Why Do the World's Fattest People Live on Islands?

It's not piña coladas. Evolution has been overwhelmed by Western lifestyles.

BY JOSHUA E. KEATING | FEBRUARY 8, 2011

Last week, a study published in the British medical journal The Lancet found that worldwide obesity rates have increased significantly over the past three decades. By far, the greatest increase was in the Pacific islands. In the world's fattest country -- Nauru -- the average body mass index (BMI) is now an off-the-charts 35.03 for women and 33.85 for men. (Above 30 is generally considered obese.) The Cook Islands, Tonga, Samoa, French Polynesia, and Palau aren't far behind. Several Caribbean islands-- including Bermuda, Puerto Rico, and St. Kitts and Nevis -- are also in the obese category. Of the 13 countries with average BMIs over 30, only Kuwait and Egypt (where just the women average over 30) aren't islands. (Although the United States, with average BMIs of 28.33 for women and 28.46 for men, is well on its way.) So why are island countries so obese?

It's a combination of factors including diet, lifestyle, and culture -- but the main culprit is globalization. Most of the Pacific islands were traditional societies, dependent on subsistence farming and fishing until the mid-20th century. The arrival of U.S., French, and British militaries during the Pacific campaigns of World War II began a monumental shift, as the countries opened up to the world. Large-scale industrialization of the Pacific islands didn't begin in earnest until the 1970s. The result was that the South Pacific had only about 40 years to adapt to the kind of modern, sedentary lifestyle that people in the West have been getting used to for centuries. (The Persian Gulf states, which are also struggling with obesity and its related health conditions, have had a similarly rapid transition to modernity.)

The ready availability of imported food has coincided with the conversion of farmland to more lucrative industries such as mining. Nauru's land area has been almost entirely turned over to phosphate mining, forcing its people onto a tiny sliver of livable land. While the traditional Pacific diet was dominated by fish, fruits, and vegetables, Nauru's islanders have now developed a taste for imported rice, sugar, flour, soda, and beer. (Spam is a particular favorite.) Western fast-food outlets have also arrived along with the island's growing tourist industry.

Many researchers also believe that Pacific islanders' bodies are genetically hard-wired to store fat more efficiently. This trait used to make a lot of sense -- living on a tiny island, highly susceptible to the effects of the weather, often involved long periods of famine and required a great deal of physical labor. But that's not quite the case anymore in a world of retail jobs and Big Macs. (People of African descent are also thought to be prone to retaining weight, perhaps a reason why the inhabitants of Caribbean islands are becoming increasingly obese.) Culture also plays a role. A large physique is also often considered attractive in Pacific island societies -- a mark of higher social status -- but you no longer need to be a chief to eat like one.

Of course, these factors are present in many other developing countries. What really sets the size of these islanders apart is the size of their islands: Tuvalu, Palau, Nauru, and the other countries on the obesity list are among the world's smallest countries in terms of land area and population. So a single tourist resort, fast-food chain, or trade deal has a much more profound effect on society than it would, say, in India or Nigeria.  

Obesity may seem like a small price to pay for access to the modern world and all its comforts and opportunities. But conditions associated with obesity are starting to take their toll. In Nauru, an estimated 45 percent of adults may be diabetic. Life expectancies, which rose throughout the region for decades, have begun to plateau in recent years because of weight-related health problems.

The situation isn't hopeless. Education programs encouraging people to eat local, healthier foods have helped bring obesity rates down in Tonga, Fiji, and Hawaii. The Aloha state -- birthplace of famously skinny President Barack Obama -- is actually one of America's trimmest.

Thanks to Richard Taylor, professor of public and international health at University of New South Wales.

Orlando /Three Lions/Getty Images

 SUBJECTS:
 

Joshua E. Keating is an associate editor at Foreign Policy.

CARRIER BAGS

2:04 PM ET

February 10, 2011

Not just on Islands

I think it's just a conincidence that more seem to live on islands, the problem really exists everywhere and as long as you have so many fast food joints and things like this, it's going to be just so easy to get fat really quickly

Carrier Bags

 

STEERPIKE

5:13 AM ET

February 14, 2011

Not so many fast food joints in the Islands

The BMI for polynesians should be higher as they do not fit within European body norms. They are shorter, wider and more muscular, a reason why they dominate in New Zealand and Australian contact sports. This body type appears to gain weight easier.

The weight gain is also cultural, from a lifestyle of hard physical work raising food to a more sedentary lifestyle. Cheap food is also a problem - canned tinned meat is fatty but fresh lean meat is too expensive to buy in isolated communities. Taro, a nutrient rich and dense root vegetable is being replaced by cheaper rice and bread and sugar is becoming a major part of the diet. Cultural cringe makes some ashamed of eating traditional food as the rich and successful eat an imported diet. Very few eat at burger chains - the standard of living makes that an expensive treat.

 

TIOEDONG

6:52 PM ET

February 28, 2011

obesity not just on islands

It's the prosperity, not the "Island" life.

and it's evolution.

And it's the propensity of "Metabolic syndrome", where the body tends to put on weight when there is plenty of food, since evolution knows that next year you may starve.

The high rate of Obesity/diabetes in some Native American tribes, in the Hispanic, and in white ethnics where their ancestors were from the poorer classes, might also be influenced by evolution.

 

ITONLYSTANDSTOREASON

4:48 PM ET

February 11, 2011

Not just coincidence

It's more than coincidence.

If it was coincidence, then we'd expect one island to be fatter, the next thinner, etc. Instead we have a systematic difference.

Being heavy is indeed a cultural norm, particularly for women and chiefs, It shows that you are loved and well-taken care of. Anecdote: I know a Islander woman who retained her youthful figure into her 30s and 40s. Other islanders speculated why she hadn't grown round, as married women should. Her husband fed her well - was she mentally/emotionally off? But all's well in the end - she's now pleasingly plump. Love conquers all!

 

ALOHA83

2:51 PM ET

February 14, 2011

No, it is indeed a massive price to pay

Dear Sir:

I am unsure on your reasons for postulating that "obesity may seem like a small price to pay for access to the modern world and all its comforts and opportunities." I can resolutely say, as a Pacific Islander, that it is needed a massive price to pay. The 'opportunities' of the modern world that you seem to be praising, must include the western tradition of monetizing the health and happiness of a person - in this case to the detriment of Pacific communities. Obesity is a disease, a disease that robs people of their ability to realize the fullest potential of their bodies (and all of the physical, mental, emotional and spiritual growth that results from increased health).

You do make points that resound in the Pacific worldview. The consequences of forced assimilation to western norms in consumption (i.e. replacement of native labor and production structures) combined with the other detrimental effects of colonization - rendered extremely productive and cohesive civilizations to peoples living under imperial wardship. The environmental and physiological balances that took millennia for Pacific islanders (and Indigenous peoples around the globe) to shape were unraveled in the span of years. Indigenous Pacific Islanders continue to pay the price for this cataclysmic upending of the livelihoods lived by our elders.

Indigenous peoples (including Pacific Islanders) continue to pay this price everyday through obesity, through social marginalization, through discrimination, through forced homelessness, through higher mortality rates, through low education attainment, through economic disparity, through drug and alcohol addiction, and for many through the western settlement of their indigenous homelands.

Obesity is a tragedy - one of many being experienced by indigenous Pacific Islanders. I ask, that in the future, you be more careful with your words and more respectful of the 'prices' paid by the peoples you write about. Mahalo.

 

GRAHAMPOSITIVE

8:26 PM ET

February 20, 2011

Tragedy

obesity is a tragedy the way the BP oil spill was a tragedy. It costs a lot of money a d hurt a lot of people- but could have been avoided easily with just a little determination and hard work. I have trouble feeling compassion for a group of people whose chief complaint is that they have too much- when so much of the world has so little. Should I feel sorry for a thirsty man who drowns himself in the water I provide for him?

 

SHANNONLOVE

4:13 PM ET

February 28, 2011

Stop Whining

Oh, give me a break.

Stop it with the polynesian version of pastural idealism. Pre-contact Polynesia was a blood soaked land of incessant warfare, conquest and mass murder. You know, just like everywhere else. The societies were highly-heirachial and oppressive and ruled by a warrior elite who gained their positions with murderous violence. Just like everywhere else. The technology level meant that the vast majority of the population lived and died at the whim of nature. Just like everywhere else.

Everything in the past uniformly sucked and everything in the present by comparison uniformly rocks. Don't believe me? Well, how about that pre-20th century dentistry? What, did traditional polynesians have some secret for antibiotics and anesthesia?

Anyone who whines about being provided to much food and treats it like a crime against humanity has never watched a child starve to death. At anytime prior to the last 30 years the idea that making people fat was doing something wrong would have provoked gales of laughter. It still should.

People like you are the reason that Polynesians are marginalized. Brained dead romantics who would rather whine about the loss of a mythical past than adapt to the modern world. Polynesians are marginalized because they don't have the individual and collective skills to make themselves powerful in the modern world. You can't use traditional Polynesian culture to find success in the modern world anymore than white Americans could act like their medieval ancestors and expect to prosper.

You whine just like American Southerners used to whine. Oh, it was so unfair that the South was as rich and economically advanced as the North. It was all the fault of the greedy and exploitive Northern industrialist and capitalist! In response, the Southern states adopted a wide range of economic policies intended to "protect" themselves from Northern exploitation such as making it nearly impossible for out of state banks to operate.

In reality the Souths economic backwardness was entirely self-inflicted. They needed to lose the slavery, lose the Jim Crow, lose economic protectionism and lose the hostility to entrepreneurism. Starting in the 1960s they did all those things and like magic the South began to grow and even outpace the North (which ironically was headed in the opposite direction.)

If you want to run your society the same way that grandpa did, expect to have grandpa's standard of living and grandpa's place in the world.

Playing on the sympathies of others just makes you a well respected beggar. Even if you it earns you a house of gold you are still a beggar and still marginalized. You still depend on the whims of others for your livelihood and you never have any real respect.

 

TAS

2:15 PM ET

February 15, 2011

thrifty gene

There have been decades of research on the pattern of obesity in populations that have had to deal with prolonged periods of food shortage. One of the more attractive theories underlying this pattern is that of the "thrifty gene". That is, those individuals that are more able to pack on the fat during the good times are more likely to survive. One group that has been very intensively studied, and much closer to home is the Pima Indians. With respect to the Pacific Islanders there was almost certainly significant genetic bottle necks as the islands were populated, again with the most "thrifty" being the ones most likely to survive.

 

SHANNONLOVE

3:38 PM ET

February 28, 2011

Yep, thrifty gene

The thrifty gene explains most obesity patterns throughout the world. There a vast numbers of people in the world that come from cultures that historically had no means of storing up significant amounts of food. In such cultures, almost all individuals experience extended famine at least once in their lifetime. This created powerful selection forces to maintain genes that stored fat and which resisted starvation (diabetic genes.)

When individuals with that heritage live in an advanced industrial world wherein famine has disappeared and food is cheap, their genes still try to store up food for the famine that will never come.

The only solution to this problem is to educate people with the genes that they must ruthlessly control their caloric intake. It is the only solution.

Well, not the only one. I guess we could periodically lay siege to them and subject them starvation as nature intended but personally, I'd rather go with the education.

 

GRAHAMPOSITIVE

8:21 PM ET

February 20, 2011

Globalization

Damn that globalization for bringing it's affordable foods, modern means of production, sedentary lifestyle and modern medicine! If only these poor honest islanders could have been left to their own devices they could live peacefully without the scourge of abundant nutrients. How dare we bring them these sinful and excessive nutrients, knowing full well that they can't possibly be expected to eat in moderation or adapt their lifestyle in matter of only four decades. For shame, western world- for shame!

 

ABLEARCHER

2:03 PM ET

February 21, 2011

i thought eating too much was to blame...

Blame globalisation for their problems, otherwise you'd have to consider that its poor lifestyle choices on their behalf. How come obesity in Europe is lifestyle but for pacific islanders its now partially my fault. As for Nauru they sold their own land for mining and became very rich off it, until they gambled it away. But I guess globalisation caused that too.

 

NSC LOS ANGELES

6:09 PM ET

February 22, 2011

I was just at the DMV...

And I can assure the problem has also occurred right here in the US (shocking, I know)! I can honestly say that the entire population at the Lincoln Heights DMV was UNDATABLE.

 

SABINEJ

7:36 PM ET

February 22, 2011

Then how are all these people

Then how are all these people getting together?

 

GREGBASH

4:16 PM ET

February 28, 2011

Western Lifestyles?

In the pic we have an Islander, barechested, wearing beads and what looks like a banana leaf and a skirt, drinking from a coconut. Pure Western Lifestyle. Brilliant.