The YouTube Revolutions

Twitter and Facebook have received all the attention, but it's the popular video uploading site that provides the best window into what's happening on the Arab street.

BY DAVID KENNER | MARCH 30, 2011

 

Location: Homs, Syria

Description: The number one rule for autocrats clamping down on an uprising, whether you're talking about Tehran in 2009 or Philadelphia in 1776, has always been the same: Muffle the press. The upheaval across the Middle East in recent months has provided some particularly vivid and disturbing examples of this phenomenon: Egypt's "day of hunting journalists," the arrest of Syrian bloggers, or the four New York Times journalists' harrowing tale of being captured by Libyan leader Col. Muammar al-Qaddafi's soldiers. Understanding the visceral power of images to shape emotions and opinions in distant countries, the dictators have been particularly attentive to television stations: During Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak's final days in office, while government thugs battled with protesters in the streets of Cairo, the state TV station blared the national anthem and picturesque images of the Nile River.

Into the void has stepped an unlikely hero: YouTube. Over the last three months, the video posting site has turned into an aggregator for homemade videos of revolution. Revolutionaries all across the Middle East, filming with the video recorders in their phones or other rudimentary technology while dodging bullets or racing through angry crowds, have created an online visual archive of the uprisings: urgent, jittery videos, punctuated by gunshots, shouts, and moments of breathtaking horror. Unfortunately, they're not easy to find -- nobody is in charge with organizing this massive amount of information, and the videos tagged solely in Arabic can be hard for English-speakers to track down. Once seen, however, they are difficult to forget -- exactly what the dictators feared.

Here, a protester in the western city of Homs tears down a poster of Hafez al-Assad, the father of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad. The writing on the gate establishes that this video was taken in Homs, but many other videos do not possess such obvious landmarks. In those cases, viewers have to take the uploader at their word that the video was shot where and when they say it was.

 

David Kenner is an associate editor at Foreign Policy.

GRANT

9:20 AM ET

March 31, 2011

No mention of the Qaddafi

No mention of the Qaddafi Zenga song?

 

DAVID KENNER

11:58 AM ET

March 31, 2011

Zenga zenga

I know! I probably should have included it. It turns out that it's rather hard to describe the humor, so I went with the Kharabeesh one instead. But for those who are interested -- the Qaddafi Zenga Zenga video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cBY-0n4esNY

 

GRANT

5:55 AM ET

April 1, 2011

For those who want to show it

For those who want to show it to concerned parents, here's a version without the girl (though sadly this means that it doesn't parody the infamous 'voluptuous blond').

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6GcUutnU2gk

 

STUBY

8:04 AM ET

April 30, 2011

I dunno if it's hard to

I dunno if it's hard to describe but it's hard to get LOL

@ What is Six Sigma?

 

AJUHASZ

11:05 AM ET

April 8, 2011

YouTube Re-revolutions

I appreciate your important contribution here as finder, translator, and curator, a function that gives Western audiences a frame to better understand these images of recent revolution with which we've been inundated. On my own blog, I go into greater detail, however, about what this piece (and most journalism) about YouTube and these revolutions, fails to produce: the context and background that would allow these images to do anything more than produce the shock and awe you so carefully reproduce.

 

STUBY

12:17 PM ET

April 26, 2011

I agree the Internet in

I agree the Internet in general has made a huge difference to freedom of speech and informing! But isn't too much freedom of information going to create the exact opposite - disinformation, confusion?

Just my 2c

Stuby from Stainless Steel Tubing

 

EEMBEE

9:28 AM ET

April 28, 2011

Youtube gives the freedom of speach

I am so glad that I live in Europa. I just cant imagine living there. Harsh !!!
Signature : Youtube View Increaser

 

ALANNEWMAN

12:54 AM ET

April 29, 2011

Web 2.0 Revolutions

It's not just about Youtube, it's all about Web 2.0, like Facebook, Myspace, news sites and social networking sites. One of my friend, Alan from Shoe Lift had a discussion with me another day and told me that some nation governments try to control the traditional media but it is just tough to do the same for these kind of sites. It's time for the old man to learn something. 

 

WEI LARK

2:42 PM ET

April 29, 2011

The YouTube Revolutions

Twitter and Facebook have received all the attention, but it's the popular video uploading site that provides the best window into what's happening on the Arab street. It's not just about Youtube, it's all about Web 2. 0, like Facebook, Myspace, news sites and social networking sites. One of my friend, Alan from Shoe Lift had a discussion with me another day and told me that some nation governments try to control the traditional media but it is just tough to do the same for these kind of sites. "Here, a protester in the western city of Homs tears down a poster of Hafez al-Assad, the father of Syrian President Bashar al-Assad. The writing on the gate establishes that this video was taken in Homs, but many other videos do not possess such obvious landmarks. In those cases, viewers have to take the uploader at their word that the video was shot where and when they say it was third eye. " I appreciate your important contribution here as finder, translator, and curator, a function that gives Western audiences a frame to better understand these images of recent revolution with which we've been inundated. On my own blog, I go into greater detail, however, about what this piece (and most journalism) about YouTube and these revolutions, fails to produce: the context and background that would allow these images to do anything more than produce the shock and awe you so carefully reproduce.