The Madness of China's Mental Health System

One of the country's leading activists and health advocates explains the tragic irony of mental health in China today: Many who need treatment won't get it, while many who don't are forced into treatment to silence political dissent.

BY WAN YANHAI | JANUARY 26, 2011

According to a 2009 article in the British medical journal The Lancet, as many as 17.5 percent of China's adult population may suffer from some kind of mental illness. Yet mental health remains a vexing, and in some cases taboo, topic in China. The trauma and reversals of recent decades, from the Cultural Revolution to the current all-consuming drive for wealth, from shifting family structures to the migration of millions of people each year from villages to cities to find work, all have put invisible strains on the people living through these vast changes. Some recent headlines from the past year indicate that untreated mental illness may be becoming a more acute problem in China: a series of grisly attacks by middle-age men on school children, some of them deadly, caused a great public panic. The suicides of several young workers at a factory in southern China assembling iPhones likewise raised questions about where migrants (most workers are living far from home) can turn to for emotional support in difficult times.

Meanwhile, even as many people who need medical attention are unable to receive help -- either because it is too costly or because of the great social stigma attached -- there are others who are healthy but are labeled "mentally ill" by authorities seeking a reason to detain them in mental-health hospitals, as the New York Times recently documented. One man mentioned in the article, for instance, is 54-year-old Xu Lindong, who was forced to spend six and a half years in mental hospitals and subjected to 54 electric-shock treatments following a land dispute. (A recent New Yorker article explored the interest -- and confusion -- among some in China regarding the ideas of Sigmund Freud.) This is the tragic irony of mental health in China today: Many whose lives could be improved will never receive medical attention, and many who don't need it are held in confinement in the name of medicine.

In this context, I would like to offer my own personal story. I was trained in medicine in the 1980s and subsequently worked for a government health institute and then for a private NGO dedicated to AIDS awareness, which brought me into contact with marginalized populations and stigmatized people in China, including those wrongly labeled as mentally ill. I have seen people sent to mental hospitals for being gay, for domestic disputes, and for political dissent.

I was born in 1963 and grew up in a small town in Anhui province. The first person I remember being described as mentally ill was my father. He was a police officer in the 1950s; he found his work very hard to do, and by the time he left his job in the late 1950s, he hated politics. During the Cultural Revolution, which began in 1966 and lasted for 10 years, he spent time in a labor camp. There were two words people used during my childhood to describe people with a mental illness: One was fengzi, which means a dangerous person without restraint or a conscience. The other was naozi shou ciji, which means someone with a mind broken by pain or stress. That was what they said of my father. He was not ever formally diagnosed because there was very little understanding of mental health at that time in China; under Mao Zedong, it was seen as a sign of weakness. I think my father's problem was not mental illness, but instead that he had an independent mind. He read a lot and thought differently about the world. In the 1970s, people often used the label of mental illness for people like that.

Getty Images/China Photos

 SUBJECTS: CHINA, HEALTH, EAST ASIA
 

Wan Yanhai is the founder of the Beijing-based Aizhixing Institute of Health Education. He is currently a fellow at the National Endowment for Democracy.

SHERLOCKMAN7

11:45 PM ET

January 26, 2011

capturing

Sir, the injustice and the pain which you describe is made more powerful by the understatement of this tragic; certainly the result of your deep sense of shame and your modesty. For you, this article must not have been easy to write. Yet, through your words seep stories of horror. Against your country's State institutions, which appear shamelessly morally constrained and corrupt, you stand as a true hero. But I believe you are not alone as thousands, even millions of Chinese and non-Chinese (I am American) internet citizens and ordinary people stand by you, and others like Liu Xiao Bo, eager to eliminate the foolish Monkey which has broken the beautiful Chinese spirit and corrupted the independent and curious mind which thought that through the experiment of communism would find freedom, only to find it trapped by horror.

 

MANOLOVEGA

9:20 AM ET

January 27, 2011

Mental Illness in China and USA

To see human suffering without feeling pain will take our humanity away.
True is illogical what suffer mentally ill patients in China agree, but we are no much better.
I even heart last night a REVEREND blame LACK OF FAITH in the family of the perpetrator of the Tucson massacre.
I blame LACK OF HEALTH CARE FOR THE MENTALLY ILL IN THE USA. our jails are full of mentally ill people, are we any different ?
In China they lack them up HERE we let them out without treatment.
As a father of a mentally ill person it was very difficult to sort all the obstacles to get help for my daughter.
Thanks intelligence and perseverance the situation is under control.
Our society is been polarized the ignorant and the uncontrollable rich that do not care of those that can not help themselves.
Let us not through stones, we have a glass roof.

 

SHERLOCKMAN7

10:29 PM ET

January 27, 2011

sherlockman

Even if your story were true, your appeal to pity story is off subject. We're talking about China. But you knew that. Which makes me think you're one of those cynical followers of the dictatorial cult from across the pond. But we all know that emotional manipulation is not below you, spiritually empty as you are. Why don't you focus on the theme of this excellent article and do some soul searching. You my be horrified by what you see in your black abyss, but that's your nightmare. Your "you also" illogical arguments is why we don't respect you, and probably why you don't respect yourselves. Don't you care about your country at all? Do you always have to point elsewhere instead of taking responsibility for your problems. It is beyond me and most Americans that you would spit your venom at a country like the US whose sense of fairness has helped you many times in the past: Universities, fighting the Japanese, access to the UN, WTO. Shouldn't you point the finger at yourselves for once and make something of your country? Perhaps then you'll be able to understand how the US's generous health care budget dwarfs that in your middle kingdom of soulless wasteland; we achieved that because we're not a nation of scoundrels who rely on claiming 5000 years of history to make themselves feel superior and wiser, your tricks are a fool's delusion. The joke is on you.

 

NEMESIS XYZ

10:45 AM ET

February 20, 2011

SHERLOCKMAN7, China takes

SHERLOCKMAN7, China takes care of its own people, for better or worse. China doesn't meddle in the affairs of other nations. If anything, the Chinese add value to everything they make. When they do make mistakes, they seek to rectify them. On the contrary, every other nation seeks to meddle in China's affairs instead of mining their own. China is not the scapegoat of the world despite everyone trying to make it so. And, 200 years of history doesn't make you an adult overnight, you still have to crawl, stand upright, walk and then run. America has tons of problems....too many opinions and not enough doers. Everyone thinks that by putting in their 2 cents everyday on every possible blog/posting is going to change the status quo. Do you really think people care about your opinions? People want to see results, people want to see action. The world is mired in American FICTION, so much so that people can't even separate reality from fiction...what an injustice.