Sword or Samovar
Latest dispatchMapping the tripPhotosArchive

The Islamic Republic of Chechnya

Why is the Kremlin-imposed leader of this republic sounding so much like the militants he's meant to be cracking down on?

BY TOM PARFITT | MARCH 15, 2011

GROZNY, Russia — When I first came to the capital of Chechnya seven years ago, large stretches of it lay in rubble.


To follow Tom's path through the North Caucasus, check out this Google map. For more photos of the North Caucasus, Russia’s bloody backyard, click here.

 

Prospekt Pobedy (Victory Avenue), the central boulevard, was lined with tottering ruins. By the Minutka roundabout stood rows of five-story apartment blocks half-destroyed by bombing and artillery strikes a few years earlier. No one could possibly live there, you thought -- until you noticed a light bulb burning dimly through a shell hole, or a splash of color where clothes hung to dry on a balcony.

Seen today, the city is almost unrecognizable. Putin Avenue -- as Prospekt Pobedy is now called -- is a pleasant street lined with cafes, shops, and beauty salons. At its southern end rises the biggest mosque in Europe, its fluted minarets gracefully puncturing the sky. Beyond that, a cluster of high-rise office buildings are under rapid construction: At a squint, it could be a corner of Dubai. And all around are huge billboards with the grinning, bearded face of the man deemed responsible for Grozny's remarkable turnaround: Chechnya's leader, Ramzan Kadyrov.

"Our city is transformed," a shopkeeper told me the day I arrived last week. But the key question in Kadyrov's Chechnya is this: At what cost came the transformation, and was it worth the price?

In the mid-1990s, Boris Yeltsin sent tanks and jets into Grozny to stop separatists from breaking away from Russia and establishing a sovereign Chechen state. Tens -- if not hundreds -- of thousands of people died in the resulting mayhem, most of them civilians. But in 1996, the Russian army was repelled, shockingly, by a motley but impassioned band of Chechen irregulars.

Then in late 1999, after a chaotic three years of de facto Chechen independence, Vladimir Putin, Russia's prime minister, sent troops back into Chechnya. Once again, airstrikes were used to annihilate resistance, with brazen disregard for the suffering of noncombatants. This time, the Kremlin won, and the resistance fighters retreated to the hills, where they have kept up a guerrilla campaign against pro-Moscow forces ever since.

In that struggle, both sides have behaved abominably. State security services kidnap, torture, and kill suspected fighters, often on flimsy evidence. Meanwhile, the increasingly radical Islamist militants -- now embedded in other Muslim republics throughout the Russian North Caucasus -- assassinate officials and send suicide bombers to kill and maim civilians in Moscow and other cities.

Nonetheless, today Chechnya is the Kremlin's success story. Billions of dollars have been poured into reconstruction. And in comparison with the neighboring republics of Ingushetia and Dagestan, Chechnya is relatively calm. There are isolated incidents of terrible violence, but Grozny has an air of normality. It's safe to go out after dark. There are shopping centers, restaurants, and cinemas, things that are virtually nonexistent 50 miles away in Nazran, the largest town in Ingushetia.*

In exchange for this peace, the Chechens have been obliged to accept as their leader the man whom the Kremlin credits with providing it: the 34-year-old Kadyrov, a former rebel fighter who switched sides and was appointed head of the Moscow-backed administration.

Modern-day Chechnya is, in fact, one long love poem to Kadyrov. His face, and that of his father, who was president of the republic until he was assassinated in 2004, is everywhere you look. "A nation that produces such sons cannot but demand respect!" cry the slogans. "Thank you, Ramzan, for caring about our future!" Meanwhile, stalls at Grozny airport sell hagiographies in Kadyrov's honor ("the rebirth and further development of the Chechen Republic became [for him] a sacred duty," they explain), and local people call bulletins on the Grozny channel "Ramzan News" because they are dominated by his latest triumphs: Ramzan handing out apartments to homeless families, Ramzan dancing the lezginka, Ramzan leaping from his bed in the middle of the night to check on a construction site.

Any meeting with a state official involves a five-minute paean of praise to Kadyrov. An essay competition launched last month in Chechen universities -- titled "The Hero of Our Time. The Leader and Patriot" -- offers the following parameters: "The authors should write about the outstanding personality of the Chechen people and the person who has made a huge contribution to the republic's revival and stability, about the leader of the Chechen youth, the Hero of Russia, Ramzan Kadyrov."

Judging Kadyrov's true popularity amid this sycophancy is difficult because independent polls are scarce and elections in Chechnya are fixed even more extravagantly than in the rest of Russia. (In 2007, the republic reported an improbable 99 percent of the vote for United Russia, the Putin-led party that supports Kadyrov.)

It's fair to say he does have some fervent supporters. On March 7, a team of Chechen ministers and retired Russian professionals led by Kadyrov played a friendly soccer match in Grozny against Brazilian stars who won the 1994 and 2002 World Cups.

I sat in the stands next to Khamzat Dzhabrailov, 54, a former Soviet middleweight boxing champion who coached Kadyrov -- once a keen amateur boxer. "He is my boy, my beautiful boy," Khamzat told me. "He is brave, strong, wise, energetic, good, handsome." On the far side of the pitch, members of the Ramzan Patriot Club were chanting their hero's name.

Musa Sadulayev

 SUBJECTS: RUSSIA, ISLAM, CAUCASUS
 

Tom Parfitt is a fellow of the London-based Royal Geographical Society and a former public policy scholar at the Woodrow Wilson International Center. His trip is supported by the Pulitzer Center on Crisis Reporting.

WNOXCHI

11:14 PM ET

March 15, 2011

Thanks.

Thank you FP for continuing on this series of articles. The roots of reform lie in transparency.

 

GRAFOMANKA

9:25 AM ET

March 16, 2011

grafomanka

"Why is the Kremlin-imposed leader of this republic sounding so much like the militants he's meant to be cracking down on?"

... because he used to be one of them?

Chechnya is clan-based society, clans may have different allegiances (pro-Kremlin, anti-Kremlin), but their methods are similar.

 

ATOMNIY

8:47 PM ET

March 16, 2011

I don't understand anti-Kadyrovtsi.

no matter what you guys say and write, Kadyrov's rejime has made a chechnya a prosperous region, in contrast to Russia's ongoing degradation, the only city or region that has surpassed Chechnya's construction, and infrastructure development rate is Sochi and surrounding area, and all that activity is only because of Olympic games.

Personally, as a chechen, i'm thankful to Kadyrov for stopping the manslaughter that was happening in Chechnya, i don't know and what price it came, but without brutal measures it would be never stopped, look at Dagestan and look at Ingushetia. Kadyrov followed a strict rules, no negotiations with rebels, detain anyone related to rebel, his friends, wife, family members. I know its cruel, but it has kicked the sh.it out of the brains of so called independence supporters and jihad supporters, now they know, if anyone of those unemployed, wanna-have-fun kids decided to get an AK-47 and go play war in mountains, his whole family, his friends will have big problems, they will have no work, they will have no support, they will become social outcasts.

I don't understand those so-called patriots, that want the Independence, neither the Jihadists, i would listen to them if they would represent an intellectual elite with a certain program that would be presented to the world, and US, Europe and Russia itself would look into what will happen after Chechnya gets an independence, Chechnya had independence for 3 years, and what did it turn into? instead of cleaning the mess, they started to be a platform for terrorists, kidnappers. Where were those patriots during those 3 years, why they allowed assault on Dagestan?

Unemployed, uneducated, wanna-have-fun men got access to weapons and money from arab jhadists and they decided to play some war, under the green flag of Jihad. They never thought and understood why Russian militants are readily selling weapons to rebels and jihadists, why 1 million something russian army can't cover the whole republic by army troops and kick all those jihadists out, and russia could do that, they are too naive, they didn't understand that russian army was interested in having that war, so they can flex their muscles and do real-life training to their men, test the weapons, new fighter jets, and get paid for that.

What independence are you talking about? And who is talking about independence? Uneducated people that stayed unemployed for most of their lives? that have no experience in politics, economics? people that sit doing nothing, and want to become rich like Kuwait overnight. Chechnya doesn't have world-class politicians to do politics, no economists, too lazy and ambitious to study and work hard to live a respectful life, easier to steal and kill by playing mafioso.

Name me a person that would be better than Kadyrov? Person that would be more effective than Kadyrov? You won't, because you don't have. Because Kadyrov's brutal methods of fighting Jihadists, the Wahabbis is the only reason why Chechnya is the most peaceful region in Caucasus. Jihadists, rebels and anyone who supports them have been taught a very good lesson. if he wouldn't do what he did, Chechnya would be Afghanistan and wahabbis would be Taleban.

 

AGRICOLA

7:59 AM ET

March 17, 2011

Credit where credit is due

When you go to a puppet show do you credit the puppet, or the puppet master with the performance?

 

ATOMNIY

8:18 AM ET

March 17, 2011

Puppet

Show me a puppet, a real puppet that did what Kadyrov did? How many puppets were before Kadyrov? Before Dudayev and after him? Did they do anything to stop the war?

I don't consider Kadyrov a puppet, i consider him a governmental official who gets paid to do his job. Are you a puppet? You do what your company tells you to do? You get the job done when your boss orders you to do so, that doesn't make you a puppet. You are an employee, if you are a hard worker you help your company to grow, if you are a loser then your company will lose, or at least a department you are working in. Consider Russia huge company with several departments (regions), Kadyrov is a head of a department (region) and he is doing his job well. Prove me wrong.

 

ALEX TROF

5:59 PM ET

March 17, 2011

Kadyrov

I think the last few paragraph of the article show that Kadyrov may be good in some ways, but ultimately fail in another. Nobody on here would argue that Kadyrov didn't bring economic development. He did his part.

The problem is the future that I see appropriate for a civilized European country vs. future Kadyrov wants for Chechnya. He is hold religious ideas that are incompatible with civilized society. Chechnya is a religious country and it is getting more and more so forcefully. There is no place for this in a civilized world. Nobody should force women to wear headscarf or prohibit alcohol. Kadyrov supports a society where half of the country has higher status than another half (women). He did it before fighting the Russians, while fighting them, and even after switching sides. He wanted Islamic state in Chechnya and he saw being pro-Kremlin as a way to get it.

A great reformer and innovator is Mustafa Kemal Ataturk. Kadyrov will never measure up to him.

 

JALISA GONZALAS

12:49 PM ET

April 15, 2011

The Islamic Republic of Chechnya

Why is the Kremlin-imposed leader of this republic sounding so much like the militants he's meant to be cracking down on?. "Why is the Kremlin-imposed leader of this republic sounding so much like the militants he's meant to be cracking down on?". "GROZNY, Russia When I first came to the capital of Chechnya seven years ago, large stretches of it lay in rubble. To follow Tom's path through the North Caucasus, check out this Google map alternative bridesmaids dresses. For more photos of the North Caucasus, Russias bloody backyard, click here. ". because he used to be one of them? Chechnya is clan-based society, clans may have different allegiances (pro-Kremlin, anti-Kremlin), but their methods are similar.