Revolution in the Arab World
Dispatches Middle East Channel Latest Scenes from the Uprisings

Egypt's Foreigner Blame Game

Hosni Mubarak tries xenophobia to stay at the helm.

BY PETER BOUCKAERT | FEBRUARY 9, 2011

A week into the demonstrations in Egypt, Hosni Mubarak's once unshakeable power structure was in full panic mode. What was once unimaginable had become reality: Egyptians seemed on the verge of overthrowing their government. Last week, hundreds of thousands marched through the streets of Cairo, Alexandria, and other Egyptian cities, shouting again and again their Tunisia-inspired mantra: "The people demand the downfall of the regime!"

As one protester told me and my colleague after viewing some of the dead at one of Alexandria's morgues, "We want to uproot this tree all the way down to its roots, and then plant a new tree" -- terrifying words for the entrenched Egyptian autocracy.

Now, however, on day 16 of the protests, Mubarak and his cronies seemed to have turned a corner. Instead of running scared, the regime is fighting back with both words and violence to quash its opponents, portraying the opposition as a foreign-backed, un-Egyptian group of conspirators. Sadly, its propaganda campaign appears to be as crude as its actual physical crackdown has been.

After Mubarak's defiant last-night speech on Feb. 1, rejecting outright the protesters' demand that he step down, authorities unleashed a stunning wave of violence and intimidation. Gangs armed with sticks and knives attacked protesters. Thugs rode in on horseback and ran demonstrators down. State-run hospitals were under pressure to conceal the toll, so my colleagues and I tried to tally as best we could, visiting wards and morgues across the capital. We've counted more than 300 deaths so far, much higher than the officially acknowledged death toll of 77.

But another target of Mubarak's wrath was, simply, the rest of the world. Thugs hunted down foreigners, including journalists and tourists. Reporters from the Washington Post and the New York Times were harassed and detained; al Jazeera's headquarters were stormed, its equipment confiscated, and at least eight of its journalists detained at various times. Attackers told their victims they were looking for an alliance of Israeli Mossad spies, American agents, Iranian and Afghan intelligence, Hamas provocateurs, and other sinister elements that were conspiring to "destroy Egypt."

Why this intense anti-foreigner violence? In short, because the regime was trying just about everything to preserve the privileges of its corrupt rule. There is considerable circumstantial evidence to suggest that Mubarak's ruling National Democratic Party, his Information Ministry, and elements of his security services sponsored a coordinated campaign to discredit and break up the largely peaceful pro-democracy protests that began on Jan. 25 and to intimidate and silence the journalists, foreign and Egyptian, who were reporting on it.

Senior officials, including Mubarak himself, have darkly hinted of supposed foreign involvement in the protests. On Feb. 1, Mubarak said that honest protesters had been "exploited" by spoilers with political interests. In a nationwide address two days later, his newly appointed vice president, Omar Suleiman, more explicitly accused "foreign influences" of spawning chaos.

Chris Hondros/Getty Images

 

Peter Bouckaert is emergencies director at Human Rights Watch. Soraya Morayef assisted with the research for this article.

PKOULIEV

4:04 PM ET

February 9, 2011

Thank you for this article.

Thank you for this article. It is well said: "Hope Dies Last". When you follow the system changing events in Egypt, you realize that there are no borders in people's aspirations for freedom and basic rights. Since there are no cultural, national, language borders in achieving dreams, there are no borders in methods of brutality, suppression, abusing used by dictators. As civilization went through abolition in 19th century, it is time to get rid of of this devil's circle where no government can violate its citizen's human rights. It is not anymore interior affairs of any government, and it can not be avoided under national interest context.

 

MINI88

7:04 AM ET

February 10, 2011

Biased

As an Egyptian female who is living through the current events taking place in the country and as a subscriber to both Vodafone and Mobinil, I can confirm that no message was sent by either (or any) mobile operator urging people to join ANY protest, whether for or against.

The only broadcast sent was, as you mentioned, a message from the Armed Forces asking citizens to protect themselves and their country.

It doesn't even make sense - no company as big as these mobile networks would take sides or associate themselves with a certain political movement.

Besides that, I am yet to come across any article in Foreign Policy that does not offer an extremely biased coverage of the events in Egypt...

 

XTIANGODLOKI

10:54 AM ET

February 10, 2011

Egyptians should be upset the West supported Mubarak for so long

Anyone else see the irony here?

If Mubarack is such as a bad guy why didn't western governments and media who supported this guy decades after decades outed him as a bad guy long time ago? Why wasn't this article written a decade ago?

 

USAMA2

12:32 PM ET

February 10, 2011

The Grave Truth About Liberal Democracy and Egypt

"If Mubarack is such as a bad guy why didn't western governments and media who supported this guy decades after decades outed him as a bad guy long time ago?"

I'm sorry to say this so bluntly, but liberal democracy and the Western world order is unfit for humanity.

I arrive at this conclusion because the SAME government authority and democratic sovereignty that legally sanctioned Western support and normal relations with Mubarak and Mubarak's rape and torture and martial law and propaganda are the same that call for liberal democracy. Their actions render authoritarianism, torture, mass repression and tyranny to be acceptable developmental stages for liberal democracy.

Mubarak IS a devout democrat. And he has instituted numerous liberalizing reforms. And he is friends with many liberal democrats in the West.

And Mubarak is part of a long line of dictators and torturers which the West have upheld and supported.

Egyptians should contemplate this reality.

 

CARRIER BAGS

2:40 PM ET

February 10, 2011

such a shame

I think this complete violence is such a shame on these people. The Egyptian people should have a right to decide who governs their own country, we need to see an end of dictatorship and introduce democracy, these people have a right to decide who leads them.

Carrier Bags