companies are fined. In China there is rarely substantial punitive sanctions against major polluters and the mentality is backward. Chinese feel they should be allowed to pollute because the west did it 100 years ago. Wow. That's backward and upside down thinking - almost Schizophrenic. Chinese companies are starting to develop green technologies... but more than likely to sell to the west. Who would pay for that in China?
...While I agree the west focuses a lot (too much) of attention on the problems of others...I am very surprised at just how tame the photo's were of what was supposed to be China's pollution problem.
As an American living in mainland China for the last two years, I found the photo's to be a rather weak pictorial of the pollution problems here.
Why does everyone have to politicize this? When I look at the photos I am heartbroken. Heartbroken for the masses that toil away in those disgusting conditions for meager pay so that government officials and corrupt businessman can buy Ferraris and Chateau Lafitte. Heartbroken for the beautfiul landscapes that are forever ruined. And heartbroken that I along with anyone who has ever bought anything "Made in China" shares a piece of the blame. I only hope someday people can agree that economic development at any and all cost is just that. Doesn't matter how many many Dollars, Euro or RMB you have in your bank account if we destory our home on this planet.
(15)
HIDE COMMENTS LOGIN OR REGISTER REPORT ABUSE
JOHNBINARY010
10:30 PM ET
December 2, 2010
What is this 'Photo Essay' Trying to Convey?
What is the point of a slide show of images of China, emerging in its own fast-forward version of the Industrial Revolution?
Simply to arbitrarily air a handful of photos, some dating back several years, as if this motley collection can be passed off as 'current affairs'?
Or to allow we in the West to *tut-tut* at the known degradation of the environment that accompanies that sort of massive steam and steel-based industrialization?
As if the US, UK and many parts of Europe have not tracked through decades of the same slate-skied gloom and oil-slicked rivers, in our own eager clamber up the material consumption slope?
We can tut sagely and sympathetically all we like; meanwhile, a nice irony is emerging as our global sweatshop-banker hustles to dominate the clean energy technologies sector (and Africa)... Tut on !
XTIANGODLOKI
10:54 AM ET
December 3, 2010
China bashing is popular :)
The reason why you see more and more pictures of suffering Chinese has more to do with the insecurity of the Western nations than the actual "declining" conditions of the Chinese population. The Western audience are threatened by China's rise and could not do much to stop it. Instead of wanting to learn how China is solving its problems, the western audiences would much rather be constantly told that China is not a superpower, that Chinese people are suffering, etc.
The truth is that the lives of the average Chinese is a lot better than it was 30 years ago. Back then China has much less pollution. Because the manufacturing industry was still in its infancy, Chinese people were also starving and lived in North Koreans. While Western audiences may be happy to see that the Chinese are not doing well today in terms of pollution, Chinese themselves are likely to see the pollution as a necessity to the modernization which China desperately needs.
The good news is that China is investing heavily on green technology today, while many Western politicians openly declare global warning to be hoaxes.
SUSANAI
12:32 PM ET
December 4, 2010
Photo Essay smog
I agree with you. What country doesn't have their own 'cesspool' photos? I am getting really bored with obsession in the west of putting down China. I respect the place and bet they will get a handle on their mess before Australia does.
DR. JONES JR.
10:45 AM ET
December 5, 2010
Shadenfreude
You're right, it can be found in some of the commentaries on China's pollution crises (although I am hard-pressed to find any in this particularly terse selection of photos-sans-essay).
However, your comments also seem to have more to do with your own insecurities than with these photos. I guess asking fenqing to calm down (in regards to ANY article that mentions China, in even the most incidental sense) would be like asking flies not to lay their eggs in rotting meat.
Some of the photos have a stark beauty about them. Good photography!
P.S.: 2005 wasn't really very long ago; I can empathize with the photographer wanting to include photos of a variety of places and particular environmental abuses. The coal-town pictures from Shanxi are the focus, however, being germane to the related article (here on FP) about the environmental showdown in Cancun.
OPOLISTIC
12:07 AM ET
December 6, 2010
When u point 1 of these, there are 3 toward YOU!
"The Western audience are threatened by China's rise and could not do much to stop it." Speaking from the America's in particular the United States (but not for the remaining 'west') The word 'audience' must be implied as anything but the majority of the 350 million who live in the US. Most Americans couldn't find China on a map let alone succumb to anything that provides awareness to other persons of the world - vision in the US is as blind as ignorance!
TYPEE123
1:56 PM ET
December 21, 2010
photo essay
These images make me want to immigrate to China forthwith. I'll bet all the people are constantly chanting equations or some other chant for the day. We are number 1! Whom do you work for John Binary?
MENSOELREY
7:27 PM ET
December 4, 2010
Suzhou
This photo essay barely scratches the surface. I was expecting at least one photo of Suzhou, a city that would be beautiful if not for the glowing green canals everywhere that smell like they look.
JIM SHORES
7:29 PM ET
December 5, 2010
Phony smog
Here in Ft. Worth, Texas as in the most of this planet we are daily bombarded by "POISON PLANES" dropping tons of Aluminum Oxide and Barium that turns our skies white. Chemtrails are sickening us. Most of the population is suffering upper respiratory problems and the gardens don't produce due to the high level of Aluminum in the soil. We have poison (FLUORIDE) put into or water supply and our money is almost worthless and phony trillions of debt to the NWO/Fed will assure our children of being debt slaves... unless we arrest the thieving criminals. Eugenicists (mass killers) claim to want 85% of the people to die. Time to outlaw governments, they are the threat and the problem!
MF SINCLAIR
12:56 AM ET
December 6, 2010
Staggering and still unchecked pollution
The amount of pollution the Chinese have allowed in order to sustain positive economic growth models is staggering and still unchecked. As some of the pro-China pollution commenter have mentioned of course there have been thousands of incidents in the west. The difference is that in the west these are being cleaned up and companies are fined. In China there is rarely substantial punitive sanctions against major polluters and the mentality is backward. Chinese feel they should be allowed to pollute because the west did it 100 years ago. Wow. That's backward and upside down thinking - almost Schizophrenic. Chinese companies are starting to develop green technologies... but more than likely to sell to the west. Who would pay for that in China?
CHENGDU
10:13 PM ET
December 11, 2010
China pollution
...While I agree the west focuses a lot (too much) of attention on the problems of others...I am very surprised at just how tame the photo's were of what was supposed to be China's pollution problem.
As an American living in mainland China for the last two years, I found the photo's to be a rather weak pictorial of the pollution problems here.
RYAN92466
8:48 PM ET
December 14, 2010
heartbreaking
Why does everyone have to politicize this? When I look at the photos I am heartbroken. Heartbroken for the masses that toil away in those disgusting conditions for meager pay so that government officials and corrupt businessman can buy Ferraris and Chateau Lafitte. Heartbroken for the beautfiul landscapes that are forever ruined. And heartbroken that I along with anyone who has ever bought anything "Made in China" shares a piece of the blame. I only hope someday people can agree that economic development at any and all cost is just that. Doesn't matter how many many Dollars, Euro or RMB you have in your bank account if we destory our home on this planet.
TYPEE123
2:01 PM ET
December 21, 2010
Nature groans for His coming.
Nature groans for His coming.
CYNA
2:12 PM ET
December 21, 2010
A group of wild geese FLIES,
A group of wild geese FLIES, not FLY ... A group FLIES. This error made the annoyingly pointless photo essay really stink.
WATERFLAWS
9:39 PM ET
December 21, 2010
Chinese or American pollution?
American birds poop
in Chinese nests.
JOHNDMOORE3000
12:05 AM ET
December 28, 2010
China it probably one of few
China it probably one of few countries on which crisis is not swept up, they both made all successively, and make creating a strong competition all