Will Facebook Friend China?

Mark Zuckerberg's meeting this week in Beijing with Baidu CEO Robin Li set off another round of speculation that the social-media giant may be coming to the Middle Kingdom.

BY CHRISTINA LARSON | DECEMBER 23, 2010

On Dec. 20, Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg -- who was recently named Time's 2010 "Person of the Year" -- stopped by the Beijing offices of Baidu, China's leading web-search company, to chat with co-founder Robin Li. The two men, both youthful, energetic, self-made billionaires, have much in common. In addition to Silicon Valley ties (after leaving Harvard University, the now 26-year-old Zuckerberg took his company to the Valley; and the 42-year-old Li studied in the United States and worked in the Valley before moving back to Beijing), they share an affection for no-frills attire (Li's bright-colored polo shirts and windbreakers are a notch fancier than Zuckerberg's storied brown hoodies), lofty spots on their country's respective most-wealthy lists (Li ranked second on Forbes's 2010 "China Rich List" and Zuckerberg was 35th on the American version), and planetary ambitions.

Whether or not any formal partnership was discussed -- Baidu spokesperson Kaiser Kuo declined to share details of the meeting with Bloomberg News -- one thing is certain: If Zuckerberg is seriously considering entering the Chinese market, which means learning to play by Beijing's rules, there is no better guide than Li.

Facebook is officially blocked in China, alongside other foreign-owned social-networking sites, including Twitter. That means that Facebook's 550 million users do not include any (or very few) of China's 420 million-and-counting Internet users. When a Facebook employee recently mapped social networks among the site's global users, China was rendered as an ominously dark space, among the last unconquered frontiers. But over the past year, there have been an increasing trickle of news stories that Facebook is eyeing the Middle Kingdom.

In October, Zuckerberg told an Internet forum at Stanford University that Facebook must "figure out the right partnerships we would need to succeed in China on our terms.... China has values that are somewhat different from the U.S.... I would spend a lot of time studying it."

Entering China would first mean bowing to Beijing's political requirements. (This spring, Google decided it was no longer willing to play ball, and so withdrew its search operations from mainland China.) No outsider can predict what Facebook's principled growth calculus might be, but it is possible to sketch out what Zuckerberg would have to stomach if China is indeed among his next targets.

Getty Images

 SUBJECTS: CHINA, PACIFIC
 

Christina Larson is a contributing editor to Foreign Policy and a Schwartz fellow at the New America Foundation.

SONGSHU

9:46 AM ET

December 24, 2010

um, censorship issues aside

Facebook has another, much more obvious barrier to entry in the Chinese market, namely that there is already a fairly well-established knockoff social networking site that is beloved and obsessed over by young Chinese with the same zeal and fervor Facebook is by young people in the US/Europe. Even if Facebook can negotiate all of the political hurdles, it will have to provide a compelling reason for loyal adherents to kaixinwang to switch

 

JIM-Y

11:03 AM ET

December 24, 2010

They will switch en masse

Chinese internet users would switch to Facebook en masse, to gain international friends and exposure--just as they would switch from Baidu to Google, if their government would allow the playing field to be level.

 

KATHYKERR

4:51 PM ET

January 22, 2011

No one cares anyways..

No one in China really cares that they can't access Facebook. Like you said, there are already established social networking sites specifically for Chinese residents. The only people who really complain about the FB ban are Chinese-Americans who have become used to the internet freedom they enjoyed outside of China, and became shocked they couldn't keep in touch with friends when they visited China. Plus, there are so many ways to get around the censorship- VPNs and proxies.. this is something I used when I visited last December: http://www.squidoo.com/securitales-review

 

JEFFERSON

7:50 AM ET

December 25, 2010

Censorship is a non-issue

I don't think Facebook users would have any problems with censored content in China. Facebook has been build upon the idea of a non-existent privacy. No one cares (so far).

 

EMMERSONJ

10:03 AM ET

December 29, 2010

Agree Completely

Facebook has continually shown a complete disregard for the welfare and interests of their users, only doing anything even slightly in their favor when the pressure became too much. Most users are completely unaware of what FB is allowed to do with their data, let alone the 3rd party developers that create many FB apps - so applying whatever censorship the Chinese government would want in order to access that market (and it's cash) would be a no-brainer

 

CUNEYT

5:30 PM ET

December 25, 2010

about Robin Li

Li graduated from State University of New York at Buffalo. When the news is about Facebook, we always see Harvard somewhere in the news, but when Baidu and Li are reported, SUNY is nowhere to be found.

I do not blame reporters, because even SUNY Buffalo people do not know about this. I guess the management and the dean of the faculty do not know this either. Because all they do is adding fees to international student tuitions. Recently, they started charging int students with a new fee under an outrageous pretext.

So what happens? They charge us, we pay, we just finish studies and never look back. I am almost sure that Li would not even want to hear about SUNY.

I had my Master's there in CS, and could not take it any longer, I moved to Europe for my PhD. If I get as influential (read rich) as LI, SUNY Buffalo should not even call me.

Stop adding racist fees to tuition, and care about students. Can you hear me Buffalo?

 

LAVITA1

11:37 AM ET

January 22, 2011

I do not blame reporters,

I do not blame reporters, because even suny buffalo people do not know about this. It's quite a bit aways from Merapi, which is closer to Yogyakarta. tivo converter?convert mod files